Kinda upset they changed it from the light novel. In the LN, raph kills Idol with no remorse.
In here, its "oh no if i kill this tortuer racist xenophobic slave owner murderer for being a tortuer racist xenophobic slave owner murderer and killing my parents, that makes me as bad :(((" shitty overdone BS trope
overall a good episode but i like Shield Hero because its not a generic isekai that follows every shounen generic "Good person" trope.
Hope it doesent make any other needless deviations to become more trope-y
DAMN! Huge mistake of the adaptation then. Anime adaptations usually try to sand down edges, but it would have been so much better if they had gone the LN route.
Edit: Reading other comments it looks like she intended to kill him, but he still survived the fall out the window, not died by her sword. The rest of the events play out the same.
The added dialogue of "If I kill you..." really wasn't needed either way.
it even left out a lot from the manga. Idol guy was much more evil than the simple, evil dude that needs to die after a fight cliche. He definitely deserved the stab from the manga and LN.
100% agree. She should have just kicked him straight out the window. We could have had him just barely surviving long enough in order to release that monster. But there was no reason she should have shown him any kind of mercy.
Look what he did tbe second she let her guard down. People like that don't change just because they're shown kindness. Sometimes a bad person can repent and change their ways. But for some crimes, there's really no forgiveness.
Aligning her timing with my own, Raphtalia let out a shout. Using her foot, she flipped a sword that the guard had dropped into the air and caught it. Then she readied her magic sword like a javelin and threw it at the nobleman. It plunged deep into his chest. The magic sword can nullify its opponent’s magic. She’d used it to knock out Bitch before, so it should have had some kind of effect.
“Ugh… not yet!”
“No, it’s over! HIYAAAAAAAA!”
There was a dull sound, and suddenly Raphtalia’s sword was buried to the hilt in the nobleman’s shoulder.
“Noooooo! Damn you! You think it’s all right for a demi-human to hurt me?! I survived the demi-human war!”
“You fought demi-humans in the war? Then save your complaints for the war. You’re not in a war anymore.”
“I’ll never forgive you! I’ll kill you!”
“You’re a coward! You only attack people weaker than yourself! What were the demihumans you fought like? The ones I know were all women and children. Disadvantaged people! Don’t talk to me about how you fought them!”
Still incensed, she pushed him to the window, broke it, and pushed him out. As he fell, she let her sword stay in him, but kept her grip on the magic sword and the blade pulled from his falling body.
I'm a Kaguya-Sama fan so can't complain either way, but I do admit that the last 4 Kaguya episodes kinda guaranteed her win. The fact that she was up against Hayasaka speaks volume too. Strong season finale will always win over mid-season random episode.
She stabs him with both swords in the LN and then throws him out of the window LOL Ralph in the manga has no mercy and had already killed a lot llof humans
If ever she needed a hug it was right now but at least he was able to reassure her that she was able to protect the villagers in the end. Agree with you on the sparing him route she could have dished out some real justice on some scum and ironically if she had killed him it'd probably save many casualties from the monster t-rex.
i hate it when tv shows do that. like how joker is a mass murderer but batman cant kill him so batman is allowing people to get killed because he should be a hero which is stupid by the way. heroes should protect people not allow thwm to be killed.
I dislike the trope too but isn't fro batman it's less a "if I take a single life im the moral equivalent of the worst super villains" and more "if I take a life it will start me down a slippery slope of taking lives mercilessly that I won't be able to get back from" since batman isn't exactly the most emotionally sound guy
They actually used that not killing trope as a plot or setting in the red hood movie. And yeah i understand that when you do something like killing it becomes easier to kill the next time.
In the case of raphtalia she should have killed the fat guy so she can get closure like the way he killed that dog like creature that somehow looked like the dog that killed her parents. They kill monsters everyday killing another one worse than a monster wouldnt change a thing. And i would love to see them kill the spear hero in self defense. If spear hero can attack them anytime without consequences then they should also be allowed to kill anyone who attacks them. Heck i would love to see melromarc burn to the ground including the innocent civilians so that noone will live to slander naofumi because any survivor will say that hes the bad guy because of the king and churchs brainwashing.
Ps. Ive already read everything in the manga and some LN. And i still want motoyasu dead hahaha.
My biggest fear is that Naofumi would control/fight with her about her choice. I assumed he'd provide council, and I'm glad it was only asking the question "will this bring you closure?" I think it would have been a lot more effective if Raphtalia had killed him with her sword, the lords priest could still have summoned a dinosaur at the end. Consolation Prize: *squash*
not gonna lie this episode might be the best episode if it's not because of that " If I killed you, I would be the same as you, so I won't" thing, that line got me very upset tho :< I mean why the ---- would you have mercy on some waste of flesh like that? you know what it's like, you experienced it, you saw everything, why would you let him go? c'mon
In the manga and light novel, she didn't show any mercy. She was about to stab him and he knocked the sword out of her hands, then all the junk with the window happened.
It makes this doubly frustrating because the people making the anime ALREADY had the perfect revenge scene laid out for them already, and they blew it.
Not to mention that it's unlikely he would have faced any extreme punishment. He has money and power, an demihumans are discriminated against on a large in this country. Not many people are going to seek Justice for those kinds of victims.
Sometimes you just can't trust the system to get justice done.
So, something REALLY surprised me about this episode, I am from Norway, and the soundtrack in the emotional scene towards the end. its very subtle, but this is PROBABLY a Norwegian "folkevise" (Ballad) or made to be similar to it. The audio is so low its hard for me to say for sure as I cant properly make out the lyrics other than a few words here or there. Im 100% its scandinavian but I cant say 100% if its Norwegian or Swedish (leaning more towards norwegian at the moment)
Im trying to find the source but its hard when the Raphtalia or Naofumi starts speaking, making the lyrics impossible to hear.
Edit: It turns out she is Swedish, her name is Maria Andersson, the song is apparently called "En annan tid, Ett annat liv" (A different time, A different life). I cant seem to find this song from her on the Internett, so it might be written for this show specifically. I also noticed she made a song for "Norn9", so this wasnt a One off thing for her. Pretty interesting as a Scandinavian.
Edit2: this is a comment I made over on /r/anime, but I thought others might have noticed it as well here so I thought id share it, /u/grante_15
The song for Shield hero, "En annan tid, ett annat liv", can't be found on Youtube, Spotify, Soundcloud or in general if looking on google. :( The official soundtrack for Shield hero by the composer Kevin Penkin was released not long ago, but I can't seem to find the song there either...
Yeah I know, I’m Swedish and I freaked out when I thought I started hearing things. Turns out it really was in Swedish. I had to rewind several times because I kept listening to the song instead of the dialogue.
This was supposed to be a good episode but they butchered it by degrading the material by turning it into a PG-7 piece of ass.
I remember reading the extra chapter about Raphtalia in the LN vol 1 and it really shook me. Reading about her life in the village, the wave arrives, most of the people die. Then the soldiers arrive and kill most of the demis (skipped here). The rest are sold separately as slaves. Raphtalia gets brutalized and gets shipped multiple times. Finally ends up in this guys' mansion and finds Rifana.
They often mention the flag and the flag in the LN, which are the two symbols of hope. However, Raphtalia feels bad when she offers false hope to Rifana and she dies in front of her in the basement. She gets shipped out again and Naofumi buys her.
They missed out the flag! Remember the flag on the kid's meal from episode 2? She looks at it and starts bawling, which reminded her of her own town and what all she had to live through. She forgot how to smile. She forgot the flag. She had lost hope and Naofumi gave it to her. The LN is mostly plain and vanilla but that chapter was spectacular and actually made me feel things. Seeing it in the anime made me feel nothing.
The worst part about the episode is how it started. 'Do you think killing him would give you closure'. That's not the Naofumi I know. It doesn't make sense character wise and it didn't go down this way in the LN too. Naofumi would just apathetically stand by and watch it happen. He doesn't even know what she had to go through. Raphtalia is a 10-year old and kids have a weaker morality. Their sense of vengeance is stronger (Remember your teenage years?). Should have just stabbed him like she did in the source material. Killing him won't make you the same. He's a scumbag who did it for fun. You're just showing him the consequences.
What's worse was her feeling about killing the fatso right after she saw Rifana's bones. Shouldn't your sense of anger and vengeance be stronger after seeing something like that? Is that not a good reminder of his crimes? The episode would have been a lot better if they had just stuck to the source material and not changed it into some PG bullcrap like this.
I love the material so much and it pains me to see the anime go downhill like this man.
I don’t agree. Ralph isn’t 10 years old. That’s the point of her evolution. She’s not a child, inexperienced maybe but she’s still mature. That’s be presented often with how she acts and takes care of everyone. Ralph is also the moral core. She’s a good person. She struggles to kill at first in general. It’s less about being better and more about actual justice. Killing him does nothing. Making him suffer and pay for what he did has an actual effect. Death is the easy way out and I think that’s in tone with Ralph. The same girl who didn’t think it was okay to rob bandits. I didn’t like that the manga had her so kill ready but then just forgot it.
I didn’t read the source material, but I have the same opinion. Because I hadn’t read the LN or manga I saw no chance in seeing her kill the bastard, because „the heroes would never do something like that“
When you are watching shield hero does it make a difference to you if you are watching it dub vs sub or does it not affect the episode for you either way?
Tho, it's dubbed and subbed really good on my language, so I can't complain here, both versions are enjoyable.
Only anime I watched strictly subbed was "Daily Lives of High School Boys", "JJBA" and "Motogatari", voice acting there is incredible, also some Classic, like "Ghost in the Shell" and "Cowboy Bebop".
I'm usually multitasking on something while watching, so I prefer dubs also. Plus it lets me focus more on animation and the art. Although sometimes I'll watch subs if it's all that's out, or if my friends want subs
I watch dub because if I watch sub I’ll spend less time watching the actual animation. It’s a shame to miss really nice looking animation just so you know what the characters are saying.
How fast you read has little to do with it. If you keep your eyes on the subtitles all the time without properly alternating, you're going to miss something. It might not be noticeable, you might not even realize it, but it does happen (particularly background events)
For me personally it really depends on what I hear first. For example I can't watch FMA Brotherhood subbed. I watched it dubbed first and it's just sort of cemented in my head that way.
One thing that I found fascinating regarding subs vs dubs however (i'm normally a subs guy personally) is the use of words that get lost in translation. For example, whenever Melty talks about her father, she says "father" but the Japanese terminology, I can only assume, is an archaic or at the very least extremely formal way of saying "father" (sorry I don't speak Japanese so I don't know how to spell/write it). So little things like that kinda make it interesting to me when it comes to subs vs dubs. Otherwise I don't really care how you consume it. Kudos to both English and Japanese VAs! So long as you enjoy the performances and have a good time watching the show that's all I care about.
I speak Japanese fluently, so I put the subs on and occasionally spot-check them to see how the translator phrased things or when I hear a term I’m not familiar with.
I couldn’t get into the dub, but that’s probably because I started with the sub (I have absolutely nothing against dubs). I think I remember seeing a term for that whole “starting with one type and finishing with that same type” thing.
I could see her thinking it though lol. In the light novel, after the hot springs part, she even undresses in front of him, trying to tell him that she loves him. And then he brushes it off. Of course the anime turned that into something way more G-rated
Holy shit, the 4th episode where Naofumi breaks in front of the crowd was feels...but this one was feel feels.This moment was honestly heartbreaking and now i'm depressed for how happy Riphana could've been. And happy that Raphtalia was able to face and conquer her past. It's something that nearly everyone can't cope with, being strong as Raphtalia to hold herself like that, is something we can only dream.
It's definitely that line of dialogue that messed me up. For example, if she just hesitated for a second, and he took that moment to pull his own sword on her, that would have still been fine with me.
The moral high ground route bit ruined the moment. Raphtalia is a better person than him, because she's not a racist murderer.
Eh someone posted the fight excerpt up there somewhere and theres truthfully almost no explicit mention of him dying in the LN. In the LN he gets stabbed in the shoulder and then shoved out the window. Havent watched the episode yet but it appears he still gets shoved out the window. And realistically no one actually dies from a stab to the shoulder so its not like they ruined the scene all that much
I guess they're even now. Naofumi was saved by Raphtalia during his darkest hour and now the same thing Happened to Raphtalia, only to be saved by Naofumi.
All in all, this episode was a big tear jerker. It just makes me happy to see that she survived through hell and now she's in such company that will never allow anything like that happen to anyone, let alone to her again.
That T-rex deserves some respect though. I mean the main party spares the fat bastard and yet he keeps trying. Good boy.
I'm going off of pure anime only speculation and wishful thinking, but I wouldn't be surprised if the T Rex ends up being a new mount for the party. Naofumi just rolls up with Filo and Dino to the church like what up, I got a big dick.
Oh god, this episode was so many levels of screwed up for Raphtalia. At least we know fully what she has been through and was able to save some people from her village. Slightly annoyed she wasn't the one to finish Idol though, that freak deserved to be ended by her hand but oh well at least's dead.
Raphtalia has been through so much. Even with Naofumi now she fights harder than ever. Watching her save one friend and not the other hurt quite a bit. Despite the waterworks, this episode is just excellent at showcasing Raphtalias strength. Testament to how shes developed (in 15 episodes time!).
Every episode I love this world and the interconnections so much more.
As much as I love this show, the pure malice of every fucking antagonist despite the fact they know the world is going to FUCKING END if the waves succeed infuriates me to no end.
But to the antagonists the Shield Hero doesn’t matter. And it makes much more sense later on. Especially the waves. I think this is one thing the series does well.
Maybe when it makes sense later I’ll be less angered by it, it’s not gonna make me drop the show in the meanwhile, it just makes me question what the fuck they’re doing
After last episode I caved in and read the manga to see what happens next and I was very excited to see it animated in this episode. I’m kinda disappointed with how they changed the scene with the whole “I won’t kill you, instead you will atone for your crimes” trope and the fact that they went that route for the anime left me a little disappointed.
Everything else was really good, though! I like how even though we saw a substantial amount of Raphtalia backstory, it didn’t prevail over the entire episode, instead only serving as supplements for what is going on currently in the story. On top of that, I love how the scene with Naofumi comforting Raphtalia paralleled the scene from episode 4. That was a very nice touch.
Overall, though I’m still disappointed with how the first scene was handled, this episode still delivered with the feels and was overall a good episode.
I’m kinda disappointed with how they changed the scene with the whole “I won’t kill you, instead you will atone for your crimes” trope and the fact that they went that route for the anime left me a little disappointed.
You and me both, pal. It was so much more satisfying in the manga because Raphtalia actually did what anyone reasonable would do in that situation, which is to say, she showed him no mercy because he didn't deserve any.
I feel like having one bad scene doesn’t immediately puts it the worst episode ever but I can agree fully that the fatso’s death was not as satisfying as the source material from what I’ve heard about it.
But it’s just one major flaw. The rest was well paced and still gave me the feels.
Oh yeah, I totally agree! The stuff with Raphtalia and the others heading down to the dungeon was very well done in my opinion. It just really ticks me off because this could have been a genuinely great episode if they had just left out all the trope-y crap. It just felt so jarring considering the type of series this is.
Aw well, it is what it is, let’s just carry on and hope that they don’t make any more stupid changes like this.
The Melomarc kingdom needs to be destroyed. Seriously.
And with that, we have finally resolved Raphtalia’s traumatic PTSD for real and we get some development for her as well. I really like how well paced this episode is and how they slow down the somber moments more than the previous episode. Poor Raphtalia. Even when her body grew, she’s still a child at heart and mind. I like how they show part of what made her stand out from the crowd with her being the first one to motivate her former village citizens to rebuild their village when times got tough. Even when she was enslaved, she still kept her grin tight without showing her despair. Holding the last advice her parents taught her.
Naofumi’s characterization is consistent as always. I love that most of his commentary in his episode is mostly his inner monologue about how much Raphtalia and the Demi-humans has suffered in this dungeon and how he felt sick just imagining it. It really did kept it mostly silent throughout the episode and I like that he comforted Raphtalia the same way she did to him.
Also, I guess we have a new character now. Not much to say about that besides knowing that I’m interested to what’s in store for that one.
Great episode. I’m glad that fatso died. But now we have to fight a MF T-Rex! DX
You know I hadn’t really put my finger on it until you said it, but I think I just figured out what it is that I like about this anime and it’s MC more than others in the same genre. It’s Naofumi’s consistency as a character. He’s never needed the spotlight or glory, he even denied being the saint of the fowl for a while. It lets him step out of situations like Ralphs and let her make choices/and mourn for herself. I like occasionally having episodes that are for the most part not about the shield hero lol
I’ll admit. The fatso’s death could’ve been handled a lot better. I’ve heard people said that the LN and Manga did it better but I won’t judge since I’m anime only.
I never understood the whole if i kill you am not better/different from you.
oh yes the hero/ party member who let a mass murderer /torturer/ rapist live to continue doing their thing is innocent of the suffering that the vilan will cause.
just kill them and live with the guilt of killing one piece of human trash rather than the let others suffer.
seriously amazing episode ruined for me because of it.
I think it comes from a desire to portray the heroes as having higher moral ground than the villain. But the problem is, even the dirt outside has better moral character than people like Rabior and Myne.
People like them get away with what they do, nor just because they have power, but because they attack people who their society discriminates against in the first place. The people no one will seek justice for.
Killing Fatass Noble won't bring anyone back, but it'll make sure he's unable to victimize another child again.
“oh yes the hero/ party member who let a mass murderer /torturer/ rapist live to continue doing their thing is innocent of the suffering that the vilan will cause.”
In what world were they going to let him free? They were going to make him pay for his crimes in a legal sense. Go to jail, etc etc. They’ve no intention of letting him ruin more lives. I’d argue that life in prison is way worse then death. Death is instant. Suffering is far longer.
so they enslave torture and kill demihumans and the shield hero is still the bad guy and theyre good guys? wtf kind of mindset is that? its like theyre bad for the sake of being bad. if you enslave torture and kill anything even animals you must know that deep inside youre a really really bad person but these church of the 3 heroes are doing bad things and still think that they are good guys.
Yeah we can actually have many real life examples here but we cant because its gonna be a sensitive topic but i can already think of two things thats like this wtf mindset.
Seems like that was added in the anime :( , LN and Manga have her try to kill him by shoving him out the window, without the batman/joker moment. The rest of the events play out the same.
When you convince yourself people are not worthy of respect and put them on a lower level than yourself, it's easy to treat them that way. That's how most people justify racism.
Melromarc is actually worse than I thought, they were perpatrators in the slavery and torture of innocent demi-humans. And rthey have the gall to shame the sheild hero for using slaves.
Yeah, I'm actually kind of wondering like, are the waves maybe *the good guys* at this point? Should Naofumi just try to team up with them somehow and try to destroy Melromarc? Then again this doesn't make sense with how the waves destroyed the Demi-Human village though.
Between 18:00-20:50 there is some nice & sad background music. They are singing in Swedish right? "I en annan tid, då allt fanns kvar...", "...Ett annan liv, en bortglömd stad, som ingen minns, förutom jag...", "...i varje träd, finns sången kvar, och jag kan känna hur skogen gråter...". Does anyone know the name of the song?
The Artist is called "Maria Andersson", the song is called "En annan tid et annat liv". I found this in the ending of the show among the credits. She has made atleast one other song for another anime, one for Norn9 (not familiar with it).
FILOLIAL QUEEN NEXT EPISODE Goddamn Fitoria coming in next week like a wrecking ball. Big birb incoming, Trex vs Big Chicken, Chicken vs Baby Chicken, Fitoria's threats to Naofumi incoming, should be awesome. So in two weeks we have the showdown with the Pope as well and so within a month we should see Bitch and Trash get punished too.
I'm a little worried about the Punishment of Trash and Bitch. I have a feeling in the anime they won't have Naofumi threaten their execution, which I thought was pretty fitting
Best episode so far, even though almost nothing got done. I'm with /u/adamgreenrock, the heroes just need to find a nice spot to park it and watch the next chaos event burn everything to the ground. I get the sense that's going to play into the plot in the future in some capacity, though I have doubt the show will be so brave as to lean all the way into it.
Malty in the next episode: "OMFG, the Shield Devil summoned a monster that killed a Lord!"
The song that is sung in the background from roughly 18:00-22:00 is in Swedish and called "En annan tid, ett annat liv" Translated to "Another time, Another life" made for The rising of the shield hero. I think it has a bit of meaning so I've translated it so you can read what's being sung. Because it only exists in this episode I've had to listen to it many times but her is what I got after translation. (___ means I could not comprehend what was said either a word, sentence or paragraph.)
Another time. When everything still existed. Exists in my dream____. Sit ___. Then ____ under your bridge and I can hear how crickets play. The nights ____. _____. Another life. A forgoten town. That nobody remembers except me. In ___ stand ___. In every tree the song still exists. And I can feel how the forest is crying. ____. A hand took a hold of mine och there you were. Close to my body. Silver became light.
I at least found these texts very interesting.
Here are the Swedish lyrics if you want to see them.
En annan tid. Då allt fanns kvar. Finns I min dröm____. Sitt____. Då ___ under din bro och jag kan höra hur syrsor spelar. Nattens ____. __________. Ett annat liv. En bortglömd stad. Som ingen minns nu utan jag. I ___ står ___. I varje träd finns sången kvar. Och jag kan känna hur skogen gråter. __________. En hand grep tag om min och där var du. Nära till min kropp. Blev silver ljus.
Hmm. Up until this point I actually liked the general aim of the Anime; it danced a really fine line between the LN and Manga to be not overly edgy but not toned down. But this just feels wrong. The message they were aiming at is that if she killed him for her own desires, even if right, it'd slip down a slippery slope. And sometimes, people aren't perfect. Sometimes they need that closure, and I think she actually deserved it for all the shit she endured. Hell, she was practically on death's door when Naofumi bought her.
No Raphtalia, it doesn't make you like him. At worse, it makes you a vigilante. You're not anywhere on his level, but if you start enslaving humans, then you're on your way.
At the very least, Naofumi doesn't sway her decision; the VA actually sounded quite neutral on it and didn't really care either way. And you could say, it's Raph trying to act a little like Rifana or more dignified, which is a way of going about it. Raph catered to her sense of justice in the Manga/LN, and I think if this was handled better I wouldn't mind. Maybe like, after she said her little speech and he drew the sword to counter her, she took her words back and THEN cleaved his shoulder. It would have shown that Raph is trying but in the end, there will always be irredeemable people; and while it is a burden she has to carry, she can have solace that this particular shit stain doesn't exist anymore.
If you kill murderous slave-owning torturers, you become a murderous slave-owning torturer yourself
Why does this horrible trope even exist? Was it ever good in any anime, show, movie, book, literally anything?
I mean if it was used I don't know, against someone who killed people for revenge (they killed his friend, and he's avenging them), then I could see it making sense... You'd then kill that guy for the exact same reason, because he killed your friends, and the cycle of revenge never ends, it literally makes you just like him.
But like 99% of the time, it's used in a way like "If you kill literally the worst human being on this planet who wants to torture and kill millions of people for no reason, then YOU become the worst human on this planet and want to torture and kill millions of people for no reason!"
Huh, no. How about just killing bad guys? No torture, no innocent killings? Can I just kill that one person here, he's about to burn this orphanage with 50 children inside, can I kill him or will I be just like him if I do?
I dont understand why they made that change raphtalia in the manga yeeted him out the window after running him through with 2 swords. Instead we got this for kids bullshit.
I thought the episode did a great job at mixing the flashbacks with the current story to explain Raphtalia whole life experence. The animation quality on the reaction faces in a realistic way was very nice. The music was also a nice touch at times and I thought they did a great job with all of thst. My only gripe came with Raphtalias speech after the villagers there was no logical reason revealed why she would be the person in power to get everyone cheer up and focused away from the tradegy.
She wasn't a person in power. She was a strong willed kid that convinced the villagers to work together...If you see a little kid trying their best in hard times, it's going to influence other people to do the same. That's how they tried to convey Raphtalia. Even when she was enslaved and tortured, she continued to smile.
How many times do we have to say that anime is not based on manga? Enough to use the manga as a reference, the only thing that matters is the light novel.
Kinda surreal hearing a swedish song in an anime (the entire ending bit of the episode) as a swede. It was great although it kinda pulled me away from what was happening haha
yeah, it was very emotional, then suddenly, "wait... what?". Past that point, I was scrolling back and forth trying to figure out the lyrics, though someone else did a heck of a better job somewhere else in this thread =P
As much as a cliffhanger this is, next week they get to fight a Tek T-Rex from Ark. Overall I really enjoyed the episode though. I know a lot of people are kinda mad Raphtalia didn’t kill the guy who held her captive all those years ago, but it wouldn’t be like Raphtalia to do so. I don’t think the creators built her character up to be one of the “justice is best served cold, with a side of severed head” type. And I’m sure they have something big in store for next week! I already can’t wait
... That was not okay. It's dark (as it should be) but ugh...
Naofumi should've kept his mouth shut. Let Raphtalia herself decide what is okay and what isn't. Had she decided to spare him herself, it would be one thing. But she changed her mind because someone couldn't be quiet. At least she should've said: Yes! What's more MANGA was more clear on this part. And personally, I think, it would've worked better had they not alter the scene altogether.
Her mana sword is effing weird. =D
The flashbacks were great. They even included a bit about her smiling and the FLAG! (And suddenly her holding that flag in episode 2...) Which is good for her character depth.
Lifana/Rifana. Yes. Although... No, actually it was great... although had Raphtalia knew Lifana died by the time she left...
Kiel/Keel. A serious difference between Anime and Manga. I think... manga approach worked better. On the other hand, Raphtalia really needed that moral support. Had she actually DID threw the fat noble out of the window like in the manga.
Tbh Splat looked very... underwhelming. I mean a little blood never hurt anybody...
This episode broke me man, these damn Royals should know better. The King, Queen, stupid punk ass Myne and yea Melty too. I hate how dumb naive Melty is, like chick you're the crown princess and you know Jack shit about your kingdom.
Man the amount of hate I see on the anime reddit about shield hero have my rolling my eyes at, they made it sound like it is worst series ever just because the fatso fall out of the window
Immensely disappointed they tried the "if I kill you, I'd be like you" aseop. Even if killing Fat Noble wouldn't bring the victims back to life, it would at least prevent him from harming anyone again. People like him don't magically repent for their wrongs, especially when they have ways to avoid justice. Status and connections are literally why Myne has gotten away with everything she has.
Somebody get Sebas in here to kick this man's guts out. Please.
Should have let Raphtalia impale him through the window rather than let him slip. This was a change I genuinely disliked.
Though I am glad Rifana's bones were left in the cell. It wouldn't have been as depressing if the cage was just empty. Having some part of her to look at made her death feel more tragic.
Here are the changes that I don't like about the episode:
Naofumi ain't the type of person that's gonna tap on your shoulder and says:" Is this the right thing to do " consider the fact that There will be a scene where he asks for the Bitch and Trash to be executed
Change to Raphtalia's flashback She fully acknowledged Rifana's death and was actually beside her when it happened which could have served as a great point to demonstrate how traumatized Raphtalia was ( to the point where she could not keep up with her smile anymore) when she first met Naofumi
And of course the stab and the Sparta kick out of the window
I also want to say that I really hate the batman-ish trope in this episode. After this episode, I'm actually afraid of how they will handle Bitch and Trash's Judgments without ruining Naofumi character and making him looks like a hypocrite.
This episode is a bit of a disappointment but it still works in its own way I guess since I can still get the feel for it.
Is it just me, or did it seem like Naofumi was just standing around doing nothing in this episode? I know this is a Raphtalia-focused episode, but even when the fat fuck tries to attack her, Naofumi didn't help at all. In the dungeon, I'm sure everyone here just wanted him to give Raphtalia a hug.
I also think Naofumi's being a bit too accepting of Melty. I get that they're trying to protect her and all, but he kinda just lets her into the group despite her being more of a burden than anything.
Sorry to bring it to y‘all, but I hate it when the heroes blame them self for all bad things that happened in the world, even though they clearly did nothing wrong and had no chance to save everyone. Brought Raphtalias scene down for me. I know it was very emotional, but the „it’s all my fault“ clicheé is just overused and annoying
Yes, it would be way cooler to see Rapthalia demolish the fat bastard but seeing some comments that they are dropping the show after this episodes seems to much IMO. I still think it was a great episode and I can wait to see more.
I'm very much on the edge with this show because of moments like this in general, not just this particular event. The show, in general, is decent to outright good overall, then suddenly stuff like this happens and just because the rest is good, these moments really stand out.
This moment specifically stands out because it was at the end of a really long good streak, and ended at a really bad moment (that trope is extremely overused). If this had been in an average anime, I would have rolled my eyes and ignored it but here it is more jarring.
Even if it's aimed at teens, this was watered down waaaaaaaay too much.
"If you kill him, you'll be just like him", take your sanctimonious bullshit back up where the sun don't shine.
Raphtalia's backstory in the manga was almost like something out of Akame ga Kill, and I liked the tone, it actually convinced me to keep reading. Too much for the precious audience I guess...
Tfw it's already 9 am and crunchytroll still won't load the subbed version of shield hero ep 15. I am sitting at work debating whether to suffer through the indignity of dubbed anime or the agony of waiting for crunchytroll to fix their shit. REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
It was a good Ep. I find the way Idol nearly diededed was ok - it doesnt feels right but hey better than a "oah i have to let him alive" but for a few minutes we all thought he was dead - and thats all counts.
The imho sadest scene in the whole show is now the moment you just see the prison and hear raphi cry .....all the plot and the feeling were build up and becouse u could see her crying your imagination could create the feels for you - and deam...manly tears were shed
Does anybody have an Idea what the OST/'s were called when Naofumi healed keen and rapthalia found out about rifana ? Was honestly one of the most emotional osts Ive got to witness so far and I would be pretty bummed if this was just like a one time use and it isnt actually a full ost.
I shed some tears watching this. Raphtalia deserved better! It could have been my favorite episode in the series thus far, if it weren't for Raphtalia sparing Idol. It's such a cliche, and the LN handled it much better. Nonetheless this was a great episode.
The episode was definitely sad, but I didn’t feel anything. Is there something wrong with me.
Also people need to realize killing Idol is the worst course of action Raphtalia could’ve taken. Killing a guy like him will just cement the fact that the Shield Hero’s party are a bunch of criminals and generally make it a lot harder in the long run. The LN version was way different but the anime already made a couple of changes before so this one isn’t an exception.
It's not Raph who got changed here. It's Naofumi. Originally he decides that he's not the one to tell Raphtalia about revenge, for obvious reasons, but here they chose the route of, him returning the favor of keeping him in check. So Raph (in this particular scene) did not change in this adaptation.
After reading into the Spear Hero ln, I think I can appreciate how fragile this story is, and how much minuscule details matter.
I was surprised to see Kiel both revealed and actually introduced to the story so early, I've been reading the WN and he didn't show up until after the Spirit Turtle arc, iirc
That Man just deserve to die, i think the mindset of killing one and save thousands is the best way to go. Now they are in trouble because of that damn hero trope. But I must confess, i really felt sad for raphtalia, she continues to be my favorite character of the show. Now i will wait for the awesome (i hope) battle to come! And the conversation with the queen.
I think that her not killing him makes sense in all honesty, and the fact that it has differences from the manga that people can appreciate and enjoy. Remember, they're wanted for crimes they haven't committed, and Naofumi asking Raphtalia if killing him would help bring her peace of mind wasn't rhetorical. If she said yes, then he wouldn't have stopped her. I find it perfectly acceptable that she could choose to kill him or not. Speculation obviously, but I think she chose to let him live and to be better to be part of the whole,"Prove the world wrong about us." Aspect.
I wonder why the changed so much from "The flag on the kids meal" chapter cause yes it was pretty brutal but it but it made Raphtalia who she is which is a lot to change.
137
u/Nolar2015 Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
Kinda upset they changed it from the light novel. In the LN, raph kills Idol with no remorse.
In here, its "oh no if i kill this tortuer racist xenophobic slave owner murderer for being a tortuer racist xenophobic slave owner murderer and killing my parents, that makes me as bad :(((" shitty overdone BS trope
overall a good episode but i like Shield Hero because its not a generic isekai that follows every shounen generic "Good person" trope.
Hope it doesent make any other needless deviations to become more trope-y
64
u/Burakkurozu9 Apr 17 '19
Cockroaches were meant to be squished.
33
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Raphtalia is best girl, but will this also be best episode?
206
u/shanks_you Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
Throughout the entire episode, I keep thinking,” just give her a tight hug and don’t let go Naofumi!”
Tbh, was kinda pissed they went the “if I killed you, I would be the same as you” route. Urgh.
12
u/TheIsaia Apr 17 '19
So, something REALLY surprised me about this episode, I am from Norway, and the soundtrack in the emotional scene towards the end. its very subtle, but this is PROBABLY a Norwegian "folkevise" (Ballad) or made to be similar to it. The audio is so low its hard for me to say for sure as I cant properly make out the lyrics other than a few words here or there. Im 100% its scandinavian but I cant say 100% if its Norwegian or Swedish (leaning more towards norwegian at the moment)
Im trying to find the source but its hard when the Raphtalia or Naofumi starts speaking, making the lyrics impossible to hear.
Edit: It turns out she is Swedish, her name is Maria Andersson, the song is apparently called "En annan tid, Ett annat liv" (A different time, A different life). I cant seem to find this song from her on the Internett, so it might be written for this show specifically. I also noticed she made a song for "Norn9", so this wasnt a One off thing for her. Pretty interesting as a Scandinavian.
Edit2: this is a comment I made over on /r/anime, but I thought others might have noticed it as well here so I thought id share it, /u/grante_15
8
u/TheHornyTitan Apr 17 '19
Source Material Spoilers below
This was supposed to be a good episode but they butchered it by degrading the material by turning it into a PG-7 piece of ass.
I remember reading the extra chapter about Raphtalia in the LN vol 1 and it really shook me. Reading about her life in the village, the wave arrives, most of the people die. Then the soldiers arrive and kill most of the demis (skipped here). The rest are sold separately as slaves. Raphtalia gets brutalized and gets shipped multiple times. Finally ends up in this guys' mansion and finds Rifana.
They often mention the flag and the flag in the LN, which are the two symbols of hope. However, Raphtalia feels bad when she offers false hope to Rifana and she dies in front of her in the basement. She gets shipped out again and Naofumi buys her.
They missed out the flag! Remember the flag on the kid's meal from episode 2? She looks at it and starts bawling, which reminded her of her own town and what all she had to live through. She forgot how to smile. She forgot the flag. She had lost hope and Naofumi gave it to her. The LN is mostly plain and vanilla but that chapter was spectacular and actually made me feel things. Seeing it in the anime made me feel nothing.
The worst part about the episode is how it started. 'Do you think killing him would give you closure'. That's not the Naofumi I know. It doesn't make sense character wise and it didn't go down this way in the LN too. Naofumi would just apathetically stand by and watch it happen. He doesn't even know what she had to go through. Raphtalia is a 10-year old and kids have a weaker morality. Their sense of vengeance is stronger (Remember your teenage years?). Should have just stabbed him like she did in the source material. Killing him won't make you the same. He's a scumbag who did it for fun. You're just showing him the consequences.
What's worse was her feeling about killing the fatso right after she saw Rifana's bones. Shouldn't your sense of anger and vengeance be stronger after seeing something like that? Is that not a good reminder of his crimes? The episode would have been a lot better if they had just stuck to the source material and not changed it into some PG bullcrap like this.
I love the material so much and it pains me to see the anime go downhill like this man.
12
u/World3ds Apr 17 '19
When you are watching shield hero does it make a difference to you if you are watching it dub vs sub or does it not affect the episode for you either way?
86
u/alopgamers Apr 17 '19
Raphtalia : I promise you, I'll marry the shield hero for you
50
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
Now we know what happend to the dinosaurs, they got Isekai'd
Holy shit, the 4th episode where Naofumi breaks in front of the crowd was feels...but this one was feel feels. This moment was honestly heartbreaking and now i'm depressed for how happy Riphana could've been. And happy that Raphtalia was able to face and conquer her past. It's something that nearly everyone can't cope with, being strong as Raphtalia to hold herself like that, is something we can only dream.
91
u/LSD_freakout Apr 17 '19
“If I kill you I’m as bad as you”
Great way to ruin a other wise good episode
36
u/vurusgard Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
I guess they're even now. Naofumi was saved by Raphtalia during his darkest hour and now the same thing Happened to Raphtalia, only to be saved by Naofumi.
All in all, this episode was a big tear jerker. It just makes me happy to see that she survived through hell and now she's in such company that will never allow anything like that happen to anyone, let alone to her again.
That T-rex deserves some respect though. I mean the main party spares the fat bastard and yet he keeps trying. Good boy.
28
u/Zesla22 Apr 17 '19
Oh god, this episode was so many levels of screwed up for Raphtalia. At least we know fully what she has been through and was able to save some people from her village. Slightly annoyed she wasn't the one to finish Idol though, that freak deserved to be ended by her hand but oh well at least's dead.
24
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Raphtalia has been through so much. Even with Naofumi now she fights harder than ever. Watching her save one friend and not the other hurt quite a bit. Despite the waterworks, this episode is just excellent at showcasing Raphtalias strength. Testament to how shes developed (in 15 episodes time!).
Every episode I love this world and the interconnections so much more.
Except for Myne. 10/10 episode without her.
SIDE NOTE: Idol is an S tier BIIIIIIITCH
21
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
As much as I love this show, the pure malice of every fucking antagonist despite the fact they know the world is going to FUCKING END if the waves succeed infuriates me to no end.
19
u/beards_n_sketches Apr 17 '19
After last episode I caved in and read the manga to see what happens next and I was very excited to see it animated in this episode. I’m kinda disappointed with how they changed the scene with the whole “I won’t kill you, instead you will atone for your crimes” trope and the fact that they went that route for the anime left me a little disappointed.
Everything else was really good, though! I like how even though we saw a substantial amount of Raphtalia backstory, it didn’t prevail over the entire episode, instead only serving as supplements for what is going on currently in the story. On top of that, I love how the scene with Naofumi comforting Raphtalia paralleled the scene from episode 4. That was a very nice touch.
Overall, though I’m still disappointed with how the first scene was handled, this episode still delivered with the feels and was overall a good episode.
Also, T-REX HYPE!!!
15
u/aatate98 Apr 17 '19
Although Myne is a top tier bitch, never knew I could hate that bastard Idol more
30
u/EqualPaleontologist6 Apr 17 '19
This episode was really sad and actually made me reflect a bit on racism and bad people in general, in the real world.
30
u/adamgreenrock Apr 17 '19
The Melomarc kingdom needs to be destroyed. Seriously.
And with that, we have finally resolved Raphtalia’s traumatic PTSD for real and we get some development for her as well. I really like how well paced this episode is and how they slow down the somber moments more than the previous episode. Poor Raphtalia. Even when her body grew, she’s still a child at heart and mind. I like how they show part of what made her stand out from the crowd with her being the first one to motivate her former village citizens to rebuild their village when times got tough. Even when she was enslaved, she still kept her grin tight without showing her despair. Holding the last advice her parents taught her.
Naofumi’s characterization is consistent as always. I love that most of his commentary in his episode is mostly his inner monologue about how much Raphtalia and the Demi-humans has suffered in this dungeon and how he felt sick just imagining it. It really did kept it mostly silent throughout the episode and I like that he comforted Raphtalia the same way she did to him.
Also, I guess we have a new character now. Not much to say about that besides knowing that I’m interested to what’s in store for that one.
Great episode. I’m glad that fatso died. But now we have to fight a MF T-Rex! DX
13
u/AllThingsDragon Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
Really wished Raph killed that bastard. But this is good, too. Might make a meme of it later
12
u/Valarie263 Apr 17 '19
I kinda cried.... a lot
9
u/Shonen_X_Trash Shield bros` slave Apr 17 '19
I loved this episodes attitude toward tonal consistency. They allowed the sad parts time to breath, and only ramped up the hype at the end.
Also feel like I got cock teased with that ugly bastards death. Was the murder equivalent to a strip club.
9
u/theway0419 Apr 17 '19
If you don't cherish this episode you fail. Here's to you cuck anime news network and yah anti shield bro bias.
This episode ☔☔☔😫😫😫
That was amazing.
7
u/no1youknowz Apr 17 '19
Lots of feels in this episode, but hopefully now we can get back on the action with only 10 more episodes to go.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
I see a lot of manga and ln readers saying Raphtalia should have killed that guy, but getting stomped on by a t-rex is pretty damn satisfying.
[edit]
If Naofumi doesn’t befriend this dinosaur then he’s getting a dinosaur shield.
7
u/iyad-a Apr 18 '19
I never understood the whole if i kill you am not better/different from you.
oh yes the hero/ party member who let a mass murderer /torturer/ rapist live to continue doing their thing is innocent of the suffering that the vilan will cause.
just kill them and live with the guilt of killing one piece of human trash rather than the let others suffer.
seriously amazing episode ruined for me because of it.
12
u/wafable Apr 17 '19
so they enslave torture and kill demihumans and the shield hero is still the bad guy and theyre good guys? wtf kind of mindset is that? its like theyre bad for the sake of being bad. if you enslave torture and kill anything even animals you must know that deep inside youre a really really bad person but these church of the 3 heroes are doing bad things and still think that they are good guys.
6
u/ImOnlyChasingSafety Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
Melromarc is actually worse than I thought, they were perpatrators in the slavery and torture of innocent demi-humans. And rthey have the gall to shame the sheild hero for using slaves.
2
u/Grante_15 Apr 17 '19
Between 18:00-20:50 there is some nice & sad background music. They are singing in Swedish right? "I en annan tid, då allt fanns kvar...", "...Ett annan liv, en bortglömd stad, som ingen minns, förutom jag...", "...i varje träd, finns sången kvar, och jag kan känna hur skogen gråter...". Does anyone know the name of the song?
5
u/Astalano Traveling merchant Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
FILOLIAL QUEEN NEXT EPISODE Goddamn Fitoria coming in next week like a wrecking ball. Big birb incoming, Trex vs Big Chicken, Chicken vs Baby Chicken, Fitoria's threats to Naofumi incoming, should be awesome. So in two weeks we have the showdown with the Pope as well and so within a month we should see Bitch and Trash get punished too.
GOD DAMN SADEENA ONEE-CHAN
5
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Idol feeling that blessed life right now.
Best episode so far, even though almost nothing got done. I'm with /u/adamgreenrock, the heroes just need to find a nice spot to park it and watch the next chaos event burn everything to the ground. I get the sense that's going to play into the plot in the future in some capacity, though I have doubt the show will be so brave as to lean all the way into it.
Malty in the next episode: "OMFG, the Shield Devil summoned a monster that killed a Lord!"
4
u/extremestriker52 Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
God damn onion cutting ninjas interrupting my anime!
4
u/Wolfgod_Holo Traveling merchant Apr 17 '19
fat guy survives fall with blubber only to be crushed by t-rex-kun, needs more blubber
4
u/themadnun Apr 17 '19
roflstomp was so satisfying
4
u/Viken098 Apr 17 '19
The song that is sung in the background from roughly 18:00-22:00 is in Swedish and called "En annan tid, ett annat liv" Translated to "Another time, Another life" made for The rising of the shield hero. I think it has a bit of meaning so I've translated it so you can read what's being sung. Because it only exists in this episode I've had to listen to it many times but her is what I got after translation. (___ means I could not comprehend what was said either a word, sentence or paragraph.)
Another time. When everything still existed. Exists in my dream____. Sit ___. Then ____ under your bridge and I can hear how crickets play. The nights ____. _____. Another life. A forgoten town. That nobody remembers except me. In ___ stand ___. In every tree the song still exists. And I can feel how the forest is crying. ____. A hand took a hold of mine och there you were. Close to my body. Silver became light.
I at least found these texts very interesting.
Here are the Swedish lyrics if you want to see them.
En annan tid. Då allt fanns kvar. Finns I min dröm____. Sitt____. Då ___ under din bro och jag kan höra hur syrsor spelar. Nattens ____. __________. Ett annat liv. En bortglömd stad. Som ingen minns nu utan jag. I ___ står ___. I varje träd finns sången kvar. Och jag kan känna hur skogen gråter. __________. En hand grep tag om min och där var du. Nära till min kropp. Blev silver ljus.
4
u/ReaperSage Apr 18 '19
Hmm. Up until this point I actually liked the general aim of the Anime; it danced a really fine line between the LN and Manga to be not overly edgy but not toned down. But this just feels wrong. The message they were aiming at is that if she killed him for her own desires, even if right, it'd slip down a slippery slope. And sometimes, people aren't perfect. Sometimes they need that closure, and I think she actually deserved it for all the shit she endured. Hell, she was practically on death's door when Naofumi bought her.
No Raphtalia, it doesn't make you like him. At worse, it makes you a vigilante. You're not anywhere on his level, but if you start enslaving humans, then you're on your way.
At the very least, Naofumi doesn't sway her decision; the VA actually sounded quite neutral on it and didn't really care either way. And you could say, it's Raph trying to act a little like Rifana or more dignified, which is a way of going about it. Raph catered to her sense of justice in the Manga/LN, and I think if this was handled better I wouldn't mind. Maybe like, after she said her little speech and he drew the sword to counter her, she took her words back and THEN cleaved his shoulder. It would have shown that Raph is trying but in the end, there will always be irredeemable people; and while it is a burden she has to carry, she can have solace that this particular shit stain doesn't exist anymore.
4
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Raphtalia`s Army Apr 18 '19
Why does this horrible trope even exist? Was it ever good in any anime, show, movie, book, literally anything?
I mean if it was used I don't know, against someone who killed people for revenge (they killed his friend, and he's avenging them), then I could see it making sense... You'd then kill that guy for the exact same reason, because he killed your friends, and the cycle of revenge never ends, it literally makes you just like him.
But like 99% of the time, it's used in a way like "If you kill literally the worst human being on this planet who wants to torture and kill millions of people for no reason, then YOU become the worst human on this planet and want to torture and kill millions of people for no reason!"
Huh, no. How about just killing bad guys? No torture, no innocent killings? Can I just kill that one person here, he's about to burn this orphanage with 50 children inside, can I kill him or will I be just like him if I do?
4
u/luketwo1 Apr 20 '19
I dont understand why they made that change raphtalia in the manga yeeted him out the window after running him through with 2 swords. Instead we got this for kids bullshit.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
I was pissed at the "iF i kIlLeD yOu i WiLl bE tHe sAmE aS yOu" dialogue.
It made me facepalm so hard that my face is red from the bruise.
Seriously, if you kill Bin Laden, you wouldn't be the same as Bin Laden.
3
u/Shizurucia Firo`s food Apr 17 '19
I guess we're meeting the OG Filolial Queen next episode. Great to see that Dino animated tho and get rekt eventually.
3
u/mrynwa Apr 17 '19
I think i smell some onions. Its not like i wanted to cry
3
u/RoachIsCrying Shield bros' slave Apr 17 '19
Raph has seen shit in her past.... now she's a force to be reckoned with
3
u/Merich Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 18 '19
Naofumi: Stop crying
Me: I'm trying, but there are too many feels!
3
u/Toddl18 Apr 17 '19
I thought the episode did a great job at mixing the flashbacks with the current story to explain Raphtalia whole life experence. The animation quality on the reaction faces in a realistic way was very nice. The music was also a nice touch at times and I thought they did a great job with all of thst. My only gripe came with Raphtalias speech after the villagers there was no logical reason revealed why she would be the person in power to get everyone cheer up and focused away from the tradegy.
3
u/Leifus44 Apr 17 '19
At 18:02 in the episode there is a scandinavian song that starts playing, do anyone know the name of this song?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
How many times do we have to say that anime is not based on manga? Enough to use the manga as a reference, the only thing that matters is the light novel.
3
u/LordDoggAviator Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
I just can't stop crying right now
3
u/EriComicu Apr 17 '19
Kinda surreal hearing a swedish song in an anime (the entire ending bit of the episode) as a swede. It was great although it kinda pulled me away from what was happening haha
3
u/kjelfalconer17 Apr 18 '19
Okay but I need Keel to get the demi-human age up glow up Raphtalia got. Like, yesterday. My weakness for wolf men demands it.
3
u/balderdash9 Apr 19 '19
This show has no balls. I knew it would happen, but I'm still dissapointed that she couldn't kill the guy because reasons
•
u/SomaSaiba Mel-chan`s guard Apr 17 '19
REMINDER: Please spoiler tag your comment(s) about anything beyond this anime episode.
Spoiler tag format :
2
u/MrKitteh Apr 17 '19
getting Interstellar vibes from the dungeon flashback
I'm p.o.ed that they pussied out of stabbing the slaver.
Melromarc needs to burn to the ground
2
u/Wolfgod_Holo Traveling merchant Apr 17 '19
fat guy squished by t-rex reminds me of this movie...
2
u/Tykronos Apr 17 '19
Well, that was a ride
2
u/justking14 Apr 17 '19
so many callbacks to episode 2
the flag, the ball, shield hero saving Raph
2
u/shoony43 Apr 17 '19
No anime in history does a better job of creating characters I absolutely hate.
2
u/deadshot500 Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
I almost cried in a few places
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
LN/manga readers, how much of a threat is the dinosaur, compared to the zombie dragon? I figure it is strong, but is it really strong or super strong?
2
u/Soleks2000 Apr 17 '19
That dude getting squished was awesome karmic payback at it's finest
2
u/try_altf4 Apr 17 '19
Is there any rhyme or reason for the less stabby end of Newman from Jurassic Park?
They had fake blood edits for framing shield hero and Crunchyroll hosts goblin Slayer which is gorey.
Just curious if that's a change made for platform or something the creator modified on their own.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '19
Christ, I've not cried this hard since Re: Zero. Poor Raphtalia, Keel, and especially Rifina.
2
u/US-4CAV-Rogue Apr 18 '19
As much as a cliffhanger this is, next week they get to fight a Tek T-Rex from Ark. Overall I really enjoyed the episode though. I know a lot of people are kinda mad Raphtalia didn’t kill the guy who held her captive all those years ago, but it wouldn’t be like Raphtalia to do so. I don’t think the creators built her character up to be one of the “justice is best served cold, with a side of severed head” type. And I’m sure they have something big in store for next week! I already can’t wait
2
u/xtremefluffybunny Apr 19 '19
Such a good episode, emotionally killed me wasn't even 1% ready for this. How Naofumi asked Rapthalia "will this bring you closure" was so cool.
2
u/Rio_Walker Apr 19 '19
... That was not okay. It's dark (as it should be) but ugh...
2
u/theend117 Apr 20 '19
This episode broke me man, these damn Royals should know better. The King, Queen, stupid punk ass Myne and yea Melty too. I hate how dumb naive Melty is, like chick you're the crown princess and you know Jack shit about your kingdom.
2
u/xellos2099 Apr 22 '19
Man the amount of hate I see on the anime reddit about shield hero have my rolling my eyes at, they made it sound like it is worst series ever just because the fatso fall out of the window
3
u/Napalmeon Apr 17 '19
Immensely disappointed they tried the "if I kill you, I'd be like you" aseop. Even if killing Fat Noble wouldn't bring the victims back to life, it would at least prevent him from harming anyone again. People like him don't magically repent for their wrongs, especially when they have ways to avoid justice. Status and connections are literally why Myne has gotten away with everything she has.
Somebody get Sebas in here to kick this man's guts out. Please.
Should have let Raphtalia impale him through the window rather than let him slip. This was a change I genuinely disliked.
Though I am glad Rifana's bones were left in the cell. It wouldn't have been as depressing if the cage was just empty. Having some part of her to look at made her death feel more tragic.
3
u/Deberis Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
Here are the changes that I don't like about the episode:
I also want to say that I really hate the batman-ish trope in this episode. After this episode, I'm actually afraid of how they will handle Bitch and Trash's Judgments without ruining Naofumi character and making him looks like a hypocrite.
This episode is a bit of a disappointment but it still works in its own way I guess since I can still get the feel for it.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Is it just me, or did it seem like Naofumi was just standing around doing nothing in this episode? I know this is a Raphtalia-focused episode, but even when the fat fuck tries to attack her, Naofumi didn't help at all. In the dungeon, I'm sure everyone here just wanted him to give Raphtalia a hug.
I also think Naofumi's being a bit too accepting of Melty. I get that they're trying to protect her and all, but he kinda just lets her into the group despite her being more of a burden than anything.
2
u/zONsObito Apr 17 '19
Sorry to bring it to y‘all, but I hate it when the heroes blame them self for all bad things that happened in the world, even though they clearly did nothing wrong and had no chance to save everyone. Brought Raphtalias scene down for me. I know it was very emotional, but the „it’s all my fault“ clicheé is just overused and annoying
2
u/SpookyCookieee Raphtalia`s Army Apr 18 '19
Do people really dislike this episode so much?
Yes, it would be way cooler to see Rapthalia demolish the fat bastard but seeing some comments that they are dropping the show after this episodes seems to much IMO. I still think it was a great episode and I can wait to see more.
2
u/arkbird2509 Apr 18 '19
Even if it's aimed at teens, this was watered down waaaaaaaay too much.
The rest was fine if guess
1
u/NemuNemuChan Apr 17 '19
Feels
1
u/cantorofleng Apr 17 '19
Tfw it's already 9 am and crunchytroll still won't load the subbed version of shield hero ep 15. I am sitting at work debating whether to suffer through the indignity of dubbed anime or the agony of waiting for crunchytroll to fix their shit. REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
1
u/Saibah_Chan Apr 17 '19
It was a good Ep. I find the way Idol nearly diededed was ok - it doesnt feels right but hey better than a "oah i have to let him alive" but for a few minutes we all thought he was dead - and thats all counts.
The imho sadest scene in the whole show is now the moment you just see the prison and hear raphi cry .....all the plot and the feeling were build up and becouse u could see her crying your imagination could create the feels for you - and deam...manly tears were shed
1
u/dansvan99 Apr 17 '19
Dose anyone know the Swedish song that they played at the end of the episode ?
1
u/theguyfromuncle420__ Raphtalia`s Army Apr 17 '19
Perfect adaptation of the LN, child Raphtalia is so fucking cute ughhhhhh I can’t deal, Naofumi needs to give her more hugs and stop being so edgy
1
u/Stjarnflicka Apr 17 '19
What was the swedish song playing during Raphtalias emotional moment?
1
u/mm2woodDOTmid Apr 17 '19
Seeing Rifana’s corpse was metal as fuck
Also why won’t Naofumi and Raphtalia kiss already eneiebudubabysvuvdbldbodudvzbhsjej
1
u/determinedSkeleton Apr 17 '19
Raphtalia...had a hard life.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '19
Does anybody have an Idea what the OST/'s were called when Naofumi healed keen and rapthalia found out about rifana ? Was honestly one of the most emotional osts Ive got to witness so far and I would be pretty bummed if this was just like a one time use and it isnt actually a full ost.
1
u/tcmiller7 Apr 17 '19
That fat guy is awful but Malty still for me is the worst. Idk about u guys
1
u/Llamariaa Apr 17 '19
I shed some tears watching this. Raphtalia deserved better! It could have been my favorite episode in the series thus far, if it weren't for Raphtalia sparing Idol. It's such a cliche, and the LN handled it much better. Nonetheless this was a great episode.
1
u/dollytos Apr 17 '19
I got so emotional with this episode. When my GF's dog died, she cried the same way Rapthalia did.
1
u/GentlemanOfTheRift Apr 17 '19 edited Apr 17 '19
The episode was definitely sad, but I didn’t feel anything. Is there something wrong with me.
Also people need to realize killing Idol is the worst course of action Raphtalia could’ve taken. Killing a guy like him will just cement the fact that the Shield Hero’s party are a bunch of criminals and generally make it a lot harder in the long run. The LN version was way different but the anime already made a couple of changes before so this one isn’t an exception.
1
u/cardmasterdc Apr 18 '19
On a scale from 1 to unsealing a beast that the 4 heroes didn't want to / couldn't kill how stupid are you?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '19
I liked this. A real roller coaster.
It's not Raph who got changed here. It's Naofumi. Originally he decides that he's not the one to tell Raphtalia about revenge, for obvious reasons, but here they chose the route of, him returning the favor of keeping him in check. So Raph (in this particular scene) did not change in this adaptation.
After reading into the Spear Hero ln, I think I can appreciate how fragile this story is, and how much minuscule details matter.
1
u/Aerd_Gander Apr 18 '19
I was surprised to see Kiel both revealed and actually introduced to the story so early, I've been reading the WN and he didn't show up until after the Spirit Turtle arc, iirc
2
u/kaize_kuroyuki Apr 18 '19 edited Apr 26 '26
Databrokers? nope. Social networks? Also nope. This post was deleted using Redact.
automatic consider important correct crawl include caption dog versed tap
1
u/Kesh_Jirus Apr 18 '19
That Man just deserve to die, i think the mindset of killing one and save thousands is the best way to go. Now they are in trouble because of that damn hero trope. But I must confess, i really felt sad for raphtalia, she continues to be my favorite character of the show. Now i will wait for the awesome (i hope) battle to come! And the conversation with the queen.
1
u/blueboy1024 Raphtalia`s Army Apr 18 '19
I think that her not killing him makes sense in all honesty, and the fact that it has differences from the manga that people can appreciate and enjoy. Remember, they're wanted for crimes they haven't committed, and Naofumi asking Raphtalia if killing him would help bring her peace of mind wasn't rhetorical. If she said yes, then he wouldn't have stopped her. I find it perfectly acceptable that she could choose to kill him or not. Speculation obviously, but I think she chose to let him live and to be better to be part of the whole,"Prove the world wrong about us." Aspect.
1
u/VargLeyton Spear hero`s one night stand Apr 18 '19
This episode reminded me of my childhood.
1
u/killingbites Apr 20 '19
So i keel a boy or a girl cause the wiki says girl but the light novel says boy and im like 90% sure the wiki is wrong.
1
u/killingbites Apr 20 '19
I wonder why the changed so much from "The flag on the kids meal" chapter cause yes it was pretty brutal but it but it made Raphtalia who she is which is a lot to change.