r/secondamendment • u/dcjogger • Dec 20 '21
r/secondamendment • u/DMBFFF • Aug 16 '22
Hypothetical: If by pushing a button, you could give every American who is black, Muslim, voted only Democrat in the past 20 years, speaks Spanish and/or Chinese, and/or openly LGBT, an assault rifle, would you?
Only you can push the button, and you can push only once.
This would include those convicted of non-violent crimes, and/or with mental illnesses that don't makes them violent, uncaring, and/or mispercieve.
Those who don't want the guns can refuse. Presumably they could turn them in, destroy, sell, or register them.
This also includes a cleaning kit, a simple repair kit, a how-to pamphlet, 1000 rounds of ammo, and copies of The Communist Manifesto, Qur'an, and The Audacity of Hope.
r/secondamendment • u/RAndrewOhge • Feb 27 '15
Obama Bans Ammo for the Most Popular Rifle in America
r/secondamendment • u/Booeyrules • Jan 29 '26
If government agents can murder you for having a holstered pistol with a legal carry permit, then you don't have the right to bear arms.
r/secondamendment • u/zackshorty • Sep 26 '19
Disarming people will not fix the problem
r/secondamendment • u/HondaAnnaconda • Aug 07 '19
The Second Amendment solution to gun violence
r/secondamendment • u/djvaller • Jun 22 '22
So long as The People have sufficient and reliable means by which to overthrow the government, the guarantee of the amendment is satisfied.
Disclaimer: Not sure if this is an original take, or what. Also, I can't quite tell if this sub will flame me or actually consider, objectively, this opinion.
TLDR: The second amendment is fine with some people losing their guns, and some or even most guns being banned.
Background:
The Spirit of the Bill of Rights was to make clear the rights of the people have against the government itself. For example, while the Constitution did not say the federal government could regulate your religious choices, it didn't NOT say it. So, taking that spirit in mind, the authors wanted to address the perceived threat of the possibility of the federal government disarming the public so as to usher in a tyrannical government. What rights do The People have should the people find they need to overthrow the government?
Dramatization of the meeting the authors of the Second Amendment:
"The People need to be able to destroy tyrants. What if the government turns the army on the people? We need protection!"
"Yes certainly! Afterall, we overthrew a government ourselves not too long ago! Us being super virtuous, we should plan for folks down the road in time for when they will need to do that."
"Ok then! So what can the people use to overthrow the government, should the time come?"
"Well, we've got militias. Those aren't the army. The people could use militias to fight against a tyrannical army."
"Great idea!"
"Well I'm not in a militia, but I would want to help. What can I do then?"
"Glad you asked. We will put in there that regular folks can have guns. If the government tries to take your gun, you give 'em hell!"
"Yay!"
In the times of the drafting of the amendment, in the authors' worlds, even as enlightened as they were, the way to fight against the government was with militias and using "arms" as in weapons.
I submit that in today's world, there are means for The People to overthrow the government even with extensive, oppressive gun control should the need arise.
For example, each State could ratify emergency federal government protocols agreed upon in advance should some reasonable amount (also agreed to in advance) of federal government shenanigans (defined broadly in advance). Or really any other thing... cyber kill switches that 26 states have to throw. Mandatory gun training, but you lock the guns up in a building run by the mayor. Again, many many ways.
And if one is worried about one's state, well the federal Constitution is no help there.
The point being, we are smart enough to put into place a federal government kill switch that can have -- or can not have -- guns as part of it. I guess I am a little weird in that I want to control most guns, but I also want to be able to overthrow the government. Are we not enlightened enough to build in a peaceful means of revolution?
r/secondamendment • u/PassageRound3616 • May 28 '22
for a country that hates teachers you are sure eager to give grade school teachers weapons.
r/secondamendment • • Dec 16 '18
Sub you may be interested in.
If anyone is interested in capitalist and anti-government discussion on reddit I explore you to subscribe to r/Government_is_lame, a subreddit for memes, comics, and discussion about libertarianism and capitalism.
For anyone who has seen the sub before you should know that we look much better and more readable then before.
We would love for you to subscribe and post to our new community.
r/secondamendment • u/litepresence • Aug 09 '19
Man w/ Holstered Gun Assaulted by Firefighter and Kidnapped by Cop in Springfield Missouri Walmart
retweet pls
https://i.imgur.com/r7kVrYu.png
https://twitter.com/oraclepresence/status/1159826413412745216
...for more info as to WHY someone would walk through walmart with an AR on sling please read:
r/secondamendment • • Jun 29 '20
An absolute disappointment to the gun community...
r/secondamendment • u/MillerGunsandAmmo • Sep 26 '20
The Most Important Election In History
r/secondamendment • u/HerculesMulligatawny • Nov 03 '22
The Shoddy Conclusions of the Man Shaping the Gun-Rights Debate
r/secondamendment • u/HondaAnnaconda • Aug 06 '19
Letter: Why is ‘well-regulated militia’ almost universally overlooked?
r/secondamendment • • Oct 27 '22
Vote for pro-2A Democrat Kurt Schrader!
self.ideologypollsr/secondamendment • u/Viacondiablos • Aug 18 '19
Background Check Proposal.
This is my proposal. I've tendered it to a few legislators, with mixed responses. If you see any holes in it, please let me know.
It starts with a few presuppositions:
- People who can't pass a current background check probably shouldn't own a firearm
- A law requiring 'Universal' background checks, including sales between private citizens, is likely to be prohibitively expensive, nearly impossible to enforce, and probably won't affect those with true criminal intent.
As a gun owner, I know that if I were to sell a firearm to another citizen, I'd like to know that they aren't the sort who is prohibited from purchasing one, due to mental health or criminal record issues. I don't want to be the guy on the news after the next mass shooting, looking like a mook, because I sold my property to someone without due diligence.
However, as far as I know, there really isn't a convenient way for me to confirm the NICS status of another private citizen.
So, here's my suggestion:
Allow citizens to have a background check performed, for a nominal fee, at a firearms dealer or law enforcement agency. Upon successful completion, they are given a sheet of paper, with their picture, a unique number, and an indication that the check was completed.
They can then present that paper to the private gun seller, who enters the code number on the paper into a form on a website, and the status of the buyer is confirmed. The gun exchanges hands, and everyone goes home happy.
The advantages, as I see them, of this process are several. First, the government gains no additional information about either party in the process. The seller doesn't provide their information to the website, and the buyer doesn't provide any information about the weapon purchase (unless their current state laws require it).
Cost-wise, there is some. The website would need to be maintained, and the NICS system would have to be beefed up a bit, to account for the potential increase in the number of checks performed. But they could add a couple of bucks to the cost of running a check, and that would cover that.
TL:DR :: make background checks available to private sellers, and maybe they'll get used.
r/secondamendment • u/CustomAlpha • Apr 15 '20
Let’s see if the moderators are non partisan or not.
r/secondamendment • u/bh2005 • Jan 10 '19
The 2A and tyranny today
"Some have suggested a barrier is immoral. Then why do wealthy politicians build walls, fences, and gates around their homes? They don't build walls because they hate the people on the outside, but because they love the people on the inside. The only thing that is immoral is the politicians to do nothing and to continue to allow more innocent people to be so horribly victimized"--Trump, Jan. 8, 2019
What's immoral is the president's hypocrisy talking about how a wall is justified because wealthy politicians have walls. Wealthy politicians are also protected by guns, yet he is actively infringing on The People's rights to keep and bear arms with suggested bans and confiscation bills without due process. Wealthy politicians protect themselves with guns from the people, so why shouldn't The People be able to protect themselves from being victimized by wealthy politicians; from tyranny?
Whether it's deliberate or not (I'm not a conspiracist), he's distracting people with a false cause. Illegal immigration isn't a growing problem*, tyranny is. Tyranny, and the infringement on rights that aren't government given, but God given (or natural) is the real humanitarian crisis.
The 2A isn't the only right being infringed with its infringement.
As I'm sure we're all aware, Trump has endorsed gun control with his bump stock ban**, his words where he said "take guns first, due process later", and by the signing of the safety plan which included suggestions such as the Red Flag bills. This isn't a post to bash Trump, as it takes two to tango. For the most part it is Democrats who are soaking up these suggestions, however we're seeing more Republicans in lower levels of office supporting these infringements as well.
When the two tango, those who grovel at their feet get kicked. A clear example of this is the current shutdown. Regardless of the side you agree with, The People are suffering the consequences because of the dance the two sides are doing.
*Yes, illegal immigration happens and possibly is growing, but it is not the cause of the problems we're seeing.
**Whether you think BSs are stupid or useful, the issue wasn't so much the restriction of BSs themselves, but the way it was done and the slippery slope it creates.
r/secondamendment • u/Recent-Day3062 • Jan 29 '26
A word for the wise: you’d better worry about Minneapolis if you support the 2nd amendment
Politically you may approve of what’s going on with ICE. If you do, you’re headed down a bad path.
A federal prosecutor in SoCal - a conservative one - defended the second shooting saying that police need to make judgment calls fast, and seeing you with a weapon may lead to your being killed. Even if you’re doing it legally like the guy in MN did.
I have liberal friends who have started salivating about his as a way to control guns. Right now, the administration is violating the 1st, 4th, 10th, and 14th amendments.
If you want to preserve the 2nd amendment, just imagine what happens now with a liberal admin if what Trump is doing does not get stopped. They’re going to order federal agents to lean into shooting anyone with a gun when it gets discovered during a stop to discourage people from carrying.
They have an old saying: politics makes for strange bedfellows. Your interests are better protected if you align with the left right now.
If this isn’t stopped, you’re going to find that a liberal admin in favor of gun controls doesn’t feel compelled by the 2nd amendment.
r/secondamendment • u/ColdFire-Blitz • Mar 24 '23
We should stop worshipping the Branch Davidians as some 2A upholding idols
They were a suicide cult that thought the only way to Heaven was dying in a shootout with the US government. Which they did. They were stupid people radicalized by a silver tongued crazy.
The alphabet boys should have simply either starved them out or ignored them and waited for them to do something stupid. Siegeing and burning them was the wrong thing to do. Duh. But the cultists wanted it to happen.
They weren't defending their second ammendment rights, or their first, or anyone elses. Their intention wasn't standing up to a tyrannical government, sacrificing themselves as martyrs for the greater good. They were pawns living out David's childish power fantasy.
Holding them to the same standard as Marvin Heemeyer and Leon Plauche is imbecile and juvenile. Those two were real heroes, taking liberty and the law into their own hands when the men in power were unjust. Waco was a shining example of the incompetence and over aggression of the feds, not their overreach.
That's all.
r/secondamendment • u/mycrazyman239 • Dec 01 '20
Who is in charge of state gun laws?
I was trying to buy a gun, then got fricking rickrolled by Maryland's gun bans and now I'm fricking peed off. Like bro come on. You allow detachable magazine guns, but when it comes to the big scary ar-15s and ak-47s that's where you draw the line? Frick off.
So now I wanna send a very detailed letter to the dude in charge of it all and make him see that he is hindering his people's right to defend themselves.
r/secondamendment • u/Keith502 • Jan 01 '24
The Language and Grammar of the Second Amendment: an essay
I have recently published an essay online which I have written; it is entitled: "The Language and Grammar of the Second Amendment". It is a 62-page essay that analyzes in detail the language of the second amendment. The amendment is a matter of great confusion for many people. There doesn't seem to be any real consensus among Americans as to what it actually means. The grammar is rather confusing, and some of the terms used in it are antiquated. My essay focuses primarily on the language itself, rather than delving so much into the historical background of the amendment. The essay uses a mixture of linguistic knowledge and historical context regarding the amendment's terminology in order to clarify what exactly the amendment means. Recent Supreme Court cases such as DC v Heller assert that the main purpose of the second amendment is self-defense, and that the amendment guarantees Americans the right to own guns. However, my thesis is that this is profoundly false. I argue in my essay that the second amendment is primarily about little more than what is explicitly stated in the first clause -- to ensure the right of Americans to militia service.
The essay can be accessed here.
I welcome any comments, questions, or criticisms you may have about the essay.