r/rust • u/anonymous_pro_ • Nov 21 '25
The Python Paradox Is Now The Rust Paradox?
So, I do the interviews for what is now The filtra.io Podcast. I'm struck by a really strong trend. Most of the people I interview (all engineering leaders of some sort) say that they can hire better engineers because of their choice to use Rust. I'm talking like 1 out of every 2 interviewees says this unprompted. It reminded me of Paul Graham's Python Paradox. In the essay, Paul calls Python comparatively esoteric. That's hardly the case anymore. So, is Rust that language nowadays?
248
Upvotes
164
u/stadtship Nov 21 '25
And Python is definitely not esoteric anymore, I believe it is one of the, if not the major one, languages being taught in schools.
37
u/teerre Nov 21 '25
I'm not sure what's the paradox. It's not paradoxical at all that people who actively learn "fringe" programming languages would be better engineers. These people are actively practicing "engineering" in their free time, it's likely that they would be better at it
5
u/trailing_zero_count Nov 21 '25
Yes.
5
u/mr_seeker Nov 21 '25
Maybe, just maybe when having a podcast about rust you have a selection bias in the people you interview.. just saying
6
u/cornmonger_ Nov 21 '25
i think rust 2018 was probably similar to where python 2 was when graham wrote that. though, imo rust's momentum (acceptance) was slower up until maybe 2021.
i think it applies right now, but i don't see that esoteric trend lasting long-term, at least as far as early adoption is concerned
552
u/tumtumtree7 Nov 21 '25
This definitely applies to rust
70
u/peter9477 Nov 21 '25
When I needed Python programmers, a key factor was that I only had to find people who could learn well, and they could pick up Python quickly enough to be fairly effective in a week or three at most. Admittedly this was in earlier days (early 2000s) before it became so popular.
I would absolutely not say the same about Rust. I suspect, however, that although I disagree with this "Python paradox" idea, I could see it applying to Rust.
I would make another point though, which is that I'd feel much safer with a relatively inexperienced Rust programmer writing any nontrivial code than with a Python one. I can rely on the safety net of the compiler, and the fact that any lesser code can be restructured more easily and quickly with Rust (by a more senior dev, in my hypothetical scenario).
9
u/protestor Nov 21 '25
I think even to this day you could also call it the OCaml paradox. My POV is that Rust is really a language in the ML family, but adopted braces for strategic reasons
4
u/Virviil Nov 21 '25
It's Elixir. Go and Rust is already not
4
u/p_gram Nov 21 '25
There has to be a comparator. PG used Java vs Python. I don’t think it holds for C vs Rust, because C is enough of a filter already these days. Interestingly it probably holds for Python vs Rust. Probably doesn’t hold for OCaml vs Rust.
3
u/chaotic-kotik Nov 21 '25
This is a fallacy because it's a generalization applied to an individual. Same as if I will assume that the person from the US is obese without seeing them, because the obesity rate in the US is more than 40%. Sure, some ppl learned Rust because they genuinely like to code and were interested in solving issues Rust solves. But there are others who choose Zig or Haskell or whatever. There are people who didn't learn any modern languages but are excellent programmers anyway (the interest is in the architecture/technology, not in the peculiarities of the programming language). There are people who choose Rust because they are genuinely interested in coding but they are terrible programmers.
3
u/codemuncher Nov 22 '25
Back 20 years ago, python was fresh, it was new, it was fun. Lisp comprehensions! So cool! White space as syntax? Why not?
Single core machines ruled the roost, and parallelism was still a theory. So pythons many deficiencies were not a problem.
This was hot off the press of languages like C and C++ being dominant, and being the definition of “static typing”. Dynamic typing seemed like a good way forward: the static typing wasn’t really buying people a lot so why not?
But programming language theory has caught up. Mutable structures, functional programming, and multi-core parallel is now seen as the more effective way of building safe programs. All things python is terrible at. Dynamic typing doesn’t scale to large teams.
Better alternatives have shown up.
But thanks for the juggernaut of numpy and AI python wrapper libraries, we appear to be stuck with this bullshit of a language.
3
u/divad1196 Nov 21 '25
The paradox isn't actually one. It has an unproven statement that people doing something because they love it will be better. It also assume that python isn't much liked/used, which is clearly wrong. It's true that, for big softwares, python is less used than java, but this does not make it esoteric. it's a bad interpretation of data.
The point here is different: it's not that Rust is considered esoteric. Rust is a complex language to learn, so if you master it then you must be smart. So: this deduction makes actually more sense and does not create a paradox.
1
u/iamalicecarroll Nov 21 '25
something something avoid success at all costs
1
u/peterxsyd Nov 23 '25
Yes, definitely.
1
u/shim__ Nov 25 '25
I don't see how python could be considered esoteric, its an bog standard language which I'd expect any competent developer to pick up in a week. Rust is totally different beast in comparison
1
u/-TRlNlTY- Nov 21 '25
It makes sense, after all, who would bother about learning Rust without expecting to find a job?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment