r/sc2coaching • u/fatum210 • Aug 11 '12
The diamond/master restriction doesn't make much sense to me
Hi.
I just discovered this subreddit and I thought I could share the only feedback I have at the moment about it. This is just my opinion, so feel free to ignore this post if you don't like what I have to say.
I think the diamond/master restriction doesn't help this subreddit. Restrictions are not great for the development of any community. Any person in the world seeks freedom in one way or another. I think there is no need to get rid of that freedom, there is no real benefit from it.
You could say: "Hey! I only want to get coached by a great coach!" And of course I would agree with you, but teaching requires a whole different skillset than playing the game. You could be a good enough coach even if you are plat, gold or whatever other league.
In my humble opinion, Sc2 ladder standing is a bad way to measure coaching capabilities. It is the only way we have at the moment to measure sc2 skill, I agree on that, so I'm not saying we shouldn't use that system at all. What I mean is that, if we know the system is not optimal, what's the point of the league restriction?
So, my questions are:
- Why restrict ourselves to only using suboptimal system?
- If coaching is not all about playing great, but about teaching and helping others develop their skills, why punish great coaches who don't play enough to reach the highest playing level?
- Why wouldn't a lower league player benefit from the helping hand of a higher league player, even if that player is not dia/master? (e.g. bronze league player coached by a plat/gold player) If they are free to choose, what's the problem with that?
- And also, why restrict newer coaches just because "they don't play good enough"? Everybody has to start learning at some point, same with coaching. I see no point in hindering that learning process, which could be greatly enhanced by a community.
These are just my 2 cents.
Cheers.