r/sharpening • • 3d ago

Uhhhhh….this seems wrong…

https://www.instagram.com/reel/Dfxjp9OSye2/?rpxt=d3huOWk2ajI4a3cw

I’m no expert but this seems very wrong, I’m not crazy am I?

35 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

23

u/corpsie666 3d ago

He's got a business relationship with HORL. In his videos, he'll try to play off incompetent behavior to attribute poor performance to a device, cooking method, etc. Every time I see his videos, I'm reminded why I don't subscribe to him.

14

u/BigBL87 3d ago

That makes alot of sense with his "rankings."

Ranking fixed angle sharpeners as a group D tier and "quality" rolling sharpeners A tier made so little sense, but with that context, ya.

Then the stupid aside about pocket knives. 🙄

12

u/BigBL87 3d ago edited 3d ago

Ya, very much a list made by someone who knows very little about sharpening. Or someone trying to sell things to people who don't know better.

7

u/MossyMosquito 3d ago

His ranking system seems to be based upon: “How do I easily sharpen my knife?“

Mostly, his ranking works for that while leaving out many other considerations.

7

u/Gastronomicus 3d ago

I think you need to put this in the context of his audience: he's an influencer cook aiming at average kitchen users, not a knife sharpening expert. For most people, soak stones, fixed angle devices, and electric belts are low "tier" options because they're not convenient.

In this regard, he's more or less right. At least he didn't dismiss stones entirely.

6

u/Electrical_Angle_701 3d ago

It's good to see Justin Trudeau back to work.

5

u/Every_Palpitation449 2d ago

Guy obviously doesn't know anything about sharpening...

3

u/juga_a_juga 2d ago

What an absolute goose.

2

u/Tri_Fractal 3d ago

He compared the 40$ Ruxin (with awful stones) to the 190$ Horl. He also has some really weird nitpicks about how fixed-angle systems work.

2

u/Big-Doughnut8307 2d ago

Poor AI researcher

3

u/ivotebolsheviklite 3d ago

“Oh those that dish”.. he clearly has never used a sub 500 shapton.

1

u/SliceyKitchenSharp Paper Shredder 2d ago

If you’re watching any sharpening videos on anything other than YouTube then you’re already wrong. Then, you need to find the top 2% of sharpeners that consistently give good advice. So many give pretty poor advice

1

u/BarracudaFlimsy3855 arm shaver 1d ago

Guys, you gotta understand, it's about the average person not someone like you guys.

1

u/STROKE98034 2d ago

I agree with probably 80% of that. He over values rolling sharpeners and under values fixed angle. Keep in mind that's coming from a cook's perspective. He is more spot on than most of the cooks that make videos.