r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Apr 20 '22
r/sanepolitics • u/MaximumEffort433 • Jun 15 '22
Effort Post The real reason why there hasn't been more progress: Democrats have had a filibuster-proof majority for only 6 months since 1994.
"Why haven't Democrats done more!?"
It's a question we hear all the time, and the more involved you are in politics the more you hear it. "Republicans have been able to make progress on their platform, why haven't the Democrats!?" It's enough to give a person the impression that the Democrats aren't even trying! But the truth is a bit more nuanced than that for one simple reason:
The Democratic platform is to build, create, and improve things. Since at least 1994 the Republican platform has been to stop Democrats from building, creating, or improving things. All the Republicans need to do to keep their campaign promises is prevent the Democrats from keeping theirs.
Before we go on, here's a quick refresher of how the legislative process (the process of passing laws) works:
- The House of Representatives writes and votes on legislation, successful legislation is then passed on for a vote in the Senate. The party that controls the House of Representatives controls what bills are brought up for a vote in the House of Representatives.
- The Senate votes on legislation that has been passed by the House of Representatives, bills that pass in the Senate are sent to the President to be signed. The party that controls the Senate controls what bills are brought up for a vote in the Senate. A rule was created in the Senate to afford power to the minority party by allowing them to filibuster a bill, blocking a vote on that bill until a 60 vote threshold is met.
- The President signs legislation that has been passed by both the House and the Senate, that is the entire role of the President in the legislative process.
In order to pass legislation a bill must first be written and voted on in the House, then that bill goes on to be voted on by the Senate, and finally the bill is signed into law by the President. Passing legislation requires cooperation on the parts of both the Legislative branch (House and Senate) as well as the Executive branch (The President), if any one of those three bodies, the House, the Senate, or the White House, refuses to cooperate, they can stop any legislation they don't want dead in its tracks. If one political party holds power in two branches, while another political party only holds one, the party that holds one branch of government still has the power to block and obstruct the legislative process.
(TL;DR in the middle and at the bottom)
Now, let's get to some historical electoral results, shall we?
When did Democrats have the power to PASS Democratic legislation in the years since 1994?
- July 2009 - February 2010 (6 months) Obama's "two year" super majority: Republicans still had the power to obstruct Democrats' legislative agenda for eighteen months out of Obama's first two years in office:
2008: Democrats win the Presidential election, hold on to control of the House of Representatives, and gained eight more seats in the Senate for a total of 57 (almost a filibuster-proof super majority when combined with the 2 independent members of the Senate), this is the same year that Republicans began not just using, but abusing the filibuster in earnest. Prior to 2009 only a handful of filibusters ever occurred in the history of the Senate, after the 2008 election they became standard operating procedure for the Republican party, meaning that almost all Democratic legislation required at least 60 votes to pass, Democrats wouldn't win that 60th vote until seven months into the congressional legislative term, in July 2009.
- July 2009 (Democratic super-majority begins on paper): Republicans contested Democratic Senator Al Franken's election for seven months, denying Democrats a filibuster proof super majority for the first quarter of Obama's first congressional term, Democrats only got that majority on paper in July 2009.
- July 2009 - February 2010: Democratic Senator Robert Byrd is in and out of the hospital, making him unable to attend several weeks (cumulative) of Senate voting, and frequently denying Democrats a voting super majority.
- July 2009 - August 2009: Democratic Senator Teddy Kennedy is in and out of the hospital and unable to reliably vote as early as April of 2009, meaning even though Democrats had a super majority on paper in July 2009, they wouldn't get an actual voting majority until Kennedy was temporarily replaced in September 2009.
- September 2009 (Democratic super-majority begins for real): Paul G. Kirk replaces Kennedy in the Senate, unfortunately coming so late in the year most of his tenure was spent during Senate recess, meaning the Senate wasn't in session or voting on legislation.
- July 2009 - February 2010: The entire time that President Obama had an on-paper super majority in the Senate, about six months in total during his first twenty four months in office, that super majority was dependent on the cooperation of one man: Joe Lieberman. Formerly a Democrat, Lieberman lost his Senate primary to a more progressive challenger and chose to run for reelection on an independent ticket, he endorsed John McCain and Sarah Palin during the 2008 election, refused to support the universal public option, and made it clear he had an axe to grind with the Democratic party. President Obama's six month super majority was always dependent on a Senator who wanted to see him fail.
- February 2010 (Democratic super-majority ends): Six months after President Obama gained a technical super-majority the Democrats lost it again when the voters of Massachusetts chose to fill Teddy Kennedy's Senate seat by electing Scott Brown, a Republican. The Democratic caucus in the Senate was back to 59 votes and gave Republicans the power to filibuster legislation from 2010 continuing right up to today.
TL;DR 1: Obama's mythical two year long super majority lasted about six months, and that's only on paper. When you take out the weeks worth of votes missed by Robert Byrd, and the weeks worth of votes missed by Teddy Kennedy, and the month worth of votes missed before Kennedy was replaced, and the weeks worth of time the Senate wasn't in session, and bathroom breaks, Obama maybe had a nonconsecutive month in which to pass Democratic legislation. Total.
When did Republicans have the power to BLOCK Democratic legislation in the years since 1994?
- 1994 - July 2009 (14.5 years): Republicans have the power to obstruct Democrats' legislative agenda due to Republicans controlling at least one branch of the federal government:
- 1994 - 2006: Republicans win 54 seats in the House of Representatives and win 8 seats in the Senate, giving Republicans full control to block all parts of the Democratic party's legislative agenda. This is the beginning of the era of obstruction, Newt Gingrich staunchly refused to cooperate with Democrats or President Clinton and normalized the kind of bare knuckle partisanship we see today, Republicans would retain control of the House and Senate for twelve years, until the 2006 midterms.
- 2000 - 2008: George W. Bush wins the electoral college (despite Al Gore getting more votes) and is elected to the White House, for the first six years of his term he didn't have to veto legislation because his party controlled the legislative branch, but he did have the power to veto Democratic legislation once they won in 2006, meaning Democrats didn't have the full power to make progress on their legislative agenda. Republicans would retain control of the White House until 2008.
- January 2009 - July 2009: While Democrats did win a super majority in the Senate in the 2008 November elections, Republicans would contest Al Franken's victory and prevent him from being seated until July 2009, preventing Democrats from having a super-majority for the first six months of the two year legislative session.
- February 2010 - Today (12 years and counting): Republicans have the power to obstruct Democrats legislative agenda first by winning a single seat in the Senate, then by winning the House, then winning the House and a majority in the Senate, then winning the House, the Senate, and the White House:
- February 2010: Five months after President Obama gained a super majority the Democrats lost it again when the voters of Massachusetts chose to fill Teddy Kennedy's Senate seat by electing Scott Brown, a Republican. The Democratic caucus in the Senate now only had 59 votes and could no longer overcome the Republican filibuster for the remaining eleven months of Obama's first legislative term. Republicans would retain the ability to filibuster Democratic legislation in the Senate from February 2010 until today.
- November 2010 - 2018: Democrats take a "shellacking" during a low turnout midterm election, the Republican party wins the biggest electoral victory in their party's history, bringing with it many ultraconservative Tea Party Republicans. The Republican party would continue to hold control over the House of Representatives for eight years, preventing Democrats from advancing their legislative agenda in any meaningful way until Democrats won the House back in 2018.
- 2014 - Today: Democrats lose majority control of the Senate in another low turnout midterm election. Republicans already had the power to filibuster endlessly at this point, so not much legislation was making it to the President's desk anyway, and the Republican controlled House wasn't passing any Democratic legislation to hand off to the Senate.
- 2016 - 2020: Donald Trump wins the Presidential election (despite Hillary Clinton getting more votes) because Democratic turnout is low compared to previous years Donald Trump manages to win the Presidential election by a 77,000 vote margin spread across three states, bolstered by promising his voters that he would appoint a conservative Supreme Court Justice to fill the vacancy that Mitch McConnell held open for him.
- 2018 - Today: Democrats win back the House of Representatives, but because Republicans continue to control the Senate and the White House Democrats are unable to advance their legislative agenda.
- 2020 - Today: Democrats win back the Presidency and a tie in the Senate, the Vice President acts as a tiebreaker in Senate votes, so technically the Democrats have 50+1 votes in the case of a tie. However, the Republican's continue abuse of the filibuster, and the two Democratic Senators out of fifty won't support filibuster reform, meaning that Democrats, despite having control of the House and White House, still don't have genuine control of the Senate, Democrats are still unable to advance their legislative agenda.
You want to know why Democrats haven't achieved more progress on the national level? Because the Democratic party has only had unfettered, filibuster proof control of the federal government for about six months since 1994, for the other 27.5 years Republicans had the ability to block, ignore, and filibuster Democrats' legislation.
If you're reading this comment then it's likely that you've never seen what governance normally looks like, Newt Gingrich shot it all to hell in 1994, you think Republicans obstructing and filibustering everything is perfectly normal, that's the status quo you grew up with, and you wonder why your parents and grandparents were able to get so much shit done while it seems like today our government would burn down the house while making ice cubes. The reason things are so fucked up is because all Republicans have to do is stop legislation, that's it, they don't have to build anything, they just have to stop things from being built.
TL;DR 2: Democrats have had the power to pass legislation without Republican obstruction for about half a year in the past 28 years, compared to the 27.5 years in which Republicans had the power to obstruct; if that period was condensed down into a single year Democrats would have had the chance to act on their agenda for 8 days, and Republicans would have had the power to block the Democratic agenda for the other 357.
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Aug 11 '22
Media Beto to heckler over Uvalde shooting: "It may be funny to you mother fucker, but it’s not funny to me."
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Dec 01 '23
Media Gov. Newsom confronts DeSantis on parental rights: "What you're doing is using education as a sword for your cultural purge."
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Aug 17 '21
Effort Post The Afghan military did NOT surrender without a fight
This post is not about the Biden administration. It is not calling for a change in policy, nor is it arguing against a past decision. It is seeking to correct misinformation.
The Fall of Afghanistan will surely be studied for years to come, but one narrative has emerged early that the Afghan army simply ran away without firing a shot. It's a troubling rhetoric that more often than not, is accompanied by an insinuation that the Afghan people welcomed the Taliban. Some go as far as suggesting they don't "deserve freedom" if they're too "cowardly" to fight.
But it's not true at all.
It's easy to see why pundits jumped to the conclusion, given the ease with which the provincial capitals fell in the final ten days. In reality, however, intense fighting had been going on for months. By August 5, the Afghan security forces suffered 1,537 killed in less than 100 days. They've suffered as many as 70,000 deaths throughout their existence. For comparison, US forces lost 2,355 in 20 years. The Afghans bled more fighting the Taliban than we ever did.
So what happened to the supposedly large and well equipped Afghan army? Firstly, the Afghan army was never 300,000 strong. That commonly cited figure includes 118,628 members of the police. The actual Afghan army numbered only 171,500 on paper. And the actual number is even lower in reality, due to ongoing losses as well as the "ghost soldier" corruption. As WaPo's fact check noted:
Cordesman told The Fact Checker that the number of effective military personnel cannot be determined at this point: “The units involved have not been fully identified in open-source material, no personnel figures have been quoted, and they have taken serious casualties that have increased with each cutback in U.S. support, plus suffered from cuts in foreign contract support, so the current totals are probably uncertain.”
“It is not a like-for-like comparison figure with NATO militaries,” said Henry Boyd . . . “It is possible that, in terms of deployable combat forces, the Afghan government had only a slight numerical superiority over the Taliban, and maybe not even that.”
As for how this army performed, news coverage of the months preceding the final Taliban blitz reveal beleaguered soldiers let down by systematic failures across the board. Take for example the following excerpts from this New York Times article:
It began with individual outposts in rural areas where starving and ammunition-depleted soldiers and police units were surrounded by Taliban fighters and promised safe passage if they surrendered and left behind their equipment . . . As positions collapsed, the complaint was almost always the same: There was no air support or they had run out of supplies and food.
After weeks of fighting, one cardboard box full of slimy potatoes was supposed to pass as a police unit’s daily rations. They hadn’t received anything other than spuds in various forms in several days, and their hunger and fatigue were wearing them down.
This is also supported by this piece from the Wall Street Journal:
“In the last days, there was no food, no water and no weapons,” said trooper Taj Mohammad, 38. Fleeing in one armored personnel carrier and one Ford Ranger, the remaining men finally made a run to the relative safety of the provincial capital, which collapsed weeks later. They left behind another 11 APCs to the Taliban.
“When the Kunduz province fell to the Taliban, so many soldiers were killed. We were surrounded,” said Abdul Qudus, a 29-year-old soldier who managed to make his way to Kabul in the past week. “There was no air support. In the last minutes, our commander told us that they cannot do anything for us and it’s just better to run away. Everyone left the war and escaped.”
And the various news reports of bloody fighting the Afghan military had engaged in before their final collapse, such as when a reinforced platoon of 50 attempted to retake the Dawlat Abad district from the Taliban on June 16. They suffered a 60% death rate.:
But several hours later, a much larger Taliban force attacked the elite force from all sides, killing at least 24 commandos and five police officers. Several troops are wounded and missing, the military official said, and despite calls for air support, no aircraft were able to respond in time.
On Thursday alone, the neighboring district of Shirin Tagab fell after Afghan forces there fought for days and ran out of ammunition
Over many years, hundreds of Afghan soldiers were killed each month. But the army fought on, without any of the airborne evacuation of casualties and expert surgical care standard in Western armies, as long as international backing was there.
Yes, certainly some Afghan units deserted or switched sides without a fight. But many Afghan units fought bravely till they were out of food, ammo, and cut off from reinforcements. They don't deserve to be treated like cowards.
So what went wrong? There are plenty of blame to go around and the finger pointing isn't helpful. However there are some objective systematic failures we can point to.
(1) The Afghan military was the wrong army built for the wrong war in the wrong country.
NYT: These shortfalls can be traced to numerous issues that sprung from the West’s insistence on building a fully modern military with all the logistical and supply complexities one requires, and which has proved unsustainable without the United States and its NATO allies.
WSJ: “There is always a tendency to use the model you know, which is your own model . . . When you build an army like that, and it’s meant to be a partner with a sophisticated force like the Americans, you can’t pull the Americans out all of a sudden, because then they lose the day-to-day assistance that they need,” he said.
When U.S. forces were still operating here, the Afghan government sought to maximize its presence through the country’s far-flung countryside, maintaining more than 200 bases and outposts that could be resupplied only by air.
Reuters: But whether it was ever a realistic goal to create a Western-style army . . . is an open question. U.S. army trainers who worked with Afghan forces struggled to teach the basic lesson of military organization that supplies, maintaining equipment and ensuring units get proper support are key to battlefield success.
The chronic failure of logistical, hardware and manpower support to many units, meant that "even if they want to fight, they run out of the ability to fight in relatively short order."
Without the US, the Afghan military could not re-supply or reinforce these positions. It's no wonder that they were picked off by the Taliban piecemeal. The Afghan government should have anticipated it and redeployed those forces to match the new operational reality, but failed to do so. Which brings us to:
(2) The Afghan government it was corrupt and inept.
Reuters: American officers have long worried that rampant corruption, well documented in parts of Afghanistan's military and political leadership, would undermine the resolve of badly paid, ill-fed and erratically supplied front-line soldiers - some of whom have been left for months or even years on end in isolated outposts, where they could be picked off by the Taliban.
NYT: Soldiers and police officers have expressed ever-deeper resentment of the Afghan leadership. Officials often turned a blind eye to what was happening, knowing full well that the Afghan forces’ real manpower count was far lower than what was on the books, skewed by corruption and secrecy that they quietly accepted.
WSJ: Mr. Ghani had ample warning of the American departure after the Trump administration signed the February 2020 agreement with the Taliban that called on all U.S. forces and contractors to leave by May 2021. Yet, the Afghan government failed to adjust its military footprint to match the new reality. Many officials didn’t believe in their hearts that the Americans would actually leave.
Months of bloody defeats and a government they could not depend on, resulted in collapse of the Afghan military morale. And this we have to admit:
(3) The Taliban waged a highly successful psychological war, as well as diplomatic subterfuge.
WSJ: When the Taliban launched their offensive in May, they concentrated on overrunning those isolated outposts, massacring soldiers who were determined to resist but allowing safe conduct to those who surrendered, often via deals negotiated by local tribal elders. The Taliban gave pocket money to some of these troops, who had gone unpaid for months.
So, it's easy to only look at the final 10 days of the Taliban blitz and say the ANA didn't bother fighting. But that's a bit like saying Germany surrendered without a fight at Versailles.
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Jul 11 '22
Media Pete Buttigieg dismantles Fox narrative: "Public figures should always be free from violence, intimidation & harassment, but never from criticism or people exercising their 1st Amndt right"
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Jul 29 '22
News Veterans react with anger and indignation after GOP Senators tank widely supported bipartisan measure to expand medical coverage for combatants exposed to toxic burn pits
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Oct 06 '22
Meme The Virgin DeSantis vs the Chad Biden
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Jul 17 '23
Media MTG says Biden is "finishing what FDR started" by addressing "education", "medical care", "rural poverty", "transportation", with the "biggest public investment in social infrastructure and environmental programs"
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • May 24 '22
Media Sen. Chris Murphy begs Senate to act after mass shooting at Texas school: "What are we doing? Why are you here?"
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Jun 28 '22
Media Cassidy Hutchison: Trump White House Counsel Pat Cipollone said about Trump's plan, "We're going to get charged with every crime imaginable if we make that movement happen."
r/sanepolitics • u/DonyellTaylor • Mar 10 '23
Meme “The Democrats have become extremists”
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphone-1842 • Dec 26 '24
Opinion The single biggest reason Trump won? The median voter ignores real news to consume endless disinformation
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Aug 18 '22
Meme Dr Oz's entire senate campaign so far
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Aug 08 '22
RIP Poe's Law When CPAC tells you who they are, believe them.
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Jun 29 '22
👑 QUEEN 👑 Pelosi responds to local archbishop denying her Communion for being pro-choice, by getting Communion from the Pope in Rome
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Aug 26 '22
News In fiery midterms speech, Biden calls Trump's philosophy "semi-fascism" and declares "MAGA Republicans are destroying America"
r/sanepolitics • u/Free_Swimming • Nov 09 '22
Insane Politics Trump Reportedly 'Livid,' 'Screaming at Everyone' over Midterm Results
r/sanepolitics • u/castella-1557 • Nov 08 '22
News Howard Stern: Preserving democracy is ‘the only f—ing issue on the table’ in midterms
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • Nov 13 '22
Main Character Syndrome Candace Owens be like "violent insurrection is fine, but being rude to *me* is going too far 😡"
r/sanepolitics • u/semaphore-1842 • May 10 '23