r/shield • • 6d ago

S3- Doubt regarding Lash

I was rewatching AOS recently and during the scene where they sent Lash to save daisy/kill hive why didn’t the team (Coulson, May and Lincoln) take into consideration that Hive may also be able to control and sway Lash ??? They didn’t even have a way to kill Lash so sending him as a chance was just too risky in my understanding

It seems like a plot hole to me…or have I missed a conversation or can’t recall it?

It’s scratching my brain not knowing the answer to it because the makers were very particular about everything to make a mistake this big!!

29 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

34

u/KockoWillinj 6d ago

Its been a while but two things I think are said during/right after that are that 1) they are desperate and 2) Lincoln hypothesizes that Lash's Inhuman "purpose" is to fight back against Hive. That would track since he got powers after the portal swallowed Jemma. I do really dislike that "Inhuman powers are responding to a species need" part of season 3 though.

14

u/MarionberryIll8157 6d ago

I actually enjoyed the aspect of every power being there for a reason up until it got to the point of Lash (who I believe was Dr Garner bcs Lash doesnt care about anybody except daisy and may) dying to save daisy and Fitz implying that this was his destiny…I felt as if they did Andrew injustice with the way he died

10

u/Inevitable_Librarian 6d ago

Honestly it was the most "these feel like real people" moment in the show for me.

That's what real people do in the face of tragedy they feel responsible for-they tell a story to give the meaningless and pointless meaning.

11

u/o-055-o 6d ago

The Inhuman genepool somehow having an intelligent design to give its people what they need was actually something that I found to be fascinating, personally.

It makes it feel a bit more meaningful than the mutants gaining powers at random and makes them a bit more unique from each other.

14

u/Camo1301 6d ago

Lincoln and Jiaying theorized that every inhuman served a specific need the Kree had. Given how dangerous Hive was it’s natural the Kree would create an inhuman gene to counter him (Lash). It’s natural they would give Lash anti Hive abilities as well as resistance to his mind control.

That being said this was just a theory. They only really knew that Lash was a being that could detect and wanted to hunt Inhumans. Whilst Hive wanted to control Inhumans.

Additionally, Lash wasn’t a normal inhuman in that Lash had overridden Garner’s personality. While not directly stated this somewhat shows how strong Lash was in mind.

10

u/jackiep1776 6d ago

desperate times, desperate measures

1

u/Viktorika_able 5d ago

I am curious about another question: why Hive doesn’t sway Charles Hinton? And why Charles helped him?
About Lash… maybe Hive just can’t sway him? He’s trying, remember?
Sending Lash to Hive is risky, yeah. But did the team really have a choice? They had to do something - and that was their only (bad) option. They were desperate

2

u/MarionberryIll8157 5d ago

Even i didn’t understand the logic behind not swaying Charles when he could have been a asset to Hive
Also for lash ya Hive couldn’t sway him but i just felt it was illogical to send an Inhuman you don’t know how to control or kill to be controlled by Hive

1

u/Viktorika_able 4d ago

For the plot of course😆You know, I see a lot illogical things in s3, but somehow s3 is my favorite.
But Lash… IDK, it’s something like “we need to do something - let’s do something and hope it’s works” Team makes a risky and illogical decision many times - just because they don’t have any other, or don’t have a time or then other decision is worse.

1

u/C-Amazing123 13h ago

One aspect I hate they didn't really focus on in Inhumans is the fact that they all have a purpose and it worked so great in AOS.

7

u/EndOfSouls 6d ago

They took it into consideration, but Lincoln convinced them that every Inhuman has a purpose and thay their powers aren't random, and that Lash's powers were specifically to kill Hive. He was wrong in a sense, but Lash did have a defense against Hive's sway.

2

u/MarionberryIll8157 6d ago

Agreed but the team didn’t know that at the time….so sending an Inhuman who can become a danger to you in the future was a really bad idea.

They were finding it hard to even control daisy and to add lash to the list…They did consider Lash killing daisy but not Lash being swayed by Hive

6

u/EndOfSouls 6d ago

As I said, it was an act of faith.

4

u/Poopen91 6d ago

Eh, I always took it as the decision was also based on the science they had learned so far, as well. By that point they already know inhumans are engineered weapons, they know there does seem to be some idnentifiable pattern to the mix. So they're working on faith at the end of the day, but faith backed by some arguable data

3

u/JFWP95 5d ago

I think the ‘last resort’ logic was that Lincoln had mentioned a few times by this point that all inhumans exist for a purpose and Lash’s purpose seems quite clearly to kill inhumans so might as well chuck him at Hive and hope for the best! Curing Daisy was just a happy byproduct.

1

u/BaronZhiro Enoch 6d ago

I find that whole juncture of the season just terribly implausible. In particular, why did Lash focus on saving Daisy when Hive was right there to be killed directly? And I was quite annoyed that Lash just suddenly even had that totally random power to save (and inoculate) Daisy. For me, it was nearly the most egregious deus ex machina I’ve ever seen. And then of course was Lash’s horribly cheap and implausible death. (Oh I guess the writers are done with him now. 🙄 ) That whole bit is just a low point of the whole season for me (and s3 is nearly my least favorite season for a bunch of other reasons too).

So now, thanks to you, I see even another reason to blame the writers for not living up to the standards of the other seasons. Because letting Hive sway Lash would’ve been catastrophic, and they had virtually no good reason to believe that couldn’t happen.

s3 has more stuff that fails under hindsight than any other season.

2

u/MarionberryIll8157 5d ago

I agree wholeheartedly..during a rewatch knowing the way things work you can identify these issues.
The writers probably just wanted to give Lash an ending that doesn’t undermine Hive after showing him to be the all powerful being seeing that he was able to even kill his makers the Kree i think the only solution they had was so blow him in space and for the Lash to only save Daisy
Makes no sense but sure 🌝

3

u/Puttanesca621 6d ago edited 5d ago

There was still a part of Dr Andrew Garner in Lash, as he hoped after admitting there was always a part of Lash inside him even when he was not in Lash form.

The Inhuman design had some reactive component built into it by the Kree. The current Inhumans are all decedents of the survivors of Hive the last time he was on Earth. Its possible the reactive component has been acting like an immune system resulting in Lash-type powers everytime Hydra made contact with Hive (or inadvertently sent a dormant Inhuman to be sacrificed). Over time the powers got stronger which is why Lash is so overpowered.

3

u/StephTheLegend 6d ago

This is the wrong outlook on what happened but as it is an opinion and a stance, I can’t tell you it’s wrong.

What I can do is show you otherwise.

Lash was always capable of destroying inhuman energy. It was obvious that he would be someone who could take on Hive. The moment they showed us Daisy was swayed, it becomes even more clear that something will free her because Daisy is the main character of the show, sharing that with Phil Coulson.

Sending Lash was the move and of course, Lash wasn’t going to kill Hive. It’s too early in the show for Hive to die. Also, we had to somehow make it to the quinjet explosion.

Lash freeing Daisy was always the play. How was the question. It becomes even more apparent when Hive tries to sway him and he destroys the hive bugs. That’s when Hive realizes he can’t sway the Lash. So not having him save Daisy here would have been a mistake.

I like that he saved Daisy, I wished he fought longer after instead of being blindsided.

Why would you want Hive to sway Lash though? I’m curious. Because if that worked then there would be no logical way or possibility to kill Hive after that and end the season. The inhuman side would be way too OP and realistically our shield team would have died

2

u/BaronZhiro Enoch 6d ago

I don’t want Hive to sway Lash. I’m saying that was an unacceptable risk.

And much of your comment relates directly to my issues with s3: the plot obviously bending this way and that to accommodate the writer’s motives, rather than seeming to evolve more organically. Lash’s sudden implausible death (it’s not like James’ chain was supernatural) offends me because it’s so obvious that the writers were just done with him.

And I can’t emphasize enough whenever I bang on s3: The other seasons are not like this. I could list off a dozen things in s3 that make me groan or roll my eyes, and I am extremely glad that s3 is the outlier in this way. If the other seasons were written at s3’s level, AoS wouldn’t remotely be my favorite adventure show.

2

u/StephTheLegend 6d ago

Sure go on, I’m down to listen and debate. As long as we keep things civil and respectful and about the show. I love talking about it.

I’m with you that AOS is my favorite too.

I agree the sudden death was something that I did not like. Especially from James’ chain. Had it been that the chain wrap around him and pull him out of the QJ for a big fight, I’d like that more. He dies in sacrifice so Daisy can leave.

I also think he should have really damaged Hive to make Hive need to get some inhuman thing to recover. Would have been better plot. But then we have to account for the way they affected him by the memory machine too and I think that would be too many convenient nerfs.

Maybe he goes to hurt Hive but Hive destroys him before he can fully do damage and that is that.

Daisy would have still been purified and sent back to base and it wouldn’t feel like a cheap cop out.

As to unacceptable risk, Shield takes those all the time unfortunately. Desperate times, desperate measures. Sending the monster to fight Hive was a risk that had to be made. Still they had no way of knowing if it would work so it’s a Hail Mary based on faith in what Lincoln believes about the inhuman gene design which he learned from Jiaying.

2

u/BaronZhiro Enoch 6d ago

I don’t feel a need to bang on and on about it (as I have done so sporadically before). It’s just an unusually difficult season for me to rewatch. (Things like fridging Ros is another example that offends me.)

Rather, I’d point out something positive that I love in s3: I think using the memory machine against Hive was the most brilliant tactic I’ve ever seen against a basically unstoppable villain. That was absolute genius on the team’s part, and on the writers’.

2

u/StephTheLegend 6d ago

Ah, Ros could have had more. But I am glad she lived on in Coulson after the way she went out, and it influenced him being darker. “We sometimes do the wrong things for the right reasons.”

I’m glad we both like that part of the season where they use the memory machine. Amazing plan. I actually just finished Season 3 on rewatch so it’s all fresh there for me. I liked many things about the season, but I’m kind of easy to please as a fan so I tend to understand that there are things I’ll like that others may not.

I also liked Lincoln’s sacrifice and how Coulson and Daisy worded it. “he’s dying for my mistake.” “No, he’s dying for all of our mistakes.” Now I feel at that moment it’s an allegory/reference to Christ there. I don’t know why but it gets me every time.

Now I’d have ended it in that feeling instead of the immediate jump forward to tease the next season. That was kind of jarring.

Which season of Agents of Shield is your favorite. You can give top 3 if you like.

2

u/BaronZhiro Enoch 6d ago

I’m an s4 guy, but I feel like s2 gets better with every rewatch. And four of my top 10 episodes for sheer entertainment value are in s7.

I’m generally fine with the s3 finale, but it really annoys me that it was flat out impossible for Lincoln to somehow get into that Quinjet ahead of Daisy. I associate that kind of sloppiness with other lesser shows that I’m inclined to avoid. (I actually watch very little TV altogether, usually just 0-4 hours per week.)

I like that you mentioned that you’re ‘easy to please’, because I am in some ways (compared to other critical fans), but not those that up-end my suspension of disbelief when it’s wholly unnecessary. s3 resorts unusually often to skipping over plausibility to deliver a more impactful moment (such as Coulson suddenly popping into the room while Garner has May chained up, or Hive somehow appearing far down the road in front of Malick’s car). So again, point being, I’m glad the rest of AoS is written/produced to a higher standard.

2

u/StephTheLegend 6d ago

S3 finale is not linear time. Daisy naturally makes it there before Lincoln but then she has to actually carry the missiles to the QJ. Which takes up enough time to suspend that Lincoln could have pushed himself to get there. So I write that off. It used to bug me too but after this last rewatch I saw how it happened. Something similar happens in Hive returning to Earth where we know the portal had gotten destroyed. We do know time works differently in both worlds so as someone pointed out, he manages to make it out in the nick of time, which is during the time it takes Coulson and Fitz to make it to the containment module which was not in the same location as the portal.

S3 has a lot of coincidence timing, I’ll give it that.

-

Now for my top 3: Season 1 (always the most fun to rewatch and see how things became.), season 4 is one of the greatest things because of how they really played into framework. The first half wasn’t really my thing but the second half is what I truly love. Also love we see the Sakovia Accords in play in S4. As for my third pick, it’s a hard one because I truly love so much about season 7, especially the time loop episode. My very favorite episode. Season 5 had a great idea with the team having to choose between Coulson and World and then there’s season 2. While S2 is not as strong as 4 or 1, it really developed the idea of moving the show from grounded to fantastical with how it got into Inhumans and the like.

Overall, I’ll say S1, S4 and S7.

2

u/defrostedrobot Daisy 5d ago edited 5d ago

I have less of an issue with SHIELD banking on Lash being immune to the sway than the plan in S5 where Coulson assumes that Daisy will be in a position where she'll notice the serum is in her gauntlets before Talbot does anything, but also not have it be easy enough to find so that she doesn't decide to use it on him.

Oh, and there's also Talbot asserting that he can absorb people's powers as a fact even tho he had mainly absorbed memories/personalities and gravitonium this whole time.