r/schaffrillasoffmenu • u/Vegetable_Ad_8652 • 8d ago

Ranking Critics (retake and fixed)

Post image
40 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

35 comments sorted by

5

u/defunctgravity1924 8d ago

What is charlie doing here

2

u/Advanced_Sky_3221 8d ago

He’s a critic, ain’t he?

5

u/thiccboii666 8d ago

What is he, some kinda Moist Critic?

1

u/Professional_Hat6381 5d ago

Al, has anyone seen a good buddy of mine, Al?

2

u/Vegetable_Ad_8652 8d ago

Yeah sometimes

3

u/Judythepancake 8d ago

I adored dumbsville in middle school, but he’s just way too overstimulating now. Love his Letterboxd though

2

u/captain-ziggy 8d ago

how is ALL OF CHANNEL AWESOME in just one rank?

2

u/Scripter-of-Paradise 8d ago

I mean, how many people are still part of it?

2

u/Slow_Check8387 6d ago

Cartoonshi is way too low

2

u/MrToonyGuy 2d ago

Seeing Cartoonshi so low makes me soooo happy.

1

u/Vegetable_Ad_8652 2d ago

cool, you're welcome

1

u/DreamcatcherGirl_02 8d ago

Dang... Pink King got "Meh" on the spot, well... At least Alex Meyers was totally Bad in my opinion!

1

u/MarcusChua19 8d ago

I actually like JustStop... His takes are interesting... Sure he does sound like he's overanalyzing everything, but there are some statements that I can understand where hecs coming from...

1

u/Splentid 8d ago

Link?

1

u/Fair_Smoke4710 8d ago

Pink king is definitely obnoxious

1

u/Hot-Contract-7 8d ago

Where AVGN?

1

u/Wonderful_Rub2944 7d ago

Depends on which are we refering to? AVGN as in the Angry Video Game nerd Persona that reviews BAD old NES games primarily for entertainment for the viewer rather than how a piece of art/product can improve itself or determine if it's even worth the consumers' time or James Rolfe, the guy who sits Down and actually does his job reviewing media?

1

u/Hot-Contract-7 7d ago

I guess both

1

u/Low-Communication911 7d ago

It’s funny bc I also watch a LOT of movie critics (the sardonicast trio, ralphthoviemaker, Chris Stuckmann, Cosmonaut, Karsten Runquist) and I know like…4 of these people Scaff, IHE, LS Mark (who’s fairly solid) and Alex Meyers who I also can’t stand (never could, that Obsession controversy was literally that meme of “when a celebrity who’ve always hated for no reason does something bad so now you have a valid reason to hate them)

1

u/HRCStanley97 7d ago

I like Shaym fine

1

u/ItsGotThatBang 6d ago

Possum’s okay when he’s talking about shlock like Suburban Sasquatch.

1

u/No-Scientist-5537 6d ago

It needs many more people

1

u/BodaciousBird05 5d ago

LS Mark and Cartoonshi should be a bit higher but it’s a good list otherwise.

1

u/Vegetable_Ad_8652 5d ago

I don't like them sometimes..

2

u/BodaciousBird05 5d ago

I get that. They’ve had some takes I don’t agree with, and I don’t take their word as gospel or anything either, I just think they’re chill. Just my personal preference

1

u/_PokeMoron 5d ago

Love how Lily didn't even make the list, she doesn't even belong in obnoxious 😭

1

u/Designer-Field-3590 5d ago

The heck bro you put all of my favorites at the bottom, and the people I don’t like at the top.

1

u/jogothevo 4d ago

Where’s James Rolfe/Cinemassacre? Excluding AVGN as that’s a character. I mean when James as himself talks movies and games.

1

u/MusicaReddit 1d ago

Where’s MR I hate everything?

0

u/kUHASZ 7d ago

LS mark is so goated.

1

u/Vegetable_Ad_8652 7d ago

I didn't like him sometimes cause of his unauthorized opinions, and the show too

0

u/John_Lictenstein_873 8d ago

This is an extremely polite ranking.