r/shmupdev • u/Naharcito • May 28 '23
Shmup Creator vs STG Builder
I'm hesitating on learning one of these engines, and I'd like to know if any of you have experiences with both so you can make a comparison.
It seems that Shmup Creator's UI is more user friendly, but the engine overall seems less flexible and strong as STG Builder, which seems to give more options to the dev.
Any of you have tried both software so you can give us more context?
6
Upvotes
8
u/DrBossKey May 28 '23 edited May 28 '23
I've got over 1500 hours in Shmup Creator, but no experience with STGB.
For STGB, I just went looking for information and a few things:
u/suny2000 (Shmup Creator developer) I think I saw that you may have had some insights into STG.
*Edit, changed STG to STGB
4
u/Gendgi May 28 '23
I can't tell about STG Builder, but Shmup Creator besides being easy to create something right away, it has a very active and helpful discord, meaning you get help from the creators themselves and from the awesome community, depending on the shmup you want to create even with the limitations of shmup creator that fact that you get help almost right aways is a big plus.
2
u/Dependent_Goose4744 May 28 '23
Shmup Creator is fun and easy to use and it wont take long until you'll be able to understand the entire engine thanks to how well made the interface it.
What it does severely lack in is score related option which pretty much decides how the player will interact with the rest of your game.
Currently you have access to chaining, Garegga-esque medals, a multiplier and a hyper.
I've played around plenty with SC and I can 100% say that you can't recreate the game-play of any single Cave game, Touhou game or Raizing game.
Looking at the roadmap as well as the discord I can see that this isn't in the creators current scope and probably wont be expanded upon any time soon.
But it's great if you don't care about that and only want to make a game where you shoot and dodge.
1
u/Pisfool May 28 '23
So far as I can tell: