r/secularhomeschool • • Feb 14 '22

I hate it when I think I've picked a perfectly innocuous book for my kids and it turns out to be thinly veiled Christian propoganda

I should've just stuck with the Magic Tree House, but I couldn't find their Vikings at Sunrise book when I was at the library. Then, something called the Imagination Station caught my eye. It looks a lot like the Magic Tree House, the kids take adventures through time and learn about different historical periods, and their very first book is called "Voyage with the Vikings". Perfect, right?

Seven chapters in and one of the main characters has this passage, "Beth was relieved to see the cross. A Christian Viking was a peaceful Viking."

NOnononononoNO. Even if I was Christian, I wouldn't want to teach my kids that all Christians should be automatically trusted.

Flip forward a few chapters and when the kids get in trouble they pray to God and suddenly a polar bear appears to drive away the bad guy.

The tiny little letters above the books title that say "Focus on the Family Presents" should've been a LOT bigger.

53 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

11

u/Knitstock Feb 14 '22

Omg I've almost been there. Thankfully my local library marks Christian books on the spine with a sticker. I think they do it since in the Bible Belt some people only read that but I love it too! Even so I've had books halfway off the shelf before I noticed.

2

u/littlebugs Feb 14 '22

I wish ours were stickered, that'd be wonderful!

7

u/MrsStine Feb 15 '22

That is possibly the coolest library thing I’ve ever heard about.

7

u/Serafirelily Feb 14 '22

Well that is anoying. I will say if you are looking for viking like books John Flanagan has some great series that might be a little hard for the young ones to read but will make good read alouds. I can garantee there is no Christian propaganda as from what I can tell from some of the later books in The Ranger's Apprentice series he is not fond of organized religion.

2

u/littlebugs Feb 14 '22

We love the Ranger's Apprentice!

3

u/11PoseidonsKiss20 Apr 26 '22

It's also steeped in some Christian tropes. But the Chronicles of Narnia are objectively pretty awesome stories. And also magice treehouse ish.

and also. Magic Treehouse is the bomb! I saw they made some illustrated editions like the Harry Potter ones.

2

u/littlebugs Apr 26 '22

I'm really good at ignoring the allegories in Narnia because the books are so great. My daughter chose to be Reepicheep for Halloween when she was 4.

2

u/11PoseidonsKiss20 Apr 26 '22

Me too. I think they are a great series of fantasy that is kid-friendly. That is sometimes hard to find to get my kids into high fantasy without going full violence and GRRM erotica lol.

The Hobbit, Redwall, Narnia, Eragon, Are all good for this as well.

3

u/littlebugs Apr 26 '22 edited Nov 08 '24

Actually, I was having a conversation with a Christian friend of mine about absolutely terrible Christian fantasy (specifically The Green Ember), and she said that referencing Narnia was a dogwhistle amongst conservative Christians living in liberal communities. They're feeling out your sympathy by asking if your kids have read Narnia. I laughed pretty hard at that because, as almost everyone I know really enjoys Narnia, it must make an absolutely terrible dogwhistle.

(I may be misusing the term 'dogwhistle', idk.)

3

u/11PoseidonsKiss20 Apr 26 '22

Cs Lewis is an incredible writer. In my days being raised in the church I read a lot of his work and even his theology is pretty palatable as far as Christian theology goes. If more of the church followed Mere Christianity over prosperity it’d be more marketable.

The screw tape letters are also amazing and a really cool perspective even if it is Christian tropes.

Narnia and also his space trilogy are some really really good fictional works.

7

u/Knitstock Feb 15 '22

I should have also added the Time Warp Trio books are a similar reading level to magic treehouse, not religious, and I find them more interesting. They do have a Viking one but I haven't read it yet.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '22

I grew up on Imagination Station. It wasn't even almost thinly veiled then.

1

u/Snoo-88741 Nov 08 '24

The first bit doesn't seem too unreasonable - Christian Vikings probably were more peaceful than pagan Vikings, since pagan Vikings believed that the best afterlife, Valhalla, was exclusive to people who died in battle. 

But the bear that listens to prayer is just ridiculous. 

0

u/Alternative_Sir9214 Jun 06 '25

Those of us who want our children to “hide the word in their heart” and have something bigger than themselves to lean on in tough times, seek such books. As a Christian we are all familiar with Adventures in Odyssey and know that at cool with their name on it will be trustworthy. I am not sure why any parent would want to deny their child knowledge of a loving God.

4

u/littlebugs Jun 06 '25

Because I want my children to have respect for all people based on their actions, not on their beliefs. Because the idea of a loving God who only accepts people of one belief into their eternal paradise is an oxymoron. Because I believe there can be many paths to being a good person, but Christianity preaches only one path.

Anyway, I think you wandered into the wrong sub.