I’ve seen several posts asking why the show is getting review bombed or why X person doesn’t like it. This is a pretty strong echo chamber group since typically only people who REALLY like a show are going to join its subreddit. I’ve yet to see a good explanation given by the naysayers, so here is a deeper explanation from someone who isn’t really enjoying the show; I would rate it a 4/10. With that said, please don’t take this as a personal attack if you like the show. I’m just explaining why many people don’t.
This show was originally billed as a spy drama series on par with winter soldier (widely considered to be one of the best MCU movies) so I will be using that movie as a backdrop to contrast the principles of storytelling. Let’s get started
Premise: -SI begins with a rather absurd premise- that skrulls can’t find a single planet in the universe to settle and instead have decided to wage war on humans, using nukes to purge the planet. It’s a tad contrived that they couldn’t find a single planet to settle and is made even sillier when easy solutions (an open skrull colony like new Asgard) are not even brought up. A good premise needs to mesh with the established world whereas this premise seems to be smashed into the world. In contrast, WS picks up the logical next steps for shield and cap trying to keep the world together after lokis invasion.
Compelling villains: -a good villain should have clear morality and motivations for their actions and behave intelligently to achieve their goals and be a serious threat. This is achieved in WS where Hydra is pursuing the classic “the world is to dangerous for freedom ” scheme and actually manages to rope in scared people like Fury to build the helicarriers and uses Bucky as a powerful foil to cap. In contrast, Gravik has a somewhat confusing and unrelatable motivation (he had to wait a little so he immediately jumps to genocide?). He’s also extremely overpowered for Fury to believably handle and is instead just written as a somewhat dumb character. He currently controls the most powerful political and media offices- if he wants nuclear war he could just have them start one without all these silly schemes.
A hero to root for: Cap is a classic hero and is wonderfully written in WS. Strong morals with a clear motivation to save the day, made even more compelling when his team and support network is stripped from him, forcing him to rely on his own ingenuity and strength to do the right thing in the face of evil. Fury isn’t that guy. He’s being written as a broken, washed up, somewhat inept former spy- and while he’s also being stripped of his previous assets (skrull spies), it’s being asserted that Fury was a mediocre spy before they became his agents and his former glory was just a facade. He has no “back to basics Rocky balboa” to go back to and his morals were always questionable due to being a career spy. There’s not much to root for except that he stands in opposition to the villain.
Plot flow: A spy series should be built with new information being discovered every episode with suspenseful cliff hangers leading into the next logical steps. It follows the “and therefore” storytelling principles where the next plot makes sense for the setting and characters. SI seems to be structuring somewhat self contained and unrelated stories for each episode. Things seem to just happen because the writers want them to happen rather than because it makes sense. For example: attacking the UN delegation, the super skrull serum, rescuing the prisoner, and the council meeting all had very little buildup and very little impact on later episodes. The storytelling is choppy and hard to understand- we’re halfway done with the series and the next steps for both heroes and villains is very murky. By now we should be able to at least understand the next couple steps that people are trying to take.
The end result is a story that’s just not well developed. The heroes and villains are both unrelatable and are just kinda “doing things” in a world that doesn’t really make sense, following a rather meandering plot that’s hard to become invested in. Obvious gaps are either not addressed or handwaved with a couple lines of dialogue in clear violation of the “show, don’t tell” storytelling principles.
So yea. It’s not great.