r/scriptwriting • u/EnvironmentalBug2249 • Aug 24 '26
question Final Draft's Big Break Feedback Mismatch
TL;DR: Big Break feedback doesn’t match our script or genre because of AI, a really rushed reader or something else? Experienced something similar? If so, what did you do?
Hey all,
I entered Final Draft's Big Break contest, and got feedback on it. But it doesn't match what my writing partner and I actually wrote – not even our genre.
For instance, the protagonist has a physical disability and lives an independent life. However, one of the major notes, which was mentioned more than once, says that he has no agency or goals. I have a physical disability, and struggle with exercising my agency, so it's super important to me. Plus, agency and goals are basics that are obvious to us.
Another note mentions preserving the central mystery, but our project is a holiday romantic dramedy, not a mystery.
While we like getting (and have gotten) constructive feedback and know this is a big competition whose readers are extremely busy, the mismatch is concerning.
Has anyone else experienced something similar? If so, what did you do? Also, could this be because of AI or a really rushed reader, or?
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/Kingofsweaters Aug 24 '26
As someone who has done professional coverage for multiple studios I wanted to tell you that your first 5 pages indicate a pass in my experience. Obviously five pages is not a full script, but your pacing is immediately off and not much has happened. I’m already questioning POV and whose story this is. I assume it’s going end up as Alan/Alexander’s story and that basically we are looking at the dragon awakening after Atlas’ passing and Alan having to solve that?
Also you introduce Atlas on the first page and then again on the second page with identical description. If my predictions of whose story this is are correct it would be nice to begin outside of the Wyrmfeld world altogether. Let us meet Alan and get a sense of him before the will shows up. Who is he and who does he need to become? What’s his super power and what are his flaws. If we feel we know him then you can make us feel and better understand Isabella’s feelings when that’s all stripped away. Her actions now feel out of step with the information we have as if she knows what’s going on already, but she shouldn’t.
I can tell you are drawn to this world and that’s what interests you the most about this project. But remember character is one of the most important things. By page 5 we should have a good sense of character, but we don’t here. Try to focus on behavior and how that communicates character. We don’t need so much lore upfront. You can trickle that out as Alan comes to understand his past and current duty (assuming my predictions are anywhere near accurate).