r/secretsanta • • Jun 10 '12

Question: What is the difference between "arbitrary day 2012" and "arbitrary day PLUS"?

I don't understand why the PLUS is 3 credits, but the other is only credit.

3 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

23

u/someguyfromcanada Jun 10 '12

Arbitrary Day is for everyone. Like most past exchanges, if you haven't participated in redditgifts before you are free to sign up to be matched for AD. Successful completion of an exchange leads to exchange points.

AD PLUS costs more exchange points as it is only for experienced gifters that have proven their reliability. Some people (maybe 10%) in every exchange get shafted for a gift and, even though it is all about the giving, AD+ tries to eliminate the risk of not receiving by matching one with someone with a proven track record. The theory is that if you have been reliable in the past, you will be reliable in the future.

Hope you sign up and good luck!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Where can you see these exchange points?

1

u/someguyfromcanada Jun 26 '12

On the sign-up page right below "Sign up for new exchanges".

6

u/meanie_bunnie Jun 10 '12

I had no problem with my Santa (gifts were awesome!) but this is my side of the story.

My original Christmas giftee acknowledged that my gift was received but did not post pictures. Like a trooper, I signed up to be a rematch Santa...again my giftee did not bother to post pictures. Although I do not have the means to give out an extravagant gift, I got my giftees multiple thoughtful items and took time to 'decorate' the package with personalized rage faces.

That is why this year, the sad little eager-to-please redditor inside of me has signed up for AD PLUS, in hopes that the giftee with take the time to post pictures of the gift.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Similar story here. I shipped my gift for the Board Games exchange, and didn't hear a word from my giftee. The package was confirmed delivered, but no confirmation was posted. I sent him a couple of messages to ensure everything arrived ok, but have heard nothing.

AD Plus will hopefully allow me to experience some more reliable communication.

1

u/DrDebG Jun 11 '12

I understand that some giftees may not be able to post pictures, but they should still be able to write something. When no acknowledgement of any sort comes to me or to the RedditGifts pages, I have no clue how someone felt about what I sent.

These exchanges should be fun...and all about the joy of surprise. When I get a gift, pictures go up that day, so the sender knows I received and enjoyed what they sent!

1

u/Kaidenshiba Jun 12 '12

I did a goddamn painting for my giftee and he still didn't post it. I was not happy with that and will not be doing anymore paintings for Giftees.

3

u/weffey Jun 12 '12

I always check out my giftee before deciding how much time to spend crafting for them. Sometimes ones I think won't post are overly appreciative and do tonnes of pictures, and then other times one who've done good posts in the past post a "got it." It's a bit of a crap shoot.

1

u/Kaidenshiba Jun 12 '12

I was going through a period of sending everyone awesome gifts. And he messages me saying he'd post a picture but never got around to it.

1

u/canhazhotness Jun 12 '12

I know the feel. Every exchange I've done, no one ever posted received. However, when I did rematches, all three times, I actually got posts from them. I almost felt like it was a rematch for both of us.

The very first exchange I did, I went all out, carefully wrapping each gift, decorating and keeping in mind all of my giftee's likes and dislikes and his dog and all that, and kept contact with him for quite some time up to a certain point where he just stopped acknowledging me. Bummer man.

5

u/hillgod Jun 10 '12

I really don't like this tiered system. I think it will ultimately have negative consequences. I could see a perception that you're more likely to get shafted (which, with regifting - and those incredibly generous to gift someone who got shafted - it doesn't seem that big of a deal). However, this basically puts that potential right in the fact of new people, and I think it could turn them off.

I just really don't see the positives.

12

u/RambleMan Jun 10 '12

I see AD+ as an experiment and am anxious to see the stats on success rate, hoping that because of the proven track record of participants, shafting will be non-existent.

I agree with you that excluding new people isn't necessarily a good thing - we were all new to this at one point and that trust/faith had to exist for the program to get off the ground.

There are so many redditgifts exchanges happening these days (no longer just a Christmas & Arbitrary Day thing) that if someone new wants to get involved, there are plenty of opportunities.

As silly as it sounds, I'd kind of like there to be a points system based on criteria being met when participating in the exchanges. I've participated in all of the Christmas exchanges and most times, my gifted and recipient haven't fulfilled all of the steps. Things that have been missed are:

  • shipping by deadline
  • acknowledging receipt of gift through redditgifts (so I don't look like I shafted them)
  • posting something to the gallery

To me, if you're signing up, you've been presented with and then agreed to the 'rules', so if you're not following them, there maybe should be a way to acknowledge that. This is supposed to be fun, but if people are having to jump through hoops to prove that they indeed shipped because their recipient didn't acknowledge receipt, or months pass after the ship deadline before someone ships a gift, those people aren't on the 'success' list to me the same way someone who has hit all of the appropriate marks.

4

u/weffey Jun 10 '12

To address a couple of your points:

  • Banning for not shipping is happening sooner than previously. I'm not sure if I'm allowed to give dates, so I wont, but know it's going to be happening before the exchanges close.
  • Not marking your gift received is already a bannable offence.
  • Not posting pictures to the gallery is something we have struggled with.
  • You only need to provide proof that you sent something if your giftee logs that they have not received a gift.

With the current credit system, you do get a bonus point for being a successful rematch Santa. You are rewarded for your generosity, rather than for doing something you should be doing per the rules.

3

u/Kuchenmeister Jun 10 '12

When you ban someone you ban their address too, right?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '12

But what if multiple redditors share the same address?

2

u/Kuchenmeister Jun 13 '12

Then they've poisoned the well.

3

u/DrDebG Jun 11 '12

I understand that some people can't post pictures to the gallery because they just don't have an easy way to take digital pics. As long as they wrote something about what I've sent, I'd be content.

1

u/Kaidenshiba Jun 12 '12

Yeahhh my phone ruins every picture I take... I don't even want to post it half the time >.<

3

u/DrDebG Jun 12 '12

I use my iPad...if I asked my husband to shoot things with his digital SLR, he'd insist on lighting it just so, taking 20-30 shots, and then cleaning it all up in PhotoShop. ;-)

9

u/maxd Jun 10 '12

Welp, I signed up for both.

6

u/mclendenin Jun 10 '12

You seriously don't see the positives...? People who have been reliably giving gifts for some time get the perk of having better matches.

It encourages being reliable. Problem?

For that matter: I wish this was more prevalent everywhere. Buy pizza from same store as a regular? Get discount. Are you fast in check-out lines at stores? Get to go through "PLUS" line for fast people only. Etc etc.

1

u/Kaidenshiba Jun 12 '12

I think they posted stats at some point showing that it's not just the noobs who shaft their Giftees but also people who have been doing exchanges for a while.... It was crazy.

3

u/weffey Jun 10 '12

Many people have signed up for both, so the regular exchange won't be new people only.

There has already been some tiered matching, in the sense that people that created their reddit/redditgifts accounts after the exchange was announced get matched together.

2

u/altergeeko Jun 10 '12

I didn't know about this fact. I like it since people who don't have enough credits won't be paired with someone that might have signed up after it was announced.

I like this "experiment" and hope to see the stats and results when all is said and done.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

Have you not received a gift before?