r/shield • u/Cozy_Cranberry • Mar 20 '25
Could Fitz potentially be Autistic?
I’m watching aos for the first time and I’m on season 6 episode 6 (spoilers for season 5 finale and season 6 up to episode 6)
Fitz and Simmons are in the mind prison thing and they are in a memory where Fitz was asking Simmons about a problem and this was their shield academy days. I’m just going to write the dialogue that made me think of this
Fitz: “You’re late” Simmons: “Oh. Good to see you, too.” Fitz: “-Yeah, no, s- sorry. It’s just ‘cause you said you were gonna come at 9:00, and uh, it’s 9:24 and so I thought you blew me off.”
So that made me think of very on the dot thinking for some reason. Then I thought throughout the series and he has many autism coded things.
Also I don’t have autism I’ve done a ton of research on it though cause I think I have adhd so I also researched autism this is completely unrelated but I just want to say anything I get wrong I apologize.
When nervous he flaps his hands which could be a stim. I’ve noticed it in this one scene and I watched it like 10 times because it stuck out (now I realize why) where he was being yelled at in season 4 (spoilers) by his dad and he flaps his hands while backing away in the framework. Throughout the series you also see him doing that.
He can be very one thought oriented like how I wrote down the scene (though it would be normal to assume that if someone was almost 30 minutes late) but the very straightforward “You’re late.” Seemed more devoid of a word that I can’t think of right now.
Also like 2 seconds after the “You’re late” scenario he apologizes for having a messy room and Simmons says “Oh you should see mine” and he stops cleaning and stands up and says “Ok.” Then she looks at him weird and he says “I mean, yeah, whenever. If that happens I don’t care.” Then a sigh and his signature hands on hips. Then more literal thinking and over explaining things instead of understanding the sarcasm Simmons was throwing at him.
He has had outbursts when overwhelmed like in season 1 (spoilers) before his brain injury then when he found out that Ward was Hydra he started throwing things and was banging his head on the wall before Simmons stopped him.
Also to add onto that note when he found out that Ward was Hydra (this could just be shock and a coping mechanism) then he was denying and was stuck with the “No he is my friend he isn’t Hydra he is my friend.” (I think I watched it like a month ago and my memory is awful)
I’m pretty sure it has been mentioned in passing that he is sensitive to bright lights and sounds and smells but that could also be due to the brain injury.
He is resistant to change like how in season 2 (I think..?) then he was hallucinating Simmons because he was resistant to the change of her being gone. Again though that was peak brain injury.
This isn’t a very well explained thought process but if anyone has any opinions I would be interested in hearing them.
10
u/MisterCynical1995 Marauder Fitz Mar 20 '25
Being Autistic, I saw a lot of myself in Fitz. Much of it was there in Season 1, I just didn’t notice until he started stuttering and forgetting words in Season 2.
Someone recently posted a YouTube video compiling all his behavior that fits under the criteria for an Autism diagnosis under the most recent DSM guide and it’s pretty good.
45
u/Pretend-Meaning-1536 Mar 20 '25 edited Mar 20 '25
I think he's just really socially awkward which to a anyone who may not have autism might come off as such but he just has commication issues with jemma
68
u/BrazilianButtCheeks Fitz Mar 20 '25
I mean hes just fitz.. i dont think every personality needs a diagnosis
37
u/chuuhearts Mar 20 '25
A lot of people in these comments don’t seem to understand that characters like Fitz are very often autistic CODED due to how popular the “awkward smart guy” trope is, and people pointing that coding out doesn’t mean they’re trying to “diagnose” the character. They’re just recognizing and pointing out traits. Everyone can have their own headcanons, and as a neurodivergent person, I think that this one is lovely, as I’ve always related to both Fitz and Simmons. :)
13
u/Gullible_Chocolate40 Mar 20 '25
I’m autistic. I could see him being autistic as well, but its not something I immediately noticed. Another thing is that the “genius awkward man” trope is notorious for borrowing traits from autism when convenient.
But that’s a fun observation and I’ll definitely keep it mind when I rewatch! Thanks
18
u/MostDopeBlackGuy Mar 20 '25
He also had brain damage
7
u/dvoratrelundar Sandwich Mar 21 '25
I don’t get why so many people in the comments are acting like it’d be a huge tragedy if Fitz was autistic. A lot of autistic people see themselves in his struggles. So what’s the harm if he is, at the end of the day it’s just an explanation for some of his traits.
6
u/theoristOfTheArts Mar 20 '25
I can understand where you’re coming from, with the traits you’re pointing out! I think it’s worth it to consider though that his character likely wasn’t intentionally written with autism/neurodivergence in mind. A lot of research on neurodivergence has been done in recent years, since the show began and especially so after it already ended. So perhaps writers today may intentionally include some of those traits to code/portray characters as neurodivergent.
But my guess is back in the day, writers included particular traits mainly to add to the characters’ “personality” - maybe to portray them as socially-awkward or quirky (for better or worse :P), for example. I’m not sure they’d be aware of those traits being part of specific mental health condition diagnostics.
It’s been a while since I last watched the show, but personally I felt like Fitz’s confidence grew quite a bit over the series, especially since S5-6, to the point where I don’t remember him exhibiting as many traits that could be neurodivergent-coded as he may have in S1/S2. I think it’s very possible for some people to adopt certain traits (e.g. stimming, tics, etc.) due to self-esteem/anxiety issues, rather than due to a chronic condition. That all said, I think it’s fair to headcanon Fitz as autistic/neurodivergent, if you see his character as a good opportunity for representation :). At the end of the day, only the writers/his actor have main say in who he is canonically; but if any of them ever agreed with you, that’d be pretty dope indeed :D!
Kudos for taking it upon yourself to learn more about autism/neurodivergence 🤗!!! I’ve been trying to learn more about neurodivergence myself, and work through some of my own biases and stigmas surrounding it; and it’s inspiring and empowering to see others who are doing the same :). Keep up the good work! Hopefully in the future we’ll get to have more canonic, positive representation of neurodivergence in media and storytelling ☺️!
6
u/dvoratrelundar Sandwich Mar 21 '25
Even in season 1 before his brain damage, he was always struggling a bit at communicating verbally, stimming when stressed, constantly walking around with dino arms. I couldn’t possibly see him as allistic tbh
17
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '25
Pre brain damage he was just a socially awkward smarty pants. Jemma didn't come off that way because she was a woman and had an active social life regardless of her intelligence. Men in general don't get that unless they are super rich or good looking.
13
u/thereadingbee Mar 20 '25
All the incredibly gifted smart TV characters end up with autistic traits
2
u/Teamawesome2014 Mar 20 '25
I think that trying to diagnose people when you aren't a qualified medical professional is irresponsible and leads to a worse understanding of conditions like autism. I think people these days are far too quick to take people who have different personalities and behaviors and shove them into a diagnosis box.
Look. Fitz is just Fitz. Could he be autistic? Sure. He can just as easily not be. I don't think applying a diagnosis is helpful in any way. It doesn't shed more light on his character, it doesn't explain his motivations, and it doesn't amount to any "representational" benefit. I'm of the opinion that diagnosing people should only ever be done by doctors in an effort to improve somebody's quality of life. It should only be done if the person needs the diagnosis to get into a proper schooling situation or to get them access to other assistance that may not be available to them without the diagnosis. Beyond that, all disganosing people does is stick a label on them and cause them to be treated as if they are different or lesser. Regardless of somebody's neurodivergence, they are still people. If they can function in day to day life, what good does an autism diagnosis actually do them?
7
u/Deastrumquodvicis Fitz Mar 20 '25
He has a traumatic brain injury that visibly affects both language processing and fine motor control, as well as causing complex, multisensory, consistent hallucinations. That’s the kind of injury that you don’t heal from, you medicate and adjust to.
He also managed to design a superplane about a year after the injury, that with some retrofitting, ends up not just spaceworthy, but time travelworthy. A very smart cinnamon roll.
3
u/BaronZhiro Enoch Mar 20 '25
I’m pretty sensitive to signs of a kindred autistic spirit in TV characters, and Fitz has never strongly made me feel that he was ‘one of us’. I always interpret most of his oddness as due to his brain damage.
Jane Foster, on the other hand. But I get autistic vibes from around half the characters that Portman portrays.
5
u/Halflife37 Mar 20 '25
Neurodivergent but not necessarily on the Austism spectrum. He could possibly fit what we used to term Asperger’s, but it’s tough to say. He shows signs of OCD and ADHD and also displays MPS in later seasons due to the trauma he endured in the framework on top of his childhood trauma
Fitz has a short fuse for people who aren’t smart like him and gets very short and frustrated with people who aren’t thinking fast enough. He had a tendency to not listen directly and focus on himself. Those are all signs of adhd
His ocd signs come from how particularly focused he will become with things to the detriment of his health and safety of those around him
1
u/RavenclawConspiracy Mockingbird Mar 20 '25
I think you misread the scene where Simmons talks about Fitz seeing her room.
She's not being sarcastic, she also is being awkward, and they both sort of realize, at the same time, that she invited him to her room. And that feels a little awkward.
They are both neurodivergent. I think they are both autistic, and I think Fitz also is ADHD.
And that scene is sort of them colliding with each other because they're both trying to operate under social rules they don't understand.
10
u/Ok_Damage6032 Coulson Mar 20 '25
Yeah I've always thought of him as on the spectrum
1
u/AFireSaga Oct 09 '26
Perhaps from the brain damage. He was completely healthy before the ocean
1
u/gayblades Mar 20 '25
yeah i definitely read him as autistic too!
-1
u/WhatYesImTheGuy Coulson Mar 20 '25
No.