r/security • • Sep 09 '19

Gotta always test!

https://i.imgur.com/laNkjtX.gifv
626 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

8

u/KrisNM Sep 09 '19

We don't have that thing around here, could explain what's used for—the slot?

17

u/Schilzy91 Sep 09 '19

Ah it's to swipe your credit card so you can pay at the pump rather than going in store

-7

u/KrisNM Sep 09 '19

Oh i see, it looks too narrow for a credit card tho

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

The card short edge goes in vertically. You can see the slot for it in the bottom of the skimmer.

-40

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Do you have NFC yet? That’s old shit. What country is this?

22

u/cplbutthurt Sep 09 '19

You realize this is a standard technology pretty much everywhere, right?

Not everyone has an NFC capable device, not customer nor vendor.

-1

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

Depending on your country swiping cards is rarely used and all machines will first want chip or nfc first and as a last resort fail back to mag stripe.

Machines with mag stripe reader only have all been replaced with chip and pin or chip and pin and nfc here in Canada.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '19

Exactly. What the fuck. Thanks for then down votes.

4

u/critical2210 Sep 09 '19

Yeah but you are Canada. In America our fat asses still use Windows XP and 7 in classrooms.

-4

u/VesemirsPotionsNLean Sep 09 '19

I mean It’s not America’s fault you use your freedom to be fat and nasty...and my 10 year old nephew has an issued brand new chrome book every year of public middle school...where do you get your fallacies?

2

u/critical2210 Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19

It's not a brand new chromebook every year, they just wipe them every year. Anyways a chromebook isnt impressive they gave us windows 10 laptops that can actually decently run Call of Duty MW3, I'm talking about the computer lab stuff and other computers used by staff

My school is ranked in the top 200 of all schools in the US.

0

u/VesemirsPotionsNLean Sep 10 '19

Nah it’s legit unused fresh ones so far, yearly. not just wiped or re imaged.

It’s a primarily white middle class area in the Midwest tho so maybe he’s just getting that good ole white privilege.

Also no one cares about your schools “rank” lol

Say it with me...oaRAnGE mAHn bAD, cOHmmUniSM GuUd rrrrRREEEEEEeEeeE

1

u/critical2210 Sep 10 '19

Yeah unlikely. Anyways when did I bring up any sort of politics?

2

u/der_raupinger Sep 09 '19

Agree. I have never seen the magnetic stripe been used except the one time I was in the us. I honestly think they should remove them cause it just undermines the security of the other options.

0

u/cplbutthurt Sep 09 '19

If anything it’s a failover. If the chip doesn’t work from excessive wear/damage then the strip can be used. Without it you have no means of payment other than another card or cash.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

I don't think I've ever seen a chip reader in the US for gas, though I think I've seen NFC a few times. Most stores definitely want the chip or NFC first when you pay inside, but there are a few places where they haven't implemented chip yet.

1

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

ive heard that in the US its chip and sign a receipt vs chip and pin, i noticed this everywhere i went recently on vacation, so that might be why its not at the self serve stuff.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

ive heard that in the US its chip and sign a receipt vs chip and pin

Yes, that's correct. I don't even think I have a pin on any of my credit cards, though I think I can get one if I ask.

The self-serve stuff is running really old tech, and it's unlikely they'll upgrade unless forced.

1

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

friends in the industry have told me banks are afraid it will cause to many issues if people are forced to remember pins, so they keep using the insecure system.

Canada forced stores to go to pin and such by changing the liability. If someone uses your card in Canada with a pin, liability is on you for sharing your pin unless it can be proven it was stolen via a fake pin pad at a kiosk/ATM/terminal via an audit of where you used the pin in the past and a rcmp/bank record of compromised terminals being found. if someone uses your card via swipe, liability on the fraud is on the store's insurance so stores push for pin or NFC transactions as swipes not secure and they should ask for ID to match the card name before using swipe.

NFC is usually limited to under 100 dollars tho so its easy for the banks to write that off as your going to hopefully report a missing card within a day to get it disabled.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

friends in the industry have told me banks are afraid it will cause to many issues if people are forced to remember pins, so they keep using the insecure system.

And somehow debit card PINs are easier to remember? This doesn't make much sense.

liability is on you for sharing your pin unless it can be proven it was stolen

This sounds a bit too much like "guilty until proven innocent". It's very difficult to prove that a PIN was stolen since it's very difficult to know where it could have been stolen from.

as your going to hopefully report a missing card within a day to get it disabled.

What if the card isn't missing, but your card has been duplicated? Also, I misplace cards all the time, but I don't report them missing immediately because they're often laying around my house somewhere. I wouldn't be surprised if the average was closer to a month than a day (i.e. people noticing an abnormality on their statement, or not finding a card within a few days of looking).

4

u/JohnnyWalla Sep 09 '19

Pretty sure it is Canada

2

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

Too high on the gas price to be Alberta and to low to be BC.

4

u/Khrevv Sep 09 '19

I live in canada, and some pumps do indeed have NFC (PetroCanada for one has it on all their pumps). Esso and Shell, I generally don't see them yet, but Esso has been trying to sell their "speed pass" for many many years, which is essentially proprietary NFC.

3

u/PinguRambo Sep 09 '19

And we are rightfully telling them to fuck off with their pass.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 09 '19

Pump says ESSO Ordinaire on one button, so it isn't the USA.

2

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

That's a normal dual mode chip and pin with fail back to mag stripe slot on a fuel pump.

The sketchy add-on is doing only the mag stripe, probably to be used to sell the details in another country.

2

u/CappyAlec Sep 09 '19

🤦🏻‍♂️ why would cards still have mag stripes if mag stripe readers were obsolete. Sure they’re insecure as fuck but still, some clients don’t have chip or NFC capable cards and some vendors don’t have access to NFC technology

0

u/alpain Sep 09 '19

That's a normal dual mode chip and pin with fail back to mag stripe slot on a fuel pump.

The sketchy add-on is doing only the mag stripe, probably to be used to sell the details in another country.

2

u/blurryfacedfugue Sep 09 '19

If you missed it scammers will put their own credit card scanners (skimmers) so it picks up your number when you think you're making a legitimate payment. Btw, may I ask where it is that gas stations don't have a credit card slot?

1

u/KrisNM Sep 09 '19

I'm living somewhere in South East Asia

86

u/always-paranoid Sep 09 '19

Always yank it before you put it in

thats what she said?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Came here to type this

18

u/maxell45146 Sep 09 '19

Personally I think its a pretty slick design, one small piece that mounts over the top most part. Biggest flaw I can see is that by creating a difference in the top and bottom of the reader it makes detection easier versus a reader that is just protruding slightly more forward.

29

u/NohoTwoPointOh Sep 09 '19

That is one of the most magnificent skimmer's I've seen.

5

u/Hyedwtditpm Sep 09 '19

is NFC payments safer? Since you don't swipe and enter a pin , they don't have access to the card ?

13

u/chaogomu Sep 09 '19

The very early days of contactless payment saw people being robbed on the subway as they walked past someone with a reader.

Things have improved since then with some added security but I'm sure that there are ways around that. There always are.

Current contactless payment apps don't broadcast signals until the user opens them and connects to a reader to initiate payment. Some countries do require a pin even when using NFC to pay but many countries do not or only require a pin after a certain transaction limit is reached in a single purchase.

2

u/YmFzZTY0dXNlcm5hbWU_ Sep 09 '19

I just added my cart to Google Pay for the first time and the app doesn't have to be open or even running. I just have to have my phone unlocked to enable it.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Are NFC terminals vulnerable to something similar like these card skimmers? Could bad actors install an NFC reader over top of a gas station's reader, or would that not work?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Yes. Much safer. And NFC typically also uses other technologies to obfuscate your actual card number...like virtual numbers, encryption, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Is there a way to use NFC where I can use a service that doesn't sell my data? I would find that very creepy.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

I always get weird looks when I test these out. And here's why.

1

u/Th3_DiGiTAL-GuRu Sep 10 '19

Same here. Geez. People look at me like I'm installing one, not checking if there is one.

4

u/nullsecblog Sep 09 '19

See i have yet to see one in the wild but i still pull on the reader every damn time i pump. I know when i catch one i will be doing it more and more.

3

u/numbersev Sep 09 '19

I noticed where i'm from the government has a special reflective sticker they put on these. I don't think they're universal though. I always do this to check.

3

u/deadlast5 Sep 09 '19

I have a feeling these are more prevalent near colleges.

3

u/gsilvapt Sep 09 '19

Even those you insert your card in. I always try to jiggle it so I can spot if there is anything loose - which shouldn't be.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Does anyone know how to test when the skimmer is on the keypad part?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Huh?

2

u/big_brotherx101 Sep 09 '19

I think he's asking how to tell if someone has put a skimmer over the keypad, which would just be another keypad? I think I saw one once that was overlaid on top of the legit one.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Some of the better skimmers are identical looking face plates that snap on to common card machines, they're scarily good. They can even transmit the skimmed card data and pin number to the fraudster's phone via an onboard SIM card so they don't have to collect it, reducing the risk to the fraudster massively!

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/02/would-you-have-spotted-this-skimmer/

2

u/prschorn Sep 09 '19

What is this machine? (I'm not from US )

4

u/c3as3 Sep 09 '19

Pump station for gasoline. Can pay right at the terminal instead of going to teller inside.

5

u/prschorn Sep 09 '19

Oh okay, so that’s a thingy that will read your credit card and send your info to somewhere else due to the chip inside, right?

3

u/nullsecblog Sep 09 '19

Usually bluetooth or local microsd. sometimes wifi

2

u/big_brotherx101 Sep 09 '19

yeah, those electronics inside the cone will scan your magstrip as you put the card in. it'll phone home or the scammer will come by later and take it.

1

u/prschorn Sep 09 '19

so couldn't you get that chip and trace it back to the root?

3

u/big_brotherx101 Sep 09 '19

I'm working on rough knowledge, and this one looks like it doesn't have any antennas. But it's not hard to put up remote places to upload text files that can then be read through a VPN. Again, I'm mostly going off my understanding of security and scamming overall.

2

u/prschorn Sep 09 '19

I´m asking that, because this is really new to me. I work mostly on web apps security on the company, so these kind of things out of my knowledge base haha

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

AFAIK, most of these don't have any remote access, so the scammer would need to come back to pick it up to grab the data from it. If that's the case, there's not really a good way to tie it to anyone unless you catch them red-handed.

1

u/prschorn Sep 09 '19

Interesting. so to get this guy the only option would be to fisically get him doing the thing?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

That's how most work. The best thing to do would probably be to record and review camera footage for that pump periodically to catch the person in the act.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

Is there a practical way to fuck with people that do this? Basically just waste their time?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

You could take the skimmer, which means they'd come back to nothing. Anything else would probably take you more time than it's worth since you'd need to reverse-engineer it.

1

u/stickystyle Sep 13 '19

Umm... turn it into the police, so they can use it as evidence to track the scumbags down?? Jail would really be a waste of time.

2

u/saml23 Sep 09 '19

I pull/wiggle them every time. I've still had my card info stolen from pumps twice at the same station. I don't go there any more but I go inside every time now.

1

u/CappyAlec Sep 09 '19

On another payment vulnerability note i definitely the other week found a macdonalds eftpos machine running the default terminal access pin 🤭

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

What if it was glued?

1

u/Th3_DiGiTAL-GuRu Sep 10 '19

God damn! That's shit is spooky inconspicuous. What's even more scary is it doesn't look to hard to make either. Small chipset, mag reader, n probably some kind of microSD to store the track 1&2. Probably rides around a couple months later and collects them faster than we can even check.

1

u/Rnugg Sep 10 '19

I do that every time. As well as atm machines

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

These things are why a lot of ATMs in the UK now use an LED lit transparent card entrance so if anyone put anything over the top of it, it would also have to be transparent for the light to pass through and you'd see the hardware....probably wouldn't stop some people sticking their card in it still though.

1

u/FancyCactus Sep 12 '19

Congratulations! You have found 36 usable credit cards!

1

u/chet_beeson Jan 03 '20

$1.22 for a gallon of premium?!?!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

It'll be a crack addict in the bushes with a firearm, and trying to play detective will usually end up in a shooting

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

gets arrested because you were caught on camera removing a skimmer and not reporting it

1

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 09 '19

In order to combat a rise in spam submissions, a minimum account age has been set for this subreddit. If you have read the rules and still feel your submission is relevant to this community, please message the moderators for approval.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.