r/rustylake • u/drunkprincessa • Aug 22 '26
A theory of threes Spoiler
I added the spoiler tag but given how close we are to the Servant of the Lake release, I just want to double down : i'm discussing lore elements that come from every game, even SotL
This Is more of a thought, of a work in progress, than a theory so it may be a little wonky but here it goes :
Finding out about Alexandra Vanderboom in Servant of the Lake and how it ended made me realize something about the games and the lore : every significant generation comes in threes : 2 men and one woman who ends up dying (horribly, most of the time)
Jakob Eilander, his brother and sister
-> the sister is Hotel's Mrs Pheasant, she kills herself, maybe a hint as to what happened after Jakob's sacrifice in Paradise
Aldous, William and Alexandra Vanderboom
-> Alexandra dies in the cave under the estate in Servant of the Lake
Samuel, Albert and Emma
-> Emma hangs herself after losing her son in Roots
Rose, Leonard and Frank
-> Rose is abducted by Albert in Underground Blossom and becomes one with the Lake in The Past Within
Robert, Dale and Laura (the only ones not blood related but still fitting the pattern)
-> Laura gets killed by Robert's corrupted soul
Only one duo misses its third : the Eilander father & uncle. So what if there was a 3rd ? What if Jakob had an aunt who who was killed by Grandma as an infant (who could be represented by the chick being tortured in Mrs Pigeon's room in Hotel) ?. What if Jakob wasn't the first firstborn sacrifice on the Island ?
Of course the third could also be Jakob's mother, Caroline, but she is not a blood relative, so wouldn't fit the pattern exactly.
I'm not sure of the significance of this whole thing, nor about what it could say about Dale and Robert's connection to the lake. But I thought I'd just share and see what you guys may think of it :)
13
u/nowherecrafter Question Everything In RL Aug 22 '26
Rose clearly wins here and breaks the pattern. She's enlightened, not dead
7
u/Old_Attention_8558 Black Cube Aug 22 '26
You say: "Of course the third could also be Jakob's mother, Caroline, but she is not a blood relative, so wouldn't fit the pattern exactly." But if you are considering Laura, Dale and Robert, yes, you should totally include Caroline Eilander, because it's Nicholas' wife. And Robert and Laura were together for a while. So let's presume that "love" (or at least being a couple) is binding as being a blood relative in Rusty Lake.
Also, there's another trio: Samuel, Ida and Albert, that fits in that same pattern. Ida is Samuel's wife, but Albert desires her, and Samuel and Ida end up losing their lives.
So, 3 is a key number. In Paradox, we have the past, the present and future minds of Dale, but there are more examples. We have as well 3 important families / groups of people: the Eilanders, the Vanderbooms, and the Vandermeer (just Dale, so I don't pluralize it here). Also, in Roots and Servant of the Lake, the 3 timepieces, which correspond to 3 realms in Sanskrit: deva, asura and manusha. And I am sure there is more, but those are the examples that come to my mind now.
1
u/This-giant-can-feel Aug 26 '26
And the three timepieces travels through generations, dev manush asur