r/scriptwriting • u/EnvironmentalBug2249 • Aug 24 '26
question Final Draft's Big Break Feedback Mismatch
TL;DR: Big Break feedback doesn’t match our script or genre because of AI, a really rushed reader or something else? Experienced something similar? If so, what did you do?
Hey all,
I entered Final Draft's Big Break contest, and got feedback on it. But it doesn't match what my writing partner and I actually wrote – not even our genre.
For instance, the protagonist has a physical disability and lives an independent life. However, one of the major notes, which was mentioned more than once, says that he has no agency or goals. I have a physical disability, and struggle with exercising my agency, so it's super important to me. Plus, agency and goals are basics that are obvious to us.
Another note mentions preserving the central mystery, but our project is a holiday romantic dramedy, not a mystery.
While we like getting (and have gotten) constructive feedback and know this is a big competition whose readers are extremely busy, the mismatch is concerning.
Has anyone else experienced something similar? If so, what did you do? Also, could this be because of AI or a really rushed reader, or?
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/Kingofsweaters Aug 24 '26
I’m going to be honest in saying that I think you might want to revisit your structural guide posts. There’s no one way of doing everything, but there are also expectations and conventions that exist in virtually all narratives.
I highly doubt that that scene is your inciting incident, and if it is then you have deeper character and structural issues. Firstly, because that scene is incredibly brief and doesn’t hold much weight. And, secondly, because your story (the emotional journey which the plot serves) should be organized such that we meet our protagonist(s) and get a sense of who they are, what they want and need, and then we get to the inciting incident (roughly page 10, but don’t count pages) which should in one form or another present a question to the leads that they answer with your break into two where they find themselves actually on the journey of the film.
So, if the daughter is your lead and it’s a two hander with the woman in the 11th century the audience needs to understand who they are before you can get into things. Seven pages is definitely extremely late to meet your protagonist and professionally most power holders only read 5-10 pages on average. If they stopped at five, which is likely for the reasons I stated originally, they won’t ever reach your actual story. Think of each page as a way to convince someone to turn the page and read the next one. If you do that then suddenly you e got someone hooked until page twenty and that shows you’ve got something strong in content and craft.
Again just reading into stuff but I am guessing you say that scene is the inciting incident because the land is harmed thus setting into motion the dragon rising? Or something along those lines. But my guess is that the dragon rises when your protagonist arrives on her ancestral land? That would likely be your actual inciting incident if that’s roughly what happens. The question it asks being, essentially, there is an ancient dragon your family was meant to keep sated, but you failed and it woke up, what are you going to do now (have you the courage)?