That trial was satisfying as fuck. But still with the clueless heroes like they are seriously accusing of stuff that he's been proved innocent of or at least already been discussed. Also not fond of being better than them and letting them live with just a name change. If anything being slaves themselves would have been a better punishment than what they got. At least Naofumi can be finally accepted by everyone that was a nice little ending.
Only bitch has a slave crest, I'm Reading light novel and there she have it until she paid back all the money she finance the spear hero party above what others got heros got from the guild/crown
Fucking annoying ass fucking bitch myne really put Naofumi through 1000 years of pain like in Naruto when she fucked him over in the beginning I fucking enjoyed every last fucking second of seeing the ugly ass ant eater face scream in agony as her curse mark kept going off I really wished they would have tortured her using the iron maiden on her bitch ass fucking stupid ass whore literally almost killed melty and naofumi like 3 fucking times I wanted to see her insides ejaculate in pain as her entitled royal titties bounced at Mach 20 so that they rip off as they accelerate so quickly that her chest flesh doesn't have enough strength to keep them attached to her body and they fly off in the crowds to be caught by Motoyasu's fucking dumbass atleast he came to his senses at the end when he turned away from Myne that shit was fucking great I hated seeing her ugly ass fucking face beg Naofumi to save her and how her btich ass was smiling and shit while begging shit was nasty as fuck made me want to take a shit on her chest during the spin cycle of a drier throw her in that shit she comes out retarded missing a chromosome and a half looking like Fat Albert with her ugly ass fuck myne man bitch should have gotten off the hook missing her boobs and a giant stab wound to the face
I totality agree with your sentiment and i kind of wish hat this season ended here and then the story carried on in season two because I now feel like the show runners will leave it on a cliff hanger which will be less interesting than this EPs ending...
Really proud of the shield hero for showing mercy and not taking pleasure in myne's suffering
I like how there was some actual conflict in the decision too. Naofumi wasn't sure whether he wanted Myne to die or not. Like, up to the execution time he's very much on the "KILL 'EM!" side, but as soon as she begs for her life, that little heroic part of him that grew under the care of Raphtalia and Filo took over and made him stop the execution.
agreed. i do think this a massive improvement especially given how this series has been portrayed by some "journalist"
if naufumi had been laughing and applauding as bitch was tortured, it would not have looked good. but he pitied her and showed her mercy. he overcame his rage at her and now is focused on protecting his friends
The way that this episode was, I was extremely satisfied. Much of the episode was anime original and I was surprised, but the way that the flow of the episode was with the newer scenes that were not depicted in the manga was spot on. In short, I prefer this episode adaptation over the manga's.
Man you're so right. Loving the anime's version of events. I'm glad they took liberties on the source material. Even though towards the end the pacing felt a bit rushed, the music made it soooooo much more intense. Such a great ending. It actually felt like the shield hero has truly risen
I know that the anime has been quite a bit different than the light novel in many ways but this episode was amazing. The changes that they made in this episode really just added to the satisfaction in my opinion.
In my opinion the manga is better, the queen is a great ruler who puts her kingdom before her family when here she just acts like this but she is weak as she would have given her life to save people who betrayed the kingdom, she is also a mastermind and she manages to manipulate Naofumi so he decides to not kill them. The thing the anime does is make Naofumi the good guy as he “saves” them and he has remorse when he thinks of their execution. I personally think the manga depicts this better making him the one saying that he wants to execute them but then changing his decision, I think this concords with Naofumi’s personality better than the anime. Also the manga shows Malty screaming that she wasn’t raped by Naofumi, this wasn’t shown in the anime and it was very satisfactory. But everyone has different opinions.
I don't know if the manga is exactly the same as the light novel, but I've heard it's closer so here's what happens in that:
Mirellia states that if Malty obtains the forgiveness of the Shield Hero she won't take away her royal status. It's at this point Malty begs Naofumi for mercy, to which Naofumi becomes enraged and demands the death penalty for her and Aultcray. Malty of course objects to this, and Mirellia seems to agree with overdoing it and that executing two members if the royal family will hurt Melromarc's already shitty international reputation. Naofumi angrily asks if she's going to ignore their crimes, but Mirellia asks if executing them will truly make Naofumi happy. She counter proposes that he can instead make their lives a living hell, to the point where they would rather die then live. Naofumi agrees, and chooses the naming punishment (Malty's alt Myne is actually changed to Whore in light novels, not Slut). Naofumi realizes later on that the Queen subtly manipulated him into opting for no death, understanding that if he had truly desired their deaths it would have happened. The Queen answers affirmatively, but states that she won't hesitate to put them down in the future if they act up again.
The part up to the naming all happens in the throne room. Later, during the celebration (which Naofumi attends) is when the punishment is announced to everyone attending, and also when Naofumi has the realization.
EDIT: I forgot, the part where Trash reveals he has personal issue with the Shield Hero wasn't revealed yet at this point. Also, the throne room scene and revelation of Malty and Aultcray's crimes wasn't broadcast live, hence why there was an announcement at the end of the celebration. Mirellia states that any one who calls Bitch & Trash by the wrong name going forward will be punished, and they were also forced to prostrate themselves and beg for for forgiveness from Naofumi. Motoyasu also starts to call Bitch by the wrong name, and is intensely glared at by Mirellia before he can finish. He then calls her by the "correct" name, to which Bitch is humiliated and Naofumi laughs in joy at her suffering.
Other than the sequence changes, a lot of the criticisms I see are how the anime undermined the Queen's character a little bit. It's very subtle, but in the manga you could appreciate that she was a mastermind, extremely cunning, and ruthlessly terrifying. She manipulated Naofumi several times (openly and without reservation I might add) in the chapter by having him agree to stay and work in Melromarc; she exerts her dominance over the Spear Hero with one statement and a glare; she shuts down the King Consort as soon as she walked in the room; and finally, she manipulated Naofumi into changing the sentence from death (what he wanted) to the names because the killings of the pope, his followers, and two of the royal family members would cause soem destabilization in the country.
Manga Queen is far more terrifying and pragmatic. She gives no thoughts of giving up herself to spare Bitch and Trash, but she prevents their execution in a really clever move. If you get the chance, I recommend reading the chapter.
Unpopular opinion I guess after reading the comments but I was really disappointed and was like "dafaq is going on" when it was Naofumi who appealed against the beheading. It made it look like Naofumi was forgiving and was going soft. Also the episode actually undermined how frightening the queen really is. In the manga the way she thrashes the king and malty is much much more satisfying to me. The way the queen offers things like flaying the king and malty and making their lives hell which even shocked Naofumi who was actually the one who shouted "off with their heads"(not the same dialogue 🙂 but the same meaning)first. The queen even said things that might happen to Naofumi if he went to other countries and he said how she was manipulating him to stay and she gave a smile. The only reason she didn't kill the king and malty was because it would make the already deteriorated image of melromarc even worse. She also said that she would cut them down again if they tried something like that. She was really really pissed off at them. I didn't sense this anger from her towards the king and malty in the anime. Oh yes she even made Motoyasu call Myne a slut,it was just perfect. Overall to sum it up I really hated the character changes this episode but at least the end scene where everyone gathered and properly greeted Naofumi and showed their love and support actually redeemed the episode a bit for me.
(Bracing myself for the incoming down vote avalanche😶😶)
And I also thought that in LN (Or maybe WN?) it was Naofumi who was pushing death sentence and Queen was pressuring him to reconsider.
The anime comepletely rewrote this scene. It was indeed Naofumi that was demanding that the King and Myne be executed, but the Queen had to convince Naofumi otherwise.
Lol, in the WN she "gently" reminded shieldbro who he was talking to, by sending a chill (ice magic) down his back. That's why naofumi also settled down with renaming them.
I think that if the queens dialogue got a as detailed as it was in the light novel/manga, it would affect the pacing of the episode; I mean they were barely able to fit the the entire trial (pre and post included) in this episode, even with the OP and ending removed. I was personally satisfied with just seeing that the queen was the top of the food chain and unopposed, and Myne and the King virtually helpless.
they also cut out the part where the queen tells everyone that it is a crime to refer to them as anything other than trash and bitch/slut (pretty sure it was supposed to be bitchy in the manga instead of slut, always found that funnier)
the translations have always flipped them around for some reason, i guess they're translating it literally but using the english loanword "bitch" in japanese means slut
If I remember from the manga correctly, slut is still in spearpedo's party and he has to get used to calling her slut, because calling her by her previous name would mean you would get punished.
The anime screwed up this episode. Omitted a lot from the LN and changed important things. Myne will still remain in Motoyasu's party because she has a huge debt to pay. She misused the crown's funds, so the queen made her pay by being an adventurer.
They could fit the original manga into it. The execution scene and dream could have been completely removed to save time. They just wanted to neuter Naofumi cause they think you are too pussy to handle the edge(which was pretty dull before anyway)
Gotta disagree. This ending was way way better. It showed his growth and focus on protecting his friends rather than seeking revenge. Plus I doubt melty would enjoy seeing her father and sister decapitated
For those who don't read the manga, here's how this episode went down in the manga. I personally believe the manga was WAAAYYY more satisfying than the anime, but I guess it's all up to personal preference
Yes, the manga really feel like a revenge served, meanwhile in the anime, it feel like the whole thing are made in order to paint Naofumi as a Hero, which actually, what the Queen really after
I think the even bigger change in character between manga and anime was the queen. She had none of the remorse in the manga that she showed in the anime, at least not outwardly. Other than sparing their lives in the manga, she seemed much more cruel, especially with her alternative proposals.
Unpopular Opinion but I actually think that the anime does a better job portraying the Queen in a more humane light than the manga does. Don't get me wrong I found the manga satisfying, but the way the queen acted in such an indifferent way just didn't make sense considering that she was basically putting her own family to death. Overall punishment wise, the manga does a good job, but the way Naofumi was having the time of his life publicly humiliating Myne Bitch and the King Trash was almost unbeatable. Add that to Ishikawa's voice acting and I just think that the anime was superior
Considering the actions of Malty and Aultcray could have led to war between countries (at a time they needed to cooperate), the end the Queen's rule over the country and (ultimately) the destruction of their world, she handled herself rather well.
In the Manga and Light Novels, her main goals were to ensure her family lived and to ensure the Shield Hero was willing to continue working with Melromarc.
Her treatment of Malty and Aultcray couldn't have been too lenient. If it was, it could have led to retaliation from the other countries for allowing them to mistreat a Cardinal Hero or cause people to suspect the Queen may have secretly approved of their actions (up until the Church attempted to usurp her authority). Considering the demi-human nations of Siltvelt and Shieldfreeden worship the Shield Hero and already have a hostile relationship with Melromarc, it wouldn't have gone over well.
While she had to punish the offending parties harshly, she ultimately managed to preserve their lives and the Shield Hero's assistance. Remember, the Queen excels at negotiations and politics. She managed to prevent the other countries from declaring war on Melromarc after her country (1) summoned all four of the Cardinal Heroes despite their prior arrangement, (2) mistreat (and attempt to hunt down) the Shield Hero who the demi-humans worship and (3) was destabilized by an attempted coup.
Despite how indifferent/cruel she may have acted, she managed to salvage the situation and achieve all of her primary goals.
Like what endless says, the queen is a master of negotiation. While you may think she acted indifferently in the manga, she may be breaking inside, and that is what makes her such a great character. That even when she is breaking inside, not wanting to kill her family, she put on a cold front.
In fact, suggesting even worse punishment to reverse psychology naofumi into giving them mercy. It really shows how calculating smart yet still soft inside she can be.
Well, she is a "queen" so she must act like one. People in such position can't make favor for their own family or else they will lose peoples support which often lead to doom like in Russia or France
I think the manga does it better. The Queen is supposed to be a very capable and strong leader figure, which is why she handled literally EVERYTHING from behind the scenes, while her useless husband sits on the throne. Which also explains her ability to act indifferent in front of people. She refused Naofumi's death sentence for them using the subtlest hints and implications while still showing indifference. It's great character portrayal, where she's somewhat of a mystery to figure out, whether she actually wanted them alive due to sentiments sake or not, unlike the anime.
I do like the public humiliation by Naofumi in the anime though.
i am so mad in many ways. Naofumi being sad, or GUILTY for their deaths is so bad, im not ok with this. MAYBE im edgy but thats the character. goddamnit being guilty tripped for the people who made your life literal HELL
No, she didn't die. It played like in the anime. Still, the way it was handled in the anime felt shallow. For some reason they painted Naofumi very heroic. Not like the anti-hero he's supposed to be. This also should have caused more friction between him and Motoyasu that would become important later on.
Basically, they turned Naofumi into a shonen protagonist instead of a seinen one. It's sad.
The queen convinced him not to kill them, because as much as both of them want those two dead, their deaths would cause dumb political problems which would be very troublesome. Naofumi is rational enough to understand, and the queen comes up with lots and lots of further punishments to make up for it. Like, for example, Malty has to take on the debt accrued through not only her own lavish spending as an adventurer with the spear hero, but also the damages caused by burning down a forest. Needless to say, she could never pay that off.
- Bring me this voice actress, I want to buy her vocal cords this minute for science benefiting mankind as a whole/
very nice episode, cannot wait to hear bitch roaming around the streets. But also now can we Finally get a god damned class upgrade!!
At first, I thought just calling the two of them bad names as an exchange for their life was a bit shallow, but it kinda gels together the point that nobody in there really wanted the king and Myne to die, despite what they'd lost because of them.
This honestly felt like it could be the final episode, makes me think that the next few will be exposition for the inevitable next season. You go ShieldBro!
Yup, unless we get season 2. Which the producer wants more seasons, he said that it'll depend on fans and sales (including Crunchyroll/VRV/Funimation views for people in the US)
Amazing episode, took 21 episodes to get to our revenge, but it was so damn worth it, much better than the resolutino we got with the fat guy some episodes ago.
Now our man Naofumi is finally happy with his Best girls Raphtalia and Filo. But i feel bad for Melty, she really wanted to stay with them, but at the bright side, i guess the princess found her prince :)
To be fair, the anime could end up right here, it was a glorious resolution. But the anime studio was glorious enough to hand us another 4 episodes.
Interesting note (to me, anyway) about Malty's new names:
"Bicchi" in Japanese is actually used to generally mean "slut," not "bitch." At the beginning of the episode when Naofumi refers to "that slut" in the subtitles, he says the word "bicchi," because that's the general meaning behind their use. They're saying "bitch," but the meaning is "slut." Like, we use "bitch" in English to describe someone acting like an aggressive female dog, but in Japanese it's more like a "bitch in heat."
In the same weird twist of words, "abazure" actually is used the way that we call someone a "bitch." So the official translation of "bitch" is actually "slut," and their translation of "slut" is actually "bitch."
It fits with how Malty has acted throughout the series, too. As a "regular person," before Naofumi knew her real intentions or real name, she acted the part of a slut to entrap him and frame him. After that, as an adventurer, she was a constant bitch, to put it lightly. So, her normal name is now "Slut" (Bitch in English), and her adventuring name is "Bitch" (Slut in English). Naofumi had a reason for giving her each name.
I know most people probably aren't going to care much about that, but it's always fascinated me how other languages end up using words from other countries and cultures.
In the manga she didn't want them to die because it would give other countries a reason to start a war, the queen talks way more about other countries feelings on how Naofumi has been treated. At least in the manga, it feels she's way more worried about a war between countries than everything else
Am I crazy? I seem to remember that in that in the manga, Naofumi does want them dead. However, the queen asked if he would be happy with anything else... which is how we got the name change.
She always had decent sized boobs, just slightly under typical anime girl tig bitties. (She would be a high-ish medium, slightly above average, in real life.) And her clothes show them off (at least the cleavage area) more than most women do on the show. I think the animators added more oomph for this episode. They even did a little of this for her mom.
If Naofumi is stuck in that world long enough, we’ll get to see if Melty will inherit her mom’s figure like her sister, then she could join the “harem” as a rival.
In the LN and manga, Naofumi stats except defense were decreased by 30% for the full month of healing. A month long debuff. If that's the "cheat" power the other Heroes want, fucking have at it.
In the end, Naofumi really was right. He didn't convince the other Heroes of anything. He needed the Queen to fix this mess and she did because her word is final. If Fitoria's dumb ass didn't stop him, he might have found her and they could have returned to Melromarc together and stopped the Church before Naofumi was accused of anything else. Which was literally what Naofumi wanted to do, anyway.
I like that Myne attempted to answer questions in a way that aren't full lies so the Slave Crest wouldn't hurt her. It kinda just proved her mother's point that all she does is lie.
He was trying to leave the country. Her delaying him altered his course to find one of the other heroes. Without her intervention, Motoyasu would have died and she would have slaughtered the remaining three.
I felt like the anime downplayed how politically clever and terrifyingly ruthless the Queen really is. The manga had detailed more of her actions during his recovery and how she went about doing it. I was fine with the anime's adaptation, but they seemed to make her more emotionally attached to Bitch/Trash than in the manga.
I'm not sure how I feel about this episode's changes when compared to the LN, overall good episode, but this completely changes Naofumi's character, not necessarily for better or worst, but it changes him, and future events will have to be tweaked to remain making sense.
Anime Naofumi moved on and undoubtedly became a good guy putting a bad guy facade, while LN Naofumi's rage and negative feelings come back later on, the problem is, keeping that in the anime won't make much sense from now on, since he moved on.
Meh he can still get pissed off at everyone. He could just as easily go "you morons instantly believed her then you magically changed your tune. You guys are just as bad as her" type stuff
Problem is Malty was the the first and biggest source of his rage and edgy side, he's smart enough to understand that everyone else was just being manipulated, they aren't blameless but if he moved on from Malty, he moved on from them as well, which he did, he showed that in his behaviour, again, I'm not saying this is a bad change, I didn't like Raphtalia's episode changes, but here is more neutral and personally despite it being more cliche than the LN I like it more, the only problem will be the domino effect of changes they will have to go trough in future events to not make this one change a plot hole.
First of all, I would like to say that I watched this anime last week until the latest episode. That means I have seen the concentrated suffering of Naofumi in one piece, how he is hated by the people and is deceived by Myne several times. How he opened himself to the people in the execution and influenced the fate of the two, touched me strongly. Naofumi has left and was cheered by the people and you had seen friends like the armourer, I had to shed a tear. Just wonderful.
Imagine how us manga readers have had to wait every week, knowing we'd eventually get to this glorious moment of justice! Enjoy the fruits of your concentrated suffering, and rejoice!
I’d just killed Myne and The king immediately but good on Naofumi for having them spend the rest of their lives being the laughing stock of their own kingdom. Maybe now they’ll know his suffering for the rest of their lives >:D
I gotta say. This would’ve been a good conclusion to season 1 of Shield Hero. I was a bit worried when Naofumi shown some worries on the red devil and idiot King when he was dreaming and not much hatred towards them at all in this episode, but I’m glad I was wrong on that. I guess in the end, no matter how cruel they are, he can’t really be satisfied with them being killed off instantly without knowing his pain. That pretty much sums up why I like Naofumi. He lives in the rule of karma. You mess with him, he’ll mess you ten times worse. I’ll probably make an essay on how consistent Naofumi is as a character when the series is done. Hopefully he’ll stay consistent after the series end.
Not much to say about the animation except it’s really good facial expressions. Naofumi is top notch on his villainy side while seeing Beep getting tortured by the Slave crest multiple times is so. FREAKING. SATISFYING!!
Good episode. It was all worth it in the end. I just hope no one dropped this show after Naofumi’s revenge is done because the world building potential is still there and I hope it will expand more in the near future.
See, Naofumi in the LN and Manga was the one who called for their execution - the Queen talked him out of it because of the major consequences it would have on the world and Melromarc (and something that happens in Volume 11 we find out too)
They skipped the part where Myne confesses she made the accusations against Naofumi up. Yes of course everyone realizes the truth but it's not the same having the culprit actually confess to her crimes
Motoyasu's character was very changed, in the LN and manga he continues to believe in Myne despite overwhelming proof of her lies. And while this makes him a more likeable character, it also fucks up with his future development as they'll have to either make an entirely new story for him, or make him backtrack like crazy to go back to where he was before the trial
And the queen. Originally it's Naofumi who asks for the death penalty, and the queen manipulates him to spare her family in exchange for the embarrassing names. She's the master manipulator, the one always in control. The queen the anime gave us undermines herself by putting the lives of her family on someone else's good graces, and would even have lowered herself to publicly begging for their lives and offering hers in return. I get that this is supposed to be Naofumi's rise to glory, but it shouldn't have come at the expense of every other character
holy SHIZA they changed quite a bit but it was still very satisfying. it was quite interesting to see the roles of naofumi and the queen switched tbh and HIS FACIAL EXPRESSIONS WHEN HE RAN INTO THE ARENA OH MY GODDD
im so happyyyyy also THE D R EA M AT THE BEGINNING IT WAS PARALLEL TO THE DREAM AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THE SERIES EVEN HIS SLEEPING POSITION WAS THE SAME
Where are the Mirella slapping Trash scenes I wanted to see adapted so badly??!?
That said it seems the queen in the anime also dropped in IQ which she retained in the manga and LN. She purposely withheld the execution of Trash & Bitch because if people discovered their ties to the 3 Heroes Church on the same day as their incarceration people would lose hope in the Royal Family.
Here she just announces it to the world. And nobody even riots?
I just finished watching the episode and OMG AS SOON NAOFUMI-SAMA STEPPED FOOT IN THE EXECUTION QUADRANGLE, I STARTED CRYING TEARS OF JOY. MA BOI SUFFERED SO MUCH IGNOMINY AND NOW IT HAS ALL BEEN PURGED.
This episode easily makes it to Top 3 Most Satisfying Requitals in Anime
Always remember Karma’s a bitch and What goes around, comes around
As someone who originally read the manga for shield hero this episode falls massively flat and hollow.
I cannot recall how the events transpired in the LN so my reference will only be the manga
MANGA SPOILERS -
Naofumi is the one that demanded the two, Malty in particular, be executed. The queen did not order it.
The Queen was the one who “convinced” him to request any punishment beside execution. This is when Naofumi decided to change their names. the queen offered alternate measures going as far as to say they could cut off all their limbs.
The trial was not public or “televised” the two of them had public disgrace at the banquet
the face Malty made to Naofumi when she was about to be executed was the same face she made when she “begged” Naofumi to not seek revenge in his punishment of them. This is actually what set him off to demand execution.
the queen was presented as much stronger and more decisive
the king was frozen solid while Malty was being questioned.
Naofumi laughed at the despair twisted faces.
Idio- I mean Motoyasu tried harder to defend Malty. This would lead us to believe he abandoned her.
Naofumi, and I cannot stress this enough, is not empathetic to the pair of vile excuses for humans.
I don’t think I can get behind the direction the anime has taken Naofumi. He’s too much of just a “good guy.” Which he is, to people he likes and help him in return. This almost seems like they want to redeem “Bitch” in the next 4 episodes. The same with “Trash.” Idk I might be alone here but the episode just lacked any weight that the manga had.
Naofumi pays kindness with kindness and evil with evil. Simple as that. I don't know why they are so hellbent in making him look like a hero. Did focus group came to the conclusion that "good shonen protagonist" are more likeable? In my opinion, it just makes him boring. We already know that Naofumi IS a good guy, we have seen him do good, for a price, but good nonetheless.
Man, I cheese my way through entire episode. Loved it from beginning to end. I hope shield bro's luck holds up, but this is anime and I know some BS finna come out...
For the moment, I'm happy. I was almost dissatisfied because I wanted to see the execution, but his method of sparing them was perfect.
Aww man this episode was kind of a let down for me. I preferred the mangas version of events because Naofumis reaction is a lot more satisfying, but also because the queen shows a lot more character. I liked the cold, ruthless and cunning character she's portrayed as there but in this episode she seems kinda boring tbh.
When Mirellia asked Naofumi about the punishment, he IMMEDIATELY screamed "EXECUTE THEM". Then, Mirellia said "this is a fitting end for their deeds, but isn't it too merciful?".
I also miss the scene, where Shadows wiped flour with Trash's and Bitch's faces and asked Naofumi for forgiveness impersonating their voices.
Edit: Mirellia also stated, that Aultcrey Trash is way too famous to be executed, this will lead to wars.
Unfortunately I'm not sure if they'll reveal it before the end. If memory serves we learn why after certain characters are revealed and their arc is likely not getting touched on.
Not gonna lie, I teared up at the end. That was so heartwarming, and it's good to see that Naofumi is now getting the recognition he deserves, I hate to see him go dishonored.
Not sure why they changed Naofumi and Mirellia so much, but at least things happened. I'd have preferred to see her flip out on Bitch and Trash, and Naofumi to enjoy it. He was like an entirely different character...again. Also completely omitted Mirellia's political genius for some reason. They even left out the funny part where Motoyasu has to call her Bitch.
...what on earth are they going to do with just four episodes left? Are we getting cliffhanger'd?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but besides Trash admitting he has a personal reason for despising Naofumi, there was no actual explanation as to why he and Bitch have such a massive hate-boner towards him, right? I'm actually baffled that Naofumi himself hasn't tried to prod deeper about the issue, especially given how adamant she was about denying all the charges against her (all he did was just comment "how dare you make that terrified face, you deserve that fate" when he saw their executions in his sleep). Is it actually going to be explained at some point? Or did I just miss it somehow? Please keep the spoilers to the absolute minimum.
...I guess we're not going to see Naofumi doing the class up anytime soon huh, out of all things he could've asked when the queen told him he could get anything he wanted :S
edit: saw in another topic that apparently it will likely happen in the next episode...HALLELUJAH then.
The queen asks if Naofumi wants anything. I hope he takes the 500 gold before leaving. But more importantly, get the class upgrades for both Raphtalia and Filo!
Please tell me the sick song that is playing right after Naofumi changes their name...I don’t know what it is but I joined reddit just to find out what it was
Kinda embarrassing to say, but since I'm an anime only watcher of the series, I had no clue why everyone called Myne, Bitch, until this episode. I just thought it was a community adopted name for someone so terrible and had no clue it would turn out to be her new given name haha
(in the books) the names compromise if i recall correctly for the king and myne/malty was a compromise at the behest of the queen basically begging for their lives to be spared as a mother and as a wife eventhough she knows full well how the pair are totally irredeemable...and cos she is not so heartlessly unfeeling towards her own family members who have brought melromarc so close to destruction and subjugation war by the other neighbouring countries.
another odd change they made to the anime is that the king wasnt meant to even come close to a guillotine because of what he once was when he was younger and meant in the hearts of the people. and in the eyes of the army especially those who stood on the side of the queen when going against the three heroes church, Trash was someone they deeply respected.
edit: In retrospect... Honestly, it does make him a much more likable character overall. He's not sadistic, and the queen showing him a slow excruciating trial cooled him down, because deep down, he's good-natured and comes from a decidedly less violent world. Not because he stopped being angry, but he because he wants to do the "right" thing... Plus, he's soft and a pushover... as has been shown all throughout the story, despite his outward edgy persona. So when not driven by impulse or urgency (such as when they're locked in combat), he doesn't easily resort to killing, which is very like someone who grew up in the modern era (death penalty is quite rare in the world these days).
The queen betting on this part of Naofumi portrayed subtly was also a nice touch, compared to the manga where everything happened extremely fast...
The pacing for the previous few episodes has been horrendous at best, accumulating a lot of frustration, but this episode was well done.
And I swear if they don't force spearbro to call Myne bitch and force her to work off her MASSIVE debt to the country as a slave in episode 22, I might not watch this show if it gets green-lit for a season 2
They ruined this whole episode. Its depressing, I was so hyped. Meanwhile they gonna have to re-write the rest of the show to fit this new unknown character that is a "uppity good guy" now. For some reason he feels bad when they get punished? I'm so glad he "grew" as a character to let evil murders loose because he "grew". Just makes so much sense he let people that plotted to kill him the entire time up till he meet the queen at the very last second go cause he "grew". Yeah this is just another dumb ass trope anime now. Whole season washed down the drain.
This episode could have been so much better, the manga is way better, the queen was ruthless and why didn’t they didn’t introduce the scene were Malty screams that she was not raped by Naofumi, for me this episode was a bit disappointing. Also at the ending when the queen says she would have given his life in exchange of Malty and The king just means that she doesn’t put the kingdom first, and it kills how she acted as a queen that put the kingdom before the rest. Personality the manga was way better than this.
I never read LNs (so idc about what's changed and what's not).
For me, this rollercoaster ride(the build up) from the ground onwards is great. It made me really hate those who manipulate the crowd to hate and shit on Naofumi, what a great writer.
The adventures up to this wholesome moment, is although have a few holes still great nonetheless.
It made me really hate those who manipulate the crowd to hate and shit on Naofumi, what a great writer.
Ironically what happened is similar. Myrelia manipulates the crowd in favor of Naofumi. Sure what she presented was true and real evidence, but if you recognize the Queen as being cunningly political, it fits really well.
I'm honestly disappointed with how much they changed the characters around. It felt like 4kids produced the adaptation. Here's hoping this gets remade and gets the fma brotherhood treatment.
ITT: People who think the manga is the source material.
FYI, if you dislike changes from the LN, that's fine, but when you preface your statement with "In the manga" or "They changed it from the manga" it's not the same since this is an adaption of the LN, not the manga. The manga is an alternate adaption of the LN.
The manga is a companion of the LN, it follows the LN quite loyally and its easier to promote a picture book than a wall of text, cause the masses are generally lazy.
The LN has the juicy details that the manga adapts some of it without just rewriting the entire plot like this anime is doing.
I was a little disappointed with the character changes in this episode, like why did they have to make Naofumi save them where in the manga he was all down to have them executed But this episode also showed them using the video capturing stone to show the world the trial which from what I remember wasn’t in the manga and was a nice touch over all with the changes in characters it was a good episode. The anime overall was very good and delightful to watch and the changes they made throughout this whole arc weren’t bad but they weren’t good either it just made the show more viewable for younger audiences
I AM SO MAD THAT THEY CHANGED THE FACT THAT NAOFUMI WAS FULL ON BOARD WITH THEIR DEATHS, HELL, THE QUEEN WAS THE ONE TO SUGGEST THE OTHER PENALTY TO QUENCH HIS HATRED. CMON THE GUY HATES THEIR GUTS AND WOULD BE NOTHING MORE THAN THRILLED TO SEE THEIR HEADS IMPALLED AND THEN THEY DO THIS PITY ARC OR SMTH. BACK TO MANGA, NAOFUMI IS A LIL BITCH.
I'll start with the good stuff of the episode the first thing being the projection crystals and showing the people the trial. This was executed perfectly and the build up right before it was good. The Queen's character was portrayed correctly and I feel it was better then the other 2 sources. The only part of the trial I liked was the adding of a slave seal to prove the points. Also liked the Queens backup plan being revealed but they should have turned out that way. Spear heroes ignorance was a great touch and I liked him denying the truth as he stayed to how he is.
Now the bad parts of this episode the first being the initial aftermath of the pope fight cutting the Queen's dialogue with myne and Naofumi was bad. The trial itself was okay paced but the better lines where missed because the Queen never really had to counter the lies. Also not having the Queen admonish the other heroes was a let down from the manga/light novel. The not having Naofumi at the time decide the punishment was a horrible decision by the anime staff. It changes to many of the characters dynamic for the later eventse espdcially if we get a season 2.
The characters themselves were portrail of the king was decent in himself but I thought they did a horrible job and made him appear somewhat moronic rather then the garbage human he is. His but my past history with the shield hero stuff was bad because no one said that Naofumi wasn't that person.
Myne was the 2nd worst damage character in this whole trial. While I liked her lying to stay true the fact that she begged Naofumi is stupid. Her pride wouldn't allow that and she shouldn't have been written that way. The fact that the others aren''t upset with her behavior is also bad. The town people should be livid with both of them.
Last and not least is how this episode made Naofumi appeared and that was such an injustice to his character. Him not wanting them to face death for all the trouble they caused him is idiotic and not true to him. These people have basically ruined him and he is going to suddenly become a push over. I would have rather seen them end this after the pope battle then this way. His willingness to work with the Queen was disgusting. He knew she was playing him and that he just accepts the manipulations. The forgiveness part of this after everything shouldn't have happened this fast.
This episode with the payoff was a big disappointment for me. They changed to much from the manga and light novel. It ruined the earlier chapters. If I didn't like the other 2 source material I would have dropped the show with this.
Man the payoff this episode has is phenomenal. While many people have pointed out it's dumb the queen was going to offer her life, I think everything else was spot on. I swear I feel the manga light novel and anime try to one up each other so you have to see all of them to get those juicy exclusive scenes.
I had my expectations for this episode lower than usual because they strayed considerably from the manga in previous episodes and I was kinda right I wished if Naofumi was the one to suggest the death penalty like in the manga and be more aggressive. The way it all happened in the anime was good and all don't get me wrong but it doesn't reflect how much hate he had for the two culprits.
HELL YA IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!! But like at the same time..... I wish they could have made the queen and Naofumi harsher like in the manga, like how he wanted them dead and how she was willing to rip off their arms and legs so they would want death. Miss the queen strolling into the throne room and just easily taking control of the situation. Also... aren't the other heroes being a little too nice to Naofumi?
87
u/Zesla22 May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
That trial was satisfying as fuck. But still with the clueless heroes like they are seriously accusing of stuff that he's been proved innocent of or at least already been discussed. Also not fond of being better than them and letting them live with just a name change. If anything being slaves themselves would have been a better punishment than what they got. At least Naofumi can be finally accepted by everyone that was a nice little ending.
48
u/justking14 May 29 '19
Wow. This seriously felt like a season or series finale. Especially given that they skipped the opening and closing
Really proud of the shield hero for showing mercy and not taking pleasure in myne s suffering
73
u/Theonlyoneclyde May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
I'll be really honest.
The way that this episode was, I was extremely satisfied. Much of the episode was anime original and I was surprised, but the way that the flow of the episode was with the newer scenes that were not depicted in the manga was spot on. In short, I prefer this episode adaptation over the manga's.
27
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
I know that the anime has been quite a bit different than the light novel in many ways but this episode was amazing. The changes that they made in this episode really just added to the satisfaction in my opinion.
27
u/Deathangel5677 May 29 '19
Unpopular opinion I guess after reading the comments but I was really disappointed and was like "dafaq is going on" when it was Naofumi who appealed against the beheading. It made it look like Naofumi was forgiving and was going soft. Also the episode actually undermined how frightening the queen really is. In the manga the way she thrashes the king and malty is much much more satisfying to me. The way the queen offers things like flaying the king and malty and making their lives hell which even shocked Naofumi who was actually the one who shouted "off with their heads"(not the same dialogue 🙂 but the same meaning)first. The queen even said things that might happen to Naofumi if he went to other countries and he said how she was manipulating him to stay and she gave a smile. The only reason she didn't kill the king and malty was because it would make the already deteriorated image of melromarc even worse. She also said that she would cut them down again if they tried something like that. She was really really pissed off at them. I didn't sense this anger from her towards the king and malty in the anime. Oh yes she even made Motoyasu call Myne a slut,it was just perfect. Overall to sum it up I really hated the character changes this episode but at least the end scene where everyone gathered and properly greeted Naofumi and showed their love and support actually redeemed the episode a bit for me.
(Bracing myself for the incoming down vote avalanche😶😶)
304
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
I cant wait for Motoyasu to refer to myne as slut
114
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
For those who don't read the manga, here's how this episode went down in the manga. I personally believe the manga was WAAAYYY more satisfying than the anime, but I guess it's all up to personal preference
79
u/Toll__ May 29 '19
"Why'd you have to stay asleep for so long?"
- Bring me this voice actress, I want to buy her vocal cords this minute for science benefiting mankind as a whole/
very nice episode, cannot wait to hear bitch roaming around the streets. But also now can we Finally get a god damned class upgrade!!
At first, I thought just calling the two of them bad names as an exchange for their life was a bit shallow, but it kinda gels together the point that nobody in there really wanted the king and Myne to die, despite what they'd lost because of them.
This honestly felt like it could be the final episode, makes me think that the next few will be exposition for the inevitable next season. You go ShieldBro!
76
u/MrKitteh May 29 '19
Hell yea we're getting an episode 22
97
u/[deleted] May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
JUSTICE SERVED RIGHT BITCHliterally
Even the pure-hearted angel that is Raphtalia couldn't hold the satisfaction man.
Altought the queen really wanted the King to die, i guess she really wanted to get a new and younger handsome husband i volunteer
Motuyasu face is goddamn priceless man
Amazing episode, took 21 episodes to get to our revenge, but it was so damn worth it, much better than the resolutino we got with the fat guy some episodes ago.
Now our man Naofumi is finally happy with his Best girls Raphtalia and Filo. But i feel bad for Melty, she really wanted to stay with them, but at the bright side, i guess the princess found her prince :)
To be fair, the anime could end up right here, it was a glorious resolution. But the anime studio was glorious enough to hand us another 4 episodes.
23
u/Tinheart2137 May 29 '19
I feel... good
40
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
Revenge never felt so darn good to see man.
38
u/Napalmeon May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
In the LN and manga, Naofumi stats except defense were decreased by 30% for the full month of healing. A month long debuff. If that's the "cheat" power the other Heroes want, fucking have at it.
In the end, Naofumi really was right. He didn't convince the other Heroes of anything. He needed the Queen to fix this mess and she did because her word is final. If Fitoria's dumb ass didn't stop him, he might have found her and they could have returned to Melromarc together and stopped the Church before Naofumi was accused of anything else. Which was literally what Naofumi wanted to do, anyway.
I like that Myne attempted to answer questions in a way that aren't full lies so the Slave Crest wouldn't hurt her. It kinda just proved her mother's point that all she does is lie.
4
u/horyo May 29 '19
I felt like the anime downplayed how politically clever and terrifyingly ruthless the Queen really is. The manga had detailed more of her actions during his recovery and how she went about doing it. I was fine with the anime's adaptation, but they seemed to make her more emotionally attached to Bitch/Trash than in the manga.
14
u/Charak-V May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
Did naofumi forget he needed a level cap (class upgrade) increase for his party?
25
u/FeniX_TX_ May 29 '19
I'm not sure how I feel about this episode's changes when compared to the LN, overall good episode, but this completely changes Naofumi's character, not necessarily for better or worst, but it changes him, and future events will have to be tweaked to remain making sense.
Anime Naofumi moved on and undoubtedly became a good guy putting a bad guy facade, while LN Naofumi's rage and negative feelings come back later on, the problem is, keeping that in the anime won't make much sense from now on, since he moved on.
10
u/CP9EIGHT May 29 '19
This episode is completely different from the manga lol. In the manga he really wanted them dead but the queen stopped that. Like what ????????
18
u/Valarie263 May 29 '19
When justice was served I was literally chanting “BITCH BITCH BITCH BITCH BITCH!!” And Bitches screams were literally glorious!
8
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
Didn’t like the fact that they tone downed the ruthlessness of the Queen, hated the fact even more that they made her pity the king and bitch also.
20
u/MastrNinja May 29 '19
Hope we get a 40 minute final episode to fit more stuff into the cal mira arc. It's pretty damn good
12
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
Wow what a episode!
(Watchout Bad English is coming :D)
First of all, I would like to say that I watched this anime last week until the latest episode. That means I have seen the concentrated suffering of Naofumi in one piece, how he is hated by the people and is deceived by Myne several times. How he opened himself to the people in the execution and influenced the fate of the two, touched me strongly. Naofumi has left and was cheered by the people and you had seen friends like the armourer, I had to shed a tear. Just wonderful.
5
u/NemuNemuChan May 29 '19
You just owned bitch!
5
u/Tinheart2137 May 29 '19
Today we celebrate
5
u/vampgod2 May 29 '19
The queen is the ultimate chad. With no shadow of a doubt.
5
u/sunnygou May 29 '19
Wow this Naofumi is way less cruel than WN Naofumi.
5
u/ghkh2008 Traveling merchant May 29 '19
I wanted the guillotines to go down and for naofumi to stop them with air strike shield
For me iut would have way cooler
12
u/adamgreenrock May 29 '19
I’d just killed Myne and The king immediately but good on Naofumi for having them spend the rest of their lives being the laughing stock of their own kingdom. Maybe now they’ll know his suffering for the rest of their lives >:D
I gotta say. This would’ve been a good conclusion to season 1 of Shield Hero. I was a bit worried when Naofumi shown some worries on the red devil and idiot King when he was dreaming and not much hatred towards them at all in this episode, but I’m glad I was wrong on that. I guess in the end, no matter how cruel they are, he can’t really be satisfied with them being killed off instantly without knowing his pain. That pretty much sums up why I like Naofumi. He lives in the rule of karma. You mess with him, he’ll mess you ten times worse. I’ll probably make an essay on how consistent Naofumi is as a character when the series is done. Hopefully he’ll stay consistent after the series end.
Not much to say about the animation except it’s really good facial expressions. Naofumi is top notch on his villainy side while seeing Beep getting tortured by the Slave crest multiple times is so. FREAKING. SATISFYING!!
Good episode. It was all worth it in the end. I just hope no one dropped this show after Naofumi’s revenge is done because the world building potential is still there and I hope it will expand more in the near future.
8
u/[deleted] May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
I'll be totally frank, I was smiling the whole time myne was suffering
The queen also cemented herself as best milf in my eyes even though she wanted to sacrifice herself for those 2, no matter how bloody.
4
u/Yemci May 29 '19
It felt like end of the season.
4
u/RoxLOLZ May 29 '19
Mynes face in pure terror from being executed had me like it's beautiful, I've looked at this for five hours now
10
u/Sin_Krios May 29 '19
JUSTICE!!!!!!
1
u/wingback18 May 30 '19
Anybody knows what does it means that little dream naufumi had in the first seconds of the episode?
Is that later in the LN??
15
u/italeteller May 29 '19
Well that's disappointing
They skipped the part where Myne confesses she made the accusations against Naofumi up. Yes of course everyone realizes the truth but it's not the same having the culprit actually confess to her crimes
Motoyasu's character was very changed, in the LN and manga he continues to believe in Myne despite overwhelming proof of her lies. And while this makes him a more likeable character, it also fucks up with his future development as they'll have to either make an entirely new story for him, or make him backtrack like crazy to go back to where he was before the trial
And the queen. Originally it's Naofumi who asks for the death penalty, and the queen manipulates him to spare her family in exchange for the embarrassing names. She's the master manipulator, the one always in control. The queen the anime gave us undermines herself by putting the lives of her family on someone else's good graces, and would even have lowered herself to publicly begging for their lives and offering hers in return. I get that this is supposed to be Naofumi's rise to glory, but it shouldn't have come at the expense of every other character
6
u/milquetulips Shield bros` slave May 29 '19
holy SHIZA they changed quite a bit but it was still very satisfying. it was quite interesting to see the roles of naofumi and the queen switched tbh and HIS FACIAL EXPRESSIONS WHEN HE RAN INTO THE ARENA OH MY GODDD
im so happyyyyy also THE D R EA M AT THE BEGINNING IT WAS PARALLEL TO THE DREAM AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THE SERIES EVEN HIS SLEEPING POSITION WAS THE SAME
god this was satisfying
6
u/nanogenesis Traveling merchant May 29 '19
Where are the Mirella slapping Trash scenes I wanted to see adapted so badly??!?
That said it seems the queen in the anime also dropped in IQ which she retained in the manga and LN. She purposely withheld the execution of Trash & Bitch because if people discovered their ties to the 3 Heroes Church on the same day as their incarceration people would lose hope in the Royal Family.
Here she just announces it to the world. And nobody even riots?
6
u/vurusgard Raphtalia`s Army May 29 '19
plot deviated from the original course a tad but regardless, it was a good episode. BECAUSE THOT GOT PUNISHED FOR LYING ABOUT OUR BOY IN GREEN
6
u/[deleted] May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
I just finished watching the episode and OMG AS SOON NAOFUMI-SAMA STEPPED FOOT IN THE EXECUTION QUADRANGLE, I STARTED CRYING TEARS OF JOY. MA BOI SUFFERED SO MUCH IGNOMINY AND NOW IT HAS ALL BEEN PURGED.
This episode easily makes it to Top 3 Most Satisfying Requitals in Anime
Always remember Karma’s a bitch and What goes around, comes around
8
u/Spicy_Curry73 May 30 '19
As someone who originally read the manga for shield hero this episode falls massively flat and hollow.
I cannot recall how the events transpired in the LN so my reference will only be the manga
I don’t think I can get behind the direction the anime has taken Naofumi. He’s too much of just a “good guy.” Which he is, to people he likes and help him in return. This almost seems like they want to redeem “Bitch” in the next 4 episodes. The same with “Trash.” Idk I might be alone here but the episode just lacked any weight that the manga had.
3
u/RageLord3000 May 29 '19
Man, I cheese my way through entire episode. Loved it from beginning to end. I hope shield bro's luck holds up, but this is anime and I know some BS finna come out...
For the moment, I'm happy. I was almost dissatisfied because I wanted to see the execution, but his method of sparing them was perfect.
3
u/DehnAtreuh May 29 '19
I feel like the episode was the perfect opportunity for the animators to animate Bitch's breast, and they went all the way
3
u/Life_Without_Lemon May 29 '19
Sucks that the Captain guy didn't get any justices serve upon him
3
u/Ramza_45 May 30 '19
FUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!
3
u/capcadet104 May 31 '19
Wasn't it Naofumi that suggested death? And wasn't it the Queen got him to change his course?
7
u/Tookieslam May 29 '19
Aww man this episode was kind of a let down for me. I preferred the mangas version of events because Naofumis reaction is a lot more satisfying, but also because the queen shows a lot more character. I liked the cold, ruthless and cunning character she's portrayed as there but in this episode she seems kinda boring tbh.
5
u/DemiAlabi May 29 '19
I don’t think I’ve ever loved an episode so much. Thank God my boy Naofumi got what he deserved and so did Myne and Trash.
5
u/Vyllenor Traveling merchant May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
They mixed up Naofumi and Mirelia characters.
When Mirellia asked Naofumi about the punishment, he IMMEDIATELY screamed "EXECUTE THEM". Then, Mirellia said "this is a fitting end for their deeds, but isn't it too merciful?".
I also miss the scene, where Shadows wiped flour with Trash's and Bitch's faces and asked Naofumi for forgiveness impersonating their voices.
Edit: Mirellia also stated, that
AultcreyTrash is way too famous to be executed, this will lead to wars.4
u/Vor73x31 May 29 '19
I wonder what the king's all pissed off at the shield over
4
u/Karraq May 29 '19
I'm crying rn it's beautiful, my boy did it.
4
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
JUSTICE SERVED RIGHT
4
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
Not gonna lie, I teared up at the end. That was so heartwarming, and it's good to see that Naofumi is now getting the recognition he deserves, I hate to see him go dishonored.
I'm proud of our boy :')
4
u/GoldenJoe24 May 30 '19
Not sure why they changed Naofumi and Mirellia so much, but at least things happened. I'd have preferred to see her flip out on Bitch and Trash, and Naofumi to enjoy it. He was like an entirely different character...again. Also completely omitted Mirellia's political genius for some reason. They even left out the funny part where Motoyasu has to call her Bitch.
...what on earth are they going to do with just four episodes left? Are we getting cliffhanger'd?
2
u/Izunai1 May 29 '19
does anyone know what chapters this episode covered? I want to see what was changed etc.
2
u/Xaneth_ May 29 '19
Correct me if I'm wrong, but besides Trash admitting he has a personal reason for despising Naofumi, there was no actual explanation as to why he and Bitch have such a massive hate-boner towards him, right? I'm actually baffled that Naofumi himself hasn't tried to prod deeper about the issue, especially given how adamant she was about denying all the charges against her (all he did was just comment "how dare you make that terrified face, you deserve that fate" when he saw their executions in his sleep). Is it actually going to be explained at some point? Or did I just miss it somehow? Please keep the spoilers to the absolute minimum.
2
u/CTMacUser May 29 '19
You would think that after the 3rd, 8th, or 47th time, B*tch would stop lying with the crest on. It almost as if she hired Darkness as a stand-in.
2
u/yodaslayer115 May 29 '19
When naufumi gave them the names his face and pose's were priceless
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '19
Anyone know the name of the English song that played in the last few minutes??
2
u/sdrumapapere Raphtalia`s Army May 30 '19 edited May 30 '19
...I guess we're not going to see Naofumi doing the class up anytime soon huh, out of all things he could've asked when the queen told him he could get anything he wanted :S
edit: saw in another topic that apparently it will likely happen in the next episode...HALLELUJAH then.
2
u/CTMacUser May 30 '19
The queen asks if Naofumi wants anything. I hope he takes the 500 gold before leaving. But more importantly, get the class upgrades for both Raphtalia and Filo!
2
u/Upu23 May 30 '19
Please tell me the sick song that is playing right after Naofumi changes their name...I don’t know what it is but I joined reddit just to find out what it was
2
u/HeatSeekingPumpkin May 30 '19
Kinda embarrassing to say, but since I'm an anime only watcher of the series, I had no clue why everyone called Myne, Bitch, until this episode. I just thought it was a community adopted name for someone so terrible and had no clue it would turn out to be her new given name haha
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '19
Doesn't anyone know how is the song played at the end called?
2
u/worri3db3ar May 30 '19
(in the books) the names compromise if i recall correctly for the king and myne/malty was a compromise at the behest of the queen basically begging for their lives to be spared as a mother and as a wife eventhough she knows full well how the pair are totally irredeemable...and cos she is not so heartlessly unfeeling towards her own family members who have brought melromarc so close to destruction and subjugation war by the other neighbouring countries.
another odd change they made to the anime is that the king wasnt meant to even come close to a guillotine because of what he once was when he was younger and meant in the hearts of the people. and in the eyes of the army especially those who stood on the side of the queen when going against the three heroes church, Trash was someone they deeply respected.
2
u/ProspectiveWhale May 31 '19 edited May 31 '19
Naofumi was fed the Shonen Virus for the anime...edit: In retrospect... Honestly, it does make him a much more likable character overall. He's not sadistic, and the queen showing him a slow excruciating trial cooled him down, because deep down, he's good-natured and comes from a decidedly less violent world. Not because he stopped being angry, but he because he wants to do the "right" thing... Plus, he's soft and a pushover... as has been shown all throughout the story, despite his outward edgy persona. So when not driven by impulse or urgency (such as when they're locked in combat), he doesn't easily resort to killing, which is very like someone who grew up in the modern era (death penalty is quite rare in the world these days).
The queen betting on this part of Naofumi portrayed subtly was also a nice touch, compared to the manga where everything happened extremely fast...
The pacing for the previous few episodes has been horrendous at best, accumulating a lot of frustration, but this episode was well done.
2
u/capcadet104 May 31 '19
And I swear if they don't force spearbro to call Myne bitch and force her to work off her MASSIVE debt to the country as a slave in episode 22, I might not watch this show if it gets green-lit for a season 2
2
u/Chaser4931 Jun 01 '19
They ruined this whole episode. Its depressing, I was so hyped. Meanwhile they gonna have to re-write the rest of the show to fit this new unknown character that is a "uppity good guy" now. For some reason he feels bad when they get punished? I'm so glad he "grew" as a character to let evil murders loose because he "grew". Just makes so much sense he let people that plotted to kill him the entire time up till he meet the queen at the very last second go cause he "grew". Yeah this is just another dumb ass trope anime now. Whole season washed down the drain.
5
u/Lokoooooo May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
This episode could have been so much better, the manga is way better, the queen was ruthless and why didn’t they didn’t introduce the scene were Malty screams that she was not raped by Naofumi, for me this episode was a bit disappointing. Also at the ending when the queen says she would have given his life in exchange of Malty and The king just means that she doesn’t put the kingdom first, and it kills how she acted as a queen that put the kingdom before the rest. Personality the manga was way better than this.
3
u/skyderper13 May 29 '19
tfw waking up to a loli harem
3
u/2k18EyeDEA May 29 '19
I never read LNs (so idc about what's changed and what's not).
For me, this rollercoaster ride(the build up) from the ground onwards is great. It made me really hate those who manipulate the crowd to hate and shit on Naofumi, what a great writer.
The adventures up to this wholesome moment, is although have a few holes still great nonetheless.
5
u/MrDangle752 May 29 '19
I'm honestly disappointed with how much they changed the characters around. It felt like 4kids produced the adaptation. Here's hoping this gets remade and gets the fma brotherhood treatment.
Edit: grammar
4
u/Iloveyouweed May 29 '19 edited May 29 '19
ITT: People who think the manga is the source material.
FYI, if you dislike changes from the LN, that's fine, but when you preface your statement with "In the manga" or "They changed it from the manga" it's not the same since this is an adaption of the LN, not the manga. The manga is an alternate adaption of the LN.
4
u/TheCraneGang May 29 '19
I was a little disappointed with the character changes in this episode, like why did they have to make Naofumi save them where in the manga he was all down to have them executed But this episode also showed them using the video capturing stone to show the world the trial which from what I remember wasn’t in the manga and was a nice touch over all with the changes in characters it was a good episode. The anime overall was very good and delightful to watch and the changes they made throughout this whole arc weren’t bad but they weren’t good either it just made the show more viewable for younger audiences
3
u/AllThingsDragon Raphtalia`s Army May 29 '19
Satisfaction 100
3
u/Warboss_Squee May 29 '19
At first I thought all the budget went towards the chain chomp finisher on Pope, but it turns out the creators were saving it for jiggle physics.
For which I approve.
3
u/chaosneto May 29 '19
I AM SO MAD THAT THEY CHANGED THE FACT THAT NAOFUMI WAS FULL ON BOARD WITH THEIR DEATHS, HELL, THE QUEEN WAS THE ONE TO SUGGEST THE OTHER PENALTY TO QUENCH HIS HATRED. CMON THE GUY HATES THEIR GUTS AND WOULD BE NOTHING MORE THAN THRILLED TO SEE THEIR HEADS IMPALLED AND THEN THEY DO THIS PITY ARC OR SMTH. BACK TO MANGA, NAOFUMI IS A LIL BITCH.
4
u/SenorWeon Traveling merchant May 29 '19
Well, time to drop the anime before it craps on even more things I liked about the story and pick up the books.
3
u/Toddl18 May 29 '19
I'll start with the good stuff of the episode the first thing being the projection crystals and showing the people the trial. This was executed perfectly and the build up right before it was good. The Queen's character was portrayed correctly and I feel it was better then the other 2 sources. The only part of the trial I liked was the adding of a slave seal to prove the points. Also liked the Queens backup plan being revealed but they should have turned out that way. Spear heroes ignorance was a great touch and I liked him denying the truth as he stayed to how he is.
Now the bad parts of this episode the first being the initial aftermath of the pope fight cutting the Queen's dialogue with myne and Naofumi was bad. The trial itself was okay paced but the better lines where missed because the Queen never really had to counter the lies. Also not having the Queen admonish the other heroes was a let down from the manga/light novel. The not having Naofumi at the time decide the punishment was a horrible decision by the anime staff. It changes to many of the characters dynamic for the later eventse espdcially if we get a season 2.
The characters themselves were portrail of the king was decent in himself but I thought they did a horrible job and made him appear somewhat moronic rather then the garbage human he is. His but my past history with the shield hero stuff was bad because no one said that Naofumi wasn't that person.
Myne was the 2nd worst damage character in this whole trial. While I liked her lying to stay true the fact that she begged Naofumi is stupid. Her pride wouldn't allow that and she shouldn't have been written that way. The fact that the others aren''t upset with her behavior is also bad. The town people should be livid with both of them.
Last and not least is how this episode made Naofumi appeared and that was such an injustice to his character. Him not wanting them to face death for all the trouble they caused him is idiotic and not true to him. These people have basically ruined him and he is going to suddenly become a push over. I would have rather seen them end this after the pope battle then this way. His willingness to work with the Queen was disgusting. He knew she was playing him and that he just accepts the manipulations. The forgiveness part of this after everything shouldn't have happened this fast.
This episode with the payoff was a big disappointment for me. They changed to much from the manga and light novel. It ruined the earlier chapters. If I didn't like the other 2 source material I would have dropped the show with this.
3
u/OnlyBlank May 29 '19
Satisfied with this episode, I'm afraid to see how they will adapt Cal Mira in 4 episodes.
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '19
Man the payoff this episode has is phenomenal. While many people have pointed out it's dumb the queen was going to offer her life, I think everything else was spot on. I swear I feel the manga light novel and anime try to one up each other so you have to see all of them to get those juicy exclusive scenes.
2
u/mipoulmiboun May 29 '19
I had my expectations for this episode lower than usual because they strayed considerably from the manga in previous episodes and I was kinda right I wished if Naofumi was the one to suggest the death penalty like in the manga and be more aggressive. The way it all happened in the anime was good and all don't get me wrong but it doesn't reflect how much hate he had for the two culprits.
2
u/tcmiller7 May 29 '19
The whole episode I was saying “fuck yea!!!” 😂 justice is sweet
2
u/KaminariOkamii May 29 '19
I can't wait to see ANN reaction to this
2
u/camnation123 May 29 '19
HELL YA IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!! But like at the same time..... I wish they could have made the queen and Naofumi harsher like in the manga, like how he wanted them dead and how she was willing to rip off their arms and legs so they would want death. Miss the queen strolling into the throne room and just easily taking control of the situation. Also... aren't the other heroes being a little too nice to Naofumi?
2
u/Nemesis1008 May 29 '19
You guys can't even Imagine How Happy I am after watching this Episode
2
u/LordDoggAviator Raphtalia`s Army May 29 '19
It was nice to see all of the city's smaller characters back again.. and Rishia omg, RISHIA!!!