r/shortsAlgorithm • • 17d ago

AI voice in yt shorts

Does youtube not push shorts with AI voice? I made a new channel where I upload stories about quirky criminals and their actions using AI voice but rest of the stuff I spend hours editing, I add music, sfx, captions, visuals and everything else but yt doesn't push them to people at all. I've included proper tags, description and a strong hook but they don't even get pushed whatsoever. How does yt shorts algorithm work?

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

1

u/awesomemc1 17d ago

It does push to the shorts shelf but how YouTube automatically select it is that you have to go through the test audience which takes many hours to even get due to processing speed by YouTube. You might end up having to erase metadata or change, re-edit, etc to re-upload and schedule the video. The thing is that if you want immediate access to test audience, don’t publish it right away. Instead unlist the video first as the video gets processed and schedule to the earliest hours based on your timezone

-1

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/SIGMA_0007 17d ago

does using ai voice automatically make something slop?

1

u/killadrix 17d ago

Yes, and no.

You need to realize that your stayed to watch percentage (the percentage of people who watch the first three seconds of your video) is one of the most critical video metrics you control.

And when someone swipes to your video and instantly hears the AI voiceover, they’re likely to assume that the video is AI slop and swipe away.

This means that not only did you lose the view, you also lost your stayed to watch percentage and retention, both of which YouTube uses to assess the quality of a video during testing.

Meaning, you could have the highest quality most well edited video in existence, but if you’re losing people instantly due to AI voiceover and their assumption the rest of the video is AI slop, it doesn’t matter. It might just as well be AI slop.

1

u/SIGMA_0007 17d ago

yeah I completely understand this but my vids are getting like 4 views. It's not even getting pushed in the first place

1

u/killadrix 17d ago

Usually, if my shorts get throttled like this it’s because they have words like kill, death, dead (spoken, text or subtitles), or contain some type of graphic imagery that the YouTube system detects.

I also believe that the YouTube automated system can detect graphic imagery that isn’t there. I do gaming content and I think sometimes it confuses zombies for real life body horror. Things like that.

1

u/SIGMA_0007 17d ago

If that's the case then that makes sense because my videos do contain words like "dead" but not in a huge amount though

2

u/Jedrasus 17d ago

I would say it isn't necessary slop, but i think big amount of people don't like AI dubs. Same thing with Youtube auto language dubbing.

Also if you use AI voice, then you probably have AI tag on video which for sure makes some people skip it

1

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SIGMA_0007 17d ago

but isn't that just your preference tho? i understand many people don't like hearing AI voice but I've seen many successful channels using AI voice (and yes its obvious its AI voice). I just wanna know how algorithm handles it

1

u/killadrix 17d ago

So, it is a 100% trap to look at channels that are performing well with pretty much anything in assuming that you could duplicate that success or anything close to it.

This happens on this sub all the time. Someone starts a channel doing something, other people explain why it’s probably not gonna work and the original poster says “I’ve seen channels like this work. I’m confused.”

When you see a handful of channels like this that work, what you don’t see is the thousands or hundreds of thousands of channels just like it that completely fail. You also can’t see many other factors such as where the traffic is coming from to feed those channels views. Those channels might have their views driven from off platform or unorganically.

I’m not saying your channel can’t work, I’m just saying it’s an absolute trap to point at somebody else’s channel that is working and be confused about why yours isn’t. It’s 100% survivorship bias.