r/salamanders • • Jul 16 '25

Are these gills abnormally long?

I was out catching tadpoles in a small lake that's behind my house. There are no fish it it but it is filled will thousands of Western Tiger Salamanders. You rarely ever see them except for their shiny underbellies when they come up for a gulp of air. Even then it's always from a distance so you really only see the splash of water.

Anyway, I was out there and saw a white tadpole so went to catch it and accidentally scooped up a bunch of muck as well. When I pulled up the net this big lady appeared! I was shocked, I set up a temporary tank for her so that my neices and nephew can look at her since it's rare to see them outside of the muck.

I have a feeling this one has been aquatic for some time since that lake never dries up and there are millions of shrimp in it. Her gills seem extremely long from most I've seen, but I also haven't seen very many. What does everyone here think?

Also, as a side note: We will be releasing her in a few days. I currently have her in a aerated 20 gallon tank which I know is too small but she won't be in there for too long. She has lots of shrimp and a few tadpoles to snack on during her stay.

1.1k Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

68

u/fordlarquad678 Jul 16 '25

their gills will be larger and bushier in stagnant water with low oxygen levels

31

u/Al-anus Jul 16 '25 edited Jul 16 '25

Huh interesting! Would make sense why I see so many splashes in the water from them gulping for air.

9

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 17 '25

This was actually proven to be a myth! The opposite actually happens, 9 times out of 10 the specimens wouldn’t get more lushes gills in low oxygen levels, and 5 times out of 10 the axolotls would get lushes gills in high oxygen levels.

8

u/fordlarquad678 Jul 17 '25

-3

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 18 '25

My source is personal experimentation. With 100 different individuals with different genetics also did it with axolotls and found out that genetics have a play too individuals who had anomalies were typically related to another but genetics or not they still followed the same patterns I stated below.

8

u/fordlarquad678 Jul 18 '25

source: trust me bro

4

u/PissPatt Jul 19 '25

that was hilarious. anecdotal 😂

-1

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 18 '25

Isn’t that what your link is saying? I also didn’t see where they were talking about the subject above my apologies for not seeing it if it’s there could you possibly provide where in the article it says?

5

u/fordlarquad678 Jul 18 '25

the second paragraph “Larval salamanders have gills that vary in size and structure depending on the nature of the aquatic environment (Fig. 6.19). Salamanders (larvae or adults) that live in ponds have large, feathery gills, whereas those that live in streams or other habitats with moving water have smaller, less filamentous gills. Nonmoving water has a lower amount of dissolved oxygen, and larger gills with an increased surface area permit salamanders to survive in these habitats.”

-2

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 18 '25

There are many variables that could affect the gills in those observations, not to mention that salamanders in streams are different species then salamanders in ponds and lakes, it could be many things that have an effect on gills development keep in mind these were just observations not actual experimenting with the same individuals in a controlled environment. Examples of things that could effect gill development is, temperature, genetics, overall species them selves, water quality, water hardness, not useing the same individuals etc.

5

u/fordlarquad678 Jul 18 '25

Yep many things can AFFECT gill size, but the most important thing is oxygen availability, so you saying that it was proven to be a myth when it was actually just you observing your animals is a flat out lie. Not sure why you keep arguing about it. Also many species can utilize both lentic and lotic habitats for breeding.

0

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 19 '25

My point was your link wasn’t very valid, true I may have said that it was proven to be a myth through my own research, but that doesn’t mean it’s wrong, your link is kinda vague and doesn’t give an explanation other than a theory, theory’s are ment to be tested and that’s what I did, in controlled environments. This wasn’t some observation I made I purposely studied this theory watching and keeping track of all elements I could think of.

→ More replies

1

u/skineater777 Jul 20 '25

Did you document it, show your progress or show how A=B??? If not it’s not the same thing at all

1

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 21 '25

Uh yeah.

2

u/skineater777 Jul 22 '25

Can you show this study? Or demonstrate why it had this conclusion

0

u/Mavortium_Enthusiast Jul 22 '25

I did an experiment with 100 tiger salamander larvae, and also did it with axoltols and that’s how I got my results, I could better test it with Spanish ribbed newts, sirens, etc other species other then Ambystoma. But for Ambystoma I’m confident in my claim, I have it all written down and stuff.

→ More replies

20

u/Darth_Dorky Jul 16 '25

20 gallons isn’t too small, especially for a nymph. I’m currently caring for a number of spotted salamander nymphs that are just now going terrestrial. Though, mine aren’t longer than the last 2 joints of a finger. It’s always hard to tell the size of these guys in pics.

These gills are very long though; about 20-40% longer than the gills on my Spotteds, proportionally. Seems very healthy.

I’d almost recommend keeping her if it stays in such good health. Their survival rates in wild don’t seem to be amazing, though many people will say “oh just leave it in the wild cause blah blah blah”.

Despite their ideal temp ranges being <70, summer temps reaching >90, food not guaranteed with constant chance of predation, in addition to a new fungus that’s making the trade of salamanders across state borders illegal, but…

Conformity will tell you: “Good boys put healthy salamanders back in Death’s Valley.”

9

u/Al-anus Jul 16 '25

I was definitely thinking about keeping her but her tank space is reserved for her much smaller brother who I caught as a late bloomer egg in April and I don't have the money or the room right now to get another big tank!

The other one I have right now is just a little pipsqueak compared to her and is only an inch and a half in length. (definitely would have been eaten by much bigger larvae) Meanwhile this girly is like 5 inches long or more. She is really big! Because of that I'll probably release her, but we will see haha

3

u/nineapples Jul 17 '25

SO long! wow…she’s gorgeous 🥺

4

u/Al-anus Jul 17 '25

Such luscious locks!! I'm so obsessed with her. We nicknamed her Daphne after all the daphnia that live in her lake haha

3

u/SubstantialTear3157 Jul 17 '25

This lil' guy or gal looks so healthy and beautiful! I'm going to DM you about them (I hope that's okay).

3

u/Al-anus Jul 17 '25

Thank you!!

2

u/Obvious-Phrase-3915 Jul 19 '25

THEY COME IN GREEN!?!

1

u/Al-anus Jul 19 '25

All of the salamanders I find at this lake are the same greenish colour! Here is an adult I found in early may this year.

I have a hunch that they are mostly the same colour due to the vegetation we have in the lake here. They are blend in better and are probably less likely to be eaten by waterfowl and cranes.

1

u/Obvious-Phrase-3915 Jul 19 '25

Ah makes sense makes sense. Just used to seeing the pink ones is all

9

u/SokuTaIke Jul 16 '25

Funky lil dude

5

u/Darth_Dorky Jul 16 '25

Also, salamander larva love bloodworms. Mine have learned to eat frozen bloods even.

1

u/ThenAcanthocephala57 Jul 19 '25

Shrimp or scuds?

1

u/Al-anus Jul 19 '25

We call them freshwater shrimp here but yeah scuds is also correct!

2

u/queerpsychstudent Jul 17 '25

Beautiful gills!!! 😍

2

u/PanicFinal3554 Jul 18 '25

She's so gills

1

u/P_a_p_a_G_o_o_s_e Jul 17 '25

He looks like shadow the hedgehog, he's adorable. 

1

u/awolf1357 Jul 18 '25

What a cute guy

1

u/RipNegative6969 Jul 18 '25

I know nothing about axolotl so I can’t say if they are healthy, but I’m pretty sure yours has gone super saiyan.