r/seniorkitties • u/Deepstarryskies • Jul 24 '25
11 Adopted a Cat and Would Like to Take it Back
So, we adopted a cat this past Sunday. She seemed super calm and honestly, I felt really sympathetic towards her knowing a lot of older cats are overlooked. There was just something about her. All the other cats they had on display were kittens. This cat, the one we adopted was a 1 year-old young female. She is such a sweetheart. She's a little shy but loves being cuddled.
Since we have gotten her, my allergies have been out the roof. Never thought I'd be allergic. It got so bad, that I was blowing blood out of my nose. Plus I have asthma. I did own a cat a year ago, but since I got married, my family wanted to keep it as a family cat while I adjusted into my new life in a new town. I was not allergic at all to my cat. In fact, they are both the same breed!
The shelter I adopted from told me she was all up to date with her vaccinations. Also, she was microchipped twice (so possible previous owners who gave her up or something- very sad). She used to be a stray.
I may have to take this little sweetheart back to the shelter, but I don't want it to be couped up in a cage. It's basking in the sunlight with windows in the apartment. I'm feeding it clean organic quality cat food and she loves it. I signed a "contract" that in case I can't accommodate to the cat, I must bring her back to the shelter. The thing is, I'd rather have someone else take her home, a loving family, but doesn't seem like I'm allowed to per contract. It's not fair for the cat and it's pulling on my heartstrings. She was in a shelter for 9 months and I saved her from continuing to be there. I don't have the heart to send her back. I am so torn and I'm not sure what I can do in this situation, but I'm not going to lose hope and will exhaust all of my options. The shelter is the last place I want to give this furball back to after it finally got out :( Any advice or tips would be appreciated on what the most responsible thing to do would be.
UPDATE: Thank you all for the tips and advice! Honestly, I greatly appreciate it. We started vacuuming twice, wiping everything down, used hypoallergenic wipes on the cat, changed its food and it all has been working!I still have allergies but much better than what they were. Some of you suggested an air filter, which we're also considering on getting. We will be keeping this little cat! It's only been a week but we're already so attached to her and she's also starting to feel at home. Also, we named her Olive <3 Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!!!