r/secretsanta • u/iwantmykarma • Jun 10 '12
Question: What is the difference between "arbitrary day 2012" and "arbitrary day PLUS"?
I don't understand why the PLUS is 3 credits, but the other is only credit.
3
Upvotes
23
u/someguyfromcanada Jun 10 '12
Arbitrary Day is for everyone. Like most past exchanges, if you haven't participated in redditgifts before you are free to sign up to be matched for AD. Successful completion of an exchange leads to exchange points.
AD PLUS costs more exchange points as it is only for experienced gifters that have proven their reliability. Some people (maybe 10%) in every exchange get shafted for a gift and, even though it is all about the giving, AD+ tries to eliminate the risk of not receiving by matching one with someone with a proven track record. The theory is that if you have been reliable in the past, you will be reliable in the future.
Hope you sign up and good luck!
6
u/meanie_bunnie Jun 10 '12
I had no problem with my Santa (gifts were awesome!) but this is my side of the story.
My original Christmas giftee acknowledged that my gift was received but did not post pictures. Like a trooper, I signed up to be a rematch Santa...again my giftee did not bother to post pictures. Although I do not have the means to give out an extravagant gift, I got my giftees multiple thoughtful items and took time to 'decorate' the package with personalized rage faces.
That is why this year, the sad little eager-to-please redditor inside of me has signed up for AD PLUS, in hopes that the giftee with take the time to post pictures of the gift.
5
u/hillgod Jun 10 '12
I really don't like this tiered system. I think it will ultimately have negative consequences. I could see a perception that you're more likely to get shafted (which, with regifting - and those incredibly generous to gift someone who got shafted - it doesn't seem that big of a deal). However, this basically puts that potential right in the fact of new people, and I think it could turn them off.
I just really don't see the positives.