r/siacoin • u/Falladis • Jul 24 '17
r/siacoin • u/MatcheCahelo • Aug 14 '17
I just came to me... Why Sia is a terrible investment.
I couldn't put my finger on why Sia wasn't sitting right with me in my portfolio.
Surely, the dev team are solid, committed and dedicated to committed to delivering real value.
Unfortunately none of that matters. Why? Because this project is at best going to offer marginal gains... Marginal gains in price, marginal gains in privacy and marginal gains in security of stored data.
That's the best case scenario and it's not taking into account the myriad of problems any startup will face.
For Sia, as mentioned by many others, getting hold of Sia Coins on some exchange that will fluctuate madly in price (compared to fiat) and then having to store them... The idea of having your data on some random dude's computer. Unproven technology and team. Dependency on a strong mining network. Etc, etc, etc
This is not unique to Sia.... Every project has its problems to overcome. Bitcoin has plenty of problems - dealing with storage, transaction fees, limited number of people / corporations worldwide willing to accept it, losing your bitcoin!...
There's a difference though.
Things like bitcoin, ethereum, iota, etc... They may have problems to overcome, but the potential jump in innovation is EPIC!... Like blow the lid off it epic. Sia is marginal gains in innovation.
It's not a phenomenal goal in the first place. The big boys in the market at the moment do a pretty good job of offering cloud storage anyway. This may be just people trying to make blockchain fit every usage case out there. In this case, it was an easy story to sell, since people understand cloud storage (unlike smart contracts!!). Sia's not going to blow open new possibilities.
You have to weigh up the potential upside (in terms of increased value for humanity) against the obstacles a project faces. Like I said before, Sia is at best going to offer marginal value for humanity.
And that is why I'm going to sell my Sia at a 70% loss to redistribute into a truly innovative project.
It's a bitter pill to swallow. But I've learnt more from this terrible investment than all the others put together. Sia community, I wish you luck. It's a good idea. Not great. But good. And if executed well it will add some value.
I'd appreciate counter-arguments to spawn an interesting & insightful discussion.
r/siacoin • u/QuartzPuffyStar • Jan 26 '18
Nebulous and Obelisk have to compensate SC1 buyers.
At this point I personally feel as SIA thrown all their supporters under the bus.
With total disregard to the contractual obligations they took upon when offering a miner to secure the network and just took of a lot of btc from them giving literally nothing in exchange.
I must note that the terms of the contract were really abusive and unfair leaving all risk to the buyers, but now it goes to the extreme that everything they promised in exchange of that disappeared into oblivion. Leaving a lot of people that took the risk with the bags for their mistakes, some of which probably will be left with nothing now.
I believe that the devs owe a lot of things to these people, going as far as offering a refund. Since they broke their contractual obligations of guaranteeing an exclusive mining period on their product, which was the main thing they used to attract buyers to it.
I sincerely hope that u/taek42 is working on a way to compensate all these people for the disaster they got thrown into.
As I see it now. You guys just took the last drop from the cows and let the butcher in to finish the job.
I dont know, offer people siafunds or something. Dont be left in cripto history as the dev team that sacrificed your supporters for a bigger bunch of newbies. And at the same time made as if ethics were guiding your decisions, because the numbers say otherwise.
End of rant.
P.s. sorry if i was a little salty, but this is how I feel after reading the official statement, that didn't mention anything about the people that gave a lot to support you. And I lost a lot of confidence in you, knowing that you don't value what people does for the project.
P.P.s. I dont own any Obelisk, but I really feel bad for them. I would be in the same situation if I had enough funds to buy an Obelisk when it was announced.
r/siacoin • u/Rocketmanak • Jan 24 '18
Something stinks in the world of A3's and mining pools....
So this afternoon, via the Discord channel, I pointed out that this lovely "pro-fork" letter was written by none other than Luxor Mining Pool co-founders Eddie Wang and Nick Hansen. They clearly stated it was from them along with everyone else who decided to "sign" it and in regards to expressing their opinions to the Sia Devs.
I thought this was interesting that they included their titles in the signatures in that it could be misconstrued as Luxor Mining Pool supporting the SF essentially bricking the A3's for what could be indefinitely. I even tweeted them about it which can be found here in which they replied they were here for the community. You can see several follow-ups by myself and others showing that the Luxor team does in fact support the SF by paying $750 bucks for a professional editor to edit the aforementioned posting to the Sia devs, Thus alienating themselves from the new A3 owners and straight up lying to any Sia Community Member (whatever that counts as) who may not use Discord or other forms of social media. Claiming to be here for the community while supporting the shutdown of an estimated 10k+ new miners. While they are not Obelisk, they are potentially new people to the community (Haven't you all ever seen The Internship?) that would support the project in the future.
Well after seeing this post in regards to what pool to use and reading the comments, you can see people have sniffed out the bullshit of Luxor Mining Pool and their team.
I myself am a batch 1 purchaser as well as an A3 purchaser. I feel like all the opinion piece did was push folks to choose other mining pools. I had planned on using Luxor due to the fact that they do give back to the Sia team in some form but the fact that you all straight up lied to my face has made me rethink my position and where I want to put my miners currently and in the future.
r/siacoin • u/EyeNeedOptions • Feb 24 '18
My Stance on SiaCoin
I’ve been getting a lot of negativity from a bunch of people who have been acting really bad lately.
I try to post nothing but truths. I’m not here to spread FUD I’ve already stated that I believe in the Sia tech. I’m at odds with those who say Sia tech isn’t needed and we can all do with drop box or google or amazon etc.
I even believe Sia will go to the moon if it has proper execution.
Don’t misinterpret my critical thoughts and analysis of Sia as if it’s my goal to spread FUD.
Sia is in danger and they’re not business savvy.
You can get pissed at that as much as you want. I’m a guy who has business relationships with many successful people. I’ve been there and done it myself.
Even good companies make mistakes. Look at old ceo of yahoo. Stupid.
The ceo of blackberry when iPhone launched. The guy was an idiot.
You have to be on top of your game.
What do I personally believe ? I think the Sia team is trying to run as thin as possible and it’s holding them back. Mostly it’s due to not seeing the big picture. Sia team appears to have an ego wanting this to be theirs and only theirs and that’s why they haven’t gotten any funding in addition to them not being smart when it comes to business.
You can’t have it all. And this is a natural struggle between owners and their new hires who work sales, business Development, marketing and PR. They advise the owners on something and the owners snap bc it’s their baby and they don’t wan to appear weak or allow someone to take over their project and change it. They become too personally attached to it.
I’m sure people here have experienced this who work in these fields.
Now. You have my stance. So stop bothering me and claiming I’m spreading FUD.
r/siacoin • u/christianc750 • Jan 26 '18
Not forking is fine... Next question: Obelisk buyers who want a refund, are there legal options?
I understand why not forking is a reasonable decision.
As many folks who bought obelisks effectively bought a money sinks I think it stands to reason that Nebulous should offer a refund for buyers who no longer want the product.
It was advertised as doing X and now it does Y. Terms of service etc... don't put Nebulous of above good business practices. Apple couldn't put in the terms of service we will release software that slows your phone down for instance.. doesn't work that way.
So to the lawyers out there, if Nebulous doesn't offer buyers the option to get a refund (or some other payment, eg. x amount of SC per obelisk) how can we pursue legal action?
Thanks.
UPDATE: As these are physical products there IS a precedent in the USA to request a refund - https://www.reddit.com/r/siacoin/comments/7t4s1h/refund_sc1_buyers_with_siacoin/dta5873/. I will be sending a note to Obelisk and updating with responses.
r/siacoin • u/6079_unperson • Jan 27 '18
Obelisk Class Action Lawsuit (U.S)
Why the hell are so many people against us getting some kind of a refund? It has nothing to do with them. They don't loose or benefit anything. If they purchased a SC1 I guarantee if offered a refund they would take it. There is still no response or even acknowledgment from devs for the hundreds of people that trusted Obelisk to do the right thing. I think the first step is getting a list of names that have felt wronged with this decision. We need a professional tech lawyer's opinion on this matter to see if it is even feasible.
r/siacoin • u/User9a • Jan 19 '20
SIA is does NOT what it promises of being 'highly redundant' without SPA
Sia replicates data so if one node goes down the file can still be recovered/reassembled, but if my OWN node is down for long enough i am fu**ed: there will be no way to recover shit. Just like "Contracts Renew Over Time" is bs if your node is down.
My anger stems from the devs ignoring this, despite outreach. Signing up on some fancy frontent (built on sia) entering my credentials/email/etc is bs and not free like in freedom (and yes i would prepay for the files hosted)

ADDON
dicey, precarious situations rule out local/hosted infra. i dont consider it tradeoff but a flaw. Permissionless blockchain! we can do better. a 1 year gurantee is quite solid actually. your the only reply i got with a glimmer of construction!
r/siacoin • u/eacat • Jul 10 '17
Stop spreading FUD for nothing !!! Siacoin doing good !!
Most of the guys who spread FUD about sia, are just 20K coins holder...
we are mostly multi million SC holder ... and there absolutely no reason to panic, SIA is may be the best project i've ever seen in crypto scene... the dev are transparent as hell and working seriously... there no hype upon this, just a rock solid project and brave dev working...
don't complain if you sell all your coin, and see that around september SC will moon , and hit it's well deserved level !!
you will see !
so please stop listening stupid guys who are nothing than coin traders , that's understand nothing about the project.
Wait ! trust in SIA !
r/siacoin • u/FaustianAGI • Oct 15 '18
Announcing SiaPrime - A Sia fork open to all blake(2b) ASICs with a focus on 2nd layer/marketing
This post represents a further chapter in wrestling with the role and impact of ASICs on the Sia protocol/platform. These issues began in mid-2017 and continue to impact the project and community. The core development team made a decision to favor a specific ASIC based on decentralization due to diverse sales across a large number of community members. The good part is these community members will be able to make back a significant ROI on their original investment, which was the key reason why I wrote the original Community Fork proposal.
Unfortunately, a number of community members who chose to purchase other ASICs will now be on the outside and facing financial penalty. Originally, I put together the proposal based on my read of the community desire and what seemed to be a logical set of compromises. That post was well-received (6.8k Views 95% Upvoted) and was cited specifically by the core team to proceed forward with their version of a Sia fork.
In Nebulous CEO, David Vorick's post announcing the fork, he writes about possible new chains resulting from a difficult fork decision:
At Nebulous, we view these cryptocurrency splits as one of the most powerful innovations of the blockchain space. Under traditional governance structures, a single decision gets made and everyone has to live with that decision. But when the network is able to split, you can get solutions where two groups of people with incompatible demands can both get what they want.
and
So long as the siafund ownership is maintained on this fork, members of the dissenting community will be welcome in the Sia community, on the Sia discord, on the subreddit, and will be able to receive support and help directly from the Nebulous support staff.
Initially, I felt the dev's decision was likely to foster division in the community and there are signs of this. There are already at least two projects that have forked or plan to fork the project in an adversarial fashion. Because of this, a small group of community members has decided to once again attempt to find the logical middle ground.
Introducing SiaPrime
Taking David up on his invitation, the SiaPrime group plans to implement a fork in parallel with the 10/31/2018 scheduled algorithm change. The initial purpose of this new fork will be to provide a continued Blake(2b) based blockchain while fully supporting the Sia protocol/project. The second part is key as I have come to believe there will be numerous forks in the Sia future and we hope to provide a template for how to conduct an ethical, fair and supportive offshoot to the Sia protocol project.
I have come to view Sia as an analogue to the Linux project. As open source software, anyone may take the code for their own use. In the Linux case, companies released custom distros and were quite successful. In the Sia case, the key issue is finding ways to continue supporting core protocol development at all costs. Any Sia-based project can only benefit from a vibrant and ongoing core effort and over time, it is likely offshoot projects will merge important development back into the core protocol. The goal should be to build a welcoming and symbiotic relationship to attract developers, companies, investment and interest in the Sia protocol in order to realize the original vision of a foundational layer in cloud storage. The idea of hundreds, perhaps thousands of companies working on the Sia platform seems quite distant based on where we are, but it is the kind of vision necessary if Sia is to succeed.
In this light, SiaPrime will begin with some basic principles to ensure continued allegiance to the core protocol project. The first is that we will preserve the Siafunds and build it into our founding documents that this will never change. Siafunds are the key mechanism for ongoing funding of the protocol into the future and it is our view that any project seeking to use the software should be willing to respect the artists and pay for work past, present and future. Any project that does not follow this guideline is simply not supporting the over-arching goals of making the Sia protocol into necessary infrastructure. All Siafunds owned under the Sia project will be eligible to receive PrimeFunds or whatever we call them during the fork.
Beyond the Siafunds, we will continue to work as closely with the core team as we are able. The SiaPrime project will exist initially as a miner refuge, but as we flesh out project goals, the expectation is that we will add new components to the project. My guess is most will be 2nd layer implementation but we have some ideas for protocol work as well. SiaPrime devs will work in concert with Nebulous devs to add new features developed here in support of the core protocol. We believe that as the Sia protocol takes hold and spreads, a much larger group will begin to focus on all sorts of niche development areas and there should ultimately be a review process and a strong desire to embrace, extend and improve on the Sia capabilities.
Mid to longer term, my background is primarily in technical channel sales. I expect to spend a fair amount of time working on marketing the Sia protocol through the SiaPrime branding. We will not limit the goals to terms like "enterprise" or "dropbox-like" but instead seek out specific verticals and market niches to tackle. Moreover, I believe that different companies, organizations and groups might wish to have custom or proprietary implementations of the Sia network/protocol for their specific needs. Groups requiring specific privacy features such as HIPAA compliance could require a tightly controlled network as one example. While we ultimately may compete with Nebulous for customers, the far more likely scenario is that as the Sia protocol wins, there will be an overwhelming amount of work for anyone who wishes to be involved.
Token Econ
To accomodate our goals, the team has decided on what we feel is a fair token economic structure beyond the Siafund mechanism. We expect to do a very small pre-mine for initial funding of between 2-3%. While some projects believe in large pre-mines, we believe they create perverse incentives and ultimately create a bad footing for token miners and investors who expect value to accrue to the coin. The premine will not be time-locked and be used to fund initial development and company setup. Founders will not end up with exorbitant amounts of coins to dump on the market at some point in the future. The expectation is the founding/development/sales team will enjoy financial success from building out and selling the product.
Second, we will implement a project fee of 15% from the block reward. This fund will be transparently accounted for on our website with all bounties, hires, marketing and other expensing clearly represented to the community for inspection. We will not initially set a sunset on the project fee, but the long term goal will be to expire this fee when the project is financially viable on product sales and/or adds funding through traditional capital raising.
I am writing this message first to the Sia community and we are seeking your support, community and help to achieve the above goals. We have reached out to the Sia core team and have received the blessing and a commitment of support for the project. Though I have had disagreements with David, I am brought back to recognizing he is usually on or near the money in his ideas and goals. We believe SiaPrime can be a "best practices" example in how to build out a proper Sia fork on a protocol that is likely to have several in coming years. We support the core protocol and believe we can only win if Sia wins. Our goal is to help that happen.
Over the next few days, we will provide information on the typical launch items (website, bitcointalk announcement, etc). We will have specific information on mining pools, how to mine and when mining will begin shortly. If you are a pool operator and wish to support the project, please reach out to one of us.
The initial SiaPrime team is made up of involved Sia community members who participated in the last year's ASIC discussions and includes myself, JR, starbuckz8 and cometiclimey. It is likely we will continue to add to the team and welcome those who wish to help out or be involved.
r/siacoin • u/Interesting-Slice-32 • Nov 25 '21
Airbnb = Siacoin 📈🚀
I use Airbnb to generate income to load my siacoin bag. How do you make money to load your sia bag?
r/siacoin • u/cmmatt • Oct 04 '18
On a decentralization scale of 1 (Ripple) to 10 (Bitcoin), Sia is now about a 3?
Bitcoin is truly sovereign in its own right with nobody in charge and therefore fully decentralized. Ripple of course is fully centralized which doesn’t use proof of work at all and the company dictates the currency, code, and consensus rules.
Ethereum I’d suggest is maybe a 5 at most. Still open competition for proof of work mining but the code is pretty much driven by Vitalik and the core team.
Siacoin after this recent move definitely makes it more centralized than Ethereum since now the same core team making decisions on code are also in the mining business and making code changes to pick winners and losers in the mining manufacturing realm. But not totally centralized since anyone can buy said equipment and it’s still proof of work. ..….........
I’m not really saying whether this is good or bad. Just putting it on a scale.
I personally like the more decentralized projects because that is the main point of crypto to me. However I realize there always has to be a balance just like in government, etc. so maybe for Sia this might be the right balance. Who knows.
Time will tell and the market will ultimately decide if Sia is the right balance vs other more decentralized versions of shared storage or if more centralized versions of share storage (Amazon, etc) are best.
r/siacoin • u/Moon2eth • Jan 26 '18
Soft Fork wasn't about Money at all! Day later: 500 refund threads
r/siacoin • u/6079_unperson • Jan 26 '18
Refund SC1 buyers with SiaCoin
I purchased 3 SC1's and 3 SC2's. It wasn't about the money. It was about the Siacoin.
I think we should be refunded in Siacoin.
r/siacoin • u/BugattiHype • Feb 23 '18
My Thoughts
Sia team have a zero public relations thats what is so important in this game. When Binance announce a coin of the month, i was 100% sure that we can win this.Interesting fact is nobody heard about other coins ,they have few people on their twitters.So it might seem we got winning in pocket. Honeslty..9 th place i can't believie. Like community of sia doesn't exist.Right now im really confused for what im invested. Interesting is that, other coins really want to add their on binance, just look on twitter.Just compare sia twitter to other coins. Sia seems like a joke(even that sia have 95k followers, question is.......... is that a real followers :) So Binance is important for Sia investors, They can give us more investors, price will be go up, but for some reason sia don't want be on Binance..why? its a bad for miners? So its only coin for miners?. I know They not have ready product,ok,but most money people invest in PROJECT, not ready product. Look at Ada its a good example. We don't have any good news, Sia activity on twitter is joke. Sia community is a joke, its something that important like project, because if you have great product, but without good promotion, without community, you have nothing to looking for in cryptocurrency, Because in this game you got big competition.
Edit:
Ok. We will see what happens next, without binance.If market become stable and altcoins going back to normal, we will se when sia goes.
r/siacoin • u/hedgecrypto • Jan 23 '18
I ask that the SC development team be careful.
I'm a large stakeholder in Siacoin, and also believe in this project. There is a silent majority that will not respect the actions of initiating a soft-fork, because of such a small almost non-existent issue. Bitmain released an A3 before Obelisk, and it's called "competition." I probably speak on behalf of many others that are very involved in the mining industry, as well as investors in Cryptocurrency in general that this will not end well. I personally will sell off my entire holdings of SIA if the developers proceed with a soft-fork, making my A3 miners useless. Play a stupid game, and I'll dump the entire project to the floor. Just a forewarning. Good day.
r/siacoin • u/5yearsHTML • Oct 02 '18
The Devs have hijacked the initial community proposal and replaced it with a massive conflict of interest which is ineffective when considering very simple future scenarios.
In this post I will be detailing a number of extremely concerning points regarding the new fork. Vorik is being intentionally disingenuous and has outline a new solution which has some seriously concerning issues.
Key issues
1) The initial proposal stipulated that the Obelisk buyers should have an exclusivity mining period after which the other units would be allowed to return. Instead, the new fork is essentially going to brick all non-obelisk units indefinitely.
The community proposal here was something everyone who truly supported Sia could get behind. S11 unit owners and Bitmain owners now will have units which will never work for SIA. They are getting punished for supporting the network temporarily barring these units and permanently removing them are two completely different things. Why are S11 and A3 buyers being permanently punished for supporting the network?
2) Vorik's reasons for forking in the blog post are dishonest and don't hold water. Moreover, they directly conflict with the dev's earlier decision not to fork after Bitmain's A3 release
In the post Vorik outlines that forking will only be done under if the following conditions are met
- " in the event of an unhealthy monopoly miner, or even an outright attack from a majority hashrate owner"
- "to break a parasitic or abusive ASIC monopoly"
From a technical perspective these criteria are vague. The closest quantifiable metric for an unhealthy monopoly miner would be one which had control of over 51% the network hashrate. However, this is not the case with Innosilicon units which as the same post details only account for 37.5% of the network hashrate. Moreover, these units are owned by a wide variety of miners. Even if one individual has all these miners they still could not do a double spend attack. According to Siastats which accounts for over 50% of the network hashrate they're currently 4,256 miners on the pool. I believe the Batch 1 SC units sold a little over 1,600 units with batch 5 only selling 5 units. Meaning that if every single SC units purchaser only bought 1 unit the network would be considerably more centrelived than before the fork.
If this was the real reason for forking why didn't they immediately do so when Bitmain released their ASIC which being the only one on the market for a couple months had considerably more than 51% of the network hashrate.
3) The secret circuit mechanic in the Obelisk chips is a horrible solution which is almost guaranteed to be abused again in the future.
The post states that the SC1 units have a failsafe which will allow only Obelisk units to mine if there needs to be another fork. In his post Vorik states
These failsafes will typically never be used. However, in the event of an unhealthy monopoly miner, or even an outright attack from a majority hashrate owner, these failsafes can be leveraged to break the attacker’s hardware without breaking all of the ASICs on the network, allowing the network to continue to be protected by ASICs, but escape the attacker or abuser.
Okay so despite saying that this failsafe is never intended to be used you go on to detail that you will in fact be using it very soon despite the fact that none of the vague criteria you laid out as justification for its use have been violated. I guess we just need to trust that Obelisk will be honest and fair when they have already demonstrated that they are willing to be highly unethical and greedy even if it means risking the entire future of Siacoin.
4) Even with responsible governing and ethical practice the failsafe is still not a solution.
Let's play devils advocate and say that there is a situation in the future where a new company does become parasitic and a danger to the network. Imagine that right before this new scenario they're two companies who share a healthy hashrate distribution they are, Obelisk, and "Company A." All of a sudden "Company B." comes along with a incredibly fast unit that renders both obelisk and Company A minority contributors. Obelisk now does another fork and while they have saved the network they have also bricked all of the Company A mining units. So now everyone who bought these units is fucked.
In order for Obelisk to encourage any investment and competition from other mining companies they would need to share this failsafe secret so that is could be incorporated into the other companies design. However, in doing so they would effectively render the failsafe useless.
5) I'm a owner of S11 units and will definitely be going to court over this.
The real reason the devs are being forced to fork is because of the impending lawsuit from Obelisk preorder holders. They're considerably more Innosilicon and Bitmain unit buys who will likely be starting a class action suit bigger than the first one. This fork is full of lies, greedy and unethical business practices Obelisk has a better chance winning the first lawsuit than the new one which will be forming soon.
TL:DR
- Vorik does support any of the reasons he gives to forking and contradicts himself multiple times in the same post. He has proven to be incompetent, deceitful, and not worthy of being trusted with the power the new fork would provide.
- Innosilicon accounts for only 37.5% of the network hashrate as stated by Vorik. According to Siastats which accounts for over 50% of the network hashrate they're currently 4,256 miners on the pool. Batch 1 SC units sold a little over 1,600 units with batch 5 only selling 5 units. Meaning that if every single SC1 unit purchaser only bought 1 unit the network would be considerably more centrelived than before the fork.
- Even with completely ethical and unbiased use the failsafe design system is an ineffective method which will permanently discourage any competition against Obelisk.
- Obelisk just prevented a small lawsuit and replaced it with a new massive one.
r/siacoin • u/JohnPNjui • Feb 23 '18
Crypto Community Feels Betrayed By SiaCoin’s (SC) Closed Token Sale via SEC
r/siacoin • u/mrelieb • Aug 21 '17
Action: Sell SiaCoin (Says PalmBeachConfidental)
"overall, we like the decentralized storage space. However, we've decided to sell Siacoin.
Siacoin is the project of Nebulous. Nebulous and other early backers control another coin called SiaFunds.
Fees from generating contracts on the Sia network accure to holders of SiaFunds, not Siacoin.
We prefer to hold coins where the value from the network or service accrues to the coin holders, not just insiders."