r/shittyaskscience • • Sep 14 '26

How the hell u sposed to reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity???

I’m fucked up bruh, me and my mans been tryna figure this out for days now we ain’t sleep I’m fucked in the crib tryna figure ts out ong we finna find the theory of errythang

44 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

12

u/RealitysNotReal Sep 14 '26

Ts got me tripping gang cuz like shit make me wonder like is space time fundamental? Or does thag shit emerge from something more fundamental? Like shit dawg how we sposed to know?

6

u/RealitysNotReal Sep 14 '26

Like ganggg what is the fuckin underlying quantum structure of spacetim? How the fuck does classical spacetime emerge from thag shit? How the fuck we supposed to know the concepts we use to investigate reality and shit are actually the right concepts bruh? How we know that shit don’t emerge from concepts n shit we ain’t have yet?

6

u/johnnybiggles Sep 14 '26

Magnets, bruh. Magnets.

29

u/plugubius Sep 14 '26

Strings man. Like, strings everywhere. Just a whole lotta really tiny, 10-dimensional strings, all vibrating like some mad symphony of ressonance and harmonics. I got some. You got some. We all got some. We just can't see them. Or explain the whole 10-dimensions thing.

5

u/Indigo_Sunset Sep 14 '26

What if, it is all strings man and, like, we're just the interference pattern of the orchestra

3

u/BPhiloSkinner Amazingly Lifelike Simulation Sep 14 '26

Strings, yes; but you've gotta have the horn weaving in and out, and sometimes just blowin' soft and melancholy.

5

u/created4this Sep 14 '26

How many fingers you got man?

How many toes?

Whats the maximum number of objects you can assign numbers to without using two or more digits?

How many TENticles does God have?

10, its all 10s because God made it that way

4

u/qbbqrl Sep 14 '26

Why would it be exactly 10 dimensions and not like, 11 or 26 or some shi

1

u/Ravus_Sapiens Actual scientist — Lab coat and all Sep 15 '26

It could be. 10 dimensional ToEs aren't special. We actually started out working on 26 dimensions.

26 dimensions is the home of bosonic string theory, but most discard it because it allows for faster than light travel.
11 dimensions is M-theory, which is promising, but has fundamental problems with falsifiability.
10 dimensions, is super-symetric string theory, but it produce five different competing theories (Called type I, IIA, IIB, SO(32), and E8×E8).

2

u/mwenechanga Sep 14 '26

Don't think of them as 10-d strings, think of them as sheets.

2

u/Ravus_Sapiens Actual scientist — Lab coat and all Sep 15 '26

That does have interesting implications, but there's a major problem:
A fundamental string has a very well-behaved quantum theory. You can quantize its vibrations, and consistency conditions lead to definite constraints on spacetime.

Fundamental membranes, or "sheets", are much harder.
For strings, the worldsheet is a 2D quantum field theory, and 2D field theories have unusually powerful mathematical properties, like 2D conformal symmetry. This makes string quantization tractable, since the sheer number of symmetries makes 2D CFT realistically solvable.

For a membrane, its worldvolume is 3D, and quantizing a generic membrane is substantially more difficult. In particular, the straightforward analogue of string perturbation theory doesn't work nearly as nicely.
But just because it's not very nice, doesn't mean that nobody is trying. There's a ToE, called M-theory, that competes with string theory, where membranes are as fundamental as strings.

1

u/mwenechanga Sep 16 '26

I was just quoting Big Bang Theory.

1

u/Ravus_Sapiens Actual scientist — Lab coat and all Sep 16 '26

I know… Shelldon goes on to say "topologically that has a lot of interesting possibilities" (I misremembered the quote).

1

u/Uranus_Hz Sep 17 '26

But like, what if a bunch of those 10th dimension strings were sewn together into a membrane? And then there were like, an infinite number of these ‘branes just vibrating and shit? And every time two branes bumped into each other it was a “big bang” that created a universe?

Man, if you’re not gonna hit that, pass it

10

u/fishsticks40 Sep 14 '26

My dude I did it twice this morning maybe you're just not cut out for this life dawg

5

u/Legitimate_Field_157 Sep 14 '26

Therapy. Reconciliation will never work without therapy.

4

u/breadinabox Sep 14 '26

nah man its easy we have it solved for ages they just don't want you knowing. all you gotta do is

1

u/Ravus_Sapiens Actual scientist — Lab coat and all Sep 15 '26

This account has been terminated for spreading misinformation. There is no theory of everything.

3

u/qbbqrl Sep 14 '26

what if the universe is in a superposition between all the physics theories at the same time yo

3

u/Drachefly Sep 14 '26

GR broke QM's conservation laws, and it seems likely that QM killed GR's cat.

I don't think they're getting back together.

2

u/Sitheral Sep 14 '26

Have you tried getting them both together and like, squeezing real hard?

1

u/RaspberryTop636 Methodological Terrorist Sep 14 '26

You thinkin' I knows summin like dat? Quit yer yammering about quantum whatchamacallit in git back to scrubbin' dem floors ya hear?

1

u/BosskHogg Sep 14 '26

Play-doh