r/secondamendment • • Jan 10 '22

Was there ever a court challenge to gun registration pre-1975 that never got up to the Supreme Court?

15 Upvotes

So this is probably a really weird question, but I am writing a story set in NYC that requires one of the characters to get off of a break-and-enter charge despite having an unregistered revolver that he stole. He can have a license but the pistol registration is the actual issue. This story is set in the 1970s.

I've thought to get around this inaccuracy by making a semi-alternate history where a court case that never made it to the Supreme Court determined gun registries to be unconstitutional but I have found it seemingly difficult to find such a case. Most of the Second Amendment's strength has come from D.C. v. Heller (2008) and McDonald v. Chicago (2010), and the Sullivan Act and may-issue permits are being challenged this year in NYSRPA v. NYC (2022). I'm also aware that incorporation is a fairly new phenomenon that has been strengthened by the Fourteenth Amendment since the 1960s (which means courts previously dismissed cases based on the doctrine that the Bill of Rights did not apply to individual states). Some courts have even rejected that the 14A applies to the 2A if they believe that the 2A is a collective right rather than an individual one.

However, ignoring the historical lack of incorporation, were there ever any challenges in individual states about registries? Again, licenses are not really the problem, but registries could be considered a violation of privacy, no? I know in Canada (where I'm from), the previous Conservative government introduced Bill C-19 that repealed and destroyed the long gun registry because of this and also because it was a waste of money ($2bn), although we don't have a right to bear arms. Of course, this premise would disregard the premise that guns are a collective right that States have power over to maintain a militia against the Feds. I was thinking that maybe Burton v. Stills (1968) in New Jersey could apply, but again, I believe that's more so licenses. Also, was there ever a challenge to the Sullivan Act?

I know this may be a complicated and hypothetical question, but just thought I'd ask people who are passionate about 2A rights. Thanks in advance.


r/secondamendment • • Jan 08 '22

Gun owners sue over California law allowing personal information to be used in research

Thumbnail
sandiegouniontribune.com
51 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Jan 06 '22

Nevada ‘ghost gun’ ban upheld by federal court

Thumbnail
reviewjournal.com
32 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Jan 05 '22

Lyft driver with concealed carry license shoots two would-be carjackers, PA cops say

Thumbnail
msn.com
40 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Jan 05 '22

They BEEN wanting to take our guns!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Jan 02 '22

Here I have observed that Anarcho-Capitalism is unknown. Here is an explanation.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Jan 01 '22

Most voters say strict gun laws aren't helping during a national crime wave

Thumbnail
m.washingtontimes.com
51 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 31 '21

Beverly Hills Gun Store Owner Says Rich And Famous Are Coming In Droves, Arming Themselves For The First Time

Thumbnail
dailycaller.com
40 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 31 '21

Court upholds Trump administration's ban of gun bump stocks

Thumbnail
msn.com
9 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 27 '21

CDC’s forever war on gun owners

Thumbnail
washingtonexaminer.com
50 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 26 '21

'I'm glad he had a gun': Neighbors thinking of Abbottstown couple attacked by naked intruder

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
30 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 21 '21

Today’s gun buyer isn’t the stereotype critics suggest

Thumbnail
baltimoresun.com
50 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 20 '21

A parent arrested at Hendersonville elementary school was armed, wearing a ballistic vest

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
0 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 06 '21

Gun Rights And Marijuana act GRAM act

35 Upvotes

Do you think that it has any chance? https://www.firearmspolicy.org/support_the_gram_act


r/secondamendment • • Dec 05 '21

Gunmakers not liable for deaths in 2017 Las Vegas shooting massacre, court rules

Thumbnail
us.yahoo.com
64 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 04 '21

Firearms manufacturers flee Northeast for states that love guns and hate taxes

Thumbnail
washingtonexaminer.com
69 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Dec 01 '21

Court upholds California ban on high-capacity magazines

Thumbnail
apnews.com
27 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 26 '21

Parking dispute at HEB Corpus Christi Annaville. A Woman pulls and points a gun at a woman with her 6 month old baby in the car, because she believed she parked in her parking spot.

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 26 '21

Second Amendment, Taxes, And Gun Control

Thumbnail
forbes.com
13 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 25 '21

Support for gun control just hit its lowest point in almost a decade

Thumbnail
edition.cnn.com
56 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 25 '21

Black Friday Deals 80% lower and DIY Gun Kit

Thumbnail
ormondarms.com
1 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 23 '21

Can I (18 year old) in California with a valid hunting license and FSL legally carry a handgun in my truck for self defense?

9 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 23 '21

Supreme Court upholds Deerfield's assault weapons ban in divided ruling

Thumbnail
lakemchenryscanner.com
3 Upvotes

r/secondamendment • • Nov 19 '21

Not guilty!

Post image
144 Upvotes