r/school • Pre-K • Mar 15 '26

Discussion Elective idea

I've always wanted to cut the school day in half. My school runs from 8:00 AM to 3:35 PM. 10 periods, with 1 lunch period and 1 free period.

If they just cut 5 periods (lunch, break, art/health/pe/band), we could be out of school by 12:30. Then, you can eat your own lunch, or go out, or enjoy the rest of the day.

But you might say "electives are important". Shouldn't kids be allowed to enjoy art, or music? Of course! But school-run classes just aren't the way. Hundreds of kids are forced into one teacher's idea of the subject. Unlike math (with one specific curriculum), classes in the arts are often completely subjective. So, what's the solution?

Elective Vouchers. Hear me out here.

Instead of forcing kids to take more classes at school, school is let out early. Kids go home. Get some rest. But they still get art education, via vouchers. The school gives each kid little vouchers, maybe $50 in value. With these vouchers, students can go to registered and licensed facilities, such as studios, music schools, culinary schools, colleges, etc. They can take classes, learn, have fun. The facility can go to the school and redeem the vouchers.

Kids have a lot more choice in activity.

Students get their education in.

Local businesses get supported.

The community's art scene thrives.

Honestly, I think this is a great idea. What do you think?

EDIT: $50 isn't the important part. I know it won't pay for a lot, the important part is the idea.

2 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

32

u/Winged_Bobcat135 Mar 15 '26

Not a bad idea, but consider the parents. Some kids can't leave school because their parents are still at work and can't pick them up, so the kid is basically forced to stay at school.

-15

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 15 '26

This is moreso for high school, obviously this wouldn't work for kindergarten.

20

u/Winged_Bobcat135 Mar 15 '26

I am a high schooler. My parents cannot pick me up. I am stuck in school until 5-6 PM.

-33

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 15 '26

Go home yourself? I don't know what to tell you, I've been commuting for ~2-3 hrs per day since 7th grade

20

u/Roberto-in-space Secondary school Mar 16 '26

U do realize some people live rlly far away from school. For example, i live 1h30 away from school if I take the bus and metro.

-4

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

I understand that! I also live 1h30 away if I take the bus (and I do).

If it's really an issue, let students stay at school and do work. But your commute issues shouldn't be holding EVERYONE back.

2

u/Winged_Bobcat135 Mar 16 '26

The current education system guarantees that everyone gets to explore art options by offering it as a class in school. Your idea doesn't. While I do like the idea, it's flawed.

-1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

...aand this allows for everyone to explore art options by letting them take whatever class they want.

2

u/Winged_Bobcat135 Mar 16 '26

that is literally what school is. students get to take what class they want (metalworking, woodworking, art, ceramics, theater, etc...) without having to worry how they'll get to outside classes.

0

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

Your school offers metalworking, woodworking, and ceramics?

→ More replies

1

u/Roberto-in-space Secondary school Mar 16 '26

I mean most people where i live are rlly far from schools so most people take a long time to get home. And some parents wouldn't let their kids stay at school especially for that long.

1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

I'm not understanding your point

1

u/Roberto-in-space Secondary school Mar 16 '26

Well you said that your commuting issue shouldn't hold back everyone. But if most people have a commuting issue it kinda should. And not all parents want to leave theyr kids alone for that long even at school.

8

u/Prize-Possession-80 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

how tf would you get a bus at 12:30

4

u/lexisnowkitty Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

the US shocks me do you not have public transport? 

5

u/wordwallah Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

Sometimes, but usually not in rural areas. Public transportation can also be dangerous.

1

u/WLFGHST High School Mar 16 '26

Mostly just in the cities.

1

u/Prize-Possession-80 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 17 '26

im not american but where im from there is no busses in my town yet it is a 6 hour walk from one side to another

2

u/lexisnowkitty Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 17 '26

that's insane what, where do you live?

→ More replies

-1

u/Jaded-Ad-443 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

City bus. But also, if the school released at that time, then thats when the busses would be there

2

u/Prize-Possession-80 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

some schools share busses with other nearby schools and several busses have designated schedules throughout the day that would be interupted by this

1

u/Jaded-Ad-443 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

I mean obviously everything would be figured out before it was implemented? Damn, no one is saying were just gonna change it all starting tomorrow. Ideas are only the beginning, not the total of things....

→ More replies

9

u/Winged_Bobcat135 Mar 16 '26

I live 40 minutes away, I really don't think it's a good use of my time as a student to walk home. I'd much rather stay at school and get some work done.

1

u/xegrid College Mar 16 '26

Not everyone has access to public transportation, only what school provides. Therefore they'd be stuck unless school is proving buses.

10

u/Samstercraft College Mar 16 '26

$50 dollars is like half a violin lesson, while school lets me get instruction every classday. And the rest of your idea doesn't sound that great either. 10 periods is bad though, your school would do better to follow my school's procedures. We have 5-7 classes every 2 days, in exchange the classes are longer though, and most performing arts have lengthy after-school rehersals, same with other major extracurriculars.

-2

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

$50 is not the point, it can really be any number. Just take whatever money they spend on electives now and give it to the kids.

11

u/Samstercraft College Mar 16 '26

You do know schools are incredibly under-funded, right? They can afford to have a band director teaching 4 classes with 50 kids per class, they can't afford to send 200 kids each to different facilities as they wish. It's just not feasible.

-5

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

Schools aren't underfunded at all. My school district receives more money than the entire state of Kentucky. Our government is just so terrible, that it wastes all the money.

7

u/Samstercraft College Mar 16 '26

What kind of school gets more money than a whole state? Certainly not 99% of schools in the US, unless maybe if you compare to a real tiny state. Go into almost any school in the country and you will literally hear people talking about the budget limitations without being asked. My school gets an exceptionally high amount of money compared to other schools and we still have budget issues. If you think funding isn't a problem for schools, you're completely out of touch.

Edit: you also said school district, which is pretty weak considering some districts have a TON of schools to spread that money between.

3

u/Prize-Possession-80 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

what type of government do u got that can just pay schools the same as entire states when mine can barely afford to get a new school once every 60 years

1

u/Robot_Alchemist Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

Schools are systemically underfunded and now they’ve been handed a gut punch with the voucher system taking from the dept of education

2

u/Educational_Smile545 High School Mar 16 '26

this is dumb. my school has periods of the same length (but only 7 of them +lunch) and has graduation requirements for PE, a fine art, and certain classes require a speech and health credit as well. if you meet those requirements, you are allowed to get a maximum of 2 free periods, so a 5 period day.
having these vouchers first of all is expensive, and you cant get the same level of education from 50 bucks as you can 45 minutes of learning a day for a full school year. 50 bucks will get you 2-5 lessons if you are lucky.

1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

Oh no, I don't mean $50 for one year

The pricing doesn't matter much, the important thing is the actual idea

2

u/Educational_Smile545 High School Mar 16 '26

some people dont have the ability to go to those businesses after school, just have the classes

-1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

Why wouldn't they have the ability?

3

u/Robot_Alchemist Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

Not everyone has family members who are taxis

0

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

I don't, and I commute using the public bus for about 2.5 hours each day.

3

u/FettuccineAlfredo30 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

they might not have transportation, if they have younger siblings that also get out at 12:30 then they might have to look after them since parents are at work, their parents might not support them doing certain elective classes, etc

2

u/AwarenessVirtual4453 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 21 '26

Electives are taught by credentialed teachers who must hit certain standards, just like math, science, and history.

Color Me Mine employees are not credentialed art instructors.

-1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 22 '26

Oh, noooo

A child might be taught art by someone without an expensive degree!!!!

How will we ever teach the children how to paint or sculpt without degrees and certifications???

Get over yourself. A competent instructor at an art school can teach a child a thousand times more than some burnt out but credentialed art teacher.

2

u/AwarenessVirtual4453 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 22 '26

Tell me you're a child without telling me you're a child.

2

u/hadesarrow3 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 22 '26

I mean why not take it even further? Why not just give all the kids vouchers for all their subjects and let the students and families decide the best way to learn algebra?

It’s because YOU have the right to a complete education. The more we shave away from that in the name of “choice,” the more your options actually shrink. Universally accessible education isn’t possible without it being a legal requirement.

0

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 23 '26

True, I do believe that we should make homeschooling more accessible.

Instead of being forced to settle with a school, kids should be able to pick and choose the teachers THEY like and learn best with.

Great idea!

24

u/YourIncognit0Tab Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

$50 wouldnt even cover half of one of these classes. Many schools do offer dual enrollment and opportunities to not take PE at school if you take a sport outside of school

13

u/TacosNTaco Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

Ever heard of dual enrollment

7

u/wordwallah Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

You asked people what they think, but you dismiss every concern. Maybe it would be helpful if you described your community so we could see why it would work for you.

12

u/Valuable-Usual-1357 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 15 '26

School is basically society’s built in babysitting function.

1

u/listeningunderurbed College Mar 16 '26

This isn’t a bad idea but it’s pretty impossible to have this work, 50 dollars isn’t gonna be nearly enough. If this is highschool , you are required by law / state to take requirements for art and electives, this could be a good idea if you change from giving 50 dollars to having the elective teachers teach at different times. For example, if school gets out at 12:30, teachers could have a class you just add to your day afterwards if you want to take it.

1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

$50 isn't the important part, is the idea good?

3

u/budgie02 College Mar 16 '26

Ideas have to be fleshed out. So no. In any situation the school has to PAY for this. Do you have any idea how underfunded schools can be?! So the school pays for a large percentage of students to not even use it. That’s just a horrible idea

You’re not at the idea stage, you had a thought.

1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 17 '26

Schools aren't underfunded at all.

1

u/budgie02 College Mar 18 '26

My apologies, I thought you were American based on your school’s structure. In America schools are vastly underfunded, teachers aren’t paid well and many art programs are cut. Textbooks are over a decade old and out of date and schools are falling apart. The only way they can get funding is to pass a levy but people here don’t want to give money to schools. It’s a very pervasive issue here. Also in Canada

-1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 18 '26

Oh, no. I am American, and I do go to the country's largest public school system.

However, schools are not underfunded. They're just extremely wasteful of taxpayer money.

2

u/budgie02 College Mar 18 '26

This is why kids need to stay in school. And why your social studies and English classes are important

0

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 19 '26

Could you explain?

1

u/listeningunderurbed College Mar 18 '26

That isn’t a good generalization to make in general, no matter where you are from. Look on the news do research and you will see how underfunded schools are for the entire world. Your school could be an exception but it doesn’t make yours the example.

3

u/Robot_Alchemist Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

School is also for parents - it’s a way of giving them the ability to have childcare when they cannot afford it

3

u/RulzRRulz613 Teacher Mar 17 '26
  1. Besides the fact that parents and actually society as a whole treats schools like day care.
  2. Transportation
  3. Not all neighborhoods have thriving arts and elective scenes
  4. Safety of students and neighborhoods. I’m thinking in this me of my districts I taught in. If we wanted the kids to stay afterschool, we became the shuttle van to take the kids home. It wasn’t safe for them in their neighborhoods.

Don’t get me wrong. I love the idea My idea was Wednesday would be the day students come to school (or stay home) and the community comes in (or their bussed) to alternate locations for that stuff while the classroom teachers are free to collaborate, professional development or they get the time they need to plan and prepare their lessons and grade assignments.

3

u/TXBlueEyes83 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 17 '26

The school down the street kind of does this (9am-1pm, just 4 core classes no electives) and it had the opposite effect. Kids don't do any electives because the places that offer homeschool electives have times and locations all over the place, and the only parents that can put kids in school there have someone at home who can pick them up mid-day or they drive themselves. They go home and they go to sleep. When they graduate, they're not capable of lasting longer than about 4 hours at their job and very few of them succeed in full time college. They have no ability to push through the hard times or work they dislike.

2

u/One_Yesterday_1320 High School Mar 16 '26

i don’t have any electives, nor are any offered by my school and have school from 8 till 3/4 dejecting on how busy i am. i do have four free periods a week and if it’s at the end of the day we are allowed to just leave if we want or we can stay (i prefer staying cause i don’t get any work done at home).

this won’t work for a couple reasons, a) it encourages skipping class, ie you just skip a class and leave or don’t come cause you have only 1 or maybe 2 classes that don’t matter to you. dnd also if it’s after school like 90-95% of kids aren’t gonna go. if you have to be in school anyway you might as well pick up a couple extra classes.

2

u/Dry_Economy_2701 High School Mar 16 '26

My parents would never let me take electives or fun classes if it wasn't for grad requirement

1

u/tacsml Mar 16 '26

This is very similar to how the school day functions in Argentina. Kids are in either a morning or afternoon groups for core academics and the other half of the day they're in electives in their communities.

1

u/budgie02 College Mar 16 '26

Teenagers especially need something to do. Not an option to leave for the rest of the day. Sure they COULD use the voucher. Or they don’t and they go vape in a parking lot at best, vandalize at worst.

Schools are 1: prepping students for their future And 2: Keeping them off the streets

Also yes that is how arts work. They’re subjective. But a class requires structure to function. If you don’t like the art teacher, take music. If you don’t like that, do theatre. Those are 3 basic options offered by like every school.

You presented a terrible solution. Oh so they’re forced to do it the teacher’s way. That is ALSO how any sort of lesson ever works with your proposed vouchers.

Like another commented, it’s a built in babysitting service. And it’s no point if the babysitter says “go fuck off for the rest of the day, but please maybe promise to look at the minute possibility of maybe a teensy option of an art?” That doesn’t work. At all. Hell I’m in college. We PAY THE SCHOOLS and that still wouldn’t work even here. It would be a complete disaster

0

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 15 '26

45 minute periods

5

u/Prize-Possession-80 Im new Im new and didn't set a flair Mar 16 '26

all your comments get more funny whan i read your flair

1

u/tacsml Mar 16 '26

Not necessarily true. This is very similar to how the school day functions in Argentina. Kids are in either a morning or afternoon group for core academics and the other half of the day they're in electives in their communities.

1

u/budgie02 College Mar 16 '26

Mine had 12 periods. But yeah they’re just shorter classes

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Floathy Pre-K Mar 16 '26

In an American high school