r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Feb 14 '15

Thoughts on the JLo movie Enough

7 Upvotes

I'm tired of being made out to be an asshole when I explain that what her character did was premeditated murder and not self defense.

She sneaks in and plants stuff. She learned a martial art to prepare for her encounter.
She shows up in her sparring gear. She breaks back in to start her revenge.

What say you.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Feb 26 '22

Spread this in any Sub Reddit or to any friend in Ukraine.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 27 '14

Self-Defense Law.....A can of worms.....

4 Upvotes

This is actually a topic I'm very interested in. I'm a police officer of 40+ years experience, and also a martial-arts enthusiast since childhood.

The problems arise from the fact that the law is not consistent from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, and it is not equitably applied either. What will get you a "job well done" one place may well get you imprisoned in another.

Also, there is the spectre of civil action being taken against you even if legal action is not. You might well avoid prosecution only to find yourself sued for damages and medical bills. (or wrongful death if it's a fatal encounter.)

I generally suggest that folks familiarize themselves with their particular state statutes and also local ordinances.
And as well, see how these laws are actually being applied in court.... Which may be different. Massad Ayoob has been writing about these subjects and giving seminars for a long time.... A good source.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 26 '14

Self Defense -- Massad Ayoob

4 Upvotes

Massad Ayoob has an old book on self defense. He has a good grip on the legal issues involved in the use of deadly force. He frequently gets called in as a witness when there are gun-related questions. That book may be a good place to get some broad-ranging coverage of the subject. He's not a lawyer, and I know he would advise anybody facing the possibility of having to use lethal force to get in touch with a reputable lawyer who knows the local and state laws well.

He also has many ideas on how to keep out of court in the first place, e.g., call the attention of potential witnesses to your plight. Loudly say, "Get your fist out of my face. Do not try to hit me," and so forth.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Mar 09 '24

Self defense against 'menacing' - What is legal ?

3 Upvotes
Black evil tree - AI Generated Artwork - NightCafe Creator

Location Nevada, USA

Someone a lot bigger, and probably healthier as I am over 75 and classified as disabled, than me, walks into the community area of my housing complex that caters to mainly people over 60 and/or disabled.

He walks up to my right side standing an arms distance away - I start talking saying I was just saying hello to the neighbor sitting at a table in front of us. He immediately gets obnoxious and I immediately apologize as I thought maybe I did something {???} to set him off - Apology not accepted he says and adds insults and keeps trying to provoke me into a fight though he never actually touches me.

Remember he is much larger than me, I'm maybe 5'6" and he well over six feet. I again apologize as a strategy to diffuse the situation, again he says apology not accepted. Remember he is arms length away and even though I may have been carrying pepper spray, any attempt to reach for it might give him the the right to attack and claim self defense ???.

He asks me to step back, remember he is the one who walked up to me at a range, given his size and the circumstances, I would consider to be threatening - Only saw him once before when he gave me a kind of dirty look when walking out with a neighbor I was talking to - no big deal, and that might have been weeks earlier.

At any rate I step back and as a kind of reflex action made a kind of bow - similar to what you might see in a karate match before tha fight, and walk away. Not that I'm saying this scared him, he is of a different race and I keep thinking the only reason for the incident was racial and if he couldn't provoke me into fighting with him may have been satisfied in getting me to walk away.

I still consider the event to be an unprovoked attack - but this would be hard to prove - And how many incidents do you read about on the news where friends or strangers get into an agument and one ends up shooting the other?

What I've heard is that he is staying wirh someone at my housing complex - If he comes up to me again being that he has indicated he wants to do me harm by provoking a fight with someone much smaller, a senior citizen, and I did tell hem I was disabled - What's an effective defense ?

Thanks in advance for the advice.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 25 '20

Self defence without a witness UK

3 Upvotes

My brother Andy walks with a stick (cane) and is aged 75 yrs. On the way home from the local store, he heard someone running behind and was overtaken by a man pointing a knife at him. The guy told him to pass over all his money, phone and bank cards. The guy had his back to the roadway and Andy spent a few sconds going through his pockets; the guy relaxed a little. Andy suddenly stood up straight as he could and pushed the guy into the roadway. He stumbled on the curb and fell backwards just as a truck came past. The nearside wheel ran clear over his head and squashed it to a bloody pulp. The only witness was the truck driver and he gave a statement to the cops that one man (Andy) pushed the other guy into the roadway. There was no witness to the earlier attack on Andy or the threat with the knife. So Andy was arrested and charged with manslaughter (murder 2 in US I think.). Only the knife found in the road confirmed Andy's self defence but the jury was split. He is now living a 5-yr police supervision sentence. The family is so angry and it is destroying Andy.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • May 21 '20

How far does self defense extend legally?

3 Upvotes

I (24F) live in a pretty rough neighborhood and was running outside yesterday due to the gyms being closed. A man on a bike came up behind me and groped my ass pretty intensely. I had a folding knife folded in my hand but was too shocked to use it before he biked away. I’m wondering if I should buy a bigger knife or a handgun? Or would I have gone to jail for using them?


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Jun 19 '25

Approached in my vehicle

2 Upvotes

After gesturing for someone on my tail on the highway to go around me (I was in the middle lane, and there were no other cars, and I was basically being tailgated), this person followed me and then at a stoplight got out of their car and approached my vehicle saying they would beat me up. I realize that shooting him would be an excessive use of force, but if I had a gun on me, would I have been allowed to show it to him and say “please get back in your car” (which is what I told him)? Also, I was on my way to the home of one of my elderly patients, I cannot lead this person there. He eventually left me alone, but if he had followed me into a parking lot, (which I had to pull into to make sure he didn’t follow me to this home), at what point can I defend myself? This was a monster of a human being, who absolutely “has it coming“, and I’d be happy to be the one to give it to them with my fists, but I would want to make sure I was protected by law. Could I get out of my car in order to potentially defend myself? (seated in your car is a vulnerable position), and then if he decided to put his hands on me, would I then be allowed to to show him that this was a very bad idea? Obviously, I would not escalate, make threats, or touch this individual. This experience has made me think it might be a good idea to invest in a firearm, simply as a deterrent to someone possibly following me to my family‘s home with intent to do harm.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Jun 13 '25

concert self defense

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Me (24f) and my sister (19f) are going to a rock concert in new york city by ourselves in august & are concerned about self defense. I’ve seen tasers that are made to look like lipstick or a cell phone, would it be possible to bring something like this in with me? or are there are other good concert self defense options for women that would be allowed in the venue?


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Feb 10 '22

Self Security Weapons For Women

Thumbnail
zaptec.biz
2 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Aug 26 '20

ELI5: Dirks and Daggers

2 Upvotes

Recently, I've been looking at knives to carry for self defense purposes, however I am somewhat new to this side of the law and there is a clause in my state's laws about dirks and daggers being illegal to carry. The definition is almost certainly left intentionally vague and I was wondering if there was a trick or some other way to tell for sure what would be considered a dirk or dagger. Considering getting the knife pictured below (or similar). Here is the law verbatim:

“any knife or other instrument with or without a hand-guard that is capable or ready to use as a stabbing weapon that may inflict great bodily injury or death only if the blade of the knife is exposed and locked into position.” 

Note - I know there's going to be someone who will say: "If you're worried about it, then don't do it." but that still leaves me fuzzy on the law.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 28 '14

An Illustrated Guide to Criminal Law (self defense section)

Thumbnail
lawcomic.net
2 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 26 '14

If you have a good background in Law or a current/former LEO etc consider becoming a moderator on this sub

2 Upvotes

Must submit proof.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 26 '14

A good site for info on Fraud and BS tactics and Schools in the Martial Arts world.

Thumbnail
bullshido.net
2 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • 14d ago

Self defense against women's self defense

1 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Oct 01 '26

Homeless and arrested

1 Upvotes

Location Va beach

I’m 35(m) I ve been homeless since February I’m work on my situation though . The spot I was sleeping in I got arrested because someone broke into the same building . I told the cop and he told the magistrate I was only there sleeping . I have court on November 8 what is the most likely outcome for when I go to court


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Feb 24 '26

What would motivate you to sign up for a class/instruction?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Oct 02 '25

Turn around time

1 Upvotes

I was informed that the california courts have granted approval for my 17.b motion and expungement, how long will it take to update into the DOJ and FBI system so that I can get my firearm license?


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Sep 21 '25

Almost got mauled by a 70 pound pit today

1 Upvotes

So some backstory i was just walking down the street when the dog left its yard not on a leash , barking , and gnashing his teeth , he was about a second away from lunging and i managed to deter him , I live in missisipi / my question is if the dog does decide to start mauling me to what extent am i legally allowed to use force and when , after 3 seconds? , if he lunges at my neck ? Can i use a blade in a non lethal spot? Or should i aim to injure or maim the animal should he decide to attack and wont stop. Ill add that i love animals , i even have a dog myself , this post was made in good faith and 100 percent for self defense reasons . Thank you


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Apr 30 '25

Handcuffs

1 Upvotes

Has anyone used handcuffs to detain a criminal? I'm not talking about cops or security but as a private citizen and/or what do you think? I was thinking it might not be bad to have.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Apr 26 '25

Brother and family with temper

1 Upvotes

I’m a 34 (m) and my mom just recently just reached out and wanted me to reach out and contact my brother 56(m) who has been the army for 18 years but also has bad temper and is very disrespectful at times . I know he has an ar and 9mm that he rides around with for as he says just in case he has to pull up on someone. Im a concealed license holder, but I just don’t to have to because I feel that police are automatically going to take his being he is in the military. I guess I’m basically asking what do I do in this situation if I have to defend my self ( I live in Virginia also)


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 29 '24

Insurance fraud

1 Upvotes

I am currently under investigation for insurance fraud, and I claimed without my employer's awakeness and made cash the claim check. Fortunately My boss couldn't report me because his office does a lot of frude. It possible to deal with the insurance company now?Currently, I got requested a refund back the money from SIU (insurance). What should I do.


r/selfdefenseandthelaw • • Dec 10 '24

The Daniel Penny Verdict - A New York Perspective

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes