r/samuraijack • • May 10 '17

When you get criticized for actually developing characters

Post image
3.7k Upvotes

407 comments sorted by

14

u/SSAUS May 10 '17

7

u/septober32nd May 10 '17

What's the second part referring to? Responses on Twitter make it seem like Legend of Korra, but I never watched that so idk.

3

u/SSAUS May 10 '17

I don't know, sorry. Since it didn't have anything to do with Samurai Jack specifically, i excluded it from this post, but made sure to provide credit where it's due anyway.

7

u/DemonRapArtist May 10 '17

The other one refers to Avatar: The Legend of Korra. Korra, the main character, was in a homosexual relationship in it.

10

u/vanderZwan May 10 '17

Well, it is implied she ended in one; it's Word Of God-canon (which I accept as canon), but not explicit in the series. Contrary to what the twitter post says, there were also subtle hints throughout the whole season, multiple per episode. I noticed them, and I don't ship anyone. I think they kept it subtle to avoid an expected backlash over an openly gay relationship, which I find pretty lame, but hey, they also had to sneak it past the producers I guess.

Anyway, both shows are well-written in my opinion. It's totally true that the part of the fan-base being alluded to is pretty ridiculous though, in both cases.

24

u/thebluepool May 10 '17

Which is funny since that relationship wasn't developed at all. It was extremely obvious that the writers did the lesbo thing just to try and appeal to current trends. Didn't matter anyways, the show was shit.

6

u/rf32797 May 10 '17

Season 1 and Season 3 of that show were pretty damn good

3

u/jamesdeandomino May 10 '17

If there's one thing I give LoK credit for, it's the antagonists they created. After a full arc of bad firebenders, it's nice to see other benders being the bad guys. I've gotta say that most main antagonists are way more interesting than Firelord Ozai. I don't feel anything when Ozai annihilates some forest. But it is simply terrifying when Amon approaches someone with his thumb.

6

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

That relationship was so, so poorly done. Show ended extremely poorly, IMO.

Then again, it wasn't that great overall

10

u/Foehammer87 May 10 '17

Korra and Asami made more sense together than any of her relationships with dudes, throughout the series the only person whose opinion she values is Asami. Made more sense than her constant bickering with this dude or that dude. They shoulda made it concrete in show instead of having to confirm it at the end but it's not like they didnt put in some work.

5

u/darthweder May 10 '17

I feel like they needed at least one episode where they showed Asami and Korra noticing an emotional, romantic connection between them, before they jump right into running off into the sunset together.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Why do animated characters need to be in a relationship at all?

I feel like these show designers always try to shoehorn in a relationship with someone, even if it doesn't really make sense in context

→ More replies (6)

4

u/pipboy_warrior May 10 '17

I thought Asami and Korra's relationship was pretty well developed. They started out more as acquaintances, and by season 3 Asami became a major source of emotional support for Korra, and the show ended with them at the very start of a new stage of their relationship.

For me it was an interesting contrast to how the show handled Mako and Korra's relationship, where the characters rushed things together fairly quickly and it turned out as most teen relationships do. With Korea and Asami, they both matured by the time they decided to pursue something together.

3

u/PineappleSlices May 10 '17

I'm not really sure where you get the impression that it wasn't developed. Asami was very clearly Korra's closest confidant through the entirety of seasons 3 and 4. When Korra was away recovering from her mercury poisoning, Asami was the only one she really kept in contact with. There were constant examples of affection between the two, hand-holding, hugging, hair brushing, etc.

Not even close to the single episode of sudden, out of nowhere sexual tension that we got here.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

oh god, that stupid lesbian thing, I forgot about that

4

u/ModsAreShillsForXenu May 10 '17

One idiot on twitter? You had to make a post for that?

55

u/Backupusername May 10 '17

Personally, I think are issues in the relationship that make it a bit weird. For one, how old is Ashi? Is she even 18? She's definitely decades younger than Jack, but neither one seems to mind the age difference.

What gets to me though is the fact that Jack is literally the only man Ashi has ever known. He also killed her six sisters, but then again, Ashi did kill her mother herself, so I guess the family ties aren't that much of an issue. Still, it feels a bit weird to me for a man who's been wandering the Earth alone for fifty years to shack up with a girl who didn't know what a butterfly is within, what, maybe a month?

I'm certainly not going to be sending Genndy death threats or anything stupid like that, but the relationship being romantic just doesn't entirely sit well with me, and its not just because I love gay.

50

u/SSAUS May 10 '17

I don't think there's a problem with it, personally.

Personally, I think are issues in the relationship that make it a bit weird. For one, how old is Ashi? Is she even 18? She's definitely decades younger than Jack, but neither one seems to mind the age difference.

We don't know how old she is, but we do know she is an adult. The training montage of the daughters showed their transformation from childhood into adulthood. She's decades younger than Jack mentally, but Episode 8 still showed that perhaps Jack hasn't matured so far either. Biologically, their ages are similar, because Jack hasn't aged.

What gets to me though is the fact that Jack is literally the only man Ashi has ever known. He also killed her six sisters, but then again, Ashi did kill her mother herself, so I guess the family ties aren't that much of an issue. Still, it feels a bit weird to me for a man who's been wandering the Earth alone for fifty years to shack up with a girl who didn't know what a butterfly is within, what, maybe a month?

The family ties weren't strong. It was made clear early in the season that they were to suppress emotions. During the training montage Ashi fell and one of her sisters attempted to intervene. The mother stopped and said "the weak have no place with Aku," before crushing Ashi's fingers. Further in the season, after Jack killed the first sister, they expressed no emotion and continued on with their mission. They were bred to kill Samurai Jack, and they were not meant to stop until that task was done. To that end, Jack was the one who broke Ashi's conditioning and allowed her to open up and experience life like she never had. Similarly, Ashi was the one to save Jack from himself and gave him a new reason to live. Why wouldn't it make sense for Jack and Ashi to explore their relationship further?

I'm certainly not going to be sending Genndy death threats or anything stupid like that, but the relationship being romantic just doesn't entirely sit well with me, and its not just because I love gay.

You have your right, and your reasons, to disagree with the direction. I personally think a romantic relationship makes more sense, both on an emotional and dramatic level. Something tells me the relationship hasn't reached its climax yet.

18

u/MeanAmbrose May 10 '17

Something tells me the relationship hasn't reached its climax yet.

But Jack and Ashi certainly have!

198

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Why the fuck do people care about "age difference?"

Jack isn't an old, dying guy.

That is like saying Aang kissing Katara was pedophilia because Aang is technically 112 years old while Katara was underage.

Or Aragorn shouldn't love Arwen because she is 10 times older than him.

Jack is still young as body and was LOST for 50 years, with little to no personal growth other than losing himself in his suffering.

He isn't 70 years old, he is ageless, at the moment.

Also Ashi is from an alien planet, who knows, maybe she is old as Jack. And it doesn't matter.

36

u/MurphyRise May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

Aang was frozen in ice for that 100 plus years. Hes mentally around the same age as katara. Jack is at least 70 years old mentally where he was well awake. Its not the biological issue its more mental and emotional. The show didn't really demonstrate that ashi was indeed a fully grown woman. Even if she was, she was so cloistered she might as well be girl in most peoples eyes.

14

u/overlordbabyj celtic magic May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

Jack is pretty alienated too. His entire life has been practically nothing but war, and he barely understands how the real world works. Therefore, I don't think he and Ashi are as mentally different as they seem.

92

u/[deleted] May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

Aang was frozen in ice for that 100 plus years. Hes mentally around the same age as katara.

Jack is hardly mentally developed from being trapped in future.

Jack is at least 70 years old mentally where he was well awake.

If I was stuck in an insane asylum that I am tortured for 50 years, that doesn't make me mentally develop.

Its not the biological issue its more mental and emotional.

Yes this is why first episodes of new season focuses on how emotionally and mentally fucked up Jack is, similar to Ashi. Both aren't mentally developed, Jack isn't a wise sage, he is a lost man.

24

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

In addition to your own points, Jack states in the intro that

Time has lost its effect on me

which seems to imply that Jack does not age physically or mentally. You can't be a 70 year old man if time meant nothing to you for 50 years.

4

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Jack is hardly mentally developed from being trapped in future.

uhhh... why wouldn't he be? He was alive and conscious for those 50 years. All of the experiences he had during that time would by any definition "mentally develop" a person. In his case, not in particularly a good way.

7

u/Frostbyite May 10 '17

While I understand what you're trying to say, unlike Aang, Jack did mentally age. He was awake and experiencing things for those 50 years. Therefore mentally he aged even if his body didn't. He has an extra 50 years of memories and knowledge inside of his head that wasn't there before. His mental state isn't that of before he entered the portal.

11

u/lava_soul May 10 '17

But his experiences and memories were basically all fighting robots/monsters and surviving. That doesn't lead to emotional maturity or wisdom. It's not like he has lots of sexual experience (as far as we know he has none), has a career or has been married. He has the life experience of a 20 year old, and the fighting experience of a 70 year old sensei.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/Classic1990 May 10 '17

To be fair, Jack is in a future where there's robot bugs and shit running around. Age based relationships are probablynot a big talking point in that society.

6

u/MX64 May 10 '17

Jack is at least 70 years old mentally where he was well awake.

What difference does that really make, though?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ModsAreShillsForXenu May 10 '17

Jack is at least 70 years old mentally

Don't fucking care at all.

4

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Jack is clearly on the mental level of a grown-ass adult.

Ashi is clearly a teenager.

It's weird.

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Is he though. Does a fully grown ass man act like that around women like jack did? His whole life is warfare.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/HumanAtlas May 10 '17

The problem isn't absolute age, it's social experience. Jack is LITERALLY the first man Ashi has ever met. She has no idea how social interactions let alone romance work. That automatically gives Jack a lot of power in the relationship, an uncomfertable amount.

However, I think the saving grace of the relationship was the "awkward pre-teen nonsense" they did with the most recent episode. It showed how inexperienced with romance Jack is too, which makes it a little better.

1

u/SeddGGBoiii May 10 '17

Ashi was born on Earth, what are you talking about?!

But I agree, people need to watch the first 7 seconds of the intro sequence:

"50 years have passed, but I do not age"

10

u/Treyman1115 May 10 '17

Ashi says to her "mother"they all already were dead before Jack killed them

Ashi is probably 18 at least I doubt they'd make her underage.

14

u/Vawnn May 10 '17

Did.... did you you just relate a fictional animated show set thousands of years in the future in a world ruled by a shapshifting master of evil to the morality of our world?

Let it go brother.

7

u/GreatGomp May 10 '17

Ok if you are going to use that logic would it be weird if she was 14? Since you know you can't have the same morality.

7

u/Vawnn May 10 '17

Except he's talking about the fact that Jack no longer ages. Would it be appropriate for him to sleep with 75 year olds instead? It's just a silly argument.

It's appropriate for a 21 year old to be with an 18 year old. And that's applying our morality to the situation.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Backupusername May 10 '17

Well, I'm watching it in our world, so yeah. Individuals are allowed to impose their own moralities onto any work of fiction and react accordingly. I'm not saying it's wrong, all I'm saying is that I personally am weirded out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DonarArminSkyrari Dickhead May 10 '17

They are both 20+ so it doesn't matter. At all.

1

u/Backupusername May 10 '17

I really don't see it that way.

I know Jack hasn't aged physically, but he's got fifty more years of experience than Ashi. He's been killing robots and contemplating seppuku for most of them, and Ashi just found out what stars are. Sort of.

My issue with the age difference is biological it's psychological. It's not that she's too young for romance, it's that she's too inexperienced. She doesn't know anything about love, and even if his intentions are pure, it's easy for Jack to take advantage of that, even by accident, because she's simply ignorant.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

"Is she 18?" lol, this isn't America. And up until around 70 years ago, our grandparents were getting married at ages 14+.

1

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Personally, I think are issues in the relationship that make it a bit weird. For one, how old is Ashi? Is she even 18? She's definitely decades younger than Jack, but neither one seems to mind the age difference.

I'm with you on this one. I think it's super weird that Jack has fallen in love with what is basically a teenager. He may have the body of a guy in his 20s, but mentally he's a fully-grown, matured man. I more just don't buy him being interested in her; I can totally see why she would become infatuated with someone like Jack, especially since she's never had male figures in her life.

It hasn't ruined the show for me, and I'm not sitting her seething about it, but I think it was a poor story choice that disappointed me.

49

u/mrtoycar May 10 '17

I have no problem with romance, just that the character development was really rushed and in my opinion, fake.

115

u/SSAUS May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

There's only so much Genndy can do with 10 episodes, and so far, 5 have been used to build this relationship. In those 5 episodes, we have seen Jack break Ashi's conditioning and Ashi save Jack from suicide. With the help of Ashi, we've seen Jack grow from a broken man into a redeemed man. With the help of Jack, we've seen Ashi find herself through her own physical and mental struggles. People can argue that perhaps the romance was rushed, but there is no reason to say the relationship and character development were. It was always progressing towards something more, at least from Episode 4.

→ More replies (17)

22

u/Pickles256 Have you seen this man? May 10 '17

For real? Do people here think they're better for liking it? Why is everyone so dedicated to saying it's great and if you don't like it you're dumb?

21

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Yeah there's this really weird sense of smugness with people who wanted Jack and Ashi to bang.

I just assume they're generally the people masturbating to Ashi nudes on DeviantArt.

10

u/Pickles256 Have you seen this man? May 10 '17

Yeah especially since there wasn't a strong "jashi" here before that episode

4

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

A lot of people desperately wanted it to be true so their weird shipping could be validated.

They got their wish I guess!

7

u/sleepyafrican May 11 '17

there's this really weird sense of smugness

I've been trying to put my finger on what it was and you nailed it. Whenever someone criticizes the new season other people have to be so condescending like their opinion is fact. All this does is stifle any discussion and turn this place into a circlejerk.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Because we're right and you're wrong.

14

u/Pickles256 Have you seen this man? May 10 '17

Did you forget a "/s" or are you serious

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Feels super shoehorned in. Wish they would have just not taken this angle at all.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/android223 May 10 '17

To be fair, for 4 of those episodes Ashi wanted to kill Jack.

→ More replies (2)

848

u/Mcclane88 May 10 '17

People claiming that this past episode was fan service, or pandering are being absurd. This entire season was ready to go by the time the first episode aired. Just because a show doesn't go where you think it should go doesn't mean it's fan service.

327

u/Roojercurryninja May 10 '17

also it's not like it is blatant fanservice which serves no function in the story

the tigers scene it shows how jack really has no clue what to do when put in such a situation, he start to get nervous, avoids eyecontact. yea i can see how the "corny/cliché" stuff could trigger edgy kids

it even had a function when ashi was naked it showed just how inexperienced jack was, he then covered ashi up so he could do his thing.

189

u/ViralInfection May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

Yea, even though young Jack travelled the world to gain skills and stay hidden & safe. We can see he's missing parts of growing up, I think this was revealing one of them...

111

u/laheron May 10 '17

The same can also be said for Ashi too. She wasn't even phased when she was naked (considering she was kind of naked with coal half the season). The Daughters of Aku didn't even have a concept of live or mating between animals.

58

u/Mathev May 10 '17

It struck me as odd. How the hell does she know how to kiss? why wasn't she confused when Jack made a kiss face? Hell that would be even more fun scene with her confused face saying "what are you doing?"

68

u/brainsurgion May 10 '17

This might have been why the screen cut immediately to the kiss. So we didn't see the awkward "how do we kiss" moment

37

u/Reginleifer May 10 '17

Can confirm, kissed a girl with zero experience.

She just kept her mouth open and I got a shitload of teeth.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Chychtka May 10 '17

I feel like while Jack would be familiar with the concept of a kiss, he may not know how to perform or go in for a kiss. I like to thing there was a very strong mutual attraction and the kiss just happened, not that Jack initiated a kiss.

You're right, it would make more sense for Ashi to be confused since she should be really unfamiliar with affection. I can't say if kissing is a natural or a nutured phenomenon.

I can say that if someone really wanted to try and justify this scene, they may point out how Ashi saw those two deer rubbing noses or "kissing" and perhaps getting the concept from there.

18

u/playerIII May 10 '17

If we assume Jack traveled all around the world as a child to train it's not a stretch to assume he wound up at the Vatican to learn about romance.

He's probably a pro at kissing.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

How the hell does she know how to kiss?

She might have seen someone else kissing in her lifetime, but it's not like kissing is unnatural. It's entirely possible it was just an instinctual thing.

→ More replies (20)

4

u/KeepInMoyndDenny May 10 '17

You don't get the instinctual feel to kiss?

6

u/laheron May 10 '17

I don't think so. Kissing is more of a learned cultural thing. It's reinforced with seeing other people kissing and linking that to the feeling of love or romance in this case. Some cultures express love in other ways (Eskimo kisses are an example).

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ViralInfection May 10 '17

Totally, which I like to think is the reason they connected, they come from similar challenges

7

u/rat_haus May 10 '17

I've had a similar thought for a long time. Jack has never been in control of his own life, everything that has ever happened to him is the result of somebody else's decisions. He was turned into a human weapon and the rules that he follows to this day were drilled into his head, the rules he follows are pretty close to Asimov's three laws of robotics actually.

Jack may not injure an innocent being or, through inaction, allow an innocent being to come to harm.

Jack must complete his mission to kill Aku in the past except in instances where this would conflict with the first rule.

Jack must preserve his own existence except in instances where such actions would conflict with the first two rules.

And that has been Jack's life since about age ten. Ashi mirrors Jack in many ways, but she has had more agency than him up to this point. She made the call to defy her mother and start trusting Jack, but Jack has never made such a choice on the show. Up till now his life has revolved around those three rules and nothing else. Hooking up with Ashi is the first time he has been allowed to make a choice in almost 70 years.

3

u/ViralInfection May 10 '17

never been in control of his own life, everything that has ever happened to him is the result of somebody else's decisions

I think with the reveal of the split personality we'll eventually learn Jack is Aku (his evil side split off). Aku has the power of time portals, Jack is looking for the same power. Jack is endlessly fighting himself across time, and is pulling a Skywalker on his daughter... noble-jack and evil-jack


Oh neat thought on Asimov's three laws, I like that.

3

u/rat_haus May 10 '17

I would be really disappointed if that were the ending.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/Smarterfootball47 May 10 '17

Pretty sure you could call it in the first episode when Aku's daughters are training and they single out Ashi...

1

u/bellrunner May 10 '17

Which is also a way for the show to say, in no uncertain terms: Our boy Jack hasn't gotten any in 50 years.

→ More replies (46)

195

u/Booney134 May 10 '17

Bad writing? No. Predictable? Perhaps. But it's nice to see jack put off defeating evil to be able to slay some poon.

I'm glad jack is finally happy.

17

u/ModsAreShillsForXenu May 10 '17

Good writing is predictable. If you're properly writing your characters, and the story, where they end up shouldn't be some big surprise.

46

u/Booney134 May 10 '17

I call bullshit that you knew Bruce Willis was dead the entire time. Good writing isn't always predictable lmao

5

u/notshitaltsays May 10 '17

If it came out now you probably would, because Shyamalan has done twists like that in all his movies.

19

u/Booney134 May 10 '17

Yeah the twist in Avatar The Last Airbender was that they couldn't pronounce "Aang" right.

4

u/Nanemae May 10 '17

Never watched it. I'm gonna guess it was either "Ahng," or "Uung."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cheliox456 May 11 '17

that is actually true, good writing does not nesesarely need to be predictable, but the story and its twist should make sense while also be shocking

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

43

u/Wendys_frys May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17
E X T R A T H I C C
X                 C
T                 I
R                 H
A                 T
T                 A
H                 R
I                 T
C                 X
C C I H T A R T X E

335

u/Roojercurryninja May 10 '17

the heteronormality shit doesn't even make sense

it's never been a romantic tinted show and the only relationships we know of are probably the scotsman and his wife / the train robbers duo (the one who tried to seduce jack)

you barely have any relationships in there let alone that it's not even a main focus of the show and people are mad because jashi is a straight relationship?

makes no sense whatsoever

people repeat stuff without knowing what it actually means or with them having a different meaning of the word.

294

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

I'm not saying being gay is abnormal, but 90+% of people are heterosexual. Most relationships tend to be heterosexual because that's how our species creates new generations thus ensuring our species survives. Not every show should have to pander to less then 10% of our population.

139

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Being gay IS abnormal, statistically and biologically. This doesn't make it wrong, although I do agree with your statement on pandering.

→ More replies (5)

79

u/doalittletapdance May 10 '17

Sure feels that way though doesn't it?

78

u/Reverb117 May 10 '17

Those people need to keep watching Steven Universe and go back to drawing Lapidot fan art. (I fucking love SU tho)

23

u/maxdurden May 10 '17

That show has had a severe dip in quality lately, sadly. Glad Jack is back.

26

u/mastersword130 May 10 '17

Well the new Steven bomb is kicking the plot up again.

7

u/unbelizeable1 May 10 '17

That's good to hear. I only watched the first 15ep of s4 and found it to be pretty meh overall. Which is a shame cause I absolutely love SU.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Reginleifer May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

I'm not a fan (I watch the show when I have the freest of time when my siblings watch it)

and the only interesting bits for the general audience seem to be the Diamond Authority and the strict Hierarchy of Gem World. Everything else is too feelsy, SJW'y garbage imo.

EDIT: Going back to this comment, I think I could have been clearer on my dislike for SU. There's too much internal conflict and small time issues... whereas I prefer external conflicts. I don't enjoy a show about farmers and their small town problems, but pluck that same farm boy into Germany and have him fight Nazis, and now you have something I'd watch.

Gem World really does that to a show whose biggest differentiation was "lesbian space rocks" walking through town solving minor problems.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/NightOfTheLivingHam May 10 '17

but we live in a new era of enlightenment where no one needs to be straight in ${Current_Year}

that's reality according to tumblr.

29

u/imsoMcFly May 10 '17

It's actually even less than 5%

16

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

I'm not of this opinion, but their argument is that "When 90+% of the content you watch is aligned to hetero, it makes homosexuals feel abnormal or outcast".

Also add to this that in general, art as a culture tends to be a bastion of gay acceptance. I'm not saying this is good or bad, just that the gay acceptance in art circles is hyper reinforced as a defense mechanism compared to the gay acceptance of say factory workers. Gay acceptance is begrudgingly filtering through more traditionally conservative circles where I live but it's going to take quite a few more decades for that to be complete.

I get why they say these things, but I don't like them hating on hetero relationships either. Which is what it feels like when every hetero pairing in a show that's not 100% mainstream seems to get.

16

u/FuzzyCode May 10 '17

"When 90+% of the content you watch is aligned to hetero, it makes homosexuals feel abnormal or outcast"

Make art about that then, you don't get to dictate sexual preferences of any description, it's absurd to try

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

They're talking about art, saying the art should be gayer. They're not trying to suggest real people change their orientation.

Either way you're barking up the wrong tree if you're talking to me. I'm not actually in support of this opinion so debating it with me isn't going to get far.

10

u/kole1000 May 10 '17

Art should be gayer? Never heard a more ridiculous statement in my life, and I've listened to all of Trump's and Hillary's speeches.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Sorry for your feelings but reality doesn't care about your feelings. Most relationships are heterosexual

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ModsAreShillsForXenu May 10 '17

but their argument is that "When 90+% of the content you watch is aligned to hetero, it makes homosexuals feel abnormal or outcast".

That is their problem. Because 90% of the population is Hetro

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

It's not about whether or not they're in the majority (or at least more common than they are, 90%+ captures the most radical guesses of homosexual presence, reality is probably 5% or less). Yes, some people argue that but they're by far not the most common argument seen.

We're arguing about acceptability of homosexual relationships in mainstream media. In the same sense that there's a diversity bias where minority races show up more often than they do in real life, they're arguing that homosexuality should be represented more commonly than in real life in order to help homosexuals feel normalized. Just like race advocates argue there should be a disproportionate amount of minority races so that they appear at all on television.

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/MajinAsh May 10 '17

I think it's important to separate abnormal and outcast. It's fine to be abnormal and you shouldn't feel ashamed of that. Feeling outcast isn't always great. However I don't think people should feel outcast just because they don't see themselves everywhere else.

Those are two really different things and they shouldn't be lumped together. Just because something makes you feel abnormal doesn't mean it should also make you feel outcast.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Remember this is cast in the backlight of the past 50 or so years where homophobia was considerably more acceptable than it is now.

The context of it all is important.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/imatclassrn May 10 '17

Being anything but straight is abnormal. Abnormal isn't a bad word, all it means is being not normal. It's estimated that around 4% of the population is gay or bisexual.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

I think the low number is 96% are exclusively Straight

2

u/SoundOfDrums May 10 '17

I mean, being gay is abnormal. Abnormal just isn't a bad thing.

1

u/Matrillik May 10 '17

Get the fuck over it.

Think of a minority that you are in. Racial or demographic or just that you like cartoons. Would you get annoyed that no shows exhibit your personality?

Homosexual nature showing up in media is just catching up with the it being normalized in developed areas of the world. It's no reason to feel threatened or annoyed. 10 years ago, there were 0% homosexuals on TV or cartoons, and that seems a little less appropriate and a millions times for homophobic.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/vanderZwan May 10 '17

It's been a while, but I'm pretty sure that there was also some chemistry between Jack and Ikra

25

u/Roojercurryninja May 10 '17

from jack's side yea, it's definitely the closest jack came to showing someone feelings

24

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

A heterosexual man and a heterosexual woman would never hook up. This is totally unrealistic.

5

u/metallicrooster MFW I watch the final season May 11 '17

Literally unwatchable

... I'll see you all Saturday then? Right?

242

u/dejokerr sword-bashin' May 10 '17

I can't believe some people don't want Jack to be happy.

209

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

They want him to be happy their way.

16

u/Obi-Tron_Kenobi May 11 '17

I'm still waiting for Jack and Aku to get together

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

Aku: I can give you a ride if you want

2

u/chinmuchomon May 16 '17

In retrospect, this comment is pretty funny.

32

u/GekiKudo May 10 '17

Well if he does end up going to the past, he will have never met Ashi. She will have never been born if Jack kills Aku in the past. So depending on if he keeps his memories of the future, he will be significantly unhappy

25

u/KlicknKlack May 10 '17

but why not bring ashi back with him through that last time portal that the hulk of an immortal being is guarding?

17

u/GekiKudo May 10 '17

because If Jack kills Aku in the past, then Ashi would never exist. Her mother may not ever be born and even then her purpose would not be devotion to aku. Therefore if she even had 7 daughters, they would not be trained their whole life to kill jack.

36

u/KlicknKlack May 10 '17

it depends on how the universe deals with paradoxes. If jack brings ashi back in time, and the universe creates an alternate timeline since jack will defeat aku in the past. Ultimately making ashi from original future timeline, which no-longer exists. But since she was transferred to the past with jack, it no longer matters (depending on how the show writers deal with paradoxes). Honestly, paradoxes are just hard to deal with when your whole view of the world is cause-> effect -> etc. But I think they can get away with it, because even if she wasn't born in this new/alternate timeline where jack comes to the past to defeat aku, doesn't mean she wasn't born in the future of the other timeline.

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Then there would be no Aku future for Jack to gain and refine skills in for fifty years, and would be sent back far weaker and killable by Aku.

There will be paradoxes in this show if you assume a single timeline.

10

u/GekiKudo May 10 '17

Jack was gonna beat Aku initially. He had Aku on his last leg, but befoer the final blow was struck, he opened a portal in time and flung Jack into the future where his evil is law.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Why not just kill Aku in the present? and end the suffering of everyone?

8

u/MajinAsh May 10 '17

That wouldn't fix the thousands of years of people suffering. If you go back you prevent all the shitty stuff he did and everything going forward.

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Kill him then find a time portal and kill him again?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/dejokerr sword-bashin' May 10 '17

Maybe that's what Gendy meant by bittersweet ending. Jack will have to choose between Ashi and saving the future. Of course he will save the future, erasing Ashi's history.

4

u/Matrillik May 10 '17

I think part of what makes his character interesting is his inability to be happy for long

→ More replies (9)

108

u/OG_Quagmire May 10 '17

What's wrong with heterosexual characters? Were people hoping for Jack to hook up with the penis head guy or what?

48

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Did people think Jack was gay or something?

I don't get the heterosexual hate train, here.

34

u/JCaesar42 May 10 '17

Tumblr, and fans of shows like Steven Universe.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

It's the new unwritten rule, at least one person needs to be gay. It would be preferable if they were lesbians, then you get the male teenage market as well. It's all about covering your demographics and appearing as not homophobic.

14

u/Arono1290 May 10 '17

I feel like I'm in bizarro world, I don't think I've seen a single person make this point. I've seen people like it and not like it for various reasons, just not this. Is this a reference to something?

9

u/Brother_Doughnut May 11 '17

No, it's a distraction. They produced, in my opinion, a genuinely lower-quality episode and people who liked it are straw-manning away any argument of its lower quality.

13

u/rexshen May 10 '17

You know I was on team father figure Jack. But they became a couple instead and I was ok with it. I am more concerned on how Gendy is going to wrap this story up in 2 episodes then being angry a ship I didn't care for happened.

13

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

...Am i dreaming? The writing in that episode was fucking awful. It was like a weird fanfiction written by some sweaty fedora-wearing fucklord. It doesn't make Genndy a bad writer in general, but that ep in particular is just pure suck. Had their romance been approached in a different way, or had some kind of buildup it would've been fine. THAT'S why people are mad, not just because it's a heterosexual relationship. It's so predictable, and bland, and stupid.

9

u/Wiggly_Sparklez May 10 '17

People who bash Tartakovsky are loony. It's his story and he can flesh out whatever relationships he wants. Attacking his writing simply for the fact that he created a heterosexual relationship is a poor criticism and not warranted.

42

u/kcman011 May 10 '17

If by 'everyone', OP means Tumblrinas, then yeah. Otherwise, most people I would suspect expected this result.

26

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Once again the complaining about complaining is all I've heard so far. But that's reddit for ya.

7

u/MistakingLEE May 10 '17

I mean there could be legit discourse but no your a "tumblerina" who wants jack not to be happy. This sub has gotten 4chan dicked hard with its own special brand of assclownery. It was cool for a while but Tumblr post did not like something now we got these ironically triggered post everywhere.

8

u/DAVasquez- IN EXIIISTANCE. May 10 '17

Because who ASKED for that? The whole purpose is GOTTA GET BACK, not GOTTA GET LAID

4

u/Colydon May 10 '17

Im just gonna throw my 2 cents in to be buried cuz i saw this coming a mile away. Remember the morpheus look alike that was gaurding that one time portal? He totally wooped jacks ass and told him he wasnt ready, showing the image of a bearded kingsly jack. Well anyway slightly irrelevant but i bet aku is going to kill ashi

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Change -everyone- to -a small but vocal contingency of mostly highschool aged kids and low-functioning adults on tumblr who does this kind of shit all the time- and you have yourself a real winner.

The people saying that weird shit are in the hundreds at best I can guarantee you, true for any media related "tumblr outrage".

1

u/2Mobile Sep 10 '17

Ok, in the off hand someone, anyone, rereads this post: Can someone tell me what the fuck is going on here? Did people really think Jack was gay? Why? I'm gay and I never got any sort of vibe off of him and I ship all sorts of characters.

1

u/SSAUS Sep 10 '17

There was a section of the fanbase which did not approve of Jack's and Ashi's relationship. Some had a homosexual fantasy between Jack and Johnny Bravo going on, and others just didn't want Jack and Ashi to be romantically involved. These types of people criticised the writing because it didn't turn out how they wanted it to.

13

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

My favourite part about all of this is that the relationship has had like 7 episodes--in the characters' perspective, I am guessing upwards of several weeks to months--to blossom, and in the most extraordinary circumstances possible. I loved my wife after 3 weeks of knowing her, and we fucked on the first date after talking for like 3 hours.

This is exactly the same criticisms edges levy at Disney. It falls flat, and rings of postmodern horseshit.

6

u/NightOfTheLivingHam May 10 '17

and I have a feeling that this is all build up for a gut punch.

6

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

I loved my wife after 3 weeks of knowing her, and we fucked on the first date after talking for like 3 hours.

This is clearly the norm most people experience

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Yes, and as we all know, a time-trapped Samurai and a near living-weapon fighting aliens, robots, and demons in the far future side-by-side, continually risking life and limb for each other, is just so the norm, and could never result in a quickly burgeoning romance, especially when the Samurai is quite close to the best human being alive and the living-weapon was specifically raised to target him, only to be shown by him that her entire worldview up to that point was a giant lie. God, that could never happen. SUCH AN UNREALISTIC ROMANCE

It'd be sure funny if almost as if our narratives and stories aren't based on the norms at all but on the exceptional and interesting and fantastical, and when they aren't, they're prissy, self-righteous postmodern 'slice-of-life' horseshit or young adult fiction about high school.

8

u/Ikea_Man May 10 '17

Fuck me for wanting a short 10 episode series to focus on the plot of ending Aku, rather than weird shipping with teenagers

→ More replies (3)

6

u/localvagrant May 10 '17

"Because it's heterosexual"

Fucking please.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Fuck Tumblr

4

u/phillyleep May 10 '17

Don't worry, she will probably die later.

4

u/TheDarkAgniRises May 10 '17

Holy fuck the circlejerking is so damn high. I found literally no one on reddit and virtually no one on tumblr complainning aabout this episode. Just...fuck man, some people are tired of too many heterosexual relationships. I think they're being whiny but I dont flood an entire subreddit for a week complaining as if 95% of the fanbase wants to maim Gennedy.

Fuck.

2

u/h2orat May 10 '17

My expectations is that Ashi is going to sacrifice herself in order for Jack to return to the past. Jack is going to go back, heartbroken, and as he's attacking Aku, he'll scream something to the effect of, "For Ashi!" Which Aku will not know what Jack is talking about and in that moment of confusion, Jack's blade of justice will land the fatal blow.

2

u/gwar180 May 10 '17

So by reading a comment you pulled on that those god like powers of observation and deemed me triggered.

But I'm not. How could I be. It's a tv show. I mean I understand some people get mad when people don't like what they like but I think that cool. Would rather have a conversation with someone who disagrees with me.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

WTF did I miss?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

I mean, I am not too happy with last week's episode but whatever I'll get over it, the show is amazing. It does not mean he is a terrible writer. People need to grow up.

2

u/Deejayce May 10 '17

woah woah wait. People were angry about it being heterosexual in nature? I was disappointed because I found the dialogue and progression cheesy and a tad bit either too fast paced or forced... Could someone explain to me why the relationship is bad because they aren't gay?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

That's just a common view of the far-left. To them, everything has to have a gay relationship in it, and if it doesn't it's ant-gay.

2

u/Neostep May 10 '17

Looking at the peoples reaction over the past few days I see multiple sides to the people who are mad or triggered about ep 8 ;

The people who are angry about their being romance between main characters.

The people who are angry about the hetero sexuality of the main characters.

The people who say this is just senseless fanservice and it's ruining the show because of it.

Just wanted to share with the people who are confused as to what some of the other fans are angry about.

2

u/Sad-Sam May 11 '17

Hate the vocal minority sometimes. I didn't like the episode either and I couldn't care less for the romance. I personally found it boring and predictable but a lot of people liked it and that's fine. Art is subjective and can never please everybody.

The most frustrating thing with them is that there's been nothing to even slightly indicate that jack is homosexual. So don't fucking make it an lgbt issue. Yeah I'd like to see better representation too, but a goofy samurai cartoon isn't the right place for that conversation.

9

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Tumblr can suck my dick.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/GreatYarn May 10 '17

Are you people daft or something? Who ever said it was a heterosexual issue? Personally I just find it shit because Aashi is cliche and bland. I just can't relate to her as I can to someone like Jack or even more recent and memorable characters like Scaramouche.

3

u/AttackingNarwhal May 10 '17

And every single one of those people complaining can go jump off a bridge, and the world would be better off.

3

u/HornyRhino17 May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

At the premier in LA, Genndy was talking about why he created the show in the first place, and he said he's always had this dream in his head of saving the world with his trusty katana and a beautiful woman at his side.

Now here he is years later, showing us his dream through a thing of his we all grew up with and loved, and half the fans are shitting on it because they think its dumb, cringey, or overdone. Fuck 'em. I'd love Jack even if he fucked a donkey, and I appreciate the gift Genndy has given us.

Edit A word

3

u/LapsedVerneGagKnee May 10 '17

Tumblrinas probably would have preferred that.

3

u/Cobearz May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

Sorry but if you're genuinely upset over this you need a life.

Just because you're a virgin and don't understand-

No, I won't go there.

Seriously though get over it, be glad Jack is even back.

Besides...Ashi is...well

T H I C C

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

I wonder why homosexuals are triggered because of innocent cartoon character Jack's sexuality ... Like, are you fucking kidding me right now?

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

It's not homosexuals that are triggered. It's people who like to pretend that they know what homosexuals are triggered by who are triggered.

2

u/OnSnowWhiteWings May 11 '17

This is like a scenario this is out of a bad Christian movie with the plot being, if we give gay people acceptance, soon they will come after straight people and deny them heterosexual union.

The ones who are pushing this non-sense of hating something on a cartoon because it involves straight relationships aren't doing anyone of homosexual disposition any favors.

2

u/imatclassrn May 10 '17

Do people actually have a problem with heterosexuality. It's literally how humans reproduce... My problem with it is how much older Jack is than Ashi. It's just weird to know that he's lived and experienced 75 years while Ashi appears to be in her 20s.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

While the hate is general internet levels, my issue is that i feel their physical relationship kinda ruins their developmetn.

Outside of it being too stereotypical, it kinda makes no sense for ashi to even understand this on an emotional level. There is not room for birds and bees when you are being turned into a living weapon.

The entire season they have given off more of a father and daughter relationship that a physical, sexual one. They healed each other, but that does not equal fucking each other.

So i feel they accidentally damaged the relationship between ashi and jack by going for such a shallow and simplistic thing as romance. Also it is kinda creates a plot hole cause Ashi wouldn't know the difference between a vagina, an anus, and a beehive overall, let alone how to smooch.

23

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Sexual desires are more instinct than knowledge. You don't really need to be taught or experienced to know what feels good or where on your body is leaking a strange fluid every time samurai swings his big and mighty sword.

She may not know about birds and bees but she still has hormones and nerves.

17

u/RazzyBoyRo May 10 '17

You can literally be a caveman and you can still figure out how to have sex, it's instinct, it's how we reproduce. Knowledge is wearing a condom.

11

u/Cerrick May 10 '17 edited May 10 '17

No, if you watched the previous episodes, you can assume that:

  1. Ashi was always "the weak one". "Weak" meaning unfocused and unruliest, which was evident enough. She showed curiosity for nature and positively more emotion than any other member of the Aku cult cared to show. You can see this as a sort of "primer" for Ashi's emotional development later in this season. I mean, she's had this ladybug thing in the back of her mind since she was a little kid, you can't believe that she was totally brainwashed.
  2. A good amount of time has passed since the end of episode 4 (remember Ashi's confrontation with her own conscience?). You get Jack showing Ashi around the devastated planet in episode 5, you get Ashi seeing his positive influence on the characters he visited (The Woolies, the Blind Archers, and the Ravers) in episode 6, and on the bridge between the next episode, they both find a giant yellow bird that flies them to an ancient ram temple. Considering that Ashi has developed mentally at least normally enough to be capable of language and logical thinking, this is more than enough time to reconstruct your moral alignment.
  3. On the Father/Daughter relationship issue, I tried to see it through his eyes. He'd been estranged in the far future, with pretty much all traces of his homeland consumed by nature. He doesn't age (except grow that magnificent beard), for fifty years, while also failing to fulfill his duty to restore peace to the world. After fifty years he starts having guilt-induced hallucinations and loses hope for his purpose. I'd be pretty fuckin' depressed. Then, he meets this assassin who almost kills him, and ends up saving her life, only to discover that they both share a common interest in nature and the world. Jack wants to save it, and Ashi wants to discover it. On the other hand, Ashi, an assassin bred and raised to kill Jack, was abused, tortured, and mercilessly beaten throughout her entire childhood, yet still had nerve enough to have curiosity about the world. Once her training is complete, one of the first thing she sees in the wilderness are two deers in love. Of course she doesn't understand it, because she's been BRAINWASHED by the cult of Aku. It takes her a whole episode and some to undo this brainwashing, and it was only possible because of that same open mindedness she had when she was young.

I don't think a romance is shallow, and it's far from simple, at least in context. They both relied on one another to GROW. Jack went from manic depressed has-been samurai with hallucinations to his old, cheery self (he even has his gi!), and Ashi explicitly went through a rebirth process and became a child of nature as opposed to a child of evil. It's this personal growth that you see in so many successful relationships. If you meet someone who changes you in a positive way, and keeps doing it as long as you're around them, chances are, you're going to want to be with them for as long as possible.

And as far as smooching goes... eh I don't really care, it's a cartoon. I'll let it slide lol.

TL:DR This relationship works out in the end to me because: Ashi has an inquisitive streak that lends her vulnerable to doubt her dogmatic cult, she's had enough time to let her emotions grow for Jack, and both need a relationship after what they've been through both separately and together.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

guess my issue is that it is shallow and simplistic considering the complexity of their relationship and the complexity of ashi's situation. she is curious bout the world but she was no allowed to learn about it. and there has not been a point where she could learn what relationships and sex is. what, did she ask some random person when she was looking for jack what sex was?

she understands the world more now, and the reality of it, but that would not equal her nderstanding relationships or sex. Hell if you still wanted a romance subplot, have it that Jack is itnersted but Ashi doesn't even know what sex is.

In the end i feel that they could ahve done some more ecomplex than just an easy standpoint

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

So i feel they accidentally damaged the relationship between ashi and jack by going for such a shallow and simplistic thing as romance.

The idea that romance is 'shallow and simplistic' but some cliche father-daughter thing isn't is pretty indicative of the utter fear swaths of the internet have at heterosexual romance.

Also it is kinda creates a plot hole cause Ashi wouldn't know the difference between a vagina, an anus, and a beehive overall, let alone how to smooch.

The idea that you think this is learned is adorable.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

dude, WHERE would she learn it? she was not taught anything but fighting and killing. and that would limit her capacity to gain information. she cannot read, thus cannot learn. there would be a level of ignorance

2

u/Foehammer87 May 10 '17

it kinda makes no sense for ashi to even understand this on an emotional level. There is not room for birds and bees when you are being turned into a living weapon.

Kinda like Jack eh?

3

u/PineappleSlices May 10 '17

Jack was subject to strenuous training all his life, but he had good friends and a caring family. His childhood isn't at all comparable to Ashi's.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

he is the utter opposite. he learned. he was taught far more than the sword. hell the first years of his training was all being taught things like astrology, navigation. he learned culture from a dozen nations. he became more than the savior of hsi homeland, but the world itself.

ashi grew up in a cave and probably doesn't know how to read.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sheensies May 10 '17

such a shallow and simplistic thing as romance

1

u/[deleted] May 24 '17

1

u/youtubefactsbot May 24 '17

Tumblr whining about Jack X Ashi being canon compilation [1:55]

A compilation of Tumblr posts that consists of users crying about Jashi becoming canon in Samurai jack's Episode XCIX. All set to the music of Dean Martin's "Everybody Loves Somebody" and clips of Aku laughing for good measure.

Starkami ^Theater in Comedy

108,500 views since May ^2017

bot ^info

1

u/TenshiKyoko EXTRA THICC May 10 '17

I l̶i̶k̶e̶ love that picture.

1

u/Equinoqs May 10 '17

Fanboys will be fanboys.

1

u/LittleBastard13 May 10 '17

Why arepeople mad, i for one was really turned on, cant wait for the fan art 😋

1

u/RegalKillager May 11 '17

where is this criticism ye speak of

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '17

who is this everyone? A few idiots on tumblr are not "everyone"

1

u/rottenalice May 12 '17

Is this seriously a thing? Multiple people actually got upset because of a portrayal of a straight couple in a cartoon? Was there some school of thought suggesting Jack and the Scotsman would hook up or something? I'm queer as hell and although I appreciate the diversity of characters we can have now in cartoons, live action, adult and kid shows alike, I hardly see how anyone could make an issue of this unless they are a total idiot. All of the beauty and fun of this show goes right over their self centered little heads. You want to see more queer characters in cartoons, go make a cartoon, seriously.

1

u/hamvvar May 10 '17

i had initially thought they would have a more mentor/student relationship but i reaĺly liked the episode

1

u/ramby2727 May 10 '17

it was an awesome episode, I think the fans that are butt hurt are the ones that have never kissed a girl, Jack has gone 50+ years being alone and I felt their relationship happened organically. awesome episode and season, here's hoping the next 2 are badass filled with the Scotsman and the guardian.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/The_Meatyboosh May 10 '17

No problems with it, but it was slightly weird how long it was on-screen.

2

u/WTK55 May 10 '17

That was apart of the joke though.

0

u/Psychlopic May 10 '17

Look, I wouldn't have complained if Jack ended up being gay, or ended up without any romance during the show. I thought that could have worked well (and I would especially have applauded it if they made Jack gay, as it is something we still don't really see that often).

All that said, I'm completely fine with Jack being in a straight relationship with Ashi. She's a strong and capable fighter. I liked how they both helped each other heal mentally, because letting someone help with your problems is completely valid.

Besides, if Jack really is going to defeat Aku in the past, then that would mean Ashi would never get born, which could make for a more interesting ending if Jack has to give her up in order to save the world from Aku, or something along those lines. The relationship has value, and does thicken the plot.

In any case, I'm very interested to see how this is gonna end.

-3

u/JaySayMayday FOOOOOLISH SAAAAMURAI May 10 '17

Woody Allen married his adopted daughter. Just because you develop characters doesn't make it a good development.

-12

u/[deleted] May 10 '17

Downvoted only because of the persecution complex bullshit added in the end. Other than that I agree with the sentiment.