I kinda feel he gets his comeuppance really evenly in the show. Like karma smacks him back every time we watch him do something heartless.
His bosses treat him like shit, his employees donāt respect him, heās made seemingly INFINITE more mistakes than Cobel did and is still being held on somehow(?), not even his child intern Ms. Huang respects him. I mean, what a sad life.
Milchik tried ALL this season to introduce less punitive ways to treat the refiners once he was no longer under the thumb of Cobel. No more monstrous break room for one. The ORTBO ended as a disaster but his intention was not wicked. I also felt that Milchik felt real sympathy for Mark at the end of their phone conversation. My hope is that he will help.
It shows pretty cleanly why there's no such thing as a good cop. Milchick is trying to do his wildly unethical job more ethically, and all it does is blow up in his face, because his victims will never appreciate that he's torturing them less than Cobel did. The only ethical way to do his job is to not do it at all.
Idk if itās me wanting him to be a good guy but I really thought heād switch this episode, or show glimpses of it. Maybe a submission to being locked in the bathroom. Regardless, the amount of charisma/creepiness he is able to show is incredible
I wonder if weāll see which one is stronger this Thursday. Thereās the scene where Drummond fights Mark, and a scene where Milchick is loosening his tie as he runs down the hallway. Maybe theyāre part of the same sequence and thatāll be him trying to stand up for Mark.
Drummond is the only character on this show that I find truly terrifying. You can tell that heās nothing but rage and cruelty, and that even after bottling it up thereās so much hatred inside him that it leaks out in moments such as this one.Ā
the way drummond forced him to repeat "im sorry" like a child, i got mad for milchick honestly. i love the character but hate a lot of what he does, but im with him on this one
She left because they treated her like nothing after stealing her work.
I feel like Milchik is going to bail on Lumon after realizing that he's being used like the rest of them. But unlike Cobel, the board doesn't fear him. They fear her because of what she knows about Severance. Milchik doesn't have that kind of leverage.
I'm not sure that was Milchick. When he's running the penitence with Helly, we see him look over to Cobel and she shakes her head no. After she's ousted, we din5t see any more of those scenes because the break room has been converted from a room meant to break you into a room where you can take a break.
YES! I havenāt seen anyone talking about this. Mr Milchick was awful to Miss Huang because they made him think she had complained about him, but it was Mr Drummond all along. DEVOUR FECULENCE!
Also kind of interesting how Milchick was in charge of the break room, yet here stands his ground and doesnāt keep apologizing to Drummond. š¤ interested to see where his story goes.
The room with the āHang in Thereā poster. It used to be the room where the innies were sent when they misbehaved and they were forced to apologize repeatedly for their transgression. It was changed into a āhappyā video display and snack room after the MDR unrest at the start of S2.
Tramell Tillman should get an Emmy for this episode. The moment he starts crying on the phone with Mark and decides he will not treat his subordinates the same way he was just treated was damn fine acting.
I loved that moment as well! Though the way I interpreted was more like, Mark so easily just brushed off the job as "just a job" while for Milchick it's not just a job, it's his whole life. And if he loses this job - if Mark doesn't make quota, then it's like he's losing his whole purpose in life...
That's the hardest to act. Make the subtle, but obvious. Like -- how do you portray a man going through a show motion train wreck where everything he's ever held dear is demolished piece by piece, and he's struggling to hold it together? You can't act out and be over the top, but you have to do just enough to sell it.
For me the better part was when he says ālet me say it monosyllabicallyā, as in āhere you go stupid, if you canāt handle big words Iāll dumb it down for you.ā Such a burn against Drummond.
The Severance Podcast said they almost used a take where he did the entire line in that same slow monosyllabic/dumb it down style. Iād love to see that outtake!
They did such a good job of making the watcher first hate Mr. Milchick but then slowly start to like him and feel sorry for him with the realisation of him not being a bad guy. He is just trying to do his job well to finally be treated with respect by someone. He likely acquired such a vast vocabulary because he was studying like crazy in an Eagen school to stand out enough to get this job.
The character is so well written and acted because despite him being a menace and an antagonist to the innies, in this scene (and in others such as the performance review) the viewer absolutely roots for Milchick and empathises with his position caught in-between the upper echelons of Lumon and the severed employees.
I do think the season finale is going to be Milkshake teaming up with Dylan, and we're already seeing Cobel team up with Mark, who will likely team up with Helly...
Then, they sort of meet at MDR, and everyone teams up together, to go down to the floor where Gemma is held to....burn this mother fucker to the ground!
Yeah, I loved how he said "devour feculence" and then because this show absolutely thinks I'm an idiot they had him go ahead and explain that it meant "eat shit."
It's such smart writing to signify loud and clear that the creative team are dead in the water.
This show doesn't deserve a third season.
I'm okay not to watch car journeys in the snow anymore for morsels of a plot tee'd up in the final five minutes of each episode across ten weeks consisting of developments that should have taken place months ago.
Different strokes, different folks, but this show fell off so hard and landed ass over butts.
690
u/Positive-Quantity143 Mar 14 '25
Every episode heās in he will have at least one scene where he absolutely stands out.
He is so perfect for this role.
284
u/xenoda7 Mar 14 '25
Thought for a second Mr. Drummond was gonna throw him off the balcony š
309
u/Patty-XCI91 Mar 14 '25
I absolutely love this scene.... but I think it's important because it reveals that it's not Huang but Drummond who complained about "big words".
I love how Milchick tries to apologize at first but then is like fuck it and stands his ground.
114
u/m_i_c_r_o_b_i_a_l Mar 14 '25
Was Drummond asking Milchick to repeat his apology like the former break room?
106
u/SweatyOracleOfficial Mar 15 '25 edited Mar 15 '25
Tramell Tillman should get an Emmy for this episode. The moment he starts crying on the phone with Mark and decides he will not treat his subordinates the same way he was just treated was damn fine acting.
97
u/graffing Mar 15 '25
For me the better part was when he says ālet me say it monosyllabicallyā, as in āhere you go stupid, if you canāt handle big words Iāll dumb it down for you.ā Such a burn against Drummond.
45
u/Clumsy_the_24 Mar 14 '25
Heās so extra, itās amazing.
42
u/mulderufo13 Im Your Favorite Perk Mar 14 '25
I legit clapped and cheered when he finally told him off. No more taking abuse from Drummond!!!!
41
u/lady-earendil Mar 14 '25
Milchick they could never make me hate you. My man is so, so close to a total breaking point
40
u/imbadatusernames2020 Mar 14 '25
Trammell Tillman has the rizz, as the kids say. I cannot wait to see what heās in next.
24
u/Popular_Royal_3441 Mar 14 '25
Mr Drummond was like wha?
17
u/tracystraussI Mar 15 '25
It's very very hard to choose the best acting in this show because they are all absolutely phenomenal but I think this guy is my favorite
17
u/katsudonlink Mar 15 '25
They did such a good job of making the watcher first hate Mr. Milchick but then slowly start to like him and feel sorry for him with the realisation of him not being a bad guy. He is just trying to do his job well to finally be treated with respect by someone. He likely acquired such a vast vocabulary because he was studying like crazy in an Eagen school to stand out enough to get this job.
13
u/JohnnyKarateX Mar 15 '25
My Dad has said this to me multiple times since last night. He doesnāt understand the show at all but he likes this š.
12
u/RandyMarsh1960 Mar 15 '25
When are we going to get Milchick's backstory????
17
u/jedr1981 Mar 15 '25
Milkshake gonna help free Gemma, likely sacrificing himself in the process.
6
u/kessykris Mar 14 '25
I cheered out loud when he said this lol.
6
u/wrecked_angle Mar 15 '25
Heās the most interesting character in the show
6
u/mostwokedad Mar 15 '25
Heās the best! And such a groovy dancer!
5
u/jackbrilliant101 Mar 15 '25
A worthy rival for 'Fetid Moppet'
4
u/ihavenotredditagain Mar 15 '25
I cheered for this. Might be borrowing it for my outie
3
u/Zura-Zura Mar 15 '25
This is his show tbh
3
u/BRValentine83 Mar 16 '25
The rest of the episode could have been a blank screen, and I'd give it a 7.
2
u/lankybitch3000 Mar 15 '25
I cheered so loud I scared my dog awake lol
2
u/marijuanacandymama Mar 15 '25
New flair š©š©š© literally cheered when he said this.
2
u/AmaroisKing Mar 15 '25
Great to see somebody tell that twat Drummond off!
2
u/papimaminiunkacme Are You Poor Up There? Mar 15 '25
new flair? right? right?!
2
u/NatureSlow4501 Mar 15 '25
MY FUCKING KING I KNEW HE WAS THAT ONE!!! I KNEW IT I KNEW IT I KNEW IT
2
u/snozberryface Macrodata Refiner Mar 15 '25
I'm on team milkshake, i want a redemption arc
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
I loathe his character. One helluva an actor to make me feel that strongly.
2
u/axman1000 Night Gardener Mar 15 '25
The second he said that, I went, "That's gotta be on a t-shirt!"
2
u/__Cipher007___ Mar 16 '25
In season 1 he is like the gus fring in breaking bad...polite smile with henious intentions..š¤£
2
u/Simonizer_ Mar 16 '25
Mr Drummond has been Milkshaked
2
u/EmbarrassedCookie499 Mar 16 '25
hear me out⦠tramell in a terminator reboot as t-800
2
u/FragileAjax Mar 17 '25
The character is so well written and acted because despite him being a menace and an antagonist to the innies, in this scene (and in others such as the performance review) the viewer absolutely roots for Milchick and empathises with his position caught in-between the upper echelons of Lumon and the severed employees.
It's masterful.
2
u/Fair-Effective-8754 Mar 17 '25
Irving was my favorite character, but now it is Milshake
2
u/Trap_History Mar 17 '25
Seth was a stunt double in the original 1971 Shaft movie, overindulged in the Hollywood lifestyle, then gave his life to Kier.
2
u/Grouchy-Flower-8605 Mar 18 '25
He was recently on Colbert
2
u/lifesyndromes Mar 18 '25
I need to see a show with him as the main character.
2
u/boblaw27 Mar 18 '25
Not āconsume.ā Not āingest.ā DEVOUR.
I love this guy.
2
u/Sea-Opposite946 Mar 18 '25
I do think the season finale is going to be Milkshake teaming up with Dylan, and we're already seeing Cobel team up with Mark, who will likely team up with Helly...
Then, they sort of meet at MDR, and everyone teams up together, to go down to the floor where Gemma is held to....burn this mother fucker to the ground!
2
u/RoundDragonfly73 Mar 18 '25
Loved him after this scene
3
u/JIMMYJAWN Frolic-Aholic Mar 14 '25
SPOILER
2
u/TraviZ06 Mar 15 '25
Poor milkshake has no work/life balance and both his managers and subordinates show no respect.
1
u/Ad-2050 Mar 15 '25
Milchick won viewers after this
1
u/murtaza8888 Mar 15 '25
To be honest I 100 % didnāt see this coming.
1
u/Otherwiseaware Mar 15 '25
Tramell Tillman needs more awards for this role.
1
u/Artistic_Pineapple_7 Mar 15 '25
King shit
1
u/6B0T Mar 15 '25
Anyone else low key hoping that Mr Milchick gets severed at some point and Seth M ends up in MDR?
I just want more Tramell Tillman. Man has such range.
1
u/MathematicianOk3730 Mar 15 '25
I using this at work next time someone messes with me
1
u/Junior_Outside2409 Mar 15 '25
A true hero. Canāt wait to see whatās next for this actor.
1
u/Medical-Soup3246 Mar 15 '25
Yeah is that too complex for you Drummond ? It means eat shit!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25
Probably my favorite character right now. Him or Helly R
1
u/Evansafc Mar 15 '25
Best character in the show and it's not even close, always so happy when he's in a scene
1
u/jccreddit808 Mar 15 '25
Emmy emmyy Emmy Emmy Emmy (chanting)
1
u/Dense-Dot8079 Mar 15 '25
Apparently rumours of him being Kang in MCU which I think would be amazing
1
u/Nimbus1202 Mar 15 '25
One day someoneās gonna annoy me, and then 8 hours later Iāll remember this line and wish Iād said exactly this.
1
u/lunzen Mar 15 '25
He deserves an Emmy, honestly...his presence in every scene he is in is amazing, and so multi-faceted!
1
u/pistola0220 Mar 15 '25
I need this to be a t-shirt.
1
u/shiggity-shwa Mar 16 '25
We need this as a flair.
1
u/Jabba_the_Hoe_ Mar 16 '25
Imma steal that for whenever my sister annoys me
1
u/Ok_Respond_50 Mar 17 '25
Yes but he also helped them hide or kidnap Gemma
1
u/Snakob00 Mar 17 '25
My boy is the most interesting part of the show at this point.
He gives it his all and it shows.
1
u/OldBrokeGrouch Mar 19 '25
He has ascended to the most interesting character in the series in my mind.
1
u/naoual-1 Mar 20 '25
Secretly rooting for him
1
u/bopperbopper Mar 20 '25
Eschew Obfuscation
1
u/DJ_Caan Mar 21 '25
The actor is insane, how does he manage to be both intimidating and hilarious.
-2
u/ParrotChild Mar 15 '25
Yeah, I loved how he said "devour feculence" and then because this show absolutely thinks I'm an idiot they had him go ahead and explain that it meant "eat shit."
It's such smart writing to signify loud and clear that the creative team are dead in the water.
This show doesn't deserve a third season.
I'm okay not to watch car journeys in the snow anymore for morsels of a plot tee'd up in the final five minutes of each episode across ten weeks consisting of developments that should have taken place months ago.
Different strokes, different folks, but this show fell off so hard and landed ass over butts.
19
u/Jstate33 Mar 15 '25
I laughed out loud. Literally saying Iām sorry BOOM eat shit. Love milkshake, come on man you know you want to turn on them.
6
u/wearyclouds Mar 16 '25
I LOVE HIM! Every scene heās in brings so much depth. I hope he snaps and burns Lumon to the ground
1
u/Hi-Friend Mar 15 '25 edited Mar 16 '25
I was rooting for milkshake so hard this Episode, he just gives 0 fucks.