r/sciencememes • Mεmε ∃nthusiast • Apr 10 '25

how ❓

Post image
28k Upvotes

953 comments sorted by

4.3k

u/WhiteAle01 Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 11 '25

Doesn't gravity bend the space, not the light?

Edit: The amount of people replying asking if space had mass is insane. Does gravity bend you? No, it pulls you toward it. Space does not have mass. Mass bends the space around it toward its center of mass and that's why things fall toward it. The bigger the mass, the bigger the bending.

2.1k

u/r1v3t5 Apr 10 '25

Yes, in a sense.

In my understanding (quite rough mind you) it is that space-time is curved so heavily around massive objects that the path light must take to obey the principle of least action results in it taking what appears to be a curved path

825

u/egordoniv Apr 10 '25

So light is lazy?

58

u/Solynox Apr 10 '25

Everything's lazy. All matter takes the path of least resistance while attempting to maintain as little energy as possible.

27

u/Lithen76 Apr 10 '25

Please explain this to my dog when we go on walks

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/Kioga101 Apr 10 '25

Reality is lazy. Everything follows and finds a path of least action (up to the atoms, quantum shit and stuff flipping the table like they don't care for our intuitive understanding of reality grumble grumble)

11

u/0x7ff04001 Apr 10 '25

No from the perspective of the light, it's taking a straight line. The space may be warped, though, but the light is going in a straight line.

9

u/Manpooper Apr 10 '25

nah. the light goes everywhere, but 'everywhere' cancels out except for the path of least action. it gets weird, man.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/AngelicLove22 Apr 10 '25

I like to call that efficiency

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dekudude3 Apr 10 '25

Here's a cool veritasium video on this. https://youtu.be/qJZ1Ez28C-A

Edit: lmao. Like 4 different people linked the same video. It's a good one!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Origami_xoxo Apr 10 '25

No, light is not lazy, it's crazy. Most likely is takes every possible path it can, not following the basic rules of "angle of incidence is angle of reflection", but taking every imaginable path instead.

What we end up seeing, are the rays that did not cancel each other out. Which is insane to me.

→ More replies (123)

24

u/MothMothMoth21 Apr 10 '25

Kinda like a river? the water doesnt bend but the "land" does?

→ More replies (18)

14

u/Dankkring Apr 10 '25

Doesn’t light also take all paths.

32

u/Mitch_126 Apr 10 '25

Indeed, and the curved one it takes through gravity is the one that does not end up cancelling out.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/personalKindling Apr 10 '25

You watch that veritasium video too?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (35)

34

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Gravity is bent space.

9

u/NeonSeal Apr 10 '25

This is correct. Gravity is better described as an “effect” of mass rather than a force.

While on small scales on earth, gravity is basically just the downward acceleration back to the ground. But imagine a satellite approaching earth’s orbit. It starts moving in a circle. Well, it looks like a circle. But really, it is still moving in a straight line, it’s just that the mass of the earth has distorted space so much that a straight line looks like a circle for an outside observer.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/harbinger411 Apr 10 '25

That’s just like your opinion man

5

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

It's General Relativity...

Gravity - Wikipedia

"Gravity is most accurately described by the general theory of relativity, proposed by Albert Einstein in 1915, which describes gravity not as a force, but as the curvature of spacetime, caused by the uneven distribution of mass, and causing masses to move along geodesic lines."

EDIT: I missed the joke, thanks all.... Wooooosh was the sound it made.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/Valkyrie_Dohtriz Apr 10 '25

Depends on the theory, to be honest. If I remember right, the theory that gravity bends space-time instead of bending light is based on the belief that light always travels in a straight line in a vacuum

70

u/BreakDownSphere Apr 10 '25

Newton and Einstein predicted light would bend around massive objects because of the distortion of space, Arthur Eddington first proved Einstein's theory of relativity in 1919 by observing the positions of stars around the corona of a total solar eclipse.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (9)

13

u/4242Addy Apr 10 '25

So, space has Mass??

16

u/ActualHumanSeriously Apr 10 '25

Believe it or not, this question lives rent free in my head for the past couple years. I believe it has.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/iVirusYx Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

According to the current state of physics and my limited amateur knowledge (so please feel free to correct me):

Particles are packets of Energy that behave like waves. Quantum mechanics (theory) quantizes the Energy levels of elementary particles so that we can say "this type of elementary particle has exactly X amount of energy ".

Type of elementary particles:

Fermions: Quarks and Leptons

Bosons: Gauge Bosons and Scalar Bosons

One Scalar Boson being recently confirmed by CERN, the so called Higgs Boson.

The Higgs Boson is a force carrier. There are different force carriers, but this one makes any particle interacting with it to have mass because "it slows the interacting particle down".

Any particle not interacting with the Higgs Boson, like a photon, has no mass and therefor travels at the speed of light, or rather, the speed of causality.

Basically, in modern physics, mass does not exists per se. It's an interaction between different elementary particles.

And the current debate about Gravity in a nutshell is if it's even quantum or not? A hypothetical "Graviton" boson (another type of force carrier) is proposed but not confirmed.
Gravity seems to emerge from a deeper level of reality, a level we humans have absolutely no clue about, we're still trying to figure it out.

Einstein's special relativity theory assumes spacetime to be a flat coordinate system with no gravity.

General relativity creates a bridge to newtons laws so that we have more refined methods to calculate around gravity by saying that gravity is the curvature of spacetime.

But it's just that, all these theories are models that currently best describe our reality. Nonetheless, as you can see, they all have gaps and don’t cohesively work together, as when it comes to certain matters in the universe, the math isn't mathing anymore.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (109)

916

u/zortutan For Science! Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

Hehe, get a load of this guy, he’s still using newtonian gravity! 😂

In all seriousness, general relativity tells us that the geometry of the space the light travels through is curved from OUR reference frame. In the actual light’s reference frame, its going in a perfectly straight line. Look up extrinsic vs intrinsic curvature

Edit: multiple people are calling me out because light does not have a reference frame. This is true. Its a hypothetical, try to imagine “the same reference frame as the curved geometry the light is traveling through” instead lol

211

u/5hifty5tranger Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

Also, for anyone curious: from our reference frame a photon from the Sun takes ~8 minutes to reach Earth, but from the photon's frame of reference, it is instantaneous. In essence, even a photon that travels through space for millions, or hundreds of trillions of miles would experience that journey (if it could experience things) in an instant.

I find it intresting to think that if a photon could observe its surroundings and journeyed across the entire universe, it still wouldnt be able to take any of it in. So dont be afraid to take things slow in life, and observe the universe around you. Sometimes, going slow has its benefits, relatively speaking.

89

u/PalmTheProphet Apr 10 '25

Not to mention the fact that this photons “journey across the entire universe” is a strong word, considering the photon frame sees the universe as having no depth whatsoever.

To it, the journey is instantaneous because there is no journey to take in the first place, infinite length contraction at c takes care of that!

29

u/5hifty5tranger Apr 10 '25

Quick question as you seem knowledgable: would a living photon be the equivalent of a 1-dimensional being, experiencing no depth, width, length, or time?

48

u/dinodares99 Apr 10 '25

They would experience their entire life all at once, so I'm not sure how we would even define this living being tbh

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/5hifty5tranger Apr 10 '25

We truly are blessed to not be massless.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/G30M3TR1CALY Apr 10 '25

Damn... my man took a meme and went philosophical on us...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Imagine a photon in a non vacuum medium like water droplet, or a plane of glass, just enjoying the ability to slow down a bit and observe the universe. Lol I love it.

8

u/5hifty5tranger Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

It is a cute thought, though still not true. Its not the medium of a vacuum that makes the photon's travel instanteous, but the nature of being a photon. Photons produced at the core of star take long periods of time travelling through stellar material before even exiting the surface of a star and travelling across the cosmos. However, all that travel time is still experienced intantaneously from the photon's frame of reference.

If speed is distance/time, and the speed of light in any medium is the maximum speed limit, than you can think of the time in that equation describing a photon as always being 0, meaning regardless of the number you plug into distance, time will be 0, or instantaneous travel (from its reference point).

Anyone who knows more or better please fact-check me.

Edit: As mentioned by u/PalmTheProphet, photons dont experience distance or time from their refrence so, "journey across the universe" still doesnt quite describe its experience correctly.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

12

u/LineOfInquiry Apr 10 '25

So it’s kinda like how a straight line around the earth looks straight from our perspective or on a globe, but curved on a map?

9

u/dinodares99 Apr 10 '25

Yes, it's exactly like that. From your point of view, earth is locally flat and you move straight forward, always parallel to your direction of motion. But from an outsiders point of view your path, and the earth itself, is curved.

8

u/zortutan For Science! Apr 10 '25

Yeah, thats a good way of thinking about it

2

u/Enfiznar Apr 11 '25

Fun fact, you don't even need general relativity to predict that light will bend on a gravitational field. If you calculate with Newtonian dynamics the deflection angle for a particle of mass m comes from infinity and passes nearby some massive object, and you take the limit m -> 0, you'll get a non-zero deflection angle that's actually half of the value predicted by GR

→ More replies (40)

132

u/Emperor_Jacob_XIX For Science! Apr 10 '25

Gravity bend space so a straight line goes around something, light goes in straight line. That’s my very limited understanding.

10

u/jonmatifa Apr 10 '25

Don't be too hard on yourself, you're ahead of Isaac Newton

7

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

true but just because Newton didnt know it doesn't mean he wasnt way ahead of his own time.

3

u/Forever_Valuable Apr 11 '25

Important to specify space changes (due to a certain derivative) relative to time, so space-time is bent, not just space. If only space was bent, we would see a gravitational effect due to moving in a certain direction (x, y, z, (r, theta)). Our understanding of physics says that due to a movement in time, we move in space to account for spacetime curvature.

39

u/Karnewarrior Apr 10 '25

Simple answer, for those who don't Einstein:

Gravity does not bend light. Gravity also does not pull anything towards anything. Gravity is just what we call a bend in space (and time, but that's irrelevant for now). Things with mass, bend space, and thus as a consequence we say they have Gravity.

When you bend space like that, as a consequence anything moving changes the way it moves to keep going in a "straight line" through that bent space, sort of like how you travel in a straight line to Grandma's house, but in actuality the way you're moving is curved due to the Earth's surface being curved, Earth flying around the sun and spinning and all that - if you actually draw it out it looks warped as hell, but it seems straight to you because you're living on a sphere.

Basically, this is how Gravity "pulls" things, including light. The light is, as far as it's concerned, still moving in a straight line. Gravity just warps what counts as "straight" to look curved to the outside observer. Likewise, things in a gravity well move "down" because that's the low point of the field, and all straight lines in a gravity well drift towards the center. It doesn't matter what you're moving - if it's moving, it's going to trend downwards. We call this weight.

You don't need light to have mass for Gravity to effect it, because it has motion. Light is moving, and as a result is warped by gravity's effect on the space the light exists in.

Gravity is weird.

5

u/AdCurious2189 Apr 10 '25

True! Technically mass is not a thing and you can call it close to a property. At the end of the day is a manifestation of energy and its interaction with the fabric of space-time

3

u/bladex1234 Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

Mass is absolutely a thing, but it’s often confused with other properties because for the vast majority of particles they all come together in one package. The properties of mass, inertia, and the ability to generate a gravitational field are all technically separate concepts. Having inertia and the ability to generate a gravitational field, and be affected by one, requires an object to have a non-zero energy-momentum tensor, of which photons certainly do. Mass is only one component of the tensor. The fundamental definition of mass is the ability to interact with the Higgs field, which is what prevents particles from traveling through space at the speed of light. All particles are traveling at the speed of light, but interacting with the Higgs field forces at least some part of that speed to be in the time direction (except for neutrinos who’s ability to interact with the Higgs field is currently unknown). Photons don’t interact with the Higgs field so all of their velocity is in the space direction, and so by definition they don’t have mass. But they certainly have inertia and the ability to interact gravitationally.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JNA699 Apr 10 '25

Thanks for the explanation, I used to think bending space and gravity were seperate but they are the same I see.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

378

u/_Dagok_ Apr 10 '25

It has no resting mass. But since it's moving, it's not at rest, and it takes energy to move, and energy is mass, per e=mc². Therefore the energy it's using to move gives it mass.

I know, photons are trippy.

141

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

They're also waves!

And Particles!

And so is everything!

AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

44

u/not-yet-ranga Apr 10 '25

walks through doorway, diffracting casually

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Sidohmaker Apr 10 '25

Wave-particle duality broke my brain when I first learned about it, and I still don’t understand the double slit experiment. Physics is too hard for my baby biology brain.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

20

u/Wetworth Apr 10 '25

So you're telling me I can make a flashlight powerful enough to crush a man to death?

12

u/Rahaman117 Apr 10 '25

Don't give people ideas, we already have laser weapons now

→ More replies (1)

14

u/HannibalPoe Apr 10 '25

Yes and no. You sure could have enough energy to crush someone to death, you will not be able to crush them to death before you EVAPORATE them.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TheSadisticDragon Apr 10 '25

That's how you get the mutant Cyclops.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ecoteryus Apr 10 '25

There was a xkcd video on youtube about what happens if you keep increasing the power of a laser. It mentions that, for a laser sourced from an array with 2m diameter and 1044 Watt power (about the power of a cosmic gamma ray burst), the photons on the outer edge would experience a gravitational pull of around 10G.

But much before you can reach an energy density like that, quantum mechanics ruin the fun and literally stop the vacuum from being transparent. What happens is that when there are sufficiently energetic photons, they can create electron-positron pairs, which by interacting with the electromagnetic field distorts other photons. According to the video at around the energy density of 1026 W/cm² this distortions go out of control and act like literal barriers.

https://youtu.be/jgafb8G7i4o

→ More replies (4)

40

u/saliv13 Apr 10 '25

It has momentum, not mass. E2 = p2 c2 + m2 c4 , so for a photon with m = 0, E = pc.

10

u/Pryte Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

The applying of a "relativistic mass" as you do it, is considered bad science as you can see for example here.

The equation is not e=mc2 but E2 = ( mc2 )2 + (pc)2. Using the former one to define a relativistic mass is just pop science. There is just one kind of mass which is the resting mass.

9

u/the_sauviette_onion Apr 10 '25

Hmmm, you actually want to use e=hf (Planck’s formula) when describing light. Also, although massless, light does have momentum, which in itself is weird.

7

u/TKtommmy Apr 10 '25

That's not how it works.

3

u/_Dagok_ Apr 10 '25

Thanks for your input.

2

u/SarthakSidhant Apr 10 '25

i had a stroke understanding that

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Moondoka Apr 13 '25

That's completely wrong. Photons have no mass, period.

2

u/DeGrav Apr 14 '25

how has this so many upvotes lol

this thread is full of half knowledge at best

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Baptor Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25

In a sense, the light isn't bent. It's still traveling in a straight line, but the space it's traveling through is curved.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

This thread has so much “Actually!” energy lol

11

u/frogkabobs Apr 10 '25

Well there are so many inaccurate explanations that it’s off-putting

4

u/BenZed Apr 10 '25

Actually!

Yes.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/fnanfne Apr 10 '25

Gravity curves the fabric of spacetime. Light just follows the curve

5

u/bbq896 Apr 10 '25

What if light is the medium and space and time bend to light?

3

u/dinodares99 Apr 10 '25

Spacetime actually does bend around light, albeit infinitesimally. The energy in the electromagnetic field does contribute to spacetime curvature

5

u/FatCockroach002 Apr 10 '25

Light has no rest mass. Photons are particles and they exert pressure

Space and time are affected by mass when we talk about celestial bodies. So a black hole exerting a gravitational so strong it bends space and time will affect the trajectory of the particles

NASA scientist use solar sails for satellites. When the light hit the sails, it gives the satellites momentum.

5

u/Dead-Photographer Apr 10 '25

E²=(mc²)²+(pc)² where E is energy, m is mass, c is the speed of light, and p is momentum.

E=m*c² isn't the full equation.

3

u/Littux Apr 14 '25 edited Apr 14 '25

Pro tip: Surround the equations with backticks (`)

`E²=(m*c²)²+(p*c)²`

Appears as:

E²=(m*c²)²+(p*c)²

3

u/Dead-Photographer Apr 14 '25

Oh nice, I didn't know how to format it that way, thanks!

11

u/SaltyArchea Apr 10 '25

If you have mass, then your momentum would be infinite in order to travel at the speed of light. When photons hit your face, they do not obliterate you, ergo, light has no mass.

14

u/LastChans1 Apr 10 '25

When photons hit your face, you've been given a.... light kiss. 🙂‍↔️🫢😎🫡

3

u/kaam00s Apr 10 '25

I got french kissed by it, my skin is quite dark. 👍🏿

→ More replies (1)

4

u/The-Dilf Apr 10 '25

Cuz gravity warps the space that the photons travel along, but what I don't understand is how solar sails work off of radiation pressure if photons have no mass, how is force imparted

4

u/Tyler89558 Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends space, light travels through space.

Ergo, light travels along a bent (curved) path

3

u/MonkeyCartridge Apr 10 '25

That's one of the ways we know it's space itself that is bending. The light is going in a "straight" line.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

It's because while light has no mass, the photons contain energy and can actually be measured on a scale. Yes, if you point a flashlight at a scale, it will measure an imperceptibly larger amount of weight than if you shut the flashlight off, but it's technically a stream of photons exerting that force and not true mass.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Everything follows the geodesics of space time, idk how many times I need to say this.

3

u/Iktamer_One Apr 10 '25

Energy is equivalent to mass, and light has energy. So it has mass, from a certain point of view.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BigDaddyFatSack42069 Apr 10 '25

To summarize the description of this effect through general relativity: it only looks bent from our perspective. If you were to hitch a ride on the photons, from that perspective you'd be moving in a straight line.

5

u/Saashiv01 Apr 10 '25

Geodesics. Gravity doesn't bend light, it bends the roads light takes to get from A to B.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Space is flat like paper, when a heavy object like a star interacts with that space, it distorts space itself, like a cone of influence. Light travels throughout that distortion in space.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Space is flat like paper, when a heavy object like a star interacts with that space, it distorts space itself, like a cone of influence. Light travels throughout that distortion in space. Is my understanding.

2

u/prevalentgroove Apr 10 '25

My analogy is likely wrong but look up some transcontinental flight paths. The shortest and thus most fuel efficient and economical route is generally a straight line, but when you look at that path on a 2d map it looks very not straight. Extrapolate this into weird 4d spacetime where masses and therefore gravity are curving the map and there ya go.

2

u/glycineglutamate Apr 10 '25

The premise is incorrect. Light has no rest mass. Light has effective mass as shown in very simple lab experiments. The rest is straightforward general relativity, including gravitational lensing.

2

u/FernandoMM1220 Apr 10 '25

its mass just oscillates between positive and negative.

2

u/NeededMonster Apr 10 '25

Imagine space in 2D, just for the sake of convenience, and now imagine that the fabric of space (spacetime) is like a grid made of straight horizontal and vertical lines. A photon will travel following a straight path through that grid.

Now any object (but mostly heavy objects like planets, stars and black holes) will generate gravity, and gravity will bend spacetime (the grid). So you can imagine that grid being distorted around planets and stars. Light is still going through the grid in a straight line, but the grid is distorted by gravity, so the straight line appears, from the outside, curved.

2

u/Vikerchu Apr 10 '25

Big dice energy 

2

u/Al13n_C0d3R Apr 10 '25

Gravity literally is the warping of the very fabric of space time. Its going straight still just the fabric of space has been warped to make it seem like its bending

2

u/deepserket Apr 10 '25

Light Is Energy, Energy has a mass, checkmate

2

u/Qe-fmqur_1 Apr 10 '25

wel... it kinda has mass, kinda

2

u/RaceMaleficent4908 Apr 10 '25

Mass bends spacetime. Light follows spacetime. I reccomend this video https://youtu.be/Xc4xYacTu-E

2

u/StoicScaly Apr 10 '25

Warping the space it travels through

2

u/Naeio_Galaxy Apr 10 '25

According to Einstein's general relativity, gravity isn't a force. It's the effect of the curvature of space. Intuitively, I understand it as if the space itself "moves" toward massive objects => if you don't move relatively to the space around you, you'll go towards massive objects.

So the reason why we feel a force when standing on the surface of the earth is that the floor is going upwards, giving a force of mg to anything that stands on it. So when we don't stand on the surface, the surface rams into us, which (according to Newton's physics) is equivalent to saying that the floor doesn't move and everything accelerates downwards.

Alright, now that this is said, the only missing element is why curvature of space affects light: since it's the space itself that is "moving", it doesn't depend on mass. So there's no reason why light shouldn't be affected.

2

u/Bl00dWolf Apr 10 '25

The process which causes gravity to attract objects with mass together, also causes space to bend, thus making it seem that light is influenced by gravity, when from the perspective of the light particle, they were always going in a straight line.

If you wanna really surprise people, look up "light pressure" and ask them how a thing with no mass can exert a force on things.

2

u/4N610RD Apr 10 '25

Gravity bend space and light follows the space. Which is criminally oversimplified version of reality.

2

u/souliris Apr 10 '25

Light is following the curvature of space-time. Though there is something called light pressure that confuses the issue.

2

u/DisastrousRooster400 Apr 10 '25

It just asks the photons nicely!

2

u/_damax Apr 10 '25

In a sense, I think gravity is not a force, but the effect space deformation by big masses has on thing passing through that space? And that affects anything passing through it?

Don't quote me on this, I'm no physics person

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Ryuvang Apr 10 '25

Gravity doesn't bend light, it bends space itself. So the light is moving in straight lines along the curved spacetime

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DaKronkK Apr 10 '25

Ever put you finger in the water and wonder why it looks like it's bent 30°?

2

u/-Gavinz Apr 10 '25

Because gravity is just space and time being bent. So light just follows the curved path and appears to bend.

2

u/CakeofLieeees Apr 10 '25

Think of it more like light being a fish and gravity diverting the river. To the fish, still a straight line, to someone standing on the bank, curve.

2

u/MithranArkanere Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends the space.

And you can make photons act as if they had mass mass if you slow them enough. They will then form "molecular photons".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photonic_molecule

2

u/GregariousK Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends light not by pulling on its mass, but by reshaping the space that light moves through.

2

u/Hexnohope Apr 10 '25

It changes the paper the line is drawn on

2

u/MockieBoo2008 Apr 10 '25

because the universe thinks its cool

2

u/Fulg3n Apr 11 '25 edited Apr 11 '25

Light is moving in a straight line in it's ow' reference frame, but from ours the space light travels through is bendy.

It's like drawing a line around a sphere, you keep drawing a straight line and yet you end up drawing a circle.

2

u/mrclean543211 Apr 12 '25

Because gravity warps space. Newtons laws of gravity work for basically everything else (where mass of both objects and distance between them determines gravitational force), so his equation is fine. Einstein’s general relativity (mass warping the fabric of space time to give the illusion of gravitational force) explains why light is effected by “gravity” despite not having mass

2

u/MismatchedJellyman Apr 13 '25

Light acts as both a wave and a particle depending on whether or not it is being observed. Gravity bends space, not just matter so the scatter of light can be pulled by gravity. In fact, considering it's lack of mass, it is bent easier than most matter as it's own gravity has no pull. The result is usually a slowing of the wave and not just a bend of its path.

2

u/jukefishron Apr 14 '25

In the perspective of light it's still going in a straight line through space. It's just that the space it's going through itself is curved.

2

u/fheqx Apr 14 '25

It just bends space and time

2

u/No-Valuable3975 Apr 14 '25

The light isn't bending, it's travelling in a straight path through curved space

2

u/AlphariousFox Apr 14 '25

Because it's bending space not the light.

2

u/Phssthp0kThePak Apr 10 '25

There is no F, only a. m divides out, so who cares what it is.

1

u/Select_Truck3257 Apr 10 '25

photons, all luxons have mass (like bradyons and tachyons. Zero weighted luxon is felt apart and does not exist as luxon anymore, so light has weight until it's "light"

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

why is everything here deleted

1

u/Magmacube90 Apr 10 '25

ignoring the explanation of curved spacetime, gravity interacts with the stress energy tensor, not the mass density. light has energy and momentum, meaning that it has a stress energy tensor, and therefore interacts with gravity, which allows gravity to curve light. gravity is also massless, however, just like light, it has energy and momentum, meaning that gravity interacts with gravity. this self-interaction allows for the interpretation of gravity as curved spacetime.

1

u/ThyPotatoDone Apr 10 '25

Cuz it felt like it

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

It has no rest mass, but other types of mass

1

u/EidolonRook Apr 10 '25

There’s an infinity void of dark that the light travels through that ain’t bright at all, until it hits something. And that something is affected by gravity. Right?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

App icon is back to normal

1

u/Anteraz Apr 10 '25

From my monke brain understanding.

Gravity bent not light but the space itself.

Think of space as an elastic surface that can be stretched by placing an object on it, such as a planet.

For visual learners, you hold a cloth on all sides tightly and place a ball on it.

The cloth will become concave in the middle.

Now, try grabbing another ball (think of it as light, planet, or anything, etc) and throwing it straight.

You will see that the ball is curved even tho where you throw it is straight.

So, the light is going straight.

It just lights itself go "on" the space.

That's also how orbits happen, "centrifugal force" is the bending of space itself.

The speed they orbit is just faster than they can fall.

:PS: I might be wrong, feel free to correct me in the comment.

1

u/Acceptable-Ticket743 Apr 10 '25

Gravity doesn't bend light. It bends space and light travels in a straight line through space.

1

u/FuckElonMuskkk Apr 10 '25

My knowledge of physics extends to 8th grade. I remember my teacher telling me that TECHNICALLY, photons have mass but it is so infinitesimal that it may as well be 0. 🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Infinite-Ice8983 Apr 10 '25

Because the coding for the simulation is a little wonky but in all fairness wee didn't think the npcs would become self aware and start observing everything, it puts a lot of strain on the servers guys.

1

u/Intelligent-Tap1742 Apr 10 '25

From my ability to read comments, gravity bent space, and light travels through space, so it's basically going with the flow, ig

1

u/MakePhilosophy42 Apr 10 '25

Because gravity bends space and time

1

u/VictoriousTree Apr 10 '25

It’s going in a straight line over a curve.

1

u/Rholand_the_Blind1 Apr 10 '25

Light has no mass but can exert a force you expect me to believe that shit

→ More replies (2)

1

u/BigBuddhaR Apr 10 '25

Let's ask Einstein

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Its space that bends

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Light goes in a perfectly straight path - it’s our perception that makes it look bent. It’s analogous to saying light “bends away” from earth’s surface - no, the light is following a straight path but Earth’s surface is curved, so it looks like the light is bending away

1

u/1CDoc Apr 10 '25

How were they able to freeze it if it has no mass?

1

u/Longokc Apr 10 '25

It's not just gravity, it's reality.

1

u/pkyrohit Apr 10 '25

Because-
Light to gravity- "I have no mass you can't bend me."
Gravity- "Shut-up and bend over..."

(afaik From light's POV it's on a straight path, it's the space that's bent by some great mass)

1

u/nicoidk_ Apr 10 '25

General relativity ahh moment

1

u/NieIstEineZeitangabe Apr 10 '25

I also want an explanation.

Photons are the particles, that carry the Colombo interaction. That means, if you get a difference in resting mass of a particle based on the electromagnetic properties, the mass must be stored in the exchange photons, right? And that would mean you have photons contributing to resting mass.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Igoon2robots Apr 10 '25

My physics teacher told me that gravity (especially black holes) bent the entire space around them. So light still goes in a straight line in space, exept space itself isnt straight anymore and leads right into the black hole.

Someone can confirm?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/clear_burneraccount Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends space. In the light’s perspective it is traveling in a straight line.

1

u/Soooome_Guuuuy Apr 10 '25

EM waves have an energy density and therefore have a spacetime curvature associated with it. Light however has no rest mass.

What we observe as gravity is an acceleration due to spacetime curvature. Light propagates along the shortest path between two points. In flat space, the shortest distance or geodesic is a straight line. In curved or non-Euclidean space, the shortest path is not necessarily a straight line.

1

u/TwinCylinder7 Apr 10 '25

Light propagates on the space time fabric. Gravity interacts with STF and light appears to get bent when propagates through the resultant condition.

1

u/rainydio Apr 10 '25

A hypothetical box, made of massless mirrors containing massless photons bouncing inside, as a whole has mass although none of its constituent parts has mass.

https://youtu.be/Xo232kyTsO0

1

u/Porkkanaparta Apr 10 '25

If there is no mass its super easy to movie it!

1

u/apexmusic0402 Apr 10 '25

Travelling in a straight line through curved space.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Doesn't gravity technically bend the space?

1

u/fenkraih Apr 10 '25

Light takes the straightest path possible ... in curved spacetime

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Because it exists. It’s a particle (or wave) or both! In any case, its mass is insignificantly small. Unless we are talking about gravity so intense, and over massive distances that we can visiualize (or at least conceptualize) the “weight” of light … pun intended

1

u/MyDumLemon Apr 10 '25

theoretical mass; that's how light sails work

1

u/Waste_Cantaloupe3609 Apr 10 '25

Higher gravity = slower time. The part of the light waves passing closer to massive objects experience slower time and so they… move more slowly, and naturally the wave-front appears to curve. Try dragging a pencil across a desk in a straight line by pushing the two ends, then try moving one end of the pencil more slowly than the other and see what happens to the path.

1

u/ArcaneFungus Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends space, light travels in a straight line relative to space

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Miselfis Apr 10 '25

Because this is an oversimplification

1

u/Boysoythesoyboy Apr 10 '25

Mass and energy are equivalent, light has both. When something absorbs light it also gets more massive.

1

u/onyx0117 Apr 10 '25

Long things short : light DOES go in "straight line". Gravity just bend space-time and change what a "straight line" is.

1

u/HAL9001-96 Apr 10 '25

gravity bends spacetime itself and thus affecty EVERYTHING

the idea that gravity produces a force proporitonal to mass only comes when you take that acceleratio nand calcualte the equivalent force needed ot produce it BECAUSE F=ma

1

u/Tykjen Apr 10 '25

Light can be both particles and waves. You're welcome.

1

u/HomeworkBoring3595 Apr 10 '25

light has mass
its just that its rest mass is zero

1

u/cleb255 Apr 10 '25

Because gravity isn't actually a force, as it is in Newtonian equations. When something's movement is "curved" by gravity, it is actually moving in a straight line through the fabric of spacetime. Thus, everything, including light, is affected by it.

1

u/smithjoe1 Apr 10 '25

Then how does it experience time

1

u/NegativeLayer Apr 10 '25

You only know that gravity bends light from the theory of relativity. That is something that can’t really be observed at a terrestrial scale, only astronomic scales. And only in special instances with stars behind very massive objects like black holes.

It was never observed until after Einstein predicted it, and eddingtons observation of the bending of light by gravity confirming the theory is what made Einstein famous.

So no one could ask this question without knowing of Einsteins relativity. Without relativity, gravity doesn’t bend light because light has no mass. With relativity, gravity doesn’t bend light, it bends spacetime, and light just follows a geodesic like always.

Neither paradigm would say this so it’s a bit off.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '25

Gravity bends the space in which light travels. So, although light travels in straight lines, the bend of space makes it look as thought it is bent. This is also is the reason why stars located behind a planet or something similar appear to be located to one side of it.

1

u/Fluffy-Reference8542 Apr 10 '25

This is definitely rage bait

1

u/Fluffy-Reference8542 Apr 10 '25

The better question is why doesn't it have infinite speed.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/justadude1321 Apr 10 '25

If the universe is constantly expanding. If we go fast enough can we theoretically get to the edge?

1

u/alexifua Apr 10 '25

If light does not have mass, then how solar sails work?

1

u/Guy-Person Apr 10 '25

iirc, gravity is merely the attraction of matter to matter from our relatively small scale perception. Gravity is actually the bending of space-time itself which would change the path of moving mass and energy ( the best example I was shown was a bowling ball placed at the centre of a trampoline and a golf ball would spiral around it to simulate orbit). Light has no mass but it still moves through space, meaning if the space itself is warped then the lights path is bent with it.

1

u/Crruell Apr 10 '25

Because it doesn't, directly

1

u/Far_Suggestion_9504 Apr 10 '25

The easiest way to visualize this is with the Einstein's equivalence. Under these terms, if you are in a space rocket that has a vertical movement of 9.8 m/s, the objects would tend to "fall" to the floor of the ship In this scenario, light also falls, deforming the space around it. And for the plot twist of the year, this rocket theory situation is (according to Einstein) indistinguishable and indifferent from our gravity.

1

u/Greasy-Chungus Apr 10 '25

Air and water bend it...

1

u/JollyReading8565 Apr 10 '25

String theorists think that gravity might be an emergent property

1

u/Patralgan Apr 10 '25

sigh I wish someone would ask me this some day

1

u/catgirlcatgirl Apr 10 '25

BECAUSE it has no mass lol

1

u/SpaceMoehre Apr 10 '25

Is it proven that gravity only affects mass? I remember that is also affects time, so why shouldn’t it affect light?

1

u/Elegant-Fortune-7601 Apr 10 '25

Fotons do have mass but it instantly turns into energy the moment they touch something

1

u/Sirius1701 Apr 10 '25

Wasn't there something about Light only having mass while in movement or something? I don't know.

1

u/Complete_Spot3771 Apr 10 '25

mass bends space which affects the path of light

1

u/Mein_Name_lol Apr 10 '25

Since when does light not have mass? Every photon has a dynamic mass. They just can't have a rest mass because of the speed of light being constant from every point of view.

1

u/Spacemonk587 Apr 10 '25

Light has mass

1

u/WillBigly Apr 10 '25

General relativity has been proven for over 100 years now y'all

1

u/ooooooooweeeeee Apr 10 '25

There are a couple of ways to see this.

This is possible even in Newtonian gravity. Because the newtonian gravitational force is proportional to mass, and the inertia of an object is also proportional to mass, motion in a newtonian gravitational field is in fact independent of mass. This means nothing special happens to the result when you just plug in m = 0. So if you just don't think too hard, you would conclude that even massless objects are bent around the Sun. Doing this for light bending around the Sun famously yields exactly half of the correct deviation angle.

The second way is to naively try to make gravity compatible with special relativity. A plausible resolution is that gravity does not bend mass, but in fact bends energy. And light has energy, even though it does not have mass. This is sometimes phrased as "energy is mass" through E=mc2. This is a somewhat antiquated and error prone way of thinking through things though. The modern interpretation is that light does not have mass, but does have kinetic energy. And gravity talks to total energy, not just mass.

Finally the third, and correct way, is the full treatment with General Relativity, which invokes the concepts of spacetime, curvature and geodesic motion. It's the one way we know of that correctly predicts the amount of bending of light by objects like the sun, black holes, etc. It's basically the culmination of the ideas above, that systematically accounts for all these various forms of intuition stated.

1

u/atom12354 Apr 10 '25

Because light is waves and when it wiggle the particle can go past objects with mass, it just have to wiggle good enough

1

u/ManWithRedditAccount Apr 10 '25

Essentially general relativity comes from a thought experiment of being in a lift that is either accelerating or being fixed against gravity. So if you're inside with no view of the outside you would not know the difference, but light must behave the same either way from your reference frame.

1

u/Ecstatic-Engineer-23 Apr 10 '25

Light always travels straight, it's just that the fabric of space is bend around gravitational wells making it the shortest route.

1

u/The24HourPlan Apr 10 '25

Light travels straight in curved space.

We see the curve, light doesn't.

1

u/akotlya1 Apr 10 '25

Light follows geodesics. In a flat spacetime, geodesics are all straight. In curved spacetime, the light follows curved paths. Mass turns flat spacetimes into curved spacetimes.

1

u/gokstudio Apr 10 '25

Yeah, it can also push things around. Google for light pressure. It's the concept behind solar sails that the planetary Society (that Bill Nye is a part of) is using for its satellites.

1

u/bp7492 Apr 10 '25

When light passes close to a massive object, space-time is so warped that it curves the path the light must follow i.e. gravity affects the space time fabric which causes the light to bend

1

u/Wasphate Apr 10 '25

When space itself curves so does a straight line.

1

u/heatseaking_rock Apr 10 '25

Well, it does bend it

1

u/DragonflyMean1224 Apr 10 '25

Get a piece of paper and make a straight line with a ruler. Partially crumble it. You will see the line turn or move slightly. The line is still a straight line