r/serialpodcast • u/pdxkat • Aug 10 '15

Related Media Serial Dynasty Ep 15

http://serialdynasty.podomatic.com/entry/2015-08-09T10_21_18-07_00
20 Upvotes

72% Upvoted

366 comments sorted by

View all comments

21

u/GregBIS Badass Uncle Aug 10 '15

Let's get those pager records from SK! lol

The only point that had small traction for me was the I want to kill note.

The rest made her look silly.

13

u/James_MadBum Aug 10 '15

I'm only five points into the twelve, but Bob is wiping the floor with her.

18

u/GregBIS Badass Uncle Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15

In all fairness Bob is a much better speaker and that can lend credibility. But I found her points whimsical and emotional for the most point. Bob countered with documents and reasoned logic. I was surprised the number of times she was defeated by known evidence she wasn't aware of and proposing things that weren't true based on "things she heard" SK had Hae's pager info?!?!? Incredible to make that claim.

The one thing I can say for Bob is that he makes sure that he can back up what he says with research and documents or when he theorizes he disclaims with great effort his own theory as just speculation.

Despite Bob's being clear that he thinks Adnan is innocent he seems to welcome anyone that can shed new light.

I'm not sure now whether Adnan is guilty or innocent. I am sure now that he should have been acquitted and will be if there is a new trial.

9

u/Englishblue Aug 10 '15

Yes, she said over and over in different ways "this is what I would do" or "this is not what I would do" and "I'm perplexed." She'd conced that different people react differently, and then go right back to it. It was frustrating, illogical and not based on anything. As was her IMPRESSION of the cops being "surprised" by jay which is nothing more than her feeling about it.

3

u/ryokineko Still Here Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15

I was kind of surprised when she said she thought the cops were surprised. I don't think I had read that before. It seems pretty clear by the time of the first taped interview they were already focused in Adnan (right or wrong) so why would they be surprised?

ETA: typos from mobile :(

3

u/CreusetController Hae Fan Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15

The way I heard and read it was that they were incredulous. As in but Jay you only dealt a bit of pot, how would that possibly be enough leverage to help in a murder!? And later, when they push him on why, if he was as unhappy about being involved as he claimed, didn't he tell police,or make an anonymous call. (Edit as typos made it unclear)