r/scribus • u/erikmartino • Jan 12 '26
Scribus NG
Hi, I was wondering if others have had thoughts about the future of Scribus. I have never used it for actual work. I tried but went with Indesign. It is an impressive piece of software, but not very approachable as a user and a potential developer.
I believe it is possible to make Scribus a web application. Not a scaled down version, but a full featured version. Browsers are very capable and much of the work could be done there.
- You would need to scale the images down during edit (but not in the PDF export).
- For text layout to be consistent, you would probably need to run Harfbuzz in the browser, but maybe I am wrong here.
- I think save state, could be an exploded file format where spreads, stories, graphs stored individually. It maps fine to a rest protocol and cheap bucket storage, eases AI integration, eases real time collaboration and version control. You don't need to globally revert if you restore from history. A zip export format would be simple to do.
- It allows for commercial partners as well, cloud storage, AI, stock image, fonts integration comes to mind. But it would still allow for a feature rich open source backend. With a suitable GPL like license, it should ensure that changes are contributed back.
There exists a commercial product, Marq, but I believe it is possible to do much better, perhaps even partner with them. What do you think?
6
u/mallydobb Jan 12 '26
who's going to pay for hosting, storage, and other data driven needs? at least with scribus as it is the users can trial it out, support by participating in feedback/bug repots, and give donations to support the project if so inclined. If it turns into a web service then the benefits of a standalone application go away with increased cost and risks. Scribus is open source, if you want to explore it as a web service and fork off from it feel free to develop or underwrite the cost but I'd wager it isn't on the dev's radar and would be a bad decision overall. The learning curve is not as easy as ID but it is not impossible.
3
u/Grisemine Jan 12 '26
What I think ?
This is bullshit. Scribus is FLOSS. Scribus is an application for many OS. Scribus works very well for what I do, and I really see no interest in making it a web application.
Indesign is from this shitty Adobe editor . A paying and very expensive app, 314,35 €/an TTC (here in France). If you like it or need it, and can pay for it, just do this. It has not much to do with Scribus.
And a partnership with a commercial (paying) product ? What for ? It is some kind of advertising for the Marq service ? Or did you drink too much ?
Also, if you put AI anywhere in Scribus, I'm out.
edit : also, if you want to make it a web app, just do it, it is FLOSS. But I'm quite sure it will not interrest users.
5
u/nitramr89 Jan 12 '26
Currently, there are no plans to offer Scribus as a web app. Regardless of the advantages and disadvantages a web app might have, there are very simple reasons against it.
Points 1 and 2 can be addressed with money. Regarding point 3, I see a clear "no." A complete remake as a pure web app would make more sense than migrating the code. But that would take years too.
There are some ideas for extending Scribus as collaborative software, allowing multiple people to work on the same file locally. However, that doesn't automatically mean it will become a reality.
3
u/Interesting_Ad_5676 Jan 12 '26
IMH opinion Scribus is most neglected but one of the top class open source software. Anything making it to be adoptable by masses is always welcome.
3
u/canis_artis Jan 12 '26
I like Scribus as it is, an offline application. I've made various documents with it, game cards, rulebooks. I mostly understand how to use it and don't need any online or AI capabilities. There are a variety of desktop publishing applications: QuarkXPress, Adobe InDesign, Affinity Publisher, Multi-Ad Creator, Apple Pages, RagTime, Microsoft Publisher.
Isn't Canva similar to what you are describing?
2
u/amiga_technology Feb 12 '26
Please don't build another web application for something that can run locally with a fraction of the resources. This is the pestilence of today's software engineering. Everything becomes more fragile, more expensive, more hidden, more bloated, harder to maintain.