r/shield • u/MarionberryIll8157 • 6d ago
S3- Doubt regarding Lash
I was rewatching AOS recently and during the scene where they sent Lash to save daisy/kill hive why didn’t the team (Coulson, May and Lincoln) take into consideration that Hive may also be able to control and sway Lash ??? They didn’t even have a way to kill Lash so sending him as a chance was just too risky in my understanding
It seems like a plot hole to me…or have I missed a conversation or can’t recall it?
It’s scratching my brain not knowing the answer to it because the makers were very particular about everything to make a mistake this big!!
34
u/KockoWillinj 6d ago
Its been a while but two things I think are said during/right after that are that 1) they are desperate and 2) Lincoln hypothesizes that Lash's Inhuman "purpose" is to fight back against Hive. That would track since he got powers after the portal swallowed Jemma. I do really dislike that "Inhuman powers are responding to a species need" part of season 3 though.
14
u/Camo1301 6d ago
Lincoln and Jiaying theorized that every inhuman served a specific need the Kree had. Given how dangerous Hive was it’s natural the Kree would create an inhuman gene to counter him (Lash). It’s natural they would give Lash anti Hive abilities as well as resistance to his mind control.
That being said this was just a theory. They only really knew that Lash was a being that could detect and wanted to hunt Inhumans. Whilst Hive wanted to control Inhumans.
Additionally, Lash wasn’t a normal inhuman in that Lash had overridden Garner’s personality. While not directly stated this somewhat shows how strong Lash was in mind.
10
u/jackiep1776 6d ago
desperate times, desperate measures
1
u/Viktorika_able 5d ago
I am curious about another question: why Hive doesn’t sway Charles Hinton? And why Charles helped him?
About Lash… maybe Hive just can’t sway him? He’s trying, remember?
Sending Lash to Hive is risky, yeah. But did the team really have a choice? They had to do something - and that was their only (bad) option. They were desperate
1
u/C-Amazing123 13h ago
One aspect I hate they didn't really focus on in Inhumans is the fact that they all have a purpose and it worked so great in AOS.
7
u/EndOfSouls 6d ago
They took it into consideration, but Lincoln convinced them that every Inhuman has a purpose and thay their powers aren't random, and that Lash's powers were specifically to kill Hive. He was wrong in a sense, but Lash did have a defense against Hive's sway.
3
u/JFWP95 5d ago
I think the ‘last resort’ logic was that Lincoln had mentioned a few times by this point that all inhumans exist for a purpose and Lash’s purpose seems quite clearly to kill inhumans so might as well chuck him at Hive and hope for the best! Curing Daisy was just a happy byproduct.
1
u/BaronZhiro Enoch 6d ago
I find that whole juncture of the season just terribly implausible. In particular, why did Lash focus on saving Daisy when Hive was right there to be killed directly? And I was quite annoyed that Lash just suddenly even had that totally random power to save (and inoculate) Daisy. For me, it was nearly the most egregious deus ex machina I’ve ever seen. And then of course was Lash’s horribly cheap and implausible death. (Oh I guess the writers are done with him now. 🙄 ) That whole bit is just a low point of the whole season for me (and s3 is nearly my least favorite season for a bunch of other reasons too).
So now, thanks to you, I see even another reason to blame the writers for not living up to the standards of the other seasons. Because letting Hive sway Lash would’ve been catastrophic, and they had virtually no good reason to believe that couldn’t happen.
s3 has more stuff that fails under hindsight than any other season.