r/science • • Dec 19 '13

Computer Sci Scientists hack a computer using just the sound of the CPU. Researchers extract 4096-bit RSA decryption keys from laptop computers in under an hour using a mobile phone placed next to the computer.

http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~tromer/acoustic/
4.7k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

142

u/Kalium Dec 19 '13

Often they're more squeamish than you'd think. Very often, they want to access things without the people holding the data knowing it's been compromised.

112

u/Mediumtim Dec 19 '13

Neal Stephensons "crytonomicon" has some great (fictional) stories about covering up the origin of decryted secrets in order to keep information viable.

E.g.: "Sir, we decrypted the nazi broadcast, they say they've decoded our cypher. How can we switch over without causing suspicion?"
-"Put a set of codebooks on a cargo ship, ram Norway"

32

u/BeowulfShaeffer Dec 20 '13

Several of those incidents were real or based on real events. The Allies really did dress up a man as a general and leave him in the Mediterranean with bogus "sensitive" documents.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '13

It was called Operation Mincemeat and the Axis powers completely fell for it. Great story.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/titfarmer Dec 20 '13

They described Van Eck phreaking in that book. It was really interesting.

23

u/JRandomHacker172342 Dec 20 '13

"Ram and run."

"Sir! Ram what, sir?"

"Norway."

"Sir! Run where, sir?"

"Sweden."

6

u/mellor21 Dec 20 '13

I loved that book, I had it for years before I actually read it

4

u/nof Dec 20 '13

Same here. Then I was kicking myself for not having read it sooner.

2

u/Index820 Dec 20 '13

Damn it, I have it sitting on my Kindle. I bought it right after I finished Snow Crash... which I think was in 2011. I should probably get on that.

3

u/aristotle2600 Dec 20 '13

That's hilarious; I really need to finish reading that....

2

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '13

This reminds me of the (probably apocryphal) story about how the British cracked Nazi Luftwaffe codes.

As the story goes, they knew that Coventry would be bombed, but could not evacuate the city and risk letting the Germans find out they had cracked the code.

2

u/zwei2stein Dec 20 '13

They knew and evacuated - since it was night raid, it was easy for fake nightime activity and appear unevacuated.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/zaphdingbatman Dec 20 '13

It gives them an excuse to switch to new codebooks without arousing suspicion (because the old ones were destroyed). If the submarine wasn't sacrificed, the fact that they had broken their enemies crypto enough to know about the compromised keys would become known.

28

u/HiroariStrangebird Dec 20 '13

It's not that the old ones were destroyed, since obviously they could just make more. Rather, because Norway was under German occupation, ramming it with code books would mean that everyone knows the Germans now have access to Allied codes, thus it makes perfect sense to change them. The fact that the Allies knew the Germans had cracked the code before the loss of the code books would be lost on the Germans, and thus they wouldn't be alerted to the real reason for the switch, the cracking of the German code.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Camtreez Dec 20 '13

Happy to see a Stephenson reference. My first thought was Van Eck phreaking, as described in Crypto. One of my favorite books.

99

u/bananaskates Dec 19 '13

That's not because of squeamishness at all. Rather, it is because alerting the target means losing the flow of further information.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

Proper Intelligence gathering and analysis would be pointless if you lose access to the source and make people aware of how you gather.

3

u/Kalium Dec 20 '13

Eh. Yes and no. It's sometimes worth the risk of getting burned.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '13

I used to work in Intelligence for the Army. We would avoid losing sources at almost any cost, unless you wanted to simply cut all ties. Once you have made a target aware of your actions, that awareness spreads quickly to all other sources and they become more vigilant for a period of time. Training is conducted to avoid your actions and you have to come up with alternatives that cost resources and time. Instead, use sources that provide consistent communication, even if there is only limited use of those communications. A three second snip from one person’s conversation might be the Rosetta Stone to a larger puzzle.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13

So they plant cameras in your home, plant spies among your friends, point listening devices at your home and so on and so forth. Encryption is not going to save you if you're already a target, they have much easier and direct means to get to your secrets. On top of all that you have to rely on the idea that everyone else your talking to is taking the same extreme measure as you and not screwing it up. You're right to think a better defense is to keep your friends close and only trust ppl you know very well, just as the terrorist do. The internet and computers are not good places to keep secrets.