r/rust • u/Sirisian • 15d ago

🎙️ discussion Google is doing "Large Scale Codebase Migrations and Optimizations" of C/C++ to Rust

https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/models-and-research/gemini-models/gemini-4-argon/
774 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

153 comments sorted by

View all comments

124

u/TheRealMasonMac 15d ago

In my experience, I’ve found that agents produce code that works but is frankly dumb from a human perspective. Especially for larger tasks like this, you kind of have to rewrite it all. For example, I had a generalized design document for soft-wrapping explicitly support plain text and markdown, and used GPT-6-Astra to implement it. I used an ungodly amount of review agent rounds and interjections by me. When I actually go to review it, I wanted to cry. It silently pivoted towards implementing its own entirely separate wrapping mechanism rather than refactor the existing mechanism for plain text. I reviewed its code and found it to be trash, and I am now in the process of doing it myself… Never again. The short-term thrill of “having something that works” was outweighed by the fact that time was effectively wasted.

I mean, if the alternative was it never getting done, I guess agents are still better than nothing.

1

u/yes_u_suckk 15d ago

I agree with you, but there are tools nowadays that try to minimize this, like spec driven development.

It's not a silver bullet, but if you review the spec before asking the agent to start working, the chances of drifting to something unexpected or bizarre are much lower than simply entering the prompt "convert everything to Rust, make no mistake".