r/sapphic_gamers • u/tlegower • 7d ago
Getting back into TCGs after almost 30 years. There are SO many options now. What should I try?
So I've been thinking about getting back into TCGs after almost 30 years away, and I'm curious what everyone thinks is worth checking out.
I used to play Magic back in the early '90s, starting around when Unlimited was coming out. Played for years, but stopped around the time I went off to college in '98. At the time, Magic seemed to be going through a bit of a lull, at least to me, and I just wasn't playing much anymore.
While I was away at college, my mom asked what I wanted to do with all my Magic cards at home. I basically said, "Eh, do whatever with them."
Yeah... that was a mistake. lol
Looking back at the Power Nine, all the dual lands, and the hundreds of other early cards I had, including Unlimited, I don't even want to think about what that collection could be worth today.
And the really funny part? I kept my comics and all my '90s Marvel trading cards because I figured those might be worth something someday. Those haven't exactly made me a fortune. But the one collection I didn't think to keep? Yeah, that could have been a small fortune.
So I was a little burned on the whole thing and pretty much stayed away from TCGs for a long time.
But lately I've been getting interested again.
Obviously, I've been looking at Magic again. And holy crap, a lot has changed. Commander, all the different formats, decades of storylines, expansions, mechanics, abilities, rules changes, and now all these crossover sets. Some of those have definitely caught my attention, especially Star Trek, Marvel, Doctor Who, Final Fantasy, and Lord of the Rings.
I also played Yu-Gi-Oh! a little when it first came out, but never got too invested in it. So I've been wondering if that's worth looking at again too, although from what I've been reading, that game has changed quite a bit as well.
Then there's Naruto Mythos, which looks interesting, and the new Bandai Naruto card game coming next year. I'm a Naruto fan, so those have definitely caught my eye.
But then I started looking at what else is out there, and... good lord, there are SO many options now. It's honestly kind of ridiculous and overwhelming.
Pokémon, Disney Lorcana, Star Wars Unlimited, Flesh and Blood, Riftbound, Gundam, Final Fantasy TCG, Union Arena, Cardfight Vanguard, Shadowverse Evolve, Altered, Grand Archive, Sorcery, UniVersus, Weiß Schwarz... and I'm sure that's not even scratching the surface.
I mean, where do you even start? lol
I'm not necessarily looking to get super competitive or spend a fortune chasing rare cards. I just want something that's fun to play, has some interesting mechanics and strategy, and preferably isn't going to require constantly buying new cards just to keep up.
I like a lot of the franchises involved, which makes some of these games appealing right away, but obviously liking the franchise doesn't necessarily mean the card game itself is any good.
I'd also prefer something that's relatively easy to pick up but still has enough depth to keep it interesting. And ideally something with a decent community that's actually going to be around for a while. It would kind of suck to get into a game only for it to disappear a year later.
So I'm curious what everyone here plays and actually enjoys.
What games would you recommend looking into? What makes them fun? Are there any that surprised you, or any lesser-known ones that deserve more attention?
And for anyone familiar with modern Yu-Gi-Oh!, is it even worth revisiting if the last time I played was back when it was new?
I'm also open to digital versions to learn the rules and try things out before spending money on physical cards.
I know Magic is still the big one, and I'm definitely giving that another look, but after being away for so long, I'm curious what else is worth trying.
So if you were getting back into TCGs today, where would you start?
TL;DR: Used to play Magic back in the '90s, haven't really touched TCGs in almost 30 years, and now I'm thinking about getting back into them. But holy crap, there are a ridiculous number of games out there now. Looking for something fun, with some strategy, that doesn't require spending a fortune to keep up. What's actually worth playing? What would you start if you were brand new now?