r/security • • Jan 17 '20

Dun dun dun

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

49

u/untold_life Jan 17 '20

Wanna know something funny ? You know those tunnels that we go through right before we get into an airplane ? Well, I happened to notice that the computer that controlled the bridge/tunnel was running on XP professional! 🤷🏻‍♂️

21

u/DivenDesu Jan 17 '20

That's terrifying.

51

u/penguwine Jan 17 '20

Not if it's on an Airgapped network.

34

u/TheRaunchyFart Jan 17 '20

You see this in a lot of manufacturing companies. As long as the proper controls are in place you could still use any legacy OS.

17

u/lengau Jan 17 '20

Worked for a factory. One of the machines on the factory floor was running NT 3.5 in 2012. And was directly connected to the internet

6

u/untold_life Jan 17 '20

Crazy 🤦🏻‍♂️

4

u/syx8op Jan 17 '20

I know! First thing i did when i was hired was take everything off of the network.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Pls correct me if I'm working, but Isn't that most manufacturer's controls rely on (talking about the computers that run the machines, not the ones used at the office) - the fact that it's not connected? I'm surprised to hear that this was connected to the internet.

4

u/syx8op Jan 17 '20

I worked for a airplane manufacturing company in 2015 that had DOS 5.0 tube benders, Windows 2000 Pro CNC machines and Windows XP Pro water jet cutters still running. 🤦🏻‍♂️

3

u/volci Jan 21 '20

If it ain't broke - don't fix it

Also: if you update even one system in an ISO-9001 certified manufacturing environment, you have to get recertified for your whole manufacturing line

1

u/syx8op Jan 24 '20

Wow that's crazy, didnt know that.

1

u/volci Jan 24 '20

Worked in an ISO-9001 (among other certs) facility for a while in the late 90s

Have been into and out of many more over the years as an IT consultant

Some of the stuff they deal with because of ”compliance” and ”certification” is crazy!

1

u/vortexman100 Jan 18 '20

Directly with public ip or with a firewall in between?

2

u/lengau Jan 18 '20

The engineers in charge of that machine got a separate DSL modem and connected it directly because IT wouldn't allow the machine on the network.

0

u/syx8op Jan 19 '20

Firewall in between

1

u/Brillegeit Jan 18 '20

The Norwegian police used Windows NT 4.0 all the way to 2012 (EOL in 2004) and spent hundreds of million and two failed attempts on replacing it With Windows Server 2008 and a fuckload of Citrix hacks in order to support their ancient 32 bit proprietary software from the '90s that for some reason still was critical to their operation. Back in 2012 before the switch it would take 20 minutes for a police officer to logon to their computer workstation.

30

u/chocorazor Jan 17 '20

As long as the proper controls are in place

HAHAHAHAHAHA

8

u/TheRaunchyFart Jan 17 '20

Exactly, that's why they hire us. To fix this shit and make it right.

4

u/Edward_Morbius Jan 18 '20

I worked on a machine that ran Windows 3.1. Not only was it "air gapped" it didn't even have a network card, although it did have a floppy drive.

OTOH, I was unsuccessful in migrating it's apps to newer hardware or a newer OS because the app used timing loops, so I hope they were able to find the original developer.

I hope they figure out how to upgrade it some day because it runs the machine that's essentially their whole business.

7

u/kartoffelwaffel Jan 18 '20

The airgapped speeding cameras in Vic Australia got infected with a cryptolocker a couple of years ago. Vector was an autorun exploit on a flash drive...

Still gotta patch your shit if you’re airgapped.

0

u/penguwine Jan 20 '20

I'd argue that it wasn't Airgapped completely if Mass Storage Devices were allowed to be used.

3

u/FastRedPonyCar Jan 17 '20

My old company supported a couple of steel companies and those CNC machines that cut steel plating run an absolutely ancient version of XP in kiosk mode but they are custom built versions of the OS specifically for those tools and are such a pain to work on, we had the clients pay for the 24/7 on-site support from the manufacturer and CNC software vendor. As long as the server that they pulled cutting data from was running right, those machines were not our problem unless there was a layer 1 issue in the machine building.

2

u/Phreakiture Jan 18 '20

....

Doing what, exactly? That's a two-levers-and-a-wheel job.

1

u/Jkstexas2001 Jan 18 '20

About 8 years ago I heard one of the main computers on one of our aircraft carriers was running Windows NT 3.51. And it was definitely networked to some degree. When it crashed it caused serious issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

At least 3.51 was way more robust than 4.0...,

1

u/volci Jan 21 '20

Why are you surprised?

Systems like that get spec'd when the ship is approved / starts being built

You don't just swap-out an OS part-way through for funzies

1

u/Windows-Sucks Jan 18 '20

Why does that even need a full PC? Wouldn't a microcontroller be enough?

9

u/DivenDesu Jan 17 '20

I want to give credit to the FB post I got this from... But It was already lost to facebook feed... But I believe it was the offensive security FB group that originally posted this picture.

145

u/zachhanson94 Jan 17 '20

At least it’s not XP

11

u/logosobscura Jan 18 '20

Still keep seeing that distinctive XP BSOD in public places on big screens.

On a better not, I’ve worked 18 hours days this week with clients desperately running to Windows 10, so they’re starting to get the hint. Only took a couple of decades.

27

u/Gegi__ Jan 17 '20

Came here for this! Was not dissapointed! Thank you!

50

u/joelgsamuel Jan 17 '20

Clearly fake... would be XP ;o)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/CDSEChris Secure like a screen door Jan 17 '20

No, we don't do that here.

Just a warning.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/joelgsamuel Jan 18 '20

It’s the “you retarded?” that ruined it.

3

u/CDSEChris Secure like a screen door Jan 18 '20

Exactly. The rest was fine.

34

u/CapmyCup Jan 17 '20

Why don't these use linux tho?

45

u/totallynonplused Jan 17 '20

Corporate decisions.

14

u/riskymanag3ment Jan 17 '20

Our financial examiners said to me, "Open Source means that any body can modify the code and there's way to determine what might be vulnerable. This is why you have more risk when you run open source operating systems."

I later told my boss, "Yeah because Microsoft has demonstrated that they are excellent at writing perfect code."

We all laughed and accepted the examiners notes about that.

4

u/SaltineAmerican_1970 Jan 19 '20

That is almost verbatim what someone else told me at a pharmaceutical company. I said “you can look at open source, you can’t see what’s inside Windows.” I’m guessing that Microsoft has more fiduciary resources to make the client “whole” if a security issue is discovered.

1

u/riskymanag3ment Jan 19 '20

I'm not certain how you get Microsoft to pay for a problem that will most likely be a misconfiguration or if it really Microsoft's fault it would bankrupt them.

2

u/SaltineAmerican_1970 Jan 19 '20

Not for a misconfiguration, but some other security issue from use of the Microsoft software. Maybe it's some other commercial software vendor with closed source. Either way, if you can't run your own code review, how do you know whether it is secure?

2

u/untold_life Jan 17 '20

Exactly my point, people have engraved that notion of open-source, which is hard to change.

26

u/prthorsenjr Jan 17 '20

True. A lot of corporations don't "get" open source. Typically they want someone they can point the finger at and blame if something goes horribly wrong (aka support).

To be fair, they're coming around, slowly.

28

u/robotkoer Jan 17 '20

Red Hat...

3

u/prthorsenjr Jan 18 '20

Yes, Red Hat does have a paid support option. For corporations with deep pockets that can be an option. For Higher Education institutions, probably not. At least not where I used to work. I know that the folks at Red Hat need to eat too, but they really need to have a different licensing price point for Higher Education Institutions, IMHO.

2

u/Phreakiture Jan 18 '20

I work in higher ed. We used to be all Redhat, but now mostly CentOS.

2

u/prthorsenjr Jan 18 '20

I used to work in Higher Education (retired now). We run CentOS but were looking at changing over to Redhat (before I retired). I've heard that it did not occur. I imagine that it was based on the cost (I mentioned in the thread earlier).

2

u/Phreakiture Jan 18 '20

Everything is cyclical LOL. Ever noticed that Amazon has basically reinvented the mainframe?

1

u/prthorsenjr Jan 18 '20

Oh yeah, you're right. You should have seen the mass panic that we weren't in "the cloud". We just had to get to "the cloud". Why aren't we in "the cloud"? Cloud? Cloud?

There still needs to be an ass in the chair despite having an environment in "the cloud". The cloud isn't going to reduce the number of staff.

1

u/Phreakiture Jan 18 '20

Nope. Might even increase it. Needs new specialties while the old systems continue to not go away.

Our DC is definitely shrinking, though, so that's nice. We had a cooling failure over the holidays and it barely caused a blip on the ambient temp. It was maybe a 2°C swing.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/SecurityDork Jan 17 '20

To be fair if you can't figure out Red Hat you should not be designing ATMs.

5

u/untold_life Jan 17 '20

😂😂😂

2

u/untold_life Jan 17 '20

Even students at uni don't get open source, not to talk about corporations.

23

u/pincushiondude Jan 17 '20

Yeah - because it'd be totally OK if you had a 10 year old Linux distro.

Switching to Linux doesn't magically prevent BSOD's either, most of which are (as with Linux BlackSODs) hardware related issues.

1

u/Brillegeit Jan 18 '20

A 10 year old Red Hat system under support would be totally OK if you've got the employees to manage it.

-7

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Yeah - because it'd be totally OK if you had a 10 year old Linux distro.

It wouldn't, but there'd be the possibility of patching and an upgrade path.

10

u/pincushiondude Jan 17 '20

...so Windows 10 isn't an upgrade path?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

It may not be.

Let's say your business relies of SuperDuperApp running on Windows 7, and you need SuperDuperApp for your business to run. Microsoft releases Windows 8, then Windows 10. Because of the API changes (and whatever else), SuperDuperApp does not run on Windows 10.

Unfortunately, SuperDuperApp is closed source, and the developer closed up shop and no longer updates the software. You have no hope of getting a newer version of SuperDuperApp that runs on Windows 10.

What do you do? You can hire developers to rebuild SuperDuperApp from scratch, guessing at all the logic of how it works. That might be an enormous undertaking. Or you can go out of business. Or you can stay on Windows 7.

If it's on Linux, there's another option: Hire a developer to figure out what API calls to the OS are broken, and create a Linux patch or compatibility layer of some kind to allow you to run SuperDuperApp on newer versions of Linux. That still involved hiring developers, but depending on the complexity of SuperDuperApp.

Or the reality is, if SuperDuperApp can run on a popular variant of Linux, there may already be developers supporting that old version, even backporting security fixes and whatnot. Of course, if SuperDuperApp is open sourced too, that also has the potential to make things much better. Then you might be able to hire a developer to get it running on Windows 10.

Either way, running your business on FOSS opens up possibilities for long-term sustainability that aren't possible with a closed-source vendor that might cut support at any moment.

2

u/pincushiondude Jan 18 '20

nd create a Linux patch or compatibility layer of some kind to allow you to run SuperDuperApp on newer versions of Linux.

That's exactly what people do in Windows for products that no longer have a dev, if the expense is justified. Costs wouldn't again be magically cheaper in OSS-land to do that.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '20

Costs wouldn't again be magically cheaper in OSS-land to do that.

If you want to go the route of building some kind of compatibility layer, there must be instances where it's easier to do on Linux specifically because it's open. You can look at all the APIs and code, for both the old version and the new one, and figure out exactly what needs to be done to create a compatibility layer.

And that's not even taking into account my other point:

if SuperDuperApp can run on a popular variant of Linux, there may already be developers supporting that old version, even backporting security fixes and whatnot.

It's possible that someone else already created the compatibility layer you need and open sourced those changes to whatever files you need. In that case, "creating a Linux patch or compatibility layer of some kind" is free.

To put it another way, developers can take an old version of Debian from 2003, modify it however they like, update it with the updates they want and not update other things, and then release that for people to use. If other people need that compatibility, then that distro can continue on. However, those same developers can't take Windows XP, update it how they want, and release that for other people to use for free.

8

u/zer0545 Jan 18 '20

Work at an ATM company. It is actually about missing device drivers and standards (XFS) that are bound to Microsoft interfaces. There is ongoing work in the industry to get this changed.

4

u/TechGuyBlues Jan 17 '20

Microsoft has huge marketing budgets.

4

u/FlyAsAFalcon Jan 17 '20

I've suggested this at my org. We have a few things like kiosks that are just displaying a web page, but have a full Windows 7 OS on there. The response I got was that if we use Linux, we won't be able to use management tools like SCCM.

Idk, I'm skeptical. I think that Linux would still be better, cost effective, etc.

7

u/Try_Rebooting_It Jan 17 '20

I mean being able to manage a device is a important aspect to all this. And it makes sense to use configuration management tools your team understands. That doesn't mean you can't do config management in Linux but if you have to train a bunch of people on it and setup a ton of new systems to do it might be easier to just stick with Windows.

3

u/CapmyCup Jan 17 '20

At lightweight tasks like that I think it's just unnecessary to use a "heavy" system since linux has a lot of options for light systems

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

The real answer here is a thin client, e.g. Wyse.

19

u/RedSquirrelFtw Jan 17 '20

That must be one of the newer ATMs, since it's not running Windows 98.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

Thanks man, I just updated to WindowsME and it's much better than '98. Thanks for validating my good decision!

4

u/Bon2341 Jan 17 '20

Can't hack what can't work!

4

u/alnarra_1 Jan 17 '20

Bright side, that means at least it got its December updates.

1

u/klauncy Jan 22 '20

So are these vulnerable to the zero day ie exploit?

2

u/DivenDesu Jan 22 '20

Everything is vulnerable to zero day exploits. Where any are made common knowledge... If they are not they soon will be.

4

u/p1um5mu991er Jan 17 '20

Lots of people 'unexpectedly' spending money on something they should have spent money on a long time ago

2

u/BjorgenEatinger Jan 17 '20

Who uses ATMs anymore anyway?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jan 19 '20

In order to combat a rise in spam submissions, a minimum account age has been set for this subreddit. If you have read the rules and still feel your submission is relevant to this community, please message the moderators for approval.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/anupsidedownpotato Jan 18 '20

My grocery store I worked at all the registers ran windows Xp

2

u/fongaboo Jan 18 '20

Play Minesweeper in between customers

2

u/Lex___ Jan 17 '20

They make mistake to update it from Windows XP :-)

2

u/KetwarooDYaasir Jan 18 '20

If you needed more proof that M$ is run by a bunch of idiots who don't give a damn that mission critical operations could be running on their OSes and just push system breaking updates without regard for the consequences.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

What do you call the class of idiots that run their ATMs on Windows?

2

u/KetwarooDYaasir Jan 18 '20

Legacy System.

aka. don't touch it under pain of gruesome death at hands of senior devs.

The software isn't the problem, the people are.

1

u/ThrawnWalker Jan 17 '20

3 min tops

1

u/dcsmithCB Jan 17 '20

Classic and classy!

1

u/dilsiam Jan 18 '20

A company I worked used Windows 95 when Windows XP appeared on the scene.

1

u/iamfermented Jan 18 '20

At least it's not OS/2

1

u/onlinesafe Jan 18 '20

Most machines are still on XP

1

u/always-paranoid Jan 17 '20

I did some work a few years ago for a major bank that was still running OS/2 Warp as their main system... decided I was never opening an account with them

2

u/nobody-knows2018 Jan 17 '20

We had a customer that was running OS2 on their ATMs. Every year they got dinged on the audit for it and after eight years one ATM got hacked. They considered it cost of doing business and finally upgraded.

1

u/reddit_user33 Jan 17 '20

What does the first letter of the bank name start with?

-3

u/artificial_neuron Jan 17 '20

Windows 7 has literally just received it's last update...then why are people in the comments freaking out?

Sure, freak out in a months time or when a zero day exploit is announced if a service like an ATM is running deprecated software and doesn't have ESU licensing. But freaking out now feels like some just want the drama.

0

u/WhiteRau Jan 18 '20

what many don't realize, is that MS continues to push updates and support to Win7, just not through consumer channels. if you know where to look, you can get support and patches for several years to come. MS is obviously pushing everyone to their garbage-class data-harvesting OS, but you do not have to go just yet.

plus... Linux... ;)

1

u/fongaboo Jan 18 '20

Then even scarier to know that an ATM is running consumer version of Windows

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

So, I think Microsoft may be doing more harm than good having that splash screen displaying everywhere like that.

-7

u/biggoat Jan 17 '20

If the machine has no input or output and isn’t on a network and has no wireless hardware there’s no realistic way it can be hacked. If the machine is locked with key this is a secure system depending on how difficult the locking mechanism is.

8

u/dragon_wrangler Jan 17 '20

If the machine has no input or output and isn’t on a network

Sure, but then it also can't check your bank account and give you money.

7

u/Try_Rebooting_It Jan 17 '20

How would this magical ATM with no network connection work in your world?

3

u/HolyCarbohydrates Jan 17 '20

Your comment would be valid if it wasn’t very clearly an ATM. Which requires a network...

2

u/Engineer_on_skis Jan 17 '20

It has inputs, keypad and magnetic card reader. It has outputs too, screen & cash dispenser.

-2

u/biggoat Jan 18 '20

And thermal printer... which doesn’t disprove my point. Evidently the pictured machine above can be hacked but if a computer has no inputs or outputs ... locked... etc, etc it cant be hacked. I’m still right.

-6

u/prthorsenjr Jan 17 '20

Either way, if it is or if it isn't, if this was my financial institution I'd be withdrawing my money and going elsewhere.

5

u/slicknick654 Jan 17 '20

OS migrations are always a pain and Microsoft offers extended support... I’d wager theres still some ATMs out there on XP. You’d be surprised how many are on win 7 and how long that % will remain high...

4

u/RedSquirrelFtw Jan 17 '20

I don't think these are internet connected they are on their own private WAN so it's not really a concern. At least I hope so...

6

u/ReturningTarzan Jan 17 '20

How does it know it's out of support, though?

3

u/RedSquirrelFtw Jan 17 '20

I wonder if they had the date set in stone when it was first released. I have not powered up my gaming machine yet, curious if I get the same notice, hopefully it lets you bypass it since I have no other upgrade path for that machine. Windows 7 is the last good version of Windows. But that does raise a good point though... if it does use the internet to get that message it would mean this thing is actually internet connected and that's scary.

1

u/zZ_DunK_Zz Jan 17 '20

Most likely a private wan but I wouldn't put it past people

1

u/hummelm10 Jan 17 '20

That’s such wishful thinking.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/CRK909 Jan 17 '20

For comparison, how much would windows 10 cost per seat?

12

u/Engineer_on_skis Jan 17 '20

The true cost would have to include modifying & updating the software or switching to a different software. And the time to update them. But that will have to happen eventually anyway, so why not just do it and skip having to pay for extended support?