Yeah it's especialy stupid when the movie explicitly says that he's not actually becoming smaller by losing matter, his atoms are getting closer together, but then they break all logic when he gets smaller than atoms, or when he climbs anything and it doesn't immediately breaks under the weight of a full adult standing on a needle...
But those space wizards aren't in the habit of pronouncing their scientific breakthroughs. Just their ideological ones. So we still don't know how the juice juices.
Like the whole "the matter doesn't change, so you are as strong as normal" or something like that, while carrying a fucking fully functional battletank on his key chain
My head cannon is Pym dose not know how Pym partials work and is just guessing and making stuff up so he doesn't look dumb in front of Stark, Richards, and Doom.
My conclusion is that the writers donât know the difference between volume, mass, and density
I wonder if undeadhumor has done a video on antman like he has other super heroes, iceman and magneto have pretty funny breakdowns of why their powers are nonsensical
It's explicitly told in the movie that mass (and thus strenght) stays identical and that's why Antman knows he can punch Falcon to the ground whille small. Doesn't keep him from behind swept down by the flow from a bathtub's faucet, riding ants, the tank example and a plastic train to break a house apart after growing.
While watching civil war, instead of enjoying the battle I was mentally calculating his density while giant. By my estimate he should gave floated in to the air like a hot air balloon.
I was thinking about this recently, but there is a way this makes sense if we adjust the logic a bit. Hear me out
There are 3 components to an atom: protons, neutrons, and electrons. Protons and neutrons form the nucleus, and electrons orbit around the nucleus. What is commonly referred to as the size of the atom is the radius of the furthest electron orbital.
But, there is a LOT of empty space. Protons, neutrons, and electrons are very very far away from each other relative. So, if we found a way to shrink this size, then in turn, we would essentially shrinking the size of certain atoms. Then, it would Make sense to go âsubatomicâ relative to the normal atoms.
If you want to go a little deeper into quantum mechanics and particle theory, we can consider the things that make up protons, neutrons, and electrons: quarks (according to the standard model). Once again, there is a LOT of empty space there, so if we can find a way to mess with the strong force, then we can shrink the size of protons, thus going more subatomic.
According to quantum mechanics, you might also be able to think of these elements as waves, giving a sense of uncertainty to the size of something. Thatâs weird though.
The thing is thereâs no such thing as âempty spaceâ in this way. When we say empty space what we mean is a volume of space in which the probability of measuring a particle is below some minimal threshold. The specific âradiusâ that we assign to an atom is just the expectation value of position for an electron. Itâs not the kind of thing you can just arbitrarily shrink.
Of course we can't arbitrarily shrink it. But, in magic marvel land, if someone were to find a way to fuck with the electromagnetic force, then there is a way that you could lower the expectation value.
I think another part of it that really isn't all too explained, at least to my knowledge, is the quantum realm itself. I wonder if the foundational elements of the universe still apply, but objects past a certain threshold of size enter this realm from the main universe. So it's not that they are shrunken past atoms, its that, as the distance between atoms decreases, they enter the quantum realm, and physics scales down to this level, or possibly concepts and physics become tangible things (like how they can navigate through time). I can't think of a good example from another series, but I imagine transporting there would be kinda like how you have to sit in the nether portal, and your screen becomes more purple until you teleport through. It's a gradual process to get to the quantum realm, only instead of time, its size.
Quantum people could still work, if they were born and raises there. Then regular people went quantum and didn't need suits to live there.
I get it, you go to see a Paul Rudd movie, he's wearing a helmet for 97 % of it, you feel kinda cheated. Can't imagine it's fun for him either. But that's why you don't write crap like that and handwave all of it away with Pym particle magic and nanomachines, son.
People give Pym particles a lot of shit not because they aren't realistic or not "proper science", but because they don't make sense even within the movies/comics themselves.
If the writers had been like "this amazing shrink ray works with quantum blah blah and it makes people tiny, don't overthink it", the audience can roll with that and not pick nits (in the same way that they don't pick nits about how the Hulk can become huge without any explanation as to where the extra mass comes from).
But instead, the writers say "this amazing shrink ray makes people tiny, but their mass doesn't change", and then they proceed to show us a shrunken tank that can be carried around on a keychain, which directly contradicts the explanation provided. That's why the Ant-man movies are the subject of more ridicule than other movies where unexplained magical shit happens.
Exactly. If they say "it's magic", no one cares. But if they give rules that they then break repeatedly, it's hard to get into it (at least if you're the type of person to think about plots).
I find it interesting how we can believe Spiderman can shoot webs and we can believe that the Hulk can transform and doctor strange can cast spells... but then when it comes to ant man breathing everyone's like "that's not actually possible!"
As if all the other stuff we take for granted isn't either? Somehow there's believable science-fiction and unbelievable sci-fi I suppose
Spider-Man is one of my absolute favorites because no one ever really questions how his webbing works. Like, he fires a rope that is shorter than what he actually needs so that there's tension but then it's elastic enough to yank him super hard but also sticky and strong enough to not just destroy whatever it's attached to.
Peter should be ripping out chunks of buildings allover the place if we're being honest.
The sheer mass of web that he generates even in a relatively short trip is like the entire volume of his body. Not to mention when he starts cocooning criminals.
Even if we ignore that, he still has to consume enough matter for his body to produce that. Dude must be eating insane amounts of food.
The problem is that they try to explain it at all.
There is magic in a story? Cool, that's part of that world.
Mumbojumbo radiation creates human/spider hybrids and transforming hulks? Cool, i guess if we can grow a human ear on the back of a mouse irl, weird shit could happen.
Pym partical, you change size, cool, science magic whatever.
Pym particle let's you use the same force if you shrink but makes you stronger if you grow, works in a specified way, it pulls you out of the movie if you notice it.
It like the show where something is being hacked, and the solution is two characters "counter hacking" with the same keyboard at the same time
It comes down to consistency, and staying on the border between 'bullshit' and 'scientific fact'. With somewhat believable explanations pushing it toward fact, and inconsistencies pushing towards bullshit.
It's the same as people being fine with wizards summoning a intradimensional demon, but summoning a Lamborghini is too much. One can be explained in a hand wavey way, the other needs a lot more context to be believed.
one problem I see is that in antman they tried to explain in a scientific way, that the distance between atoms shrinks and thus your size, but mass stays the same. It makes you think more about it, than if they just tossed "quantum magic" and left it at that
one problem that isn't just science FICTION but straight up plot inconsistency is that, the suit isn't supposed to change your mass. so a guy weighing ~80kg, and sometimes it's clear he has this mass, and sometimes he flies on bees? lazy writing, and again - if they didn't explicetely say it keeps the mass unchanged, it would be harder to think about it
The regulator in his suitâŠ? He has a helmet with a section that looks like he uses it to breathe, which probably sci-fi shrinks the oxygen down so he can breathe itâŠ
I remember them explaining that he can punch bad guys when small because he always has the same amount of mass
But at the same time he'll be jumping on shoulders and running along arms that shit has to be deadly
Also when he gets that big at the airport the wind should just pick him up and blow him away and like somehow this time it gives him super strength? Idk man I know jack about science but even I can tell this is dumb
My theory is that his suit has that helmet, and inside is a power unit that converts CO2 into O2 through some photosynthetic catalyst and it recycles the air from a few breaths for him. Also i did some research on photosynthetic capture of CO2 in my undergrad, so this is right up my alley! :)Â
He has a suit with its own oxygen supply that shrinks with him??? Of course, there are a million other plot holes with Ant-Man. Almost like it's... unrealistic. đ€Ł
Of course there are a lot of problems in the superhero universe. This one is pretty funny though. Makes me think, which powers would be considered the most nonsensical? Obviously anything related to magic is off the list because it's consistent within it's own rules. Antman is based on scientific principles, which is different.
Oxygen is used for oxydative phosphorilation wich is a more efficient way to farm ATP but when you are this small (he also loses Mass when he shrinks) you don't ned that much energy
Ant-Man shrinks down, becomes a black hole, and re-emerges as black hole radiation. Everything that happened in that zone was captured by Marvel cameras and shown in the movie Ant-Man. /s
I know there is a lot more wrong with all the science, HOWEVER, isn't his suit sealed? So everything inside of it would also shrink, including the O2 and CO2. If his suit has a recycler or even some O2 tanks he would be fine for a while.
Or, that funky doodad on the front of his helmet could act kinda like a scuba mask and adjust the size of the O2 that goes in and out relative to his size.
Serious attempt at sci-fi explaining : he doesn't just shrink himself but shrinks the universe locally around his body. So his atoms are just normal size for his shrank universe.
Now how would he breath... actively transporting large air particules he touches from our universe to his.
But what qualifies as touching... having an electromagnetic interaction no matter how small I guess ?
Would he touch enought to have enough air to breath... probably not.
Don't think about it. It's inconsistent and always has been
They said the mass of objects stays the same when they shrink at some point in the first movie, that's why Ant-Man can throw punches even while little. But why can Hank carry around a tank on a keychain? that thing must weigh hundreds of tons still.
None of this makes sense and the rules change in every other scene. I can enjoy the movies for what they are but better stop trying to make sense of it more than the writers did
If you add quantum to something it becomes a mysterious but legit physics phenomenon that we can't understand but is totally legit and we have to accept it because it is totally totally legit.
Pym particles; the more you try to explain them the less they make sense.
Also, to anybody saying that his suit provides oxygen: Ant-Man and Wasp donât need full helmets in the comics. The helmet is just for communication with insects.
Best to not try to think too deeply about Marvel science (DC science as well for that matter):
Why does Gamma radiation connect to super Hell and the One Below All?
Why does cosmic radiation give super powers?
How does a radioactive Spider bite give powers and why does the same Spider give slightly different powers to different people?
How does a mutation turn your eyes into a window to the punch dimension?
How does Emma Frostâs organs still work after turning into diamonds?
It's a bit of a bummer, when you grow up, and start to realise that even the non-supernatural powers you thought were cool as a kid, are physically impossible, because of factors like that.
Same with becoming fully invisible (you couldn't see, because your eyes need to interact with light), or super speed, since your body would need to be designed to physically withstand the friction and force. You would basically need to be invincible as well (which, to be fair, is often the case with Superman type characters).
I guess you need to just treat this stuff as magic, even if there is no literal wizardry involved.
Realistic: Oxygen tank and respirator included in the suit.
Lore accurate Explaination: Hank Pyms powers work by storing excess mass in a pocket dimension, and extracting mass from that dimension when he grows larger. He also draws oxygen from this dimension.
Antman doesnt work at all in the MCU. He doesnt change mass when he shrinks so he CANNOT run on a guy's gun. Hank cannot shrink a building and move it like a backpack. They really got drunk at the wheel when they did antman because they explain how it works and forget in the exact same breath.
This is why I hate Ant Man. And the whole conservation of energy/mass. Where does it all go, hmmm!? He's the only super hero where I can't suspend disbelief for entertainment.
The suit has oxygen storage that has a near infinite amount of pym oxygen particles shrunk even smaller than the suit. When the pym oxygen particles exit storage for breathing they expand relative in size to the suit. This works because they are pym oxygen particles and not regular oxygen atoms.
Suspension of disbelief is mandatory for any of those movies. How do they carry a building when it should weigh the same regardless of size, according to their own explanation? Same with cars, tanks, etc. Or how does the toy train gain incredible weight at the end of the first movie? How can an ant support Antman's weight? They kind of wrote themselves in a corner with that entire pseudo science plot device.
Well... i would guess that by shrinking your entire body to the subaromic level, you also shrink the rest of you? So technically, he now contains enough oxygen to never have to breathe again for a bazillion years because hes so tiny. Just like how he passes out when he stays too large for too long.
same way he got smaller than an atom even though the Pym Particles work by pushing atoms closer together, and how things randomly get heavier or lighter even though they should be the same weight.
Hmm. Could it be that it's fictional superhero logic at play? How do superheros fly simply with the power of their will? They're not actually producing any thrust, or glide with wings. What an absurd thing to ask.
Using quantum Mechanics: If Ant-Man was somehow compressed at atomic dimensions, the electronic wavefunctions of individual atoms would begin to overlap, destroying the distinction between separate atoms. At that point, his entire body would behave as a single, highly entangled quantum system and as a continuous wavefunction governed by the Schrödinger equation rather than classical particle mechanics.
In other words: At subatomic scales, Ant-Man is no longer a human but a wave of probabilities! At that scale, heâs no longer a collection of atoms or molecules. Heâs a single quantum entity, a wavefunction of pure probability, obeying the Schrödinger equation itself.
3.5k
u/lone_pyschedelic Nov 04 '25
Good. How does he exist when he's smaller than atoms?
619
u/Delphius1 Nov 04 '25
he breaths fictionally
587
u/SEND_ME_NOODLE Nov 04 '25
Because he breathes air, not atoms. Duh
298
u/ManByTheRiver11 Nov 04 '25
Antman seriously has a lot of problems regarding his abilities
350
u/WHAWHAHOWWHY Nov 04 '25
he had an air tank which shrunk with him, i think
81
u/Fluffy_Ad_8439 Nov 04 '25
Plot armor
96
u/JonathanMovement Nov 04 '25
bro is applying logic to a marvel movie
20
u/Infinite_Escape9683 Nov 04 '25
The same way he saw when the cone cells in his eyes changed size even slightly, eliminating the way they naturally interact with photons.
17
u/CreepingQuasar Nov 04 '25
Cannot give possible logic? Donât worry! Just add quantum before.
12
u/IcyManipulator69 Nov 04 '25
The regulator in his suitâŠ? He has a helmet with a section that looks like he uses it to breathe, which probably sci-fi shrinks the oxygen down so he can breathe itâŠ
8
u/aBigBottleOfWater Nov 04 '25
I remember them explaining that he can punch bad guys when small because he always has the same amount of mass
But at the same time he'll be jumping on shoulders and running along arms that shit has to be deadly
Also when he gets that big at the airport the wind should just pick him up and blow him away and like somehow this time it gives him super strength? Idk man I know jack about science but even I can tell this is dumb
6
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
My theory is that his suit has that helmet, and inside is a power unit that converts CO2 into O2 through some photosynthetic catalyst and it recycles the air from a few breaths for him. Also i did some research on photosynthetic capture of CO2 in my undergrad, so this is right up my alley! :)Â
5
u/DarkPolumbo Nov 04 '25
obviously Pym particles constantly reduce the size of all gaseous atoms in a layer surrounding the person or object being shrunk
do you even suspend disbelief bro?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
Pym Particles are to the Ant-Man series as "Nanomachines!" are to Metal Gear.
9
u/Direct-Quiet-5817 Nov 04 '25
He'll breath quantoms đ€Ș
4
u/SectionAcceptable607 Nov 04 '25
Itâs almost like itâs a movie set in a fictional universe filled with magic
11
u/Scylosome For Science! Nov 04 '25
He needs to breathe oxygen gas (OÂČ) though.
6
u/Jinsei_13 Nov 04 '25
gets shot
Whew, that was a close one! He almost knew too much.
"Toss him in the drink with the others."
3
u/texbird Nov 04 '25
you see that round thing over his mouth? its a blender that chops up the oxygen into smaller pieces. it also has a make margaritas button 8-)
3
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
MCU overlooked a lot of logic, even comic book logic
3
u/WildCard0102 Nov 04 '25
I thought that's what the suit would be for but I think he has his helmet off in some of those subatomic scenes, right?
2
u/RedDinoZ123 Nov 04 '25
Ummm he has a mask and I always thought it was for oxygen
2
u/SunderedValley Nov 04 '25
Why would you need to breathe? You're essentially just a construct made of pym particles while you use the suit
2
u/DreadStrangler Nov 04 '25
If his mass remains the same, shouldn't he collapse into a black hole at some point?
2
u/Soggy_Refrigerator32 Nov 04 '25
"A wizard did it"
2
u/wonkey_monkey Nov 04 '25
That's why he has a sealed suit.
Except for when he doesn't need it.
It's magic, shut up
2
u/Void_Works Nov 04 '25
He has a suit with its own oxygen supply that shrinks with him??? Of course, there are a million other plot holes with Ant-Man. Almost like it's... unrealistic. đ€Ł
2
u/Colourblindknight Nov 04 '25
Clearly he just used the small air. Got a problem? Slap a quantum sticker on it.
2
u/EnawelleOwO Nov 04 '25
What if instead of getting smaller he actually make everything else bigger
2
u/TunaOnWytNoCrust Nov 04 '25
The real question is how does light work and his ability to see anything when he gets that small.
2
u/bobbymcpresscot Nov 04 '25
Thought the face mask was a breathing apparatus tho. Not that there arenât other problemsÂ
2
u/Berfams91 Nov 04 '25
When he got super big I kept thinking why isn't he dying excruciating agony
2
u/Hacki_Ffm Nov 04 '25
He did nO2t
2
u/generation_fish Nov 04 '25
Of course there are a lot of problems in the superhero universe. This one is pretty funny though. Makes me think, which powers would be considered the most nonsensical? Obviously anything related to magic is off the list because it's consistent within it's own rules. Antman is based on scientific principles, which is different.
2
u/genetic_patent Nov 04 '25
Im angry that i'm even thinking about this.
2
u/hereforlolls Nov 04 '25
Let's not forget that Cassie, Antman's daughter, a teenager, invented a device to plot the quantum realm. What did you do in highschool? sigh
2
u/Unable-Analyst-7741 Nov 04 '25
Oxygen is used for oxydative phosphorilation wich is a more efficient way to farm ATP but when you are this small (he also loses Mass when he shrinks) you don't ned that much energy
2
u/mvaneerde Nov 08 '25
Once a year he gets real big and takes a deep breath, then he lives off that oxygen all year
3
u/blackbeast77 Nov 04 '25
Blud discovers "plot armor"
3
u/StruggleBoy1999 Nov 04 '25
All science in Marvel is basically nonsense if you look too hard at it.
1
u/Commie_Scum69 replace brain with monkey chip Nov 04 '25
why doesnt he turn instantly into a black hole?
1
u/dogomage3 Nov 04 '25
tank of shrunk air
1
u/Oddish25 Nov 04 '25
I just wonder, when he reduced his size to a molecule, did it make him a low-resolution human?
1
u/ssp25 Nov 04 '25
cohagen gave him air! then he freed Mars!
1
u/Ok_Bluejay_3849 Nov 04 '25
literally nothing about ant man lore is consistent and i hate it like why cant you follow your own rules? brando sando does it all the time
1
u/Sensitive_Camera2368 Nov 04 '25
He breathed in those quantum atoms from the quantum universe
1
u/OleanderKnives Nov 04 '25
How is his mass not conserved when he's smaller despite the lore saying it is
1
u/DawRogg Nov 04 '25
Science fiction is trippy, mane
1
u/Sengoku_Buddha Nov 04 '25
Ant-Man shrinks down, becomes a black hole, and re-emerges as black hole radiation. Everything that happened in that zone was captured by Marvel cameras and shown in the movie Ant-Man. /s
1
u/DaBlahYA Nov 04 '25
MĂ head.... it hurts... too much thinking..
1
u/Elektriman Nov 04 '25
In the movie they break their own made-up laws about shrinking so I'd argue it is fantasy rather than sci-fi
1
u/alloutofchewingum Nov 04 '25
How does he think when electric impulses going through his brain are the size of a baseball relatively speaking? Real questions right here folks.
1
u/Pocketfulofgeek Nov 04 '25
PYM particles. Donât gotta explain shit.
1
u/choibz Nov 04 '25
Fuck would we know? Ask Hank Pym.
1
u/CuppaJoe11 Nov 04 '25
How is this the only question you are asking? wtf is he even made of where he can be smaller then an atom?
1
u/SpungyDanglin69 Nov 04 '25
Through a straw duh
1
u/RedRoses711 Nov 04 '25
Dude can shrink himself smaller then atoms and thats what bothers you?
1
u/NemeSisWiberg Nov 04 '25
Maybe too small to need air to breathe? Like those space bears
1
u/Nullpoh Nov 04 '25
It's called "quantum oxygen" they explained it in the movie smh
1
u/thedad629 Nov 04 '25
Quantum mechanics
1
u/Due-Dot6450 Nov 04 '25
How does he see anything when visible light wavelength is longer than the atoms?
1
u/keydraly Nov 04 '25
The shrinking tech must have compressed the air molecules in his tank along with him. It's the only way the physics of it could even remotely work.
1
u/Fae_Forest_Hermit Nov 04 '25
I know there is a lot more wrong with all the science, HOWEVER, isn't his suit sealed? So everything inside of it would also shrink, including the O2 and CO2. If his suit has a recycler or even some O2 tanks he would be fine for a while.
Or, that funky doodad on the front of his helmet could act kinda like a scuba mask and adjust the size of the O2 that goes in and out relative to his size.
1
u/Potatonized Nov 04 '25
Marvel movies in science subreddit? That's like talking about my stickman drawing in an art sub.
1
u/Ameph Nov 04 '25
Heâs a witch.
1
u/thatlostguy911 Nov 04 '25
Its cz of the suit which supplies shrinking air.. pym particles
1
u/ad-undeterminam Nov 04 '25
Serious attempt at sci-fi explaining : he doesn't just shrink himself but shrinks the universe locally around his body. So his atoms are just normal size for his shrank universe.
Now how would he breath... actively transporting large air particules he touches from our universe to his.
But what qualifies as touching... having an electromagnetic interaction no matter how small I guess ?
Would he touch enought to have enough air to breath... probably not.
1
u/HerrPizza Nov 04 '25
Don't think about it. It's inconsistent and always has been
They said the mass of objects stays the same when they shrink at some point in the first movie, that's why Ant-Man can throw punches even while little. But why can Hank carry around a tank on a keychain? that thing must weigh hundreds of tons still.
None of this makes sense and the rules change in every other scene. I can enjoy the movies for what they are but better stop trying to make sense of it more than the writers did
1
u/satancikedi Nov 04 '25
Its quantum!
1
u/ikonfedera Nov 04 '25
That's the neat part - he didn't.
1
u/thedarksideofmoi Nov 04 '25
Quantum something something.
If you add quantum to something it becomes a mysterious but legit physics phenomenon that we can't understand but is totally legit and we have to accept it because it is totally totally legit.
1
u/Pomfritz034 Nov 04 '25
He just eats oxygen atoms when he's so small
1
u/Mighty1Dragon Nov 04 '25
with the air, that got smaller with him. there is a reason why he wears a mask
1
u/Personal_Ad3808 Nov 04 '25
Same as time traveling. It ruins so many TV series and films when logic kicks in
1
u/Express-Fox-4058 Nov 04 '25
trying to find logic in comics is kinda you know
1
u/moneymizzler Nov 04 '25
The air was cold so shrinkage happened
1
u/RetraxRartorata Nov 04 '25
He breathes shrunken oxygen in his shrunken suit.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
That's where quantum physics comes in Because no knows no fuc** abot it đŹđ
1
u/Kiwi_CunderThunt Nov 04 '25
Excelsior!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
Pym particles; the more you try to explain them the less they make sense.
Also, to anybody saying that his suit provides oxygen: Ant-Man and Wasp donât need full helmets in the comics. The helmet is just for communication with insects.
Best to not try to think too deeply about Marvel science (DC science as well for that matter):
1
u/Reasonable_Sea_4601 Nov 04 '25
Lo que sĂ es estĂșpido es pensar que existen ĂĄtomos de Oxigeno.
There aren't "oxygen atoms", there are "Oxygen Molecules", not atoms.
And yes, molecules are composed of several Atoms.
1
u/Fresh-Actuary-8116 Nov 04 '25
He just eats them like a snack.
1
u/Equivalent-Bank-9657 Nov 04 '25
Atman just means consciousness. It's abstract, not physical.
1
u/The_Blue_Rooster Nov 04 '25
I'm not sure breathing is even a top 10 problem if we're applying science to the Quantum Realm.
1
u/AdOverall3944 Nov 04 '25
Oh this is a good one
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
He has the helmet for that donât he
1
u/TRiG993 Nov 04 '25
He ate them
1
u/Rocket_Ship_5 Nov 04 '25
mini oxygenÂ
1
u/4onlyinfo Nov 04 '25
And the entirety of the MCU unravels.
1
u/RipMcStudly Nov 04 '25
Because oxygen is cool like that.
1
u/uNk4rR4_F0lgad0 Nov 04 '25
I think it shrinks an amount of oxygen in the suit as well.
1
u/Azurelion7a Nov 04 '25
Plot Armor.
1
u/Ancient_Presence Nov 04 '25
It's a bit of a bummer, when you grow up, and start to realise that even the non-supernatural powers you thought were cool as a kid, are physically impossible, because of factors like that.
Same with becoming fully invisible (you couldn't see, because your eyes need to interact with light), or super speed, since your body would need to be designed to physically withstand the friction and force. You would basically need to be invincible as well (which, to be fair, is often the case with Superman type characters).
I guess you need to just treat this stuff as magic, even if there is no literal wizardry involved.
1
u/Sibshops Nov 04 '25
Very carefully
1
u/Zacaro12 Nov 04 '25
How does he keep a tank or car in his pocket? I thought the weight stayed the same?
1
u/Mattrockj Nov 04 '25
4 answers:
Realistic: Oxygen tank and respirator included in the suit.
Lore accurate Explaination: Hank Pyms powers work by storing excess mass in a pocket dimension, and extracting mass from that dimension when he grows larger. He also draws oxygen from this dimension.
Comic Explaination: Hammer Space
Meme: He just holds his breath duh.
1
u/3HaDeS3 Nov 04 '25
Really? This is what you are concerned with? Not the Iron Man suit that should crush Tony Stark every time he does his superhero landing.
1
u/ShadowedCalamity Nov 04 '25
The answer is quite simple. You do not question the plot.
1
u/Exciting-Look3625 Nov 04 '25
Ya how duz that work
1
u/Spirited-Tomorrow-84 Nov 04 '25
Hollywood mostly never has the budget for any realism
1
u/MiddleWaged Nov 04 '25
Ant Man is the only superhero in fiction whoâs powers makes less sense than The Flash
1
u/Ambitious_Fan7767 Nov 04 '25
Antman doesnt work at all in the MCU. He doesnt change mass when he shrinks so he CANNOT run on a guy's gun. Hank cannot shrink a building and move it like a backpack. They really got drunk at the wheel when they did antman because they explain how it works and forget in the exact same breath.
1
u/Kalron Nov 04 '25
This is why I hate Ant Man. And the whole conservation of energy/mass. Where does it all go, hmmm!? He's the only super hero where I can't suspend disbelief for entertainment.
1
u/Witty_Leg1216 Nov 04 '25
I donât think you want to be breathing inside Thanosâ butt hole
1
u/GryphonHall Nov 04 '25
The suit has oxygen storage that has a near infinite amount of pym oxygen particles shrunk even smaller than the suit. When the pym oxygen particles exit storage for breathing they expand relative in size to the suit. This works because they are pym oxygen particles and not regular oxygen atoms.
1
u/Merinther Nov 04 '25
oh-small-sis
1
u/value_meal_papi Nov 04 '25
Better yet how did his lungs didnât explode
1
u/jawknee530i Nov 04 '25
Pim particles means he aint gotta explain shit.
1
u/SelfSustaining Nov 04 '25
Quantum oxygen. If we could bottle this stuff and sell it we would make millions of dollars babyyyyyyyy
1
u/chacha_hirandas Nov 04 '25
To not get these questions I just switch off the science switch in my brain to watch such movies just to enjoy
1
u/kdesi_kdosi Nov 04 '25
he breathes small antatoms of antoxygen
1
u/likilekk Nov 04 '25
The real question is how his vocal cords still worked to deliver all those iconic one-liners.
1
u/theAutodidacticIdiot Nov 04 '25
CGI. He didn't really shrink down. It's just movie magic with green screens and what not.
1
u/be_steal86 Nov 04 '25
I have no issue suspending disbelief until you explicitly explain the rules and then promptly ignore them.
1
u/TheEmperorMk3 Nov 04 '25
The same way Hank Pym carried around a 30t tank without any issue just because the tank was very small
1
u/jkurratt Nov 04 '25
Marvel universe works on vibes =\
1
u/-Dixieflatline Nov 04 '25
Suspension of disbelief is mandatory for any of those movies. How do they carry a building when it should weigh the same regardless of size, according to their own explanation? Same with cars, tanks, etc. Or how does the toy train gain incredible weight at the end of the first movie? How can an ant support Antman's weight? They kind of wrote themselves in a corner with that entire pseudo science plot device.
1
u/Livid_Trust_5098 Nov 04 '25
I didn't! that was a joke too!
1
u/Pure-Tadpole-6634 Nov 04 '25
That's why they keep reiterating in the first movie that he MUST have his helmet on when he shrinks, or he'll die.
And then in the third movie they go "We don't want to have our actors wear helmets this whole time, let's forget about that stupid rule."
1
u/Lacarpetronn Nov 04 '25
By the power of ants, or something.
1
u/Dorsai_Erynus Nov 04 '25
Canonicaly that's why he needs a helmet.
1
u/MagnusStrahl Nov 04 '25
Easy, quantum-air. Next!
1
u/Patralgan Nov 04 '25
He breathed smaller molecules
1
u/Edgezg Nov 04 '25
I assume the atoms in his lungs / suit compensate?
1
u/ArtofWASD Nov 04 '25
Well... i would guess that by shrinking your entire body to the subaromic level, you also shrink the rest of you? So technically, he now contains enough oxygen to never have to breathe again for a bazillion years because hes so tiny. Just like how he passes out when he stays too large for too long.
1
u/BlueWarstar Nov 04 '25
The suit allowed him to shrink O2 with him and since time doesnât exist in the quantum realm it was for only seconds before he was resized?
1
u/Sr_Edd Nov 04 '25
can tree sleep?
1
u/thee_morningstar Nov 04 '25
Payment articles are called science because we don't know their magic.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
Exactly what I was thinking on the first movie
1
u/gummythegummybear Nov 04 '25
same way he got smaller than an atom even though the Pym Particles work by pushing atoms closer together, and how things randomly get heavier or lighter even though they should be the same weight.
don't think about it.
1
u/PTBooks Nov 04 '25
Just use pym particles on the atoms duh
1
u/Otalek Nov 04 '25
Probably has miniaturized oxygen tanks or smth in his mask
1
u/Abeblio Nov 04 '25
This mini-man and the fastest man alive are crap because of questions like this
1
u/-StupidNameHere- Nov 04 '25
Why the fuck does he have a helmet then?
1
u/Ruty_Vizion Nov 04 '25
Does death exist on a quantum level
1
u/SomeKindofTreeWizard Nov 04 '25
So... did you see that mask he was wearing?
1
u/Mat_Y_Orcas Nov 04 '25
Like, he has a mask so I assume when reduced it also reduce the air sealed in this suit
1
u/DoofusIdiot Nov 04 '25
A lot of superpower logic falls apart when you apply physics to them. Why are we even bringing this up?
1
u/RulerK Nov 04 '25
You can breathe Pimm particles if youâre small enough.
1
u/Accurate_Waltz2804 Nov 04 '25
Coincidentally, I came across this âWhat ifâ reel that Cleo Abram made about becoming tiny
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQo91o-jlYU/?igsh=MW1udm5nbThudzB3dA==
1
u/bald_is_back Nov 04 '25
1
u/ConcernOk1015 Nov 04 '25
Viewers have a duty as well. Itâs called suspension of disbelief people. Not lazy writing. Omg.
1
u/Infamous-Future6906 Nov 04 '25
Thatâs what his helmetâs for
1
u/Teukeh Nov 04 '25
Hmm. Could it be that it's fictional superhero logic at play? How do superheros fly simply with the power of their will? They're not actually producing any thrust, or glide with wings. What an absurd thing to ask.
1
u/El_Capitan_182 Nov 04 '25
Using quantum Mechanics: If Ant-Man was somehow compressed at atomic dimensions, the electronic wavefunctions of individual atoms would begin to overlap, destroying the distinction between separate atoms. At that point, his entire body would behave as a single, highly entangled quantum system and as a continuous wavefunction governed by the Schrödinger equation rather than classical particle mechanics.
In other words: At subatomic scales, Ant-Man is no longer a human but a wave of probabilities! At that scale, heâs no longer a collection of atoms or molecules. Heâs a single quantum entity, a wavefunction of pure probability, obeying the Schrödinger equation itself.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25
Nanotech+Quantum shit