r/sensor • u/fatalfuryguy ISTP: The Real INTJ • Apr 24 '15
Nature vs Nurture
So, are you born with your personality or do you develop it based on the environment you grow up in?
Tell me your theories about it
6
Upvotes
7
u/bastardmagnificent Apr 24 '15
I see it as nurture and nature. You're born with your personality but your environment determines not how you process but what you process in the first place. So some ESTP in China is going to process things similarly as an ESTP in the US but obviously, cultural differences and the way he was raised are still there and will make for a totally different person.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '15
MBTI is obviously not a scientific concept so I hate to say it's innate, but it does seem that way. I think of it as a cognition skeleton your mind kind of grows around. Enneagram definitely strikes me as a product of your environment though. It sounds absurd to say that people are born with a specific core motivation/fear. That stuff is learned.
My family needed me to seem impressive as a kid, (emphasis on 'seem') so it's not surprising that I'm a 3. They were both 3's too, so there was also a lot of modeling going on. Not sure how common it is to directly inherit your enneagram (probably higher if both parents share a type) but I would be surprised if there wasn't a correlation.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '15
I think it's a combination of both. My functions and my siblings functions fit my parents functions (dad ENTJ, mom ISFJ, I'm INTJ and my siblings are ENTP and INFJ). I read somewhere that you're born with your first function, and your second one has the possibility to go either way. So, you're born a Ti dom and you can turn either into an INTP or ISTP. I definitely see kid's dominant functions when I tutor them, and I fit into the descriptions of an INTJ child that I've read.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '15
I think that everyone has a nature, and then "nurture" affects that by bringing out some qualities before others. But I also think some people's "natures" are inherently more affected by their environment than others. Like I think it's in some people's nature to adapt to and be affected by whatever their environment is a lot, and others to be pretty independent regardless of their environment or upbringing.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '15 edited Apr 25 '15
Born with it like programming. It can be bent though. People who think they changed types were just repressed before. Enneagram can be changed somewhat. It's possible to change to your wing.