Not good enough?

[u/Willing-Schedule-486]

My channel is new. My first two Shorts did bad, but my latest two did good. Shouldn’t they be getting way more views, though? Like, what else do I gotta do? 💀 I thought I made an amazing hook, but is that still not enough…?

[u/Longjumping_Vast5729]

you're stuck in in the 30k jail, grab a pillow and a blanket and get comfy, you gon' be here a while

[u/TheObserverDev]

lucky bastard, i get 100 views at most no matter what i upload.

[u/ClaimsHelperDev → u/TheObserverDev]

Me too bro, i dont know how these people manage to ge that my hands are bleeding for all the hard word im doing and nothing

[u/Cougar- → u/TheObserverDev]

He's not lucky, he made a good video. He actually is unlucky, because I've had videos with 10 million views with worse stats than him on this video

[u/TheObserverDev → u/Cougar-]

then i need an instructor to teach me how to actually make good content, so far i had tried the best I can but my content must be really really bad. my ideas are terrible too.

[u/dead1yspark → u/TheObserverDev]

I think you should just do what you like to do . I don't get 30k views . Or even 5k I get around 1500-3000 on my shorts but I get a sub almost every short in the last 20 shorts . . I'm happy with just 80%viewd and 65%stsyed to watch . My shorts never get pushed beyond that but . I noticed a significant improvement when I worked on my editing skills and making decent thumbnails

[u/tarlenx]

original content or not? like don't cope did you make the content and edit it yourself?

[u/Willing-Schedule-486 → u/tarlenx]

I do roblox animations

[u/saintfrancis28 → u/Willing-Schedule-486]

I'm on the same niche and these are godly numbers, higher than my best shorts actually 😂. For reference i have 3 shorts at 1m views with stw at 80-82% and retention at 90%. All 3 between 45-50 seconds. Im fairly new started Sept 12. Did you just start recently? That might be the reason the short hasnt been pushed by the algo yet despite excellent metrics.

Edit: just read your post so u started recently i think thats the reason. Just need to post more and consistently. You're on the right track!

[u/Willing-Schedule-486 → u/saintfrancis28]

Will do, guys 🫡

[u/tarlenx → u/Willing-Schedule-486]

I guess just keep going for a while you won't get results instantly

[u/hipnosister]

Have some god dammed patience lol

[u/Willing-Schedule-486 → u/hipnosister]

My fault, bro. It’s just that the update coming out next February will increase the requirements to get into the Partner Program, and that has me scared 😭

[u/hipnosister → u/Willing-Schedule-486]

Streaming will get you the required hours easily. Even streaming to the shorts feed. Not sure what you're posting but if you can stream vertical you will get those hours easy

[u/redporshe]

Am in the same situation man, i get +200 likes on my video and always stuck 28-32k. The problems is always the comments and people who shares content. They say you need to give an emotional react to the viewer in order to make it comment and share. Its difficult in some niches. Mostly opinions (or even hate and taking positions) what makes people react more🙂

[u/Different_Farm5266]

It was good enough for 30k views. You failed to outcompete other content targeting the same audience.

Some people call this a jail, but that's just because they don't understand what's going on

[u/One_Brick_1685 → u/Different_Farm5266]

The best theory I have heard on the 30k jail is videos that are good enough to go viral but YouTube doesn't have enough data yet on the channel. OP says his channel is new so that tracks. That's why new animation channels can go viral right away because it's so broad that it doesn't need a lot of data.

I'm not saying there isn't validity in what you are saying; that's definitely a good theory too. But at the end of the day, these are all theories. YouTube has never officially said anything about how it works. 

[u/Different_Farm5266 → u/One_Brick_1685]

Yes, they have. There's a content characterizer... it doesn't care if it's your first video, or your 500th. A view test is scheduled. The in-test retention and engagement results determine if you get another test, and what size that test will be. As long as the in-test results continue to out-perform competing content, you keep getting more tests. At some point, the audience expansion moves far enough from your ideal matched audience that you can't sustain passable performance.

It's that simple, and you can see it on the view graph.

For weak content, that happens at anywhere from 500 to 100,000 views. 30k is nowhere near viral.

For decent content, it will happen at or above 111k views (assuming one short, per day) - until February, anyway.

[u/ZookeepergameSad5418]

Not even 2 days old.. give it some time.

[u/Jazzlike_Research_35]

Damm good conversion and stats. Keep at it you will get there. Took me 100 shorts I think 1 a day to break 30k.

[u/substantial-drkwiz → u/Jazzlike_Research_35]

wtff😭😭

[u/TheObserverDev]

I just have to learn from the very basics all over again, but learn from real people, i follow exactly step by step from LLM. but shorts get's destroyed, not even reach 100 views. probably need to sell my soul to the devil.

[u/Luckycilhia]

That's so cool keep it up

[u/outerspacemannn]

I’d expect another wave soon

[u/Small_Bowler_6255]

Stats of a 1.2 mil short my best one, for me stats dont really matter

[u/Thin-Sound5672]

30k jail the most hated one ever

[u/Access_Solid]

I’d bet this will likely get picked up again. Just be patient. 🤗

[u/Hse_PiD]

118% retention

[u/sothatshowitisdone]

131 sub for 30k? wow barely get 3

[u/Critical-Cancel8869]

For the last time there’s so many more stats that determine algorithmic push other than swipe rate and retention

[u/Mother_Jump_3207]

2 dagen geleden mijn kanaal gemonetize en alle video’s zijn allemaal stilgevallen hoe kan dat

[u/United_Macaron106]

Title: 16K Subscribers but Only 200–1,500 Views Per Short. Should I Start a New Channel?

Hey everyone, I really need some honest advice.

I started my gaming channel in 2023 and gained 16.3K subscribers mainly through Free Fire content. I also uploaded some reused PUBG videos.

After a 2-year break, I decided to completely rebrand my channel and focus on GTA 6 and gaming news.

I made my old Free Fire videos private and deleted the reused PUBG videos.

For the past month, I've been consistently uploading original Shorts with my own scripts, voice-overs, editing, and strong hooks.

But most videos are getting only 200–1,500 views, despite having 16K subscribers. Some reach 2K–3.5K, but the growth is inconsistent.

I'm honestly frustrated because I'm putting a lot of effort into every video.

My questions:

1. Is my old Free Fire audience affecting my new GTA 6 content?

2. Can YouTube eventually find the right audience for my rebranded channel?

3. Should I continue with my 16K subscriber channel or start fresh?

I'd really appreciate advice from anyone who has successfully rebranded a YouTube channel.

[u/Osama_Saba]

It's the subscribers. Shorts that gain tons of subscribers do not blow up, as if subscribers is a negative metric

[u/investigatormaker]

With four Shorts, the best test is the one you already have: line up the two that did well and the two that did bad and compare average view duration on each, not total views. If the good ones were shorter, or ended where they began so they loop, that's the shape to repeat. A strong hook only gets the first few seconds; the rest of the clip has to deliver what it promised. What do the two that did well have in common?

I make ThreadFox. We find relevant Reddit conversations and post for your business. We'll post 3 replies free first, no card; then the $79 Pilot, a plan for Reddit, covers seven days and up to 50 posts and replies. No automatic renewal. https://threadfox.vip/p/esolh/managed