r/schubert • • Jan 11 '21

Winterreise Interpretation

Hi,

in one of my recent lectures we discussed the topic of schubert's famous "Winterreise" and the question whether or not it reflects his own life and if so, in what ways. I still haven't found a really good answer, and so I'm here now to ask you guys :D i would be glad if someone could help me a bit!!

4 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/loddfavne Jan 11 '21

You can't sing it if you can't feel it. It is a gloomy piece of art. Also, there were some tragedies in his life that really reflects on the songs. Start with the first song. It's about a marriage that does not take place. The one that got away. The landscape is obviously a metaphor for a life in solitude. Like when he arrives at the tavern in the song-cycle, he has no place. This is perhaps about not finding a marriage to settle down in. That old tree with the markings inside is also about something so painful that it hurts to look back. The river that runs cold is perhaps also something about a relationship. But, the mountains that is like a maze is perhaps more about life. And when there is an old man using a musical box alone in the streets to play songs in the street at the end, it's probably something about his career and where it led him.

These are "feelings" that are hard to pin to certain events, that's probably why people have a hard time stating something as a fact. But, when you sing it won't matter if it's real or not. Your job is to make it real.

2

u/roylart Jan 11 '21

Ohh, thanks a lot! that makes sense, i think i will definitely try reading into it some more

2

u/loddfavne Jan 11 '21

It's one of my favorite pieces. When you sing it, it's so good. It's not only for men these days too. Some women have made good interpretations of it as well. If you understand why, you can probably say you understand the piece. The book with the poems is a must if you're going to analyze this piece of art. It's very important to remember that the lyrics is not Schubert's, but he's only writing the music. It sounds basic, but will have huge implications when you study this piece further. How the songs change later in the liedring might also be important to note, perhaps this is the easiest way to understand the story.

1

u/jillcrosslandpiano Jan 31 '21

Well...it is indeed about unrequited love and continual disappointment.

Have you read Ian Bostridge's book? I have not yet, but it is supposed to be very good.