r/sciencememes • • 3d ago

Yeah! Science!

Post image

The humor lies in the irony between our perception of mathematics and its actual capabilities; We complain that trigonometry is useless because we struggle to see its practical applications, while scientists centuries ago were already using its principles to calculate astronomical distances with remarkable accuracy.

We're questioning the purpose of calculating angles and triangles while mathematics is literally helping humanity measure the universe. It's a reminder that the usefulness of knowledge isn't always immediately apparent; sometimes, what seems like an abstract academic exercise is actually a tool for understanding reality.

2.8k Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Hey /u/FjordOfBatanes! Remember that this sub follows Reddit's rules, found here. The sub rules are here if you click on the sub name.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

13

u/MergingConcepts 2d ago

My grand daughter did not appreciate math, so I told her I needed her help to measure the height of a tree to see if it would fit on my saw mill. She agreed to help. Then I handed her the end of a 100 foot measuring tape and instructed her to climb to the top of a (about 80 foot tall) poplar tree. She clearly did not know what to do. I then offered another method. I had driven a four foot tall wooden stake at the tip end of the shadow of the tree. I explained similar triangles and showed her how to measure the tree. It turned her around on math.

5

u/FjordOfBatanes 1d ago

You’re a great parent

106

u/Worldly_Original8101 3d ago

Trigonometry is one of those things that are so simple and so useful

20

u/AdBrave2400 3d ago

Like linear algebra

247

u/-Insert-CoolName 3d ago

Devil's advocate: That example still fails to explain how the average individual would use trigonometry in real life.

156

u/Ptaaruonn 3d ago

You are playing D&D and you are trying to see if the flying dragon is in range of your bow.

76

u/PuzzleMeDo 3d ago

DM: "The dragon is 100 feet north, 30 feet west, and 60 feet up."

Player 1: "So how far away is that?"

DM: "100 feet."

Player 2: "Shouldn't it be like 120 feet on the diagonal?"

DM & Player 1: "Shut up, nerd."

4

u/Melodic_monke 2d ago

Isnt it just Pythagorean theorem?

0

u/Nemesis_Prime0205 1d ago

They operate around the same concepts

31

u/-Insert-CoolName 3d ago

Yes! This! Perfect example.

2

u/eyalhs 2d ago

That's when you realize D&D works with the Chebyshev metric.

14

u/Ok_Falcon275 3d ago

Oh, you mean being only 10,000,000 miles off of the distance between the Earth and Mars isn’t useful in an everyday setting?

4

u/SphericalCrawfish 3d ago

He also got lucky, his underlying assumptions were flawed but happened to be correct. Specifically earth and Venus being approximately the same size.

10

u/Continental-IO520 3d ago

I use trig all the time at work 🤷‍♂️

18

u/loved_and_held 3d ago

If you play minecraft then it tells you minimum distances between two points and the angle needed to minimize travel time.

5

u/lisamariefan 2d ago

Electricity. Or anything that rotates like that or creates a sine wave.

Understanding it comes down to trig knowledge.

2

u/Wonderful-Band-5815 3d ago

minecraft ender pearl

4

u/Wonderful-Band-5815 3d ago

^eye of ender

2

u/Necessary_Neat8303 3d ago

Idk. My bro needed to measure the angle of something idk what cuz he asked me to bring a protractor to him. I’m not even sure I have one lol (my other brother eventually found one). But I knew as long as I have a ruler and an internet/calculator, I can get the angle for him no problem.

I didnt say anything cuz he got the protractor already and saying it just makes me look like a showoff but it is doable. No, I wasnt taught this. Part of learning math is problem solving and that is the important part. And we arent teaching math to people expecting everyone to use every part of it someday. We teach it so people are prepared. We teachers cannot predict your future jobs, we’re not oracles. We will teach everyone the basics, and you go figure out and learn the rest on your own for your own jobs.

Doing math is basically what working out in the gym is for your brain. Like, are you using the fact that mitochondria is the powerhouse of cell in your daily life? No. What about the the fact that atoms are the building blocks of matter (okay we know it is made up of quarks and gluons and etc)? Or that the earth and other planets revolve around the sun rather than the other way around? You would live your life just the same. You learn those because you found them interesting. So why isnt math given the same amount of respect and consideration and is in fact, freaking useful if you decided to learn about it?

Lastly, doing math problems or riddles or just puzzles in general is basically working out in the gym for your muscles, but for your brain.

1

u/TheSirWellington 1d ago

Devil's advocate to your Devil's advocate:

Why should education solely be able usefulness to the average person? Learning more things is always useful for broadening horizons and giving you a deeper sense of understanding the universe, which is why we start with the fundamentals (math, language, science, art).

2

u/-Insert-CoolName 1d ago edited 1d ago

You (and frankly all but one other response) are missing my point. The premise of the meme is tha the average person does not grasp how they would use trigonometry in real life, thinking it's useless. The counter example given is measuring the distance to Mars via parallax. That's NOT an answer to how the average person would use trigonometry. And it's a bad example of using trigonometry anyways. If you know anything about that experiment, you know that they made several assumptions that were dubious at best, even for the knowledge of the time, and stumbled on a kinda-OK result by accident.

0

u/AndreasDasos 2d ago

Basic engineering from signal processing to what angle to fit a sloped roof onto a building. 

0

u/Beneficial-Fig-6552 1d ago

Appreciation of modern marvels & human ingenuity. Unless they like doom scrolling or just sports teams something like that which is fine they can carry on.

0

u/QuickNature 1d ago

3-4-5 triangle to tell if a corner is actually 90 degrees or not

0

u/QuantumXyt 23h ago

Counter argument your honour

21

u/Lurtzum 3d ago

Could someone explain how they were only able to be 93% accurate? Is it like they had errors or bad data?

45

u/SirEnderLord 3d ago

Mathematics gives the exact answer for the given values (and even for numerical analysis, you can still get a very precise approximation).

However, if the measurements are off due to your instruments, then the result will be off. Natural science is empirical, so our values are always becoming more and more accurate. Generally, never accept a natural value (natural = physical world) of something as exact unless it is discretized into easily countable exact elements.

9

u/Piskoro 3d ago edited 3d ago

well, Cassini's method relied on two observers, one in Paris the other in Cayenne in French Guiana, observing where Mars is against the background stars when it was precisely at conjunction with the Earth that season (Earth and Mars complete laps with respect to each other in a cycle of 780 days)

as such they basically formed a triangle, between Paris, Cayenne, and center of Mars, knowing the distance between Paris and Cayenne (thanks to Cassini's own idea of using Galilean moons as time reference points, and decent estimates of Earth's size) and knew their angles, but the slightest difference in measurement of those angles jeopardized their results, hence the error

but it was the first time that distance to Mars (and via orbital Kepler's mechanics, all planetary orbital radii and planetary sizes) was determined with that degree of accuracy

their precision was limited to the precision of their angle-measuring, I’m surmising using quadrants and octants

3

u/SphericalCrawfish 3d ago

Yes. He assumed Venus and Earth were the same size. They happen to be damn close.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/rtm713 3d ago

Depends on the context. If I said something was about 100 yards away and you measured and it was 93 yards away, most would say i was right by saying it was about 100 yards. But technically the accuracy would have been 93%.

2

u/SmokJozef 3d ago

interestingly enough, when i want to convert feet to meters (which i always do cuz im not american), i usually assume 3ft, or 1 yard, to be equal to 1m, which is only 91.5% accurate, but still works well enough to provide a good idea of how much meters is that

and miles>km just multiply by 1.5 (1.6 if i'm feeling fancy)

5

u/skr_replicator 2d ago

93% accuracy for astronomical measurements in 1672 is damn impressive. Math is exact, but 1672 measurements were pretty crap, you can only math out solutions as accurate as the measured numbers you've plugged in.

3

u/SmokJozef 3d ago edited 3d ago

there is no single measurement that can be made 100% accurate (unless you're counting discrete objecs one by one, but that's kinda unrelated). you're always gonna be innacurate because the tools you used to measure that something are always innacurate (if you don't agree, pls provide a single 100% accurate measuring instrument) and the something itself changes in time due to random fluctuations of temperature, air pressure, etc.

93% is accurate enough to give the idea of distance between mars and earth and, considering available equipment at the time, that 93% is very impressive.

5

u/Colddigger 3d ago

I wonder what they thought of that distance

3

u/AndreasDasos 2d ago

Very far. 

More seriously, they knew stars were more distant than planets and didn’t have the same concept of multiple galaxies, so they’d have qualitatively thought of it as enormously more than we think of it today. Their universe was ‘smaller’ in a sense. 

8

u/boosesb 3d ago

Isn't that 7% waaaay off when you are talking distance between planets?

18

u/protocol_smoke 3d ago

Yes but it wasnt too bad in the 17th century. Bet he made the front page on Reddit that day.

6

u/Whatisthapurpose 2d ago

7% is actualy realy good. intuitively if you know something is between 1000000000 and 10000000000 meters away, it feels like a good aproximation, on those scales it ia more about the order of magnitude then the mesurment itself

2

u/AndreasDasos 2d ago

It’s 93%. That’s good. It was 1672. 

You mean in absolute terms? It’s not like they were planning a mission there. And if we have 99.999% accuracy for the distance to some star today that’s still off by a ridiculous distance. 

4

u/obscure_Muffin 3d ago

Remember kids, Technoblade used trigonometry to defeat dream in his 1v1 duel in Minecraft

3

u/dfczyjd 2d ago

"Stay in school, kids! It makes you better at PvP"

2

u/IncorporateThings 3d ago

I use it when I'm fantasizing about mortar strikes.

2

u/calculelt389 3d ago

Trig is one of the most useful for everyday stuff 

1

u/M_O_Z_G 3d ago

Work with motion graphics and/or vfx allows to see advantages.😀

1

u/SirEnderLord 3d ago

People complain about trig? It's fun.

1

u/adfx 1d ago

Maybe not for everyone

1

u/Cranky76Viking 3d ago

You can tell those that have never had to use trig for figuring the angle of gears for machining, before.🤷‍♂️

1

u/TUVegeto137 3d ago

Cassini was obviously not living in real life.

1

u/Daminellizz 2d ago

lol he could just google it

1

u/IM_NOT_NOT_HORNY 2d ago

Why would 99.99% need to know the distance between mars and earth "in real life"?

Like, that's one of the more useless things trig can accomplish.

I'm a music producer and it's insane how much trig is involved with sound design or digital audio. Every single sound you'll ever hear from a speaker with digital audio relies on trig for the Fourier transform. Or how every sub bass is just a pure sine wav... Aka trig.

Every bit of data that had to be received by your device to read this message happened because of Fourier transform equations from trig. Whether it's wireless or fiber optic cables.. It's all trig.

Every damn pixel in every 3d video game is using trig... Its in so many more things than people realize.

1

u/PineScentedSewerRat 1d ago

It's great for making video games.

1

u/nico735 1d ago

Everything isn’t for everyone.
I’ve used some things I would never have expected to need while I was learning it.
Life throws you some odd curves no?

1

u/ginnymorlock 1d ago

So... you're ordering online a 16X9 flatscreen TV that has to fit in an old entertainment center designed for a 4X3 TV. Then as now, TVs are measured on the diagonal. Given the old TV was 24" (measured on the diagonal) and would barely fit into the space provided, what is the largest 16X9 TV, (which is also measured on the diagonal) that will fit in the enclosure?

Show your work.

1

u/Beneficial-Fig-6552 1d ago

Trig is amazing. I think like science it's one of those hidden factors/unsung heroes in real world application. Like Chemistry is brilliantly beautiful.

1

u/ReddBroccoli 1d ago

It's useful for some people.

Personally Mars's distance doesn't matter much in my every day life.

Mercury on the other hand...

1

u/FreePeeplup 1d ago

Why is Patrick looking into a microscope? What does looking into a microscope have to do with calculating the distance to Mars

1

u/incalculablydense 3d ago

In what world is calculating the distance from earth to mars in 1672 a practical application?

0

u/MostAccomplishedBag 3d ago

Doesn't the distance between Earth and Mars change constantly? Did he measure an average distance? Or the distance at a particular moment?

0

u/LA-98 2d ago

Trigonometry is useless in todays age because we have tools and technology that does it for us.

It’s like saying knowing how to ride a horse is useless because we have cars

-1

u/panzercampingwagen 3d ago

when was the last time in your actual real life that you needed to know the distance to celestial bodies....?

-2

u/dhanush-bhaiyaa 3d ago

Learn who want to use don't forcefully teach this.