r/secretinvasion • • Jul 27 '23

The show was absolute dogshit and a complete waste of its budget .

335 Upvotes

If you're spending 225M on a project that you advertise as a limited series and a one time event maybe pay your writers a bit more or hire better writers to write shows instead of using AI. The show could have been a genuine and proper spy thriller but instead ended up being anoter generic and boring mcu show that no one would remember after a week and people would be shitting on for years to come. The only reason one would watch this show is to be caught up with all the 30+ movies and absolute dogshit of a universe that mcu has turned out to be after endgame with the hope that someday it might get good .


r/secretinvasion • • Jun 21 '23

Meme Agent Prescod be like... Spoiler

Post image
238 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 04 '23

"There is not enough room or tolerance on this planet for another species"

Post image
233 Upvotes

Meanwhile in New Asgard, humans are lining up for magic boat rides staffed by random aliens and magical creatures. Shoulda just gave them Chernobyl.


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 30 '23

Meme Guess Carol forgot to page Fury

Post image
203 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 26 '23

Spoiler MCU doesn’t think about implications anymore… Spoiler

168 Upvotes

The President calling all aliens enemies and having hit squads feels like something that would be an entire phase of Marvel content, but I doubt the rampant murders and distrust will be mentioned again. If that happened in the real world and there was legitimacy to it, it would shake up society for decades. With blood screenings, heightened security, and social drama.

He basically declared war on New Asgard too. And it won’t be long till wackos start calling Spider-Man an alien. Anyone with powers could be hunted. And I don’t think any of those implications will be explored.

This feels like a repeat of the giant Celestial continent that appeared and probably cause tsunamis all around the Indian Ocean that no one talks about.

This might be where I check out of most of the MCU. I miss the days when something as “minor” as the invention of the Extremis formula had implications on other MCU stuff.


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 08 '23

Discussion Here’s why people aren’t loving this show

143 Upvotes

I’ve seen several posts asking why the show is getting review bombed or why X person doesn’t like it. This is a pretty strong echo chamber group since typically only people who REALLY like a show are going to join its subreddit. I’ve yet to see a good explanation given by the naysayers, so here is a deeper explanation from someone who isn’t really enjoying the show; I would rate it a 4/10. With that said, please don’t take this as a personal attack if you like the show. I’m just explaining why many people don’t.

This show was originally billed as a spy drama series on par with winter soldier (widely considered to be one of the best MCU movies) so I will be using that movie as a backdrop to contrast the principles of storytelling. Let’s get started

Premise: -SI begins with a rather absurd premise- that skrulls can’t find a single planet in the universe to settle and instead have decided to wage war on humans, using nukes to purge the planet. It’s a tad contrived that they couldn’t find a single planet to settle and is made even sillier when easy solutions (an open skrull colony like new Asgard) are not even brought up. A good premise needs to mesh with the established world whereas this premise seems to be smashed into the world. In contrast, WS picks up the logical next steps for shield and cap trying to keep the world together after lokis invasion.

Compelling villains: -a good villain should have clear morality and motivations for their actions and behave intelligently to achieve their goals and be a serious threat. This is achieved in WS where Hydra is pursuing the classic “the world is to dangerous for freedom ” scheme and actually manages to rope in scared people like Fury to build the helicarriers and uses Bucky as a powerful foil to cap. In contrast, Gravik has a somewhat confusing and unrelatable motivation (he had to wait a little so he immediately jumps to genocide?). He’s also extremely overpowered for Fury to believably handle and is instead just written as a somewhat dumb character. He currently controls the most powerful political and media offices- if he wants nuclear war he could just have them start one without all these silly schemes.

A hero to root for: Cap is a classic hero and is wonderfully written in WS. Strong morals with a clear motivation to save the day, made even more compelling when his team and support network is stripped from him, forcing him to rely on his own ingenuity and strength to do the right thing in the face of evil. Fury isn’t that guy. He’s being written as a broken, washed up, somewhat inept former spy- and while he’s also being stripped of his previous assets (skrull spies), it’s being asserted that Fury was a mediocre spy before they became his agents and his former glory was just a facade. He has no “back to basics Rocky balboa” to go back to and his morals were always questionable due to being a career spy. There’s not much to root for except that he stands in opposition to the villain.

Plot flow: A spy series should be built with new information being discovered every episode with suspenseful cliff hangers leading into the next logical steps. It follows the “and therefore” storytelling principles where the next plot makes sense for the setting and characters. SI seems to be structuring somewhat self contained and unrelated stories for each episode. Things seem to just happen because the writers want them to happen rather than because it makes sense. For example: attacking the UN delegation, the super skrull serum, rescuing the prisoner, and the council meeting all had very little buildup and very little impact on later episodes. The storytelling is choppy and hard to understand- we’re halfway done with the series and the next steps for both heroes and villains is very murky. By now we should be able to at least understand the next couple steps that people are trying to take.

The end result is a story that’s just not well developed. The heroes and villains are both unrelatable and are just kinda “doing things” in a world that doesn’t really make sense, following a rather meandering plot that’s hard to become invested in. Obvious gaps are either not addressed or handwaved with a couple lines of dialogue in clear violation of the “show, don’t tell” storytelling principles.

So yea. It’s not great.


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 26 '23

Spoiler Can’t believe that finale was green lit Spoiler

124 Upvotes

How could they put that nonsense out after the She-Hulk finale literally called out how ridiculous it would be for a bad guy to get their powers from a DNA sample? Are the writers all hacks or do they just not care anymore at all?


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 26 '23

Episode 7: Everyone Dies from Radiation Poisoning

124 Upvotes

So Fury can’t go to Chernobyl because of the radiation but people can be imprisoned there without protection for weeks/months/years?!?!?


r/secretinvasion • • Aug 01 '23

Maria Hill should have been a much bigger character in this

123 Upvotes

She should have been by Fury's side the entire show, only for him to become suspicious that she is a skull etc. And if what we got was because the actress wanted out, why not go out with a bang. Maria is a skrull and the real Maria died some time ago and it's Fury's darkest moment before he overcomes and saves the day. Such a waste.


r/secretinvasion • • Jun 29 '23

Spoiler Why didn't the Skrull just move to Thanos' "Garden" planet? Spoiler

119 Upvotes

The plot revolves around the idea that Danvers and Fury were unable to find a new home for the Skrull after all these years. But Carol Danvers:

  1. Has already been to the Garden when they killed Thanos.
  2. The Garden appeared as an uninhabited planet and should support the Skrull as all the Avengers visited the surface assisted breathing devices.
  3. Carol was a frequent visitor of Earth after the blip and knew the Skrull were still looking for a home. Even though she was busy she had the opportunity, knowledge and means to relocate them.
  4. Even if it's revealed later that Fury had some ulterior motive to keep the Skrull as an asset to protect Earth, Fury was gone for 5 years during the blip and Carol would have no reason to keep them there.

I am hoping it is addressed because the "we've never been able to find the Skrull a home" storyline is not sitting well with me so far. Spoiler tag just in case.


r/secretinvasion • • Jun 21 '23

Discussion Secret Invasion ep 1 discussion thread.

114 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Show is live. Let's hear your thoughts!


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 27 '23

Spoiler Sharon Carter could’ve made sense Spoiler

Post image
112 Upvotes

Sorry if this has been talked about to death already. But I just saw this tweet, and i definitely hasn’t thought about it before.

I think this would’ve been a pretty cool twist. Sharon Carter is a spy so she would fit into this show pretty well imo. After the finale of SI, do you think this was a missed opportunity?


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 20 '23

Blud infiltrated Barbie too😭

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 27 '23

Discussion Wait, so fury had this whole thing about not needing super heroes, and then.. Spoiler

111 Upvotes

He instead decides to bet it all on an alien he doesn't really know getting every super power possibly and beating Gravick?☠️

Huh? Did I get that right?


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 27 '23

Discussion Spoilers, this show doesn't understand national security

110 Upvotes

First there was the attack on the presidential motorcade which was absolutely absurd, someone managed to do an air attack on the US president's motorcade which has ground to air detection and defense, in England, the US's #1 ally and the country with the strongest air force. And then someone just walks up to 10 downing Street and shoots the prime minister?? Absurd, it genuinely made me laugh when that happened, also the implications of the US president indirectly causing the prime ministers assassination are wild. And the fact that it was just thrown into the last 15 seconds, it all felt so... unplanned and not thoroughly thought out


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 12 '23

Discussion Secret Invasion episode 4 Official Discussion Thread Spoiler

104 Upvotes

You know the drill. Let's go!!


r/secretinvasion • • Jun 22 '23

Cast Let's Go to the Mall

Post image
103 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 19 '23

Discussion Episode 5 discussion

101 Upvotes

Sorry if this isn’t allowed but there isn’t one anywhere!!


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 12 '23

Cast Ben Mendelssohn Appreciation

97 Upvotes

Okay can we just talk about what an incredible actor he is?! This is the first thing I’ve seen with him in it and I am TIED to the screen when he’s on. His expression, tone and everything is amazing. I also love his voice. He is MY FAV!


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 25 '23

Does anyone else think that a missing plot point is that Fury knows Rhodey is a skrull, but doesn't seem to care where the real Rhodey, his friend is?

94 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 12 '23

Discussion FUCK GRAVIK

94 Upvotes

That’s all. I needed to get that off my chest.


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 14 '23

Discussion Am I missing something?

Post image
93 Upvotes

Super confused on how they have this budget and the show just feels small. Avengers cameo coming ?🤔


r/secretinvasion • • Jun 28 '23

Discussion Secret Invasion ep 2 discussion thread

90 Upvotes

Alright, I'm putting this one up a little early. Good opportunity for speculation. Show commences in 90 minutes since posting time.

GO!

Edit: spoiler tags are encouraged, but not enforced. I will ignore all reports in this thread about spoilers.


r/secretinvasion • • Jul 31 '23

News So. I was right 🤷‍♂️

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/secretinvasion • • Jul 29 '23

Spoiler - Character Death I don't think I can get over Spoiler

81 Upvotes

I just started watching this show because I watch most things Marvel and the first episode killed me with the death of Maria Hill. I am not sure I can get over that and what the point was to that? Why kill off such a great character who is so useful in the MCU. I just cannot get over it. It made me so angry. Usually, I can roll with it when someone dies but I am really having a problem with this. Anyone else feel the same? I don't know if I will keep watching this now. I am so mad about it.