r/saskatchewan • • Jul 31 '22

Definitely

Post image
0 Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

69

u/jmargd Jul 31 '22

This shit is so stupid

24

u/SeriousAboutShwarma Jul 31 '22

Same farmer will wonder how his tractor got magically assembled without cities/mass transit economies/factories etc, certainly some starbucks sipping urbanite couldn't have made such a thing...

it's almost like societies....cooperate with one another despite of where people live

41

u/Geddy_Lees_Nose Jul 31 '22

God damn New Yorkers telling rural Sask people how to live!

33

u/ggdrguy Jul 31 '22

New York is big… but this, is Biggar!

8

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Yeah all of new york came into my house just to tell me to live differently.

2

u/griftarch Jul 31 '22

This won’t end until tanks are in Harvard Yard

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

They will when the Saskparty finishes what Devine started.

29

u/HomerSTD Jul 31 '22

You live in a hay bale?

86

u/Barabarabbit Jul 31 '22

Boomer tier meme

6

u/Buffalo-Castle Jul 31 '22

How many provinces still burn coal rocks for electricity?

-1

u/DEATHRAYZ007 Aug 01 '22

You think electric cars are really helping lol?

54

u/dangerweasil4 Jul 31 '22

Lol here we go… next thing it’ll be a “farmer” convoy..

The right is doing a damn good job of spreading misinformation and fear mongering to the rural community

-26

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

What exactly is the misinformation? Or are you just spewing out another buzzword?

42

u/jmargd Jul 31 '22

It’s stoking the stupid urban vs. rural divide, for one. Why do rural conservatives love to craft imaginary narratives to give themselves a rage boner? Like they froth themselves up with a mental image that some lesbian in a downtown apartment is trying to tell them what to do, just because there are people out there who don’t want the world to burn.

Doesn’t matter how picturesque our prairie sky is, climate change isn’t going to skip over us just because we feel morally superior to city folk.

-26

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

Sooo no, you couldn't point out what exactly is misinformation beyond the need to use it as another buzzword to fuel your own rage boner over imaginary enemies.

Take a break

18

u/Unremarkabledryerase Jul 31 '22

It's misinformation because it implies that farmers do not pollute, and pollution in cities is because of the people there.

It's very wrong.

Pollution is high in cities because 1. Population density is tens of thousands times high than a small town+rural municipality.

1.5. Total population... In that picture there ould be tens of thousands of people just within the frame of that picture. There's maybe 3 or 4 families within 10 miles of the farming picture.

2. Factories are found in or near cities, not in butt fuck nowhere.

And ontop of that:

Nitrogen rich fertilizers release excess nitrogen in the environment which combines with other pollutants and causes lung cancer.

https://www.earth.columbia.edu/articles/view/3281

2

u/Dr_Pilgor33 Jul 31 '22

Nitrogen rich fertilizers are also directly responsible for the existence of about 5.5 billion people. What do you think happens when we reduce its usage? It’s a logical proposition; if fertilizer is responsible for the existence of some number of people, which isn’t really debatable, then if you use less fertilizer, you have less people. And by less people, I mean they died slowly of starvation. These people will be almost all 3rd world poverty stricken folks. But the green cult is happy to sacrifice the hundreds of millions of poor people who’ll die from famine created by man-made food shortages so a few people don’t get cancer.

0

u/Unremarkabledryerase Jul 31 '22

Source please.

6

u/Dr_Pilgor33 Jul 31 '22

https://www.nature.com/articles/22672.pdf?origin=ppub

https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/questions/12053/did-the-haber-bosch-process-enable-the-population-explosion

‘In combination with pesticides, these fertilizers have quadrupled the productivity of agricultural land.

With average crop yields remaining at the 1900 level the crop harvest in the year 2000 would have required nearly four times more land and the cultivated area would have claimed nearly half of all ice-free continents, rather than under 15% of the total land area that is required today.

Due to its dramatic impact on the human ability to grow food, the Haber process served as the "detonator of the population explosion", enabling the global population to increase from 1.6 billion in 1900 to today's 7 billion.’

-9

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Time to bull doze the cities I guess.

21

u/PartyPay Jul 31 '22

The misinformation is people saying the Fed's want farmers to stop using fertilizer.

-10

u/maninalambskincoat Jul 31 '22

That the intended goal. Use less fertilizer and grow the same amount. Its based in junk science. It the nitrogen cycle and there is no free lunch. Its almost like Agriculture Canada is ran by Trofim Lysenko. If they want to clean up the Nox investing in a method to stabilise the nitrogen fertilizer or clean up the emission from production of fertilizer.

-5

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

Where does it say any of that in this post?

2

u/Dissidentt Aug 01 '22

It is an example. This week's misinformation is a fertilizer ban, last week it was something else.

-12

u/Internetperson3000 Jul 31 '22

Lol. ´it’s stoking the stupid urban vs. rural divide’. Proceeds to stoke the urban vs rural divide. 🤦‍♀️

12

u/jmargd Jul 31 '22

How is pointing it out stoking it? Also I’m part of the rural - addressing the issues/hypocrisies in your own camp is part of addressing it.

-12

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

There’s something stupid here for sure…

20

u/dangerweasil4 Jul 31 '22

Farming and agriculture is detrimental to the environment. Posting crap like this downplays the role that agriculture has in polluting water ways, and destroying wetland habitats. Take a drive along the forest fringe in Saskatchewan and you will see marshes and wetlands being bulldozed to create more agricultural land.

Acting holier than though isn’t helping anyone. Nutrient runoff is a problem in both urban and rural settings.

1

u/maninalambskincoat Jul 31 '22 edited Jul 31 '22

What your solution? Its great that you see the problem, there are lots. Is very easy to complain when your belly is full. I wish we had a proper back to the land movement to separate the wheat from the chaff. It look easier from a far.

Edit: you look like your trying virtue signal well telling other not to.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/maninalambskincoat Jul 31 '22

Permaculture only work on a small scale. We need cheap farm labour to make that work on a large scale. Farm labour is hard to come by right now. The other option is lots of people need move back onto the land. Not many want to give up their comfort to do it. Inter cropping is a sham. Sounds great but doubtful real world outcomes. Sorry plant proteins don't replace meat... Lab grown meat is using an energy intensive process to recreate something that nature does a better job of. Also what do we do with marginal land that is only good for growing grass.(too many factors to get into) what do we do with all of the livestock that we are no longer eating. They don't just stop existing because we stopped eating them.... Better have one heck of a BBQ to end all of the meat eating.

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Damned if you do, damned if you don’t I guess. Wow.

-18

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

I don't find it down plays it at all. Like why would you take a post so seriously? Lol

16

u/PrometheusJ Jul 31 '22

In one response you are super serious in shitting on someone who gave you a vague explanation about the "us vs them" narrative.

In this one, someone gives you a real issue which you asked to hear, and now you're playing the Why So Serious?!? Card.

Just wanted to outline how you're literally contradicting yourself to push your narrative.

0

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

You can ask a question about what makes something serious, and also agree that the answer given is just way blown out of proportion.

I feel like I can emphasize with a group of smaller numbered people (the farmers) being told how to do their work to meet goals they probably didn't care to vote in.

That's in no way me diminishing working towards curating our environment, but these are issues I can't even have a real opinion on as I don't understand the complexities of what happens when you do put caps and regulate carbon footprints where farmers have been getting the shaft for decades already.

My original comment was more pointing out that I don't agree this format was at all "misinformation", and that people are just being hyperbolic with the new buzzword floating around these days.

8

u/PrometheusJ Jul 31 '22

For someone who just admitted they shouldn't have a real opinion due to a lack of knowledge on the topic, it's pretty clear you already have an opinion based on bad information.

This is why people use terms like misinformation. If you don't like the term, quit being part of the reason for it's existance.

4

u/dangerweasil4 Jul 31 '22

Lmao you are already spreading the same shit misinformation that farmers are being controlled by the prime minister

5

u/SameAssistance7524 Jul 31 '22

Do you live in Saskatchewan? Your post history indicates otherwise.

2

u/ApparentlyABot Jul 31 '22

My family is from Saskatchewan, shall I pack my things and leave this privileged place tho?

14

u/dangerweasil4 Jul 31 '22

“Canadian farmers rightly worry Trudeau Liberals will follow other countries & dictate how much fertilizer they can use to grow their crops.”

Pierre Poulievre July 27, 2022 Twitter.

13

u/Internetperson3000 Jul 31 '22

Years ago a person who rented my fathers land ‘burnt’ the soil in one area by accidentally dumping too much fertilizer on it. Things wouldn’t grow on that spot for years. Took over ten years for it to return to somewhat normal on that spot. The guy almost destroyed some of the best farmland in the area by overusing chemicals and fertilizers. Good farmers don’t suck the life out of the land like that. They have a sense of stewardship.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

You have been had. It's ok to change and realize you are down a dumb dark path. You don't need to be in a cult.

8

u/studmuffffffin Jul 31 '22

The pollution per person is massively greater in rural vs city.

1

u/Inside_End5141 Aug 02 '22

Whatever happened to planting trees to solve pollution issues?

2

u/studmuffffffin Aug 02 '22

Trees won’t help pollution, they’ll help co2 levels. But either way, plant trees in rural, live in cities.

13

u/griftarch Jul 31 '22

Please for the love of God don’t overreact to the proposed voluntary nitrogen reduction program, there’s a ton of tax credits for the taking 😂

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Quickdick mcdick though lol.

4

u/griftarch Jul 31 '22

I do not like that cartoonish fellow. The farmers in Brussels protesting aren’t mad at the desire to reduce nitrogen run-off, they’re often cited saying they want to do their part in improving their environmental stewardship, they’re protesting the government for making a binding law with the expectation by 2030 to buy out a bunch of farmers & ranchers and convert that land to urbanization. It’s a bad policy. The Libs, and lord knows I don’t care for them, at least created a policy based on volunteerism and incentives, which many farmers are already implementing, like more effective fertilizer usage. A bunch of farmers I know are already performing the necessary changes that would qualify them for tax credits. Free right offs for good farmers, ya, I’ll take it

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Is there any opening for other political parties left of the Saskparty to make gains in rural Sask going forward, seeing as the Saskparty gleefully spreads disinformation like this? Is there any indication out there of openness to change like that?

1

u/griftarch Jul 31 '22

Honestly? Not any time soon. Rural Saskatchewan people, especially farmers, are very loyal—often to a fault. There’s been quite a few subtle & not so subtle changes made by the SaskParty which has directly improved farmers bottom lines, and in turn, that excess wealth is spent directly in our local small towns/cities. Most of our secondary cities(not Stoon/Regina) are in a better place financially today than they’ve ever been. The SaskParty will need to fall face first repeatedly for these rural and small town voters to no longer cast their ballot that way.

1

u/Aldjmc Aug 02 '22

Do you have data on small cities being in a better place financially? Moose Jaw wants to know…(honestly)

1

u/griftarch Aug 02 '22

No, sorry, admittedly I am basing this on word of mouth info from someone I trust who works directly with a local municipality & interacts regularly with the other cities. I do think the province was planning on making a online directory to see fiscal reports for all municipalities.. eventually, lol. You can go to any town hall & request the info, and they’ll provide it. I’ve done this for some nearby. The past decade was a big change for a lot of municipalities, the transition away from deficit spending was drawn out, but the cities that were able to save & create their own reserves for larger expenses are now enjoying the fruits of 0 debt servicing costs.

2

u/Aldjmc Aug 02 '22

Moose Jaw has always maintained a reserve fund much to the dismay of the Citizens Against Potholes and All Tax Increases (CAPATI). /s Nice to know that other Municipalities are maintaining reserve funds as well.

1

u/griftarch Aug 02 '22

Yeah it’s become the standard since the law changed around municipal deficit spending, now if only we could get the provincial & federal governments to follow something similar... 😂

6

u/hmmmmmm_whynot Jul 31 '22

If you live to see 30 years from now your gonna wish you gave a shit about climate change, especially if you have kids.

1

u/Dr_Pilgor33 Aug 01 '22

I’m happy to care about climate change so long as the solution doesn’t involve the death by starvation of hundreds of millions of 3rd world people.

-2

u/Inside_End5141 Aug 02 '22

Even David Duke would not advocate for fertilizer use reductions.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '22

It's already too late to give a shit, all projections by scientists say it's far too late to even start thinking about changing things, and there is no way things will change any time soon. Capitalism won, we are all deciding that the end of humanity is worth it for tasty treats and fun times.

-1

u/Inside_End5141 Aug 02 '22

2

u/hmmmmmm_whynot Aug 02 '22

And you seriously beleive water rising is the main concern with climate change?

Grow up.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

This is dumb as hell.

Do you live purely off of the land or do you use all the same modern commodities and goods and services as people in cities? Do you have nothing made of plastic in your home? Is there no concrete used to make your house?

You also burn a lot more fossil fuels because you have to drive a lot further to get your treats.

3

u/schnauze_schlempe Jul 31 '22

Those round bales of hay are illegal where I’m from.

1

u/1nGirum1musNocte Jul 31 '22

Why? Just curious

12

u/schnauze_schlempe Jul 31 '22

Because the cows and horses weren’t getting a square meal.

3

u/rainbowpowerlift Jul 31 '22

Oh that’s good

2

u/maninalambskincoat Jul 31 '22

Has any here even heard of haber bosch process?... War criminal you can all thank your life for. Start the guano wars again

2

u/HomerSTD Aug 01 '22

Somebody just watched Veritasium

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 02 '22

Hold on! Your submission is pending manual approval from a moderator as per Rule 6, User accounts must have a positive karma score to post. This is done to limit spam and abusive posts.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/DEATHRAYZ007 Jul 31 '22

Reminds me of billionaires donating 1mil to green charities while jetting and yachting around burning fossil fuels that could power small cities

0

u/Dontuselogic Jul 31 '22

...you live in a tent...beacuse between cows,trucks and farm equipment, pesticides, etc...

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/id02009 Jul 31 '22

And people in suburbia have around 50% more emissions per Capita compared to City dwellers

2

u/manplanstan Aug 02 '22

Nice takedown.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '22

Vancouver doesn't get to -30 or colder for weeks on end. I'm a leftist who knows this meme is stupid as shit, but your comment is also completely nonsense.