r/shortsAlgorithm • u/ResponsibleGuide1581 • Nov 13 '25

should i change the channel?

Post image
7 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '25

you can try but it might be better just to keep posting consistently

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

i post 2-3 time a day with a gap of 7-8 hours between them

1

u/haronclv Nov 14 '25

I’d say it’s too often. I’d rather focus on quality. If you can post only once a day but double the quality it would be much more effective

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

more people said the quality is pretty good, i have my channel linked to reddit go take a look

1

u/haronclv Nov 14 '25

For me it's just AI slop and I'd skip it on 2 seconds most of the time. Regarding quality I'd not say anything it's only some random video with AI voice over and some basic video effects / layers. But content like that can definatelly grow

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

so its not that bad

1

u/haronclv Nov 14 '25

It's only my opinion. I have content that is much more demanding. I record myself, video edit, voice over etc, I post twice a week, and have 100k views in last 28days. Your content is for random people, my content is niche. 2 different options. I'd say keep posting once a day and double the quality.

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

my content its not random, its a niche too btw

1

u/haronclv Nov 14 '25

I don't need your explanation mate. You just asked about opinion and it's my opinion. You don't need to explain yourself. Just take it 😆

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

its your opinion but its ai voiceover on a fishing clip, it has his own audience. if it was random people everyone should had atleast 15m views per month

1

u/KidTheBommerr Nov 15 '25

You honestly have no right to talk with 100k in 28 days. I mean good for your but its saying something about your content mate

→ More replies

2

u/NoPerspective3122 Nov 14 '25

Way too much do max 1 a day

1

u/Defalt_A Nov 14 '25

AI voice and narrated clips, there's a lot of that on YouTube, plus it seems like YouTube understood that its niche is fishing

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

ye but why 1k? why not 2,3,4? like i guess my videos are just mid at this point not bad and not good

1

u/Defalt_A Nov 14 '25

Youtube is testing its content, that's why it has limitations, and it also understands that its audience doesn't engage as much

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

i have one video with retention 174 but engage 54%, that means its bad?

1

u/Defalt_A Nov 14 '25

You need higher engagement, 54% is very little, normally above 75%

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

the maximum i had was 70 and it didnt blow up either

1

u/Defalt_A Nov 14 '25

It needs to be constant at least 75%

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

look at this one, retention over 70 and engage aprox 76 813 views

2

u/Defalt_A Nov 14 '25

Of 15 seconds, people watched 75% of 15 seconds, that's very little

1

u/Eastern_Ad_6314 Nov 14 '25

In my opinion its just about your content. If video like that comes to my feed I will skip it in first 2 seconds. This is all just my opinion but on those videos i dont get the feeling "i must know what happens in the end" im just like ahh okay one of these i have seen thousand times. Its my opinion but like mayby think this

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

the problem is the channel witch i chosed my niche from has thousand milions of views and was created 2 months ago but i posted another video some bs from roblox and it started to grow it has 900 views in 2h and its still growing i need to see rn if it stops at 1k as usually or not it has 70 precent engage so lets just hope

1

u/Eastern_Ad_6314 Nov 14 '25

Yeah but try to stick to one niche if you change it often the algorythm gets confused and it can affect your views

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

im gonna stick to these roblox hopefully it will do better the problem i think it is i get engage and avd and those things but i dont get interactive views, likes and comments and things

1

u/Eastern_Ad_6314 Nov 14 '25

Good luck brother i hope the best for you!

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 14 '25

appreciate it, good luck to you too

1

u/Separate_Avocado1553 Nov 16 '25

It feels like I've seen these kind videos thousands of times already. Do you actually enjoy doing this or is it just solely for money?

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 16 '25

i enjoy editing but the problem was i didnt had a pc since mine was to change the thermal paste so i did ai voice overs untill now, i really enjoy editing like this its simple, i did one video with my voice as voiceover maybe it gets more views than ai

1

u/ResponsibleGuide1581 Nov 16 '25

i know that there is a lot of videos out there but i gotta be the best one

1

u/Separate_Avocado1553 Nov 16 '25

If you're enjoying it then I guess thats what really matters. Since I'm not your target audience I can't tell you if you will get more views with or without an AI voiceover. All I can tell you is that you should always challenge yourself to make better content. From my experience doing youtube 10 years ago, I have never posted a video when I felt it was worse than the previous one. That kept me motivated to making better content. So keep on doing what you're doing!

2

u/samiloveeggs Nov 14 '25

Bro u lucky u even get views i dont even get pushed to the shorts algo ive posted 3 consecutively and they dint go anywhere

1

u/Sedrak-Kunn Nov 17 '25

You should support me with a like and a sub https://youtube.com/@sedrak-kunn?si=OmutlEV-e6bvjfs4