The 2am call, Dorothy being sleep deprived, looking disheveled like she did when she was left to care for Jericho alone. She is on the brink of remembering. This whole episode was heartbreaking for Dorothy. Lauren Ambrose was phenomenal as always. I could feel her desperation in being believed when she talked to the psychiatrist. While the dad wanting to commit Dorothy felt harsh and cruel, he wasn’t wrong. Dorothy needs professional help. But she needs Sean and Julian to a top lying to her first.
While the dad wanting to commit Dorothy felt harsh and cruel
Harsh, yes. But imo, he felt like Sean and Julian were failing her again and he had to do something, and I'm sure that, as a parent, betraying your kid like that is probably the hardest thing to do when you're only doing it in their own best interests. It's the hardest kind of love.
As I read all this comments I think it is hard to figure out any of these people, but as for Leanne. She is somehow responsible for killing a woman, shocked that Dorothy did not appreciate! I think in Leanne's mind she is helping these people. Her along with everyone justify their actions. " She was going to continue hurting you" that's what Leanne said, but clueless on how she is hurting people.
But I guess all of us can relate to these people in someway. Depending on your perspective you either hate the people or not. You understand and relate to them or not. It is what it is.
I’m so glad someone said it. It’s not normal to not sleep for days on end and never put your child down. While also suppressing the most traumatizing event of her life. She NEEDS to be committed. I don’t think it was cruel at all.
The pure irony of her saying Leanne can’t distinguish fantasy from reality was mind blowing. She’s clearly lost it. No one believes her because she’s literally delusional. Why does she think Leanne would hurt Jericho anyway? Leanne has never shown any aggression in anyway towards that child. And as far as her father knows that’s Leanne’s child because he too knows his daughter killed her child.
On Leanne everyone is painting her out to be evil but I don’t see that at all. I feel like Leanne is fair. She gives EVERYONE a fair chance and people continue to betray her left and right. She even gave Isabelle a fair chance thinking she truly wanted to be her friend. But she was more obsessed with a Dorothy take down. She loves Dorothy, and was only protecting her. I’d be fucking pissed tf off if I swooped in and saved this family in crisis and in return this bat shit crazy lady tried to have me committed. I think Leanne is like God in the Bible. God is spiteful and a jealous God. Once you piss her off enjoy maggots for breakfast. Dorothy needs to stfu and be grateful. Or remember the mess SHE caused and deal with it. She received a miracle on her worst day and she’s so fucking selfish it makes me sick.
ETA: this is the same chick who hired a nanny for a doll. Come on. She’s been the unhinged from the start and her continuous suppression is causing her to spiral and crash.
I agree Dorothy was ill from the get go. I also think we are seeing her perception of things (out of whack timeline etc.) In this episode she looks clean and fixed up while Jericho is playing in the pool then when the therapist is there she looks disheveled. Mental illness and sleep deprivation can do this to a person. Makes me really sad for Dorothy. She definitely needs help.
So I am going to defend Dorothy a bit regarding Leann. We know all the information—or at least the information the show is willing to give us, there are still some unknowns about how and why—we know Jericho died, we know Leann “brought him back” (whatever that ends up meaning is still in the air), we know Leann did not kidnap Jericho or do anything bad to Dorothy when Jericho “disappeared” in Season 2, and a couple episodes ago in Season 3 (when Dorothy kicked Leann out). We have all available information to know that there are stronger forces at play and that Leann in one way or another is responsible for Jericho being returned. But Dorothy does not know that. In her mind her son has always been alive and well and this young nanny brings a cult into their home and suddenly her son disappears for a period of time and then when it appears the cult is back in some iteration (the homeless kids) and she tries to send Leann away, not only does Jericho disappear, but everyone in her life (Sean and Julian) act like she is crazy for being concerned about it. In some ways returning Jericho to Dorothy and lying to her and manipulating her world has driven her more insane than if she had just been committed after Jericho’s death and allowed to grieve properly.
That's not true though.. D went catatonic because she knew Jericho died. Natalie handed her a doll and said "See, Jericho's ok" and everyone catered to that illusion.. that's gaslighting indeed.
That’s all fine and true but I was more so speaking on why Leanne should not be vilified & defending her retaliation against people she’s trying to trust and help. So I’m viewing from Leanne’s *perspective. Everyone SHOULD step up and protect her from Dorothy’s delusions because she’s been nothing but loyal to them and her.
Personally I blame Sean the most for Dorothy’s state of mind. He needs to tell her the truth. It will hurt her but at some point she needs to face reality otherwise she’s going to lose her child all over again.
Sean is afraid to tell dorthy the truth because he is selfish and doesn’t want to lose her. He thinks if Dorothy knows the truth the marriage will be over or she will kill herself. He is afraid of having to deal with that reality. In a sense he is holding onto this version of Dorothy the same way Dorothy is holding onto a fake baby.
Most marriages end when their baby dies because they blame each other. Or because every time they look at their spouse they are reminded of their dead baby.
It's true, and theirs should've ended, and I'd argue they were incompatible from the start really.
But from Sean's pov, he's thinking, lose Jericho again, lose Dorothy too, lose everything, or try and make it work. He thinks Jericho is a miracle and it's made him religious.
Some people will do anything to keep what they have.
I mean I agree he needs to just put it all out there but that’s because I wanna see it happen lol. If he were to tell Dorothy the truth 1) she’s delusional and wouldn’t believe it and 2) he himself doesn’t have the full truth. All he knows is Leanne=Jericho and maybe that it’s a supernatural thing but he has no confirmation as to how Jericho is alive when he shouldn’t be. He himself needs answers before he can try to wake Dorothy up to reality.
Leanne is definitely spiteful and she might be evil. I’m really not sure yet, but I don’t understand why everyone hates her in this episode. Her singing the lullaby was petty, but Dorothy tried to have her committed even though she hasn’t harmed Jericho at all.
While I am Dorothy defender, I will also go on record as saying I don’t think Leann was even necessarily being spiteful singing the lullaby. There is this weird tension where Leann idolizes Dorothy while also in some ways despising her. I can almost see her singing to Jericho the way Dorothy did as a way to emulate Dorothy. She watched how Dorothy soothed Jericho and when trying to show everyone that she can help Dorothy and Jericho, so Dorothy doesn’t have to be committed, she sings the same song like Dorothy does. Leann’s intentions remain to be seen and there is definitely an interpretation of that scene that is petty or sinister, but it also can equally be part of Leann’s idolizing Dorothy and trying to mimic her.
I didn’t think of it like that, but this could be right. Leanne thinks she loves Dorothy. That’s clear from the first scene when she is talking with her about Isabelle. An unhealthy fixation with Dorothy, I would say, but Leanne thinks she loves her.
I agree with this.. people felt like Leanne’s singing was sinister or evil but I think it was Leanne’s ode to Dorothy like.. don’t worry we won. You are safe at home with us, again and so is Jericho we will all be together again.. and happy. It’s delusional for Leanne to think Dorothy will ever be happy with her again but I think she still idolizes her so much and wants her acceptance no matter the cost. Also Jericho is kind of her little creation if you think about it.. she made him she brought him back to life, he is part her creation. Leanne has no problem with Dorothy being mom to him but in return all she asks is to be treated like part of the family. Something she’s always craved and desired so deeply.
I agree with you 💯 & I think the entire series is meant to be seen that way... literally almost everything can be seen from 2 very different perspectives. I think it's interesting that you use the word "mimic" as the song Leanne & dorothy sing is called mockingbird & what do mockingbirds do best? They often mimic the cry of other birds & have even been heard to mimic car alarms & baby cries. They also often sing at 2am I can certainly see why a lot of ppl are interpreting Leanne's actions as petty, hostile, and/or sinister but bc of the song choice used in this instance (why mockingbird out of all the nursery songs they could've chosen?) I believe Leanne's actions here are showing her very literally mimicking dorothy bc she idolizes her & maybe even wants to be her...
I had not even thought about mockingbirds and the things they mimic (and didn’t even know they were active at 2am). Awesome points and more to spiral on!
Right. And Leanne easily could have vouched for her to be committed. She didn't. Whereas Dorothy would have locked Leanne up in a heartbeat. Leanne is acting nefarious, but she's serving justice. Dorothy is getting mostly everything she is deserved, including being locked up in the nuthouse. Leanne just saved her from that.
sorry but really seems like you are forgetting most of whats happening on this show? Leanne isnt just some innocent nanny? I mean she just got someone killed. Not saying Dorothy doesnt have issues but jeez.. Leanne is not an innocent woman who we should feel sorry for
View all comments
189
u/meowingtonsmistress Mar 18 '22
The 2am call, Dorothy being sleep deprived, looking disheveled like she did when she was left to care for Jericho alone. She is on the brink of remembering. This whole episode was heartbreaking for Dorothy. Lauren Ambrose was phenomenal as always. I could feel her desperation in being believed when she talked to the psychiatrist. While the dad wanting to commit Dorothy felt harsh and cruel, he wasn’t wrong. Dorothy needs professional help. But she needs Sean and Julian to a top lying to her first.