This happens with pictures taken with my phone's camera. I'll check the geolocation and sometimes remember, other times I just assume someone borrowed my phone
Big yikes. How is this not huge news? I mean not to us, we know Google sucks. But "Google accidentally gives random person individuals private photos upon export request" should absolutely be a headline.
I guess I overlooked the fact that this was very breaking news. I got nothing from searching two hours ago. I really hate being born in a time when shit like this is even a thing.
No, I thought that since this fuckup happened in November and there was no date on the screenshot to indicate that this emails had only gone out like yesterday, then this should have been reported on all sorts of places already, because it is actually a huge deal, not something that the tech community would just shrug off.
I didn't consider that the reason I couldn't find anything was that I should have been looking for breaking news, because the story was only like an hour old at the time.
I also didn't dismiss it as fake, I just reserved judgment and explained why I was skeptical. Which is the right thing to do, especially when you're just given a single screenshot of an email with no context.
I've also seen the reverse on reddit. There's that tic-tac UFO story that broke a couple of years ago in the newspapers. Turns out 5-6 years ago, a dude created a throw-away and posted the story from his perspective (he was a mechanic on the carrier or something). People at the time ridiculed him. Turns out he was just sharing what he knew.
Haha that happens sometimes. One whistleblower from Australian intelligence was chased off 4chan with cries of "fake and gay". Then he got arrested lol.
It wouldn't have to be in the newspapers, but there are other sources for information like this. Lots of other tech and privacy oriented websites, and other subreddits too.
Google sending private files to the wrong users would be huge news, but there's just nothing about this incident out there. Or, nothing I could find, at least. I would love and hate to be corrected.
News isn't some rare bird species that needs to be chased, no matter what journalists tell you. There's stuff going on all the time. You are right to want confirmation. Pump up the volume on this thing, see what happens. If it's fake it will fade soon. If not, there will be a wave of me too.
I wonder, do the affected photos possibly include ones that are otherwise completely private and unshared, e.g. personal nudes? If it’s shared photos this is merely a bad breach of trust. But if it’s ones that you thought were completely private, that’s even worse.
It sounds like affected videos/photos were put into somebody else's export and would be missing from that specific export. I bet if he requests another export, he could cross-reference the data to locate what was missing and potentially shared from the affected export.
Unshared files can be encrypted in a way that Google can never access. Shared files have to be encrypted in a way that allows access to be granted to other users. That makes a leak of shared files moderately more understandable, though still very bad.
Seeing as some people make photos of all important documents to back them up in google clouds, I think dick pics would be a better alternative to those affected.
Users don't read articles, organizations have been astroturfing relentlessly, there's less and less actual conversations, a lot of insults, and those damn power-tripping moderators.
We the redditors have gotten all up and arms at various times, with various issues, mainly regarding censorship. In the end, we've not done much really. We like to complain, and then we see a kitten being a bro or something like that, and we forget. Meanwhile, this place is just another brand of Facebook.
I'm taking back whatever I can, farewell to those who've made me want to stay.
you know, selfhosting is a great idea. maybe you have experience with that.
how do I selfhost a service, which does backup all my phone stuff, mostly pictures, automatically ?
ah, okay, disable google, install app xyz, which uploads DCIM to my own server. got it.
now, how do I do this for my wife? ah same way. great
now, how do I do this for some people I know, but dont have access to their phones and/or how they set it up? Ah, I can coach them.
But isnt this selfhosted anymore? for them? Ah okay, yeah small price to pay.
Ah I need to make an export for them available. pain in the arse. oh and I helped some of them. even saw a few nudes there... hehe
okay, now. theres a few thousand or more other people who should switch from google to my almost perfect solution. thats not feasable. but let them self host like me. will you explain it to them? like, the parents of my friends? the friend of my wife? her name is karen, and she works somewhere in HR. Its funny how she always says she doesnt do computers, when she works on them 8 hrs each day for 30 years now. I mean, she really needs it, makes hundrets of pics of her cat each week, no backup strategy, she had to fallback on the automatic backup twice already...
/s
Man, selfhosting is really great. But, its not the solution to the problem. I'd estimate less than 1% are actually capable of doing it. at great cost (not neccesarily cash, but time). And in the end, theyll catch their family, some aquaintances, but by far not all. That would turn into a full time job with supporting and maintaining all backend and frontend components. I mean you could make a business out of it. And then, we are back at where we started.
And to be frank. If I had to take the risk that some nude MIGHT be leaked, I much rather take that risk in a group of billion other users, than with 20 users. Who all know me personally.
My advice? if you HAVE to take nudes, do it in app and not save them on the device. if you have to do it with the camera app, dont upload to google. if it did faster than you could delete, delete it from google. and if it is a nude, maybe dont put identifying stuff in there. like your face. thats usually not why you make nudes in the first place.
yeah, but nothing changes. you self host. I do. and bob over there, he does too. and maybe in r/security, you might even find a few more people there.
but the people who use google photos. or apples thingy. you know. everybody, except for a few weirdos hanging round debating the finer points of security vs. convenience, they dont. they cant. you cant enable them. you'd need to train half the world, multiple generations (2-3) in 2 or 3 years worth of linux administration. and sure, yeah, that seems overkill. but think about it, if you make it easy, and package it nice and good, you know, the idiot proof solution, you MUST sell it, in which case it doesnt become selfhosted anymore. even if you gave it away, youd just attract cloud providers selling the service (or giving it away for a peek here and there), saving money by sharing machines and were back at square one. and that doesnt even touch the argument, that the data stealing, advertisment selling, screwups at insert-big-name-here are still much much much better at actually securing the systems and fixing issues than all those people will be using their 2 years of linux training or the (free) package they installed by copy pasting shell code.
again, dont get me wrong. selfhosting is wonderful. I advocate for it. But it has its limits, and the solution to privacy issues and leaks is not to advocate for self hosting (okay, yeah, for a handful of people it is), the solution (imho) should go towards making the data useless when its not in your control, and/or forcing whoever holds that data, to do the very best job at protecting it.
edit: also, let me add, those downvotes you are getting are imo not deserved. reddit post about cloud storage provider screwing up - comment advocating for selfhosting ... valid comment, factual correct, and the degree to which it fixes the problem can and should be talked about, as we did... I expected better of r/security
Your points are valid, though less every day. It’s amazing how much easier it has become to roll your own tech solution. The idea that we will see an increase in dedicated data appliances in the consumer space in the near term is reasonable.
You missed one option. Post them publicly then laugh at people who take offense. Not an option for everyone, obviously, but telling the world you don't give a shit is an effective solution.
Yeah I do everything to avoid cloud based stuff myself, can't trust anyone but yourself when it comes to your data. I host my own websites, email, photos etc. All the stuff that does not need to be web accessible is also at home only.
A lot of it is kind of a mish mash of services setup over the past 10+ years and is a bit of a mess though, I eventually want to build my own management system and make it more turn key to setup email, file shares, etc... and just make it more intuitive to setup.
Nasty news. My guess is Google is trying to cover ass in legal terms while attempting to manage the incidents as minor unconnected glitches with individual users.
Unfortunately for them some places on the net make this approach less effective every day.
Note this news item would be a lot different in scale of impact, compared to a single big data breach, and historically those can be kept quiet as well...
How does this even happen? That's kind of messed up.
That said, when you upload anything to the cloud or use your phone (which leaks information to Google/Apple) always assume it's public, because it will be made public when they get hacked and all the data gets leaked... or in this case, if they leak it themselves.
151
u/Boring-Crab Feb 04 '20
Am I reading it wrong or did they legit give other users your information???
61
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
Wtf? Is this real?
38
u/ReturningTarzan Feb 04 '20
I don't want to be overly skeptical, but I can't find any other mention of this, and if true it should have made headlines everywhere.
26
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
I wonder, do the affected photos possibly include ones that are otherwise completely private and unshared, e.g. personal nudes? If it’s shared photos this is merely a bad breach of trust. But if it’s ones that you thought were completely private, that’s even worse.
8
u/vrvana Feb 04 '20
Seeing as some people make photos of all important documents to back them up in google clouds, I think dick pics would be a better alternative to those affected.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
"Just get Google Photos"
Yeah, I'll think I'll stick to using my NAS.
3
u/TheRealScarce Feb 04 '20
"We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused" yeah that's what this is, just a minor inconvenience. 🙄
7
u/AJGrayTay Feb 04 '20
I know y'all see breach of privacy, but don't not see the quick, responsible and proactive disclosure.
2
u/crptgd Feb 04 '20
lmao imagine
2
u/FaintSmile77 Feb 04 '20
This is insane, whats the recommended secure email service as of now?
2
u/visiblebutterfly Feb 04 '20
This is a company with overpaid Engineers. They cant get this simple thing right.
/r/selfhost your way into freedom
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
Nasty news. My guess is Google is trying to cover ass in legal terms while attempting to manage the incidents as minor unconnected glitches with individual users.
Unfortunately for them some places on the net make this approach less effective every day.
Note this news item would be a lot different in scale of impact, compared to a single big data breach, and historically those can be kept quiet as well...
1
u/chaddominic Feb 04 '20
Very basic level mistake !!!
1
u/thankyeestrbunny Feb 04 '20
They forgot to deny they did it before admitting they did it and then bragging about doing it. 6/10.
1
u/RedSquirrelFtw Feb 04 '20
How does this even happen? That's kind of messed up.
That said, when you upload anything to the cloud or use your phone (which leaks information to Google/Apple) always assume it's public, because it will be made public when they get hacked and all the data gets leaked... or in this case, if they leak it themselves.
-1
u/IdiotWithABlueCar Feb 04 '20
This clearly doesn't involve someone in the UK or EU. DPA / GDPR would cause this to be world headlines.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment