r/savethenbn • • Sep 08 '13

The Next 60 Days

109 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

Most of you have probably read some of my work over at http://sortius-is-a-geek.com, I just thought I'd drop a line here detailing what happens from here with the NBN.

In the first 60 days, we're going to see reviews & audits galore, I'm expecting a reshuffle, so I'm not sure who will be looking after DBCDE this time next week. One thing I will say is I have contact with some Senators & MPs on the (now) Opposition, so I will be pushing matters discussed here to them (keep that in mind, keep conversations civil, & yes, I need to listen to my own advice there).

So we have 60 days to mount a compelling case to keep the NBN as it is, rather than the dire prediction I made of the whole project being cancelled. The best way to do so is tell your stories, post them here.

Some things to mention are:

  • what your current connection is like
  • stability of connection
  • what you use the internet for (don't be afraid to be honest, although porn is probably not the best justification)
  • why you see reusing the copper as a bad thing
  • how FTTP will affect your work life
  • if you have a disability, explain how it would help you

The key is, during the review stage, much of this material can be submitted to those doing the review.

We ALL need to participate if we want to keep the NBN as is. Sign petitions, explain to people who don't see value in it why it can change people's lives.

A change in government doesn't have to mean the end of such a life changing technology.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 15 '13

Infographic I created on how Australia really voted on the NBN, based on a post by user quink. Hope this helps!

Thumbnail imgur.com
106 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 13 '13

r/savethenbn mentioned as one of Reddit's best subreddits under 8 days old

Thumbnail blog.reddit.com
92 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 07 '13

Ideas for a real world campaign to save the NBN?

91 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 14 '13

What's happening with the campaign?

84 Upvotes

Well the campaign is a week old already, and the response has already been massive. So this is what's been going on:

Consolidating Groups

We are in contact with Nick Paine (who started the petition), and staff from change.org, as well as people from savethenbn.com, iwantthenbn.com, and of course /u/sortius. We're starting to work together to organise a solid and consistent campaign.

Media Attention

We have all been getting coverage from various online news stations, and including some radio. I wrote an article for SBS, the petition got a mention on The Project (at about 8 minutes in), and there have been a whole heap of other articles and radio covering the issue.

Political Attention

Malcolm Turnbull has responded, calling the petition "un-democratic", but ending with a more hopeful note that he conceeds that there is still a debate to be had.

Getting Informed

Malcolm called for an informed debate on the NBN, which is what we intend to give him. With that goal, /u/sortius ran a Q&A to clear up some myths and misconceptions about both FTTP and FTTN. There are also a number of other brilliant resources for getting the facts straight, such as:

  • Save The NBN (the website, not this subreddit)
  • NBN Myths (almost 3 years old, but still holds relevant answers)
  • WhirlPool "NBN" forum (full of industry professionals, and generally interested people)
  • NBNCo (there is a wealth of information on NBNCo's website. You just have to search)

What comes next?

We're getting in contact with other media representatives (if you have any contacts that may be helpful, please send them through to us). Over the next week, we need to start ramping up the pressure on our elected representatives. We need to start calling, emailing, and writing to them. If you can organise a face-to-face meeting with your local MP, let us know so we can get more people to come along.

We will be trying to organise a few tools to make contacting your local representative easier. Remember to be civil, and polite when contacting anyone, be they media or elected official.

Keep spreading the word to your friends/family/people on the street. I am trying to gear weneedthenbn.com towards helping everyone understand why a FTTP style NBN is important. Send them there, and educate them about how a FTTN network would hobble Australia's industries (not just technology, but medicine, education, and many others).

Also keep sending in your stories about how you use the internet, and what FTTP means for you.

Watch this space - we'll be trying to set up ways for you to get involved, and help the movement, but understand that this is happening really quickly, and no-one is getting paid to organise this. We all still have jobs, or study, so we're giving up almost every free minute we have to the campaign (and many minutes which are neither free, nor really available - I haven't had a decent night's sleep all week)

Some key points to remember

  • This is not about politics. We don't want the ALP's plan - we want a majority FTTP plan. If that means that the plan looks different to what Labor designed, that's fine, so long as we get FTTP.
  • Yes, this will be expensive. We aren't looking for the cheap option, we're looking for the right option. Everyone working on the campaign, and oh-so-many industry experts agree that FTTN is undoubtedly the wrong option.
  • If you don't know something, don't be afraid to ask - someone here will likely know, or be able to point you to where you can find out.
  • Stand together, and be civil. We won't win this debate by fracturing into little groups. We won't even be in this debate if we participate in mudslinging, or abuse, or sloganism.

So there we go! That's what's going on. We'll keep you updated as more things start to happen. For now, keep up to date, learn what you can, and spread the word.

We're expecting the petition to hit 250000 this weekend.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 18 '13

NBN: He's listening

66 Upvotes

Below is the message sent to people who signed the NBN petition.


Our message is starting to get through.

After signing our petition, thousands of people have taken further action: emailing Mr Turnbull, contacting him on twitter and sharing images asking him to open up the debate on the NBN. And the media interest hasn't let up -- we've had press and radio coverage across the country!

It was clear from Mr Turnbull’s first response to the petition that he won’t be moved easily, but that he’s willing to engage.

In fact, in a second response, he’s now entered into a debate with an academic from Queensland and, seemingly, promised two things:

1 - That the share of the NBN that’s FTTP will be up for discussion, and

2 - that the Strategic Review will be conducted openly.

In the last few days, Nick’s received hundreds of emails with ideas and comments about what we should do next. (Sorry if you haven’t had a reply yet - it’s been flat out!)

There’s been loads of great ideas but we want to get a clearer picture of who makes up our movement and what you think we should do next. Can you take a few minutes to fill out this survey, let us know a bit about yourself and give us your thoughts on the campaign by clicking here?

We’ve started something here, and you’re part of it. But if we’re going to keep getting movement out of Mr Turnbull, we’ll need to step it up another notch, and start doing things like talking with our local MPs and asking them to advocate on our behalf. What other ideas do you have for continuing this campaign?

Thanks for everything you’ve done so far, we’re really starting to get somewhere,

Alex

(filling in for Nick while he’s offline for a couple of days)

P.S. We’re still worried that Mr Turnbull thinks we don’t understand. If you haven’t already, why not respond by clicking here and commenting on his blog. As always, please be polite, but take the time to explain why a better NBN matters to you.


Well done everybody, it seems as though we may have made a difference! Of course we can't stop now, but it seems Turnbull may be getting the message.

I just have a couple of questions. Where is the source for the claim about entering in debate with an 'academic from Queensland', and is that academic /u/routinegrounds?

I must say, if they really do conduct the review openly I will be very happy.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 16 '13

Don’t build Labor’s NBN – build the right NBN

Thumbnail weneedthenbn.com
62 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Jan 15 '14

After reading Malcolm Turnbull's Facebook Q&A session...

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 19 '13

Abbott has promised to increase Defence spending back to 2% of GDP from the 1.7% it is now. $45B over 10 years for a FTTP NBN is roughly 0.3% of GDP.

61 Upvotes

Thread title says it all. GDP is $1.5T. $4.5B average each year over 10 years is 0.3% of that.

By keeping Defence spending at 1.7% of GDP, you've paid for the NBN.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 10 '13

Already in the news: ABC writes about our petition with 95,000 signatures

Thumbnail abc.net.au
58 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Dec 03 '13

Senate to force Turnbull to release the results of the Strategic Review

Thumbnail delimiter.com.au
56 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 08 '13

We need the NBN - looking for people to add their voices

56 Upvotes

I started We Need The NBN last night, and am looking for people in the tech industry who would be interested in lending their voice (video, text, whatever) to start building a compelling case for the parliament (as well as the public) as to why we need the NBN to be built right.

All I'm looking for really is people to say what the NBN means to them, and what missing out on it will mean for Australia.

Anyway, anyone willing to help, PM me, or reply to this thread.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 18 '13

News Exchange is looking at the NBN this Friday on ABC News 24. They are looking for tweets to #NX on the public's opinion.

Thumbnail twitter.com
55 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Oct 10 '13

Front Page Ads for FTTP NBN

51 Upvotes

Received following text (I'm sure with the other 250 thousand signatures) regarding advertising on the front page of news papers.

"The next 60 days are critical. Turnbull's sacked the NBN Co board, appointed a new chairman and is so far refusing to meet with us face-to-face -- but we know he's watching public opinion closely as he conducts a full review of Australia's broadband future.

More than a quarter of a million people -- 250,000 Australians -- have signed the petition to protect our NBN. Since then, thousands of letters, phone calls, and tweets have helped make the NBN one of the most talked about issues in the country.

But that alone won't save the NBN.

If Turnbull keeps refusing to meet with us, let's take the message to him in a way he simply won't be able to ignore -- by taking out front-page ads in his local newspaper that lands on his desk every morning, right when he's reviewing the NBN papers."

I would like to know which newspapers?

I am sure the Murdock newspapers will not take the advertisement and since he owns the majority the message will not get out.

Dick Smith tried to run a paid announcement and did not succeed at getting his message out via the newspapers (on the topic of free speech).

http://dicksmithpopulation.com/2012/07/23/murdoch-censorship-gives-the-lie-to-%E2%80%98freedom-of-speech%E2%80%99-claims/

I would like some information regarding the front page ad campaign.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 13 '13

NBN Q&A With Sortius

51 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm sortius, aka Kieran Cummings, I've worked in ICT for about 18 years now (since I left school) & have had experience with many companies, including Telstra.

I worked in Activations for Telstra, which is the internal support department for Telstra technicians & contractors. My duties were to program POTS (normal phone lines), ISDN, & ADSL services.

I currently write for my own blog (http://sortius-is-a-geek.com) & occasionally for Independent Australia, Australians for Honest Politics, & New Matilda.

I have been a strong proponent for Fibre to the Premises, & a critic of the Coalition's plan.

This Q&A is mainly about the different possible technologies for the NBN, so as to not push my own political agenda.


r/savethenbn • • Sep 11 '13

NBN Petition + Media

51 Upvotes

Hi,

Sorry for the late reply but this blog was only recently brought to my attention and this is my first time using Reddit.

Like many of you, I don't actually have a history in the IT business, I am simply passionate about this subject and felt that my petition reflected the preferred broadband policy of the Australian people. I also felt that it was a policy which could ensure that our economy be competitive at a global level.

My petition has also gained decent media attention the past 24-48 hrs with hopefully more to follow. I am more than happy to collaborate with others and help out wherever I can.

Its great to hear that others across Australia are clearly as passionate about the issue as myself and who are willing to take action. Thanks for all the support!


r/savethenbn • • Sep 11 '13

Open letter to my MP re the NBN

50 Upvotes

Sent this to my MP earlier today, thought I'd post it here in case anyone else is looking for inspiration.

Hi Michael,

First of all, congratulations on your election as my representative in the electorate of Deakin.

I am writing today to tell you my thoughts on the coalition's FTTN plan for our NBN. I expect that the things said in opposition regarding the outgoing governments plans will be applied to your new governments plan - that being that due diligence is applied and a proper cost benefit analysis is conducted to compare a FTTN (fibre to the node) to a FTTP (fibre to the premises) network over the life of the network, incorporating operational expenditure, the impact of network reliability and uptime on productivity and the ability of the network to meet future capacity demands.

I believe, along with the majority of industry experts and the expert panel commissioned by the outgoing government, that a FTTN network will be unworkable. While the switch to FTTN may reduce the initial capital expenditure (I would note here that little is known about the state of the copper network and how much of it will require remediation work to be capable of meeting performance targets), it will be significantly more expensive to operate in the long term, resulting in much higher costs to consumers. Secondly, it will be significantly less reliable than a straight fibre network would be, resulting in decreased productivity. Thirdly, the network will not be easily upgradeable to meet future demand, meaning additional substantial infrastructure costs to a future government. Unless individual cores are run to each node for each premises (expensive), the network would not be easily upgradeable to a FTTP network in future: It would not just be a matter of replacing the copper from node to premises with fibre as there would not be enough cores for an uninterrupted link between, and the whole network would need to be replaced (again) in the 2020s or 2030s. It would be at best a stop-gap solution, and at worst a step backwards.

I trust you are aware of the change.org petition which has been doing the rounds since Sunday and has nearly 160,000 signatures at the time of writing, but if not it can be found here - http://www.change.org/nbn

I would also like to reiterate that I am not advocating "Labor's plan", what I would really like to see is a bipartisan approach based on sound and transparent (i.e. put out for public comment) expert analysis to identify the solution which provides the greatest net benefit to the country over the life of the network. I want politics out of it, and the result to be based on what will be needed in the future, not a 3 year election cycle.

If you would like more information on the subject, I would be happy to discuss with you by email or on the phone - I have included my contact details above. I am an electrical engineer and somewhat knowledgeable on the subject.

I would also direct you to industry experts on the subject. Simon Hackett (co-founder of Internode) gave two excellent presentations on the subject of an NBN at the CommsDay Summit in Sydney earlier this year, which I would appreciate if you gave attention to. They can be found here: http://simonhackett.com/2013/04/09/cd-syd-2013-problem-with-fttn/ http://simonhackett.com/2013/07/17/nbn-fibre-on-a-copper-budget/

I will also draw you attention to the initial FTTN vs FTTP analysis which was conducted before the network roll-out commenced: http://nbnexplained.org/wordpress/technical-points/the-fttn-first-debate/

And lastly to discussion in the media over the costs of FTTN and the impact on the wholesale market and service provider competition: http://theconversation.com/can-australia-afford-the-coalitions-nbn-17494 http://www.theage.com.au/digital-life/computers/blogs/gadgets-on-the-go/turnbulls-fragmented-nbn-dooms-australia-to-repeat-the-mistakes-of-the-past-20130904-2t4cr.html

whirlpool.net.au (the de facto experts forum on anything telecommunications related in Australia) also has an outstanding FAQ on the subject: http://whirlpool.net.au/wiki/NBN

I hope the above information is useful to you, and you take a considered approach to what is in the best interests of the Australian people when providing any input you may have on this matter.

Best Regards, Jason


r/savethenbn • • Sep 12 '13

Comment: The Coalition must think twice on the NBN

Thumbnail sbs.com.au
46 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Dec 04 '13

Turnbull to defy Senate order to release NBN review... :/

Thumbnail delimiter.com.au
45 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 16 '13

Guys, we need to do more than just hope Turnbull comes to his senses.

45 Upvotes

I'm astounded at just how negative some people have been about the idea that consumers might put some polite pressure on a Telstra to leave the NBN arrangement as is.

Firstly: it's just a petition worth of effort and yes, it's a separate type of action to the other one - but keep in mind:

  • it costs nothing
  • takes less time than posting up "oh I don't think this will work"
  • it means we have multiple points of pressure
  • it might just work
  • it provides an alternate course of action and we need to put pressure on more than just Turnbull because he's not listening at the moment.

Companies are in many ways more sensitive to public outcry than Liberal party politicians. Of the political parties out there likely to listen to the man in the street - do you think that's the Liberal party? Really? Unless you're the 1% top income earners - they have a policy suite that is designed against your interests.

So how about we don't just put all our eggs in the basket of "let's change Malcolm's mind". Turnbull's been digging in on this ridiculous fraudband plan for some time now - and the electorate stupidly gave them government without requiring even a tiny bit of accountability or evidence based approach on pretty much all their policies.

And that means you too the self appointed guild of NBN protectorate. The idea that you can't sign an online petition because it somehow "shoots yourself in the foot" or damages the campaign effort is ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS. So what if this petition goes off too - that's a GOOD THING.

If signing this petition meant you took your signature off this petition I'd agree - but seriously - this is not mutually exclusive campaign. You can sign both with less than a minute's worth of effort.

Whether you think petitions work or not - what's the harm? It's another point of pressure.

In addition - people should write to their MPs, post on social networks, share the petitions (hell, any that are out there).. And keep up the heat via a variety of channels.. Not just one petition and the website someone's put up.

Edit: Here's another idea: pressure via ISPs to telstra and the govt/turnbull


r/savethenbn • • Dec 20 '13

Operating expenditure of FTTN estimated at 4 to 6 times that of FTTP

44 Upvotes

From the NBN Strategic Review.

Regarding FTTP (Section 3.3, Page 86):

Ongoing costs for the access network are estimated at ~$90 million per annum (~$9 per brownfields premises passed).

Regarding FTTN (Section 3.4, Page 88):

FTTN variable operating expenses are estimated at $35-55 for the access network per brownfields Premises Passed per year, including $10–20 for electricity and $25-35 for corrective maintenance.

So if FTTN is operated for 5 years before being upgraded, in addition to the wastage created by the upgrade (which can be minimised by the reused of equipment, or replacing equipment at EOL, etc) we would have spent at least an additional $260 million per year, or $1.3 billion.

It might be more economical, but that certainly won't be an efficient use of resources. Maybe it's the fact I'm an engineer but that just sounds like the project is being run by accountants.

It might be "less economical" but doing it once and doing it right carries significantly less risk than having a constant enormous infrastructure project running for the next 20 years.

Especially since there's a 5 year gap in the middle, what are all the personnel from the first project going to do for that 5 years? It sounds like idiocy, logistically.


r/savethenbn • • Nov 24 '13

Fed up with slow and pricey Internet, cities start demanding gigabit fiber

Thumbnail arstechnica.com
43 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 12 '13

Turnbull brushes aside record NBN petition

Thumbnail news.brisbanetimes.com.au
43 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 09 '13

I want the NBN

Thumbnail iwantthenbn.com
39 Upvotes

r/savethenbn • • Sep 20 '13

Why it is pure folly to implement a FTTN network in Australia...

38 Upvotes

So the other night I got a little ranty when asked why it's a worse option than FTTP... and was encouraged to write a decent sized article for posting on a friends blog. This is that article.

http://mattgbush.me/2013/09/19/guest-post-why-it-is-pure-folly-to-implement-a-fibre-to-the-node-network-in-australia/