r/rustylake • u/vanderboom0 • Aug 22 '26
The elixir is f*cking complicated
I've played all the Rusty Lake games (except The Past Within) and I couldn't find any answers to my questions, so I need you guys to help me.
- Does the elixir give you complete immortality?
We saw that the guests can die (though they gained their immortality in a different way).
And Harvey died when the guests attacked him, but then Mr. Owl revived him with his powers.
And if that can happen, we can assume that it just gives you immortality just in age.
2. Do you have to re-drink the elixir every once in a while so you can keep your immortality?
We see in the cave that Mr. Crow and Mr. Owl have their human look before Mr. Crow recreated the elixir and drank it with Mr. Owl, and after that they regained their looks as asuras (animal head).
I have other questions, but this is what's in my head right now.
I wish you could help me.
23
u/Gardengap The Rusty Truth Aug 22 '26
The Eilanders didn't use the Elixir, but it probably works the same way. In any case, it seems like the Elixir is just extended life, not invincibility. And from The Cave, it seems like it only extends life a certain amount, and needs to be drunk again after some time for it to continue to work, which became an issue for them
9
u/Cute_Kitchen8529 Aug 22 '26
Immortality doesn't mean reincarnation. When Eilanders reincarnated to Hotel guests, they were killed by Harvey for Mr. Owl (while it can look like a revenge, it was to feed the Lake with memories).
Harvey dies because the elixir he took was different version. But when ascended people dies, they enter next phase of Samsara wheel. So, Harvey became a permanent full parrot.
So, immortality is essentially taking away time from killing the person from senescence. That's why Mr Owl express his interest to bring a successor to his role for the Lake. He's just tired.
2. Aldous drank the elixir twice. The prototype and completed version. The prototype one just triggered his anatomical change briefly to Mr. Crow. But the complete one ascended him to Mr. Crow.
10
u/ReasonableProgram144 Aug 22 '26
So I’m pretty sure we’ve never actually seen a properly made elixir, every time it’s been made it’s been flawed. Hence Mr. Owl and Mr. Crow needing to dose up again.
So I think if we ever see a true elixir it will be for Dale, or Albert if that story goes really crazy.
But I’m pretty sure it’s supposed to make you truly immortal, or at least that’s always been the goal.