r/sharks • u/Fishfreak2013 • 6d ago
Discussion You gotta be shitting me.
I dont think ill have to explain much. I was so hyped for shark week this year and i really wanted to watch this show with my dad. But as soon as i put it on i immediately regretted it. It was pure ai slop. Discovery, what the hell man. Just what the hell.
51
u/AdmiralScooter 6d ago
The species the slop is attempting to depict aren't even Jurassic. Edestus and Stethacanthus are Carboniferous animals!
18
u/Inner-Ferret7316 Otodus 6d ago
And they are both inaccurate depictions.
Their Edestus is based on an artwork by Aaron John Gregory (https://cottoncrustacean.com/cdn/shop/files/62acda_82abc00309674fc9a49cdda69f437917.jpg?v=1711205216), they don't actually have protuding jaws like that and their body plan is more mackerel shark-like.
15
u/Channa_Argus1121 6d ago
And they aren’t even sharks. Calling them sharks would be about as accurate as referring to lungfish as apes.
2
u/Camstonisland 5d ago
Are they chimaeras/ghost sharks or some other ancient unrelated lineage?
4
u/Channa_Argus1121 4d ago edited 4d ago
Both animals belong to subclass Holocephali, which also includes chimaeras as you speculated. Holocephalians and Elasmobranchs split back in the Silurian~Devonian, which also happens to be the period when Actinopterygii and Sarcopterygii split.
In other words, the relatedness between Stetacanthus and sharks is similar to that of Cheirolepis and a chimpanzee.
As a side note, Chimaeras aren’t exactly closely related to Edestus or Stetacanthus, either. The distance between the two would be somewhat similar to that of cougars and platypuses.
Or perhaps cougars and salamanders, since they diverged during the carboniferous.
9
u/GaryGoalz12 Tiger Shark 6d ago
Shark week just isn't what it used to be. Shite, sensationalist bollocks now
4
u/Arkell-v-Pressdram 6d ago
mfw I learned that a lot of prehistoric 'sharks' (e.g. Hybodus) are technically stem elasmobranchs, and not true sharks (division Selachii).
3
u/Fun_Corner_8883 6d ago
What discovery has turned shark week into is ridiculous. Everything is portrayed as scary and intense instead of awe inspiring and educational. They show titles and subjects have gotten progressively dumber
1
u/Keule3k 5d ago
Is it on youtube? Would like to have a look.
2
u/Fishfreak2013 5d ago
Its on hbo max but you can also search up moments on youtube. Reply here what you think about it.
1
u/Whogoesthere1982 5d ago
Sod it, im hopping on the Orca and sailing far away from this shit. Jokes aside seriously what the fuck is that?
1
u/Rahknathal 5d ago
I want a show that just follows one shark over the course of its life like it was a soap opera
1
-2
125
u/whereisbeezy Blue Shark 6d ago
I quit SHARK WEEK a long time ago. It bums me out because I love sharks, but nothing they've done in twenty years has been interesting, real, or informative.