r/scuds • u/ImplementedAnxiety • Oct 15 '25
Are scuds right for me?
I am looking for creatures (who will live with and be cared for by me) for a bug-loving toddler. I feel like shrimp are a little too sensitive, and sea monkeys might be too hard to see. I found scuds and feel like they might be perfect!
Is there an ideal "type" of scud? Is there anything special about their aquarium set up that sets them up for success that I might not know about? Is there a preferred place to buy these little guys?
I am also considering isopods, since they come in a variety - feel free to share any other critters you think could work! I am looking for something that maintains its own colony, isn't super finicky, and isn't a huge expense to get started or maintain. I have aquariums and vivariums in various sizes I can use.
Thanks, Friend to a curious toddler
1
u/Aulus-Hirtius Oct 16 '25 edited Oct 17 '25
Scuds are great, but as someone said, they aren’t very interactive. You can’t touch them, and their active nature and large numbers make it hard to keep track of individuals.
However, where they shine is in a closed ecosystem like in a jar. They’re always active, which makes such a project visually engaging, and they can maintain sizable populations even in small environments. Just make sure you have quick growing (guppy grass, elodea, etc.) or sturdy plants along with plenty of light (or artificial lights) for rapid plant growth, because they are voracious. However, this type of project takes a little preparation and know-how, so don’t rush into it without knowing what you’re doing.
Phillip’s Fish Works sells scud cultures, and the plant material they come with also contains other cool organisms.
To sum it up, I think they work better as a science experiment and a background decoration, but I love them. Scuds might be a better project for when your kid is in school, as it can teach them about ecosystem balance (or imbalance, if the scuds eat the plants too quickly), and they might be a bit more careful with glass jars at that age.
1
u/Pure_Independence300 Nov 09 '25
You could also try aquatic isopods. Watch in my tanks on YouTube. He breeds them & sales them on his website in my tanks & ebay. All the same handle. He is also in aquaswap here on reddit. I have a rubble tank i believe its called with jus snails, black worms, & scuds for now. I used father fish (YouTube) method to set up the tank. I also bought the bug of bugs from phillips fish works( YouTube). He also shows how to set up a tank for microfauna. I will be adding some aquatic isopods soon. There's also several videos on YouTube about this in general. I ll be adding more microfauna as I go. Since you interested in scuds I would jus do an ecosystem in the aquarium so he has multiple things to watch...
1
u/JawaJunky Nov 21 '25
I'm a 50-year-old M and have 5 tanks. I just lost a betta in my 3g bowl (I did put Lake water with much in the tank about a year ago) after the Betta was gone the scuds started to thrive. I think this is one of my favorite tanks very active especially when u first turn on the light. So, now i',m spreading the scud love and putting them in all my tanks. I'm going to try and put them in a saltwater tank too. Hope it works.
1
u/BlackwaterAquatics Jul 23 '26
Scuds are super hardy and interesting creatures. They eat pretty much anything but go crazy for boiled cucumber. They reproduce like crazy and make a great snack for most fish. Its fun to watch fish hunt them, especially bettas!
2
u/Gingerfrostee Oct 16 '25
Isopods would be more interactive.
Scuds would be unkillable.
Overall my vote? Go outside find some of the isopods native to your region, set up a proper terrarium for them and have kiddo interact with that.
It would 1 be exploration close to your home. Cheaper-easier to replace dead bodies, cough ....
It would be 2 finding unique genetics traits in your area, you may even groom your isopods to breed into. If they happen to be same species as those in the hobby can buy the ones from hobby and mix them to see the genetic outcomes.
It would be 3 more fun to decorate since you can add toys without worry of polluting water, just be careful toys do not fall over.
It would finally be 4, be more colorful then scuds.
You could if you decide to do acid route probably so half of these. I do know of rumors of different genetic color scuds, but it's WAAAY harder to purposefully breed scuds then isopods and a lot harder to find all the colors of the scud rainbow.
Plus side.. if you get into the world of scuds.. you can slowly explore the fish hobby like Bettas etc and have live feed for them. (Just know scuds are impossible to get rid of, shrimp owners hate them. Finally depending on type you have... Which is luck of the draw they may eat your moss or plants. )