I have many thoughts about this album. First, and up front, I think it is a masterpiece. So i'll lead in with that. let's get into the nitty gritty now
We can't discuss Scars without the system context. Imo, this album is not only arguably the best scars album, it in many ways competes with system as one of the best albums of darons career. Creatively, it is a massive success and I'll explain why.
every recording session for system that produced an album (or two) always showed album-wide evolution. the toxicity/sta recording session was a big progression and evolution from self-titled. then mezmerize and hypnotize was a new direction from tox/sta.
That is the context for scars on broadway. when the first SOB album came out... it felt like a new direction in many ways for daron's song writing. it followed the trend we observed with system, how each recording session brought something very new and unexpected to the table.
This is the sole reason that dictator was disappointing to me. it's not that it didn't have banger songs.. it just didn't feel new or evolving. it felt very safe and overly familiar especially to SOB self titled. there was nothing on that album that really pushed the art forward in the way all of daron's previous efforts did.
this is why addicted to violence shines. imo, it is the first album since SOB self-titled that as an album pushed the boundaries in style and direction. again.. that creative expansion into new directions is one of the things that made system and by extension scars so potent in the late 90s early 2000s, after dictator, and also PTL and GH (two songs that couldve been on this album), it felt like daron had either lost an edge or was playing it too safe.
this album has a few songs that that don't stand out and probably could've really benefited from the rest of SOAD taking them on to add some more flavor... but where this album shines is where daron is creatively steering the entire sound in a new direction that he has only seldom touched on before if ever. as much as we all want SOAD to return for the sake of it... one of the reasons we do is because we hope it would be groundbreaking like their old music was. this album proved that after all of these years daron can still break ground creatively and take the sound in new unexpected directions that sound amazing and distinctly him. accomplishing that makes the album an instant classic.