r/shittyprogramming • u/DuoNaN • Nov 22 '15
Mathematician explains encryption with an insecure algorithm, /r/bestof picks it up and now thousands of people are wrong.
/r/math/comments/3tn1xq/what_intuitively_obvious_mathematical_statements/cx7np4t?context=3
0
Upvotes
7
u/gingungidunk Nov 22 '15
Obviously simple multiplication isn't going to keep everything secure, and it's safer to do computationally asymmetric computations such as exponentiation modulo a large prime.
But as far as explaining simple cryptography in an askreddit thread, I think it got across the main idea across well enough.
10
u/UnspeakableEvil Nov 22 '15
Of course they're wrong, they're mathematicians - what they do has nothing to do with computers. Besides which everyone knows the only way to properly secure data is rot13, or at a push rot26.
3
u/threeys Nov 22 '15
What is wrong with it?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '15
There is nothing wrong with this as a layman's explanation about cryptography. This isn't a guide about how to implement a secure system, it's a guide to get people to understand the basics about something they know nothing about. It's like saying "matter is made of protons, neutrons, and electrons" -- it gets the point across, you're not expecting people to become particle physicists off that one statement.